Tension rises as Aussie star threatens ALDI over one 'copycat' item

In the world of celebrity-endorsed products, authenticity and brand recognition are everything.

So, it's no surprise that a pop icon's team has been seeing red over another product that bears a striking resemblance to the singer's own branded beverage.


Budget supermarket chain ALDI could be in potential legal action after Kylie Minogue's representatives noticed uncanny similarities between ALDI's Rosalie Cotes De Provence Rosé and Kylie's signature sparkling rosé.

Since diving into the wine industry in 2020, Kylie Minogue has captured the hearts of music fans and the palates of wine connoisseurs.

Kylie Minogue's wine collection, which included a non-alcoholic bottle, sold about 17 million bottles and earned £34 million (about $65 million) in profits.


compressed-kylie wines.jpeg
Kylie Minogue launched the sparkling rose wine in 2022. Image Credit: Kylie Minogue Wines


Kylie's wines were showcased at ProWein, the world's largest wine fair, and earned accolades along the way.

However, the wine collection's success has been soured by ALDI's Rosalie wines.

The retailer's wine mimicked Kylie's product with its bottle design, label, and brand font.

The ALDI version, priced at £8.49 ($16.37), undercuts Kylie's, which sells for at least £9 ($17.35).


These findings stirred the interest of consumers, who took to social media about the similarities.

According to an insider, Kylie Minogue's team expressed their frustration to the press.

'It is obvious to everyone exactly what they are trying to do. It is duping, plain and simple,' the pop star's management team stated.

However, ALDI did not shy away from the controversy.

In a bold move, the supermarket acknowledged that the Rosalie bottle was a 'dead ringer' for Kylie's product.

According to an ALDI spokesperson, wine expert Sam Caporn blind-tasted both rosés and found them to be 'completely identical' in taste and colour.


This is not the first time ALDI has been embroiled in a dispute over product similarities.

In 2021, Marks & Spencer launched a High Court claim against the budget retailer for allegedly copying its Colin the Caterpillar cake with its own Cuthbert version.

Though the case got settled confidentially out of court, ALDI gained significant attention with its 'Free Cuthbert' marketing campaign.

As Kylie Minogue celebrated four successful years in the wine industry, she acknowledged the 'incredible growers, winemakers, distributors, and partners' that contributed to her brand's success.

Meanwhile, ALDI stated that the company strives to offer quality products that match leading brands at a lower price, all while adhering to strict copyright guidelines.
Key Takeaways

  • Kylie Minogue's team has been considering legal action against ALDI for selling a rosé wine resembling her brand.
  • ALDI's version had a strikingly similar bottle design to Kylie's wine, to which customers pointed out the resemblance on social media.
  • ALDI acknowledged that their bottle was a 'dead ringer' for Kylie Minogue's wine, and a blind taste test by a wine expert claimed that the two wines were 'completely identical'.
  • The supermarket also faced another dispute with Marks & Spencer in 2021, which was dubbed as the 'Caterpillar Wars'.
The potential legal battle raised important questions for consumers. What do you think of Kylie Minogue's debacle with ALDI? How much does branding influence your choice of wine? Share your thoughts with us in the comments section!
 
  • Haha
Reactions: BJM, Sass and Petra
Sponsored
I would be interested in knowing which wine came first 🤔.

Secondly it always amazes me that consumers don't seem to realise they pay extra for famous people's endorsement of products and that money goes into the pockets of people who have more money than they can sensibly spend in a lifetime 🤔.

Thirdly, there have been many great products that have disappeared over the years because a competitor had deeper pockets and used their money to get superior product placement and advertising. Lotus was a far superior product to Excel and the similarities were extraordinary but Excel came from a richer person and Lotus is now history.

Lastly, a bit off track but similar. You see rich people pay enough money for paintings which are frankly rubbish, solely because one of their own class deems the artist to be great.

TThey will even pay millions for fakes they think are real and can't be distinguished from the original, then scream blue murder when they discover they have been duped.
To me this says: "The empower has no clothes on"
 
I'm with ALDI here. They bring us their own products, which can mimic brand names, but at vastly reduced prices. It's a competitive world so the Kylie brand needs to stop whining!
98 cents is not vastly reduced. If Aldi said they would sell Kylie's Rosé why make the same one? Why not stop stocking Kylie's brand. Then change it. It sounds like dishonest practices
 
Aldi over Kylie any day for me. I don’t buy brand names. Why pay more just because they have a brand name on them.
 
Well, apparently making 'dupes' of more expensive products has become the norm for businesses like Aldi, Kmart and many others. In fact, tracking down dupes seems to have become quite a trend for many. Why leave all the power in China to create cheap dupes when others can do a much higher quality version? Personally, I don't agree with the practice of duping. I think it's riding on the hard work of other designers and artists, let alone the free advertising, but my opinion is purely personal as an artist myself. But if it's an unavoidable aspect of our over- commercialised world now, at least go for those duping the quality, not just the look. It appears this Aldi product is every bit as good as Kylie's, so why not?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mr Chips
Weird that they taste the same! And don't tell me Kylie personally developed 'her' rosé...

So, the wine (already bottled?) came from a bulk supplier. Kylie's label is stuck on one and a horrendous price is charged. Aldi sells the 'cleanskin' at an affordable price.

I know which one I'll spend my hard-earned dollars on!
 
While in WA I was lucky enough to get Aldi wine. They have a great selection at reasonable prices and they taste great. I go by taste than price. Pity SA won’t let Aldi sell wine here, but then Cole’s would,object more. Our government sucks
 

Join the conversation

News, deals, games, and bargains for Aussies over 60. From everyday expenses like groceries and eating out, to electronics, fashion and travel, the club is all about helping you make your money go further.

Seniors Discount Club

The SDC searches for the best deals, discounts, and bargains for Aussies over 60. From everyday expenses like groceries and eating out, to electronics, fashion and travel, the club is all about helping you make your money go further.
  1. New members
  2. Jokes & fun
  3. Photography
  4. Nostalgia / Yesterday's Australia
  5. Food and Lifestyle
  6. Money Saving Hacks
  7. Offtopic / Everything else
  • We believe that retirement should be a time to relax and enjoy life, not worry about money. That's why we're here to help our members make the most of their retirement years. If you're over 60 and looking for ways to save money, connect with others, and have a laugh, we’d love to have you aboard.
  • Advertise with us

User Menu

Enjoyed Reading our Story?

  • Share this forum to your loved ones.
Change Weather Postcode×
Change Petrol Postcode×