What has happened to op shops? Have charity shops become greedy?

Charity shops (commonly known as op shops) used to be the choice for shoppers with tightened budgets. Others are simply looking for a bargain or trying to be more sustainable. But now, op shoppers are finding they’re no longer the soundest option, especially with rising costs that do not necessarily come with better items.


One op shopper took it to Reddit to vent. They said:

‘I was recently out and doing some browsing around the local op shops in the area and I was shocked by several things. First was the prices. Not going to name names, but I went to three of the "big name" op shops and a couple of local ones, and the prices on things were crazy. We are talking $30 for a pair of old jeans, t-shirts were all $10+, even the books were $10 for old paperbacks and kids' toys – they were asking $20 for a Thomas the tank engine plushie!

‘Seriously? For most of these things, you could get brand new for that price or not much more... I thought op shops were supposed to be a place for people facing financial issues to pick up some cheap donated products, not a second-hand up-market boutique store stocked by the charitable donations of the public.

‘And speaking of stock, every store I went to had the labels ripped off, not just the branding ones but the size tags too. I can only assume this is to prevent people buying "brand name" items and reselling them, but from what I could see, there were no "brand name items" there anyway.’


They also reminisced about the good old times: ‘I remember only a couple of years ago, going op shopping and coming away with a good size bag of clothes for the kids and myself that were good quality close to new looking. Now all that is on the floor seems to be close to being rags, and whatever was not was priced at ridiculous levels. Seriously, there were a couple of nice (though well-worn) dresses priced over $300! At an op shop!’

The Redditor shared the last straw: ‘The final cherry on top was that there was next to nothing in the ‘kids’ sections, the men's sections of all the stores consisted of a single rack and the majority of the stores’ floor space were dedicated to showcasing specialty women's wear or racks of women's clothing. Where are all the donations I see piled up in and around the bins going?’

prudence-earl-8F0I12ypHPA-unsplash.jpg
Once considered a last resort, secondhand stores are seeing a boom in price-sensitive and eco-conscious customers. Credit: Unsplash

Other shoppers’ observations were not far off from the author’s. One said: ‘I’ve been op-shopping since the 1990s, and I’ve definitely noticed a change in pricing in the last few years. They’ve become terribly greedy and it’s rare to find a “good buy” now. Some things are more expensive than buying new!’

The commenter also noticed the shift in attitude regarding secondhand clothing. ‘It’s also a supply and demand thing. I think at the end of the 2000s and into the 2010s, with the hipster/retro boom, kitsch and vintage items increased in value (e.g. all things MCM) and op-shopping became a cool hobby or thing to do. My father told me that when he used to op-shop in the early 1980s, he was made to feel embarrassed by his middle-class peers, as it was considered the domain of poor people.’


Secondhand shopping is certainly becoming more appealing, and the numbers show that. The global ‘re-commerce’ market is expected to boom to 325 billion AUD in 2026, while already valued at 143 billion dollars in 2021.

Younger shoppers are also seemingly keener to buy pre-loved items than older generations. And while affordability remains the top reason for shoppers, others are motivated by their desire to curb the environmental effects of shopping for apparel. According to an eBay report, 34 per cent of consumers cited sustainability and reduced waste as reasons to shop secondhand.

It also doesn’t hurt pre-owned apparel shoppers are also seen as better dressers – a study found that people who rank higher on style consciousness are more likely to shop secondhand. The perception has somewhat changed, but the effects that came with it aren’t always desirable.


Another op-shopper chimed in: ‘op shops where you pay $5 for a leather jacket are few and far between. I miss finding cool bargains in op shops.’

A third said: ‘The standard of donations isn't what it used to be too, with much being cheap Kmart junk, to begin with. True quality items are rare, skimmed in sorting, or purchased quickly.’

A Redditor also commented: ‘The glory days are long behind us. Now, employees/volunteers are aware that many people buy just to flip for $$, so they price things higher accordingly.’

Someone who claimed to be working at Vinnies said it was the higher-ups responsible for the rising costs: ‘It's corporate that demands the prices go up. I can't stand it. They were selling a plastic toy car for $6!’

With inflation decreasing purchasing power, many Aussies are turning to thrift and secondhand stores for the first time. Shopping pre-loved has also become easier through online marketplaces. Platforms such as Gumtree, Facebook Marketplace, and eBay are all reporting a rise in secondhand listings and sales. But shopping for apparel can be tricky when you can’t try on items to determine fit, explaining the continuing appeal of op shops.

Recently, shoppers have called out op shops for their ‘ridiculous’ prices and charging ‘an arm and a leg for absolutely anything,’ however.


Like most businesses, charity op shops say they are struggling to strike a balance between good prices and revenue. Vinnies and Salvos refer to the price increase of goods for their pricing strategy, but they also have to cover operation costs and their charitable efforts.

Op shops maintain that they still are working to serve shoppers with different budgets. In an interview with The Guardian, Salvos’ General Manager for Customer and Strategy Edwina Morgan said: ‘Our prices are reflective of the Australian consumer market, and although perception is that inflation has had an impact on preloved or second-hand clothing prices broadly, we are continuing to focus on providing a diverse range of price points across our store network to cater to all types of needs and wants.’

So, what do you think, folks? Are you observing the same in your local op shops? How do you feel about the rising prices set by secondhand stores? Let us know in the comments!
 
Sponsored
I worked at the salvos many years ago They treat there volunteers as slaves cleaning windows etc
sorting out the clothes you had to hang so many clothes per days you had to each day make budget
per day manger’s would get bonus if there shop made a profit
they could sell the clothes and items a lot cheaper because the are donated free of charge
The regional manger gets a car and petrol plus all his expenses paid even volunteers had to pay full price if they wanted to buy any thing I remember a day where we had a brand new everything for a baby and I mean everything and has the manager daughter was pregnant she put everything in her car

I mean everything for a new baby The person that donated the clothes and babies items either had lost her baby after giving birth
or a miscarriage
The next thing she was on the phone to her daughter bragging what she had came into The salvos and had put into her car for her There was not a few dollars worth but hundreds of dollars
The manager did not put one cent into The till,that day or the next two days then we had Sunday
I was back on Monday but no money was put into the till
I think the manager got hundreds of dollars worth of babies clothes and a basinet baby bath etc etc
as far I was concerned she stole all the babies things
This was in Western Austarlia I regret not reporting it
 
I worked full time at an op shop for free and will never do it again. When I retired from years of retail management I decided to give back and volunteered for 3 years at a local op shop. While the people donating, buying and volunteering were lovely, management was awful. Never again.

The larger multinationals are now corporate owned and a very small amount goes to charities - that is why prices have sky-rocketed. If you want a good deal or you want the majority of your donations to go to help the poor then only donate to the independents or the church run shops.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ricci and Penny4
I worked in a OP shop it was a church run for quite a while and our prices ranged between $2 to $5 and we even gave people who were desperate free clothes for their family mostly women and children. Our turnover of clothes where great. I'm OP shopper love them !!!. But there are a few that charge huge prices for second hand clothes etc. I refused to pay some of these prices. The sad thing is most of the time K Mart and places like that are cheaper. We even have a OP Shop at our local Tip and theirs prices are beyond belief.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ricci and Penny4
I have had the same I am south of wollongong\ & all the Op Shops are greedy & I was told that most do not belong to the charity that the name says they are sub let & the new contractor puts allt eh prices higher & they keep the charity name so they get the labour come in free as they think they are helping this charity it is mostly a
scam really
but there is one Op Shop that is real & the prices are excellent it is in Dapto just a little shop I great staff
thanks ozzy
 
  • Like
Reactions: Chicky and Ricci
I followed your suggestion and took a look at the Salvos site. They are not what I would consider great bargains. Spotted a lovely blue glass bowl on there and was shocked that it is $350! Admittedly it is a "designer" bowl but $350 for something they got for free? And on top of that, it is damaged (website states "Unfortunately there is a small internal fracture. Is underneath and not seen on display.")
My goodness, that is absolutely outrageous! ..... I have heard that Salvos stores are expensive but to charge this much??? 😨
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ricci
Charity shops (commonly known as op shops) used to be the choice for shoppers with tightened budgets. Others are simply looking for a bargain or trying to be more sustainable. But now, op shoppers are finding they’re no longer the soundest option, especially with rising costs that do not necessarily come with better items.


One op shopper took it to Reddit to vent. They said:

‘I was recently out and doing some browsing around the local op shops in the area and I was shocked by several things. First was the prices. Not going to name names, but I went to three of the "big name" op shops and a couple of local ones, and the prices on things were crazy. We are talking $30 for a pair of old jeans, t-shirts were all $10+, even the books were $10 for old paperbacks and kids' toys – they were asking $20 for a Thomas the tank engine plushie!

‘Seriously? For most of these things, you could get brand new for that price or not much more... I thought op shops were supposed to be a place for people facing financial issues to pick up some cheap donated products, not a second-hand up-market boutique store stocked by the charitable donations of the public.

‘And speaking of stock, every store I went to had the labels ripped off, not just the branding ones but the size tags too. I can only assume this is to prevent people buying "brand name" items and reselling them, but from what I could see, there were no "brand name items" there anyway.’


They also reminisced about the good old times: ‘I remember only a couple of years ago, going op shopping and coming away with a good size bag of clothes for the kids and myself that were good quality close to new looking. Now all that is on the floor seems to be close to being rags, and whatever was not was priced at ridiculous levels. Seriously, there were a couple of nice (though well-worn) dresses priced over $300! At an op shop!’

The Redditor shared the last straw: ‘The final cherry on top was that there was next to nothing in the ‘kids’ sections, the men's sections of all the stores consisted of a single rack and the majority of the stores’ floor space were dedicated to showcasing specialty women's wear or racks of women's clothing. Where are all the donations I see piled up in and around the bins going?’

View attachment 10602
Once considered a last resort, secondhand stores are seeing a boom in price-sensitive and eco-conscious customers. Credit: Unsplash

Other shoppers’ observations were not far off from the author’s. One said: ‘I’ve been op-shopping since the 1990s, and I’ve definitely noticed a change in pricing in the last few years. They’ve become terribly greedy and it’s rare to find a “good buy” now. Some things are more expensive than buying new!’

The commenter also noticed the shift in attitude regarding secondhand clothing. ‘It’s also a supply and demand thing. I think at the end of the 2000s and into the 2010s, with the hipster/retro boom, kitsch and vintage items increased in value (e.g. all things MCM) and op-shopping became a cool hobby or thing to do. My father told me that when he used to op-shop in the early 1980s, he was made to feel embarrassed by his middle-class peers, as it was considered the domain of poor people.’


Secondhand shopping is certainly becoming more appealing, and the numbers show that. The global ‘re-commerce’ market is expected to boom to 325 billion AUD in 2026, while already valued at 143 billion dollars in 2021.

Younger shoppers are also seemingly keener to buy pre-loved items than older generations. And while affordability remains the top reason for shoppers, others are motivated by their desire to curb the environmental effects of shopping for apparel. According to an eBay report, 34 per cent of consumers cited sustainability and reduced waste as reasons to shop secondhand.

It also doesn’t hurt pre-owned apparel shoppers are also seen as better dressers – a study found that people who rank higher on style consciousness are more likely to shop secondhand. The perception has somewhat changed, but the effects that came with it aren’t always desirable.


Another op-shopper chimed in: ‘op shops where you pay $5 for a leather jacket are few and far between. I miss finding cool bargains in op shops.’

A third said: ‘The standard of donations isn't what it used to be too, with much being cheap Kmart junk, to begin with. True quality items are rare, skimmed in sorting, or purchased quickly.’

A Redditor also commented: ‘The glory days are long behind us. Now, employees/volunteers are aware that many people buy just to flip for $$, so they price things higher accordingly.’

Someone who claimed to be working at Vinnies said it was the higher-ups responsible for the rising costs: ‘It's corporate that demands the prices go up. I can't stand it. They were selling a plastic toy car for $6!’

With inflation decreasing purchasing power, many Aussies are turning to thrift and secondhand stores for the first time. Shopping pre-loved has also become easier through online marketplaces. Platforms such as Gumtree, Facebook Marketplace, and eBay are all reporting a rise in secondhand listings and sales. But shopping for apparel can be tricky when you can’t try on items to determine fit, explaining the continuing appeal of op shops.

Recently, shoppers have called out op shops for their ‘ridiculous’ prices and charging ‘an arm and a leg for absolutely anything,’ however.


Like most businesses, charity op shops say they are struggling to strike a balance between good prices and revenue. Vinnies and Salvos refer to the price increase of goods for their pricing strategy, but they also have to cover operation costs and their charitable efforts.

Op shops maintain that they still are working to serve shoppers with different budgets. In an interview with The Guardian, Salvos’ General Manager for Customer and Strategy Edwina Morgan said: ‘Our prices are reflective of the Australian consumer market, and although perception is that inflation has had an impact on preloved or second-hand clothing prices broadly, we are continuing to focus on providing a diverse range of price points across our store network to cater to all types of needs and wants.’

So, what do you think, folks? Are you observing the same in your local op shops? How do you feel about the rising prices set by secondhand stores? Let us know in the comments!
I worked for Vinnies for years as a volunteer. It is now a business as far as I can see because those in charge running 3 or 4 shops are WELL paid will cars, computers, phones etc included. & get extra bonuses whenever a shop exceeds their budgeted profit.
 
  • Sad
  • Wow
Reactions: Penny4 and Ricci
Salvos are so picky about furniture. Some op shops don’t sell furniture purely because they don’t have the space. I drove into the car park at my local vinnies and Before I had even parked a woman sorting donations shouted at me we don’t need anything, take it somewhere else. I wasn’t quick enough to say something like “oh you don’t have room for this diamond ring” !!! She was so rude I won’t donate to them any more, she could have handled it very differently if they were overwhelmed with donations.
I often find that prices can, at times, be completely outrageous! These 'charities' are making some big profits from the people that need them the most!
 
  • Sad
Reactions: Ricci
I was in an op shop the other day when someone came in with some clothes to donate. He was told no sorry we have too many clothes and was told to try another op shop up the road !!! Never heard of this happening before. So sad. Surely there is a lot of homeless people that would love them.
There is a $2 dollar op shop in Margate Queensland opposite Woolworths - lovely lady with nothing over $2.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ricci
My goodness, that is absolutely outrageous! ..... I have heard that Salvos stores are expensive but to charge this much??? 😨
some op shops want $6-$10 for a kmart t shirt that is $3 brand new.. after many op shops you get to know the prices, the brands, the best shops.. etc.. we always use the app "opshop.org" to find opshops in the area where we are
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ricci
I worked at the salvos many years ago They treat there volunteers as slaves cleaning windows etc
sorting out the clothes you had to hang so many clothes per days you had to each day make budget
per day manger’s would get bonus if there shop made a profit
they could sell the clothes and items a lot cheaper because the are donated free of charge
The regional manger gets a car and petrol plus all his expenses paid even volunteers had to pay full price if they wanted to buy any thing I remember a day where we had a brand new everything for a baby and I mean everything and has the manager daughter was pregnant she put everything in her car

I mean everything for a new baby The person that donated the clothes and babies items either had lost her baby after giving birth
or a miscarriage
The next thing she was on the phone to her daughter bragging what she had came into The salvos and had put into her car for her There was not a few dollars worth but hundreds of dollars
The manager did not put one cent into The till,that day or the next two days then we had Sunday
I was back on Monday but no money was put into the till
I think the manager got hundreds of dollars worth of babies clothes and a basinet baby bath etc etc
as far I was concerned she stole all the babies things
This was in Western Austarlia I regret not reporting it
karma will get them ☸️
 
  • Like
Reactions: Marj53 and Ricci

Join the conversation

News, deals, games, and bargains for Aussies over 60. From everyday expenses like groceries and eating out, to electronics, fashion and travel, the club is all about helping you make your money go further.

Seniors Discount Club

The SDC searches for the best deals, discounts, and bargains for Aussies over 60. From everyday expenses like groceries and eating out, to electronics, fashion and travel, the club is all about helping you make your money go further.
  1. New members
  2. Jokes & fun
  3. Photography
  4. Nostalgia / Yesterday's Australia
  5. Food and Lifestyle
  6. Money Saving Hacks
  7. Offtopic / Everything else

Latest Articles

  • We believe that retirement should be a time to relax and enjoy life, not worry about money. That's why we're here to help our members make the most of their retirement years. If you're over 60 and looking for ways to save money, connect with others, and have a laugh, we’d love to have you aboard.
  • Advertise with us

User Menu

Enjoyed Reading our Story?

  • Share this forum to your loved ones.
Change Weather Postcode×
Change Petrol Postcode×