New Design
  1. Enable New Design

Should Uber drivers have the right to reject passengers because of weight?

Offtopic / Everything else

Should Uber drivers have the right to reject passengers because of weight?

  • Maan
  • By Maan
image1.png Should Uber drivers have the right to reject passengers because of weight?
Melbourne man alleges Uber weight discrimination. Image source: Youtube/A Current Affair

A Melbourne man has accused Uber drivers of repeatedly refusing to pick him up—claiming it is because of his weight.



Each time he books a trip, he braces for the possibility that the driver will take one look at him and keep going.



For Martin, that gut-wrenching moment has become an all-too-familiar part of trying to get around the city.




Martin, who lives on a disability pension due to his size, said his experiences have left him feeling ‘less than a human being’.



‘It’s because of my size. I’m morbidly obese, I don’t shy away from that,’ he told #A Current Affair.



‘The drivers take one look at me and they go right past me.’



He said he had grown accustomed to watching a driver approach, only to have them turn away at the last moment.



When they reached the corner, they would cancel the trip—leaving him standing on the kerb with a hollow feeling in his stomach.




"It feels like I'm less than a human being. I want to be able to be like everyone else."

Martin, speaking to A Current Affair




Relying on rideshare services



Martin relied on rideshare services to visit his elderly parents, whom he cared for.



He said personal circumstances had prevented him from losing the amount of weight he wanted, despite his best efforts.



Under Victoria’s Equal Opportunity Act 2010, it is illegal to discriminate against someone based on their physical features.



The law also places a ‘positive duty’ on companies to take steps to eliminate discrimination in the workplace.



Businesses can be held responsible if their workers engage in discriminatory behaviour.



Martin said the problem was not confined to rideshare trips—he often felt judged while eating in public, walking through shopping centres, attending medical appointments, or even trying to get a haircut.




Taking action against discrimination



Over several years, Martin kept a record of every Uber driver who cancelled on him after seeing him in person.



When he complained to Uber, he claimed he was told that drivers would receive better training.



‘They occasionally send me a $10 voucher because that’s how much a human’s dignity is worth,’ he said.



Martin wanted the company to take action against drivers who discriminated against passengers based on weight.



He said he simply wished to be treated with dignity.



Did you know?


Australia’s National Obesity Strategy 2022-2032 Specifically identifies tackling weight stigma and discrimination as a key principle for creating a healthier Australia.




Uber’s response



Uber responded in a statement saying it had a ‘zero tolerance policy towards any form of discrimination’.



‘Our community guidelines clearly prohibit discrimination of any kind,’ an Uber spokesperson said.



‘We work to inform driver partners about those standards, hold them accountable for their actions, and make it clear that this behaviour can result in them losing access to the Uber app.’



Uber has been contacted for further comment.



Watch the full report below.



Source: YouTube/A Current Affair





What This Means For You


If you or someone you know faces discrimination when using rideshare services, you have options.



Document each incident, report to both the company and the Victorian Equal Opportunity and Human Rights Commission, and know that the law is on your side. Your experiences matter and your dignity is non-negotiable.




Seniors Discount Club

Sponsored content

Info
Loading data . . .
Maybe he should look at his diet and do some exercise,unless he has a medical issue , then that’s not an excuse to be overweight either , it can be controlled by his GP . No excuse .
 
Like any business,they make the rules , he needs to stop whinging and work on the weight problem, stop feeling sorry for his dilemma .
 
He knows he is morbidly obese so he needs to do something about it. He must be 300 kg plus.

Someone that large needs to request the proper vehicle maybe a van rather than a car.

We drove an obese lady to a funeral we went to and we felt it in the car. We have a good car but it was struggling. Another problem was she couldn't even put the seat belt on . She also struggled to actually get in the car. It might sound mean but we wouldn't take her anywhere again ( she is the sister of a friend)

Not only is he harming himself, but he is creating a huge impact for others, including medical staff that might need to attend to him as well as the cost to the medical system.

As for Uber I actually understand as
Increased weight can accelerate wear on certain components like seats, door pins, and suspension, and definitely affects fuel efficiency. Additionally, obese drivers/ passengers experience more difficulty getting in and out of the vehicle and could potentially be at a higher risk of injury in an accident due to changes in weight distribution and restraint effectiveness.

Here's a more detailed breakdown:
  • Mechanical Wear:
    Seats:
    Seat bolsters and other interior components can wear out faster due to the increased friction and pressure from larger individuals.

    Door Pins & Bushings: Leaning on the door for support when getting in and out can damage door pins and bushings.

    Suspension: While the suspension is designed to handle a certain amount of weight, constantly exceeding that weight capacity (especially with bumps and potholes) can lead to faster wear and tear.

  • Fuel Efficiency:
    Increased weight, in general, will negatively impact fuel economy.

 
A bit mean you don’t know if it’s a medical problem or not !
Regardless its his problem and he for one should be ordering a larger vehicle eg a van .

I saw this interview and I'm sure he would have stated it was a medical issue but he didn't

85% of morbidly Obese are from over eating
 
A bit mean you don’t know if it’s a medical problem or not !
Read my comment again ,I said if he had a medical condition .
 
I hear how this man must feel as he is left like a piece of rubbish on the kerb. I also hear the drivers and the problems that have been noted. I would like to think he could get a little van for people with special needs either weight or equipment and a caring driver who would be there for him.
 
Maybe he should look at his diet and do some exercise,unless he has a medical issue , then that’s not an excuse to be overweight either , it can be controlled by his GP . No excuse .
Live the life and you can be so cruel. He is who he is and doesn’t deserve a strangers judgement,
 
Read my comment again ,I said if he had a medical condition .
I did see that but many things contribute to over eating , I know people who eat like birds and can’t drop weight. I on the other hand am naturally ridiculously skinny and it is considered a virtue.
 
Maybe he should look at his diet and do some exercise,unless he has a medical issue , then that’s not an excuse to be overweight either , it can be controlled by his GP . No excuse .
Brings me to tears to see such judgement of a stranger just trying to get around. Reasons behind it ? Well we just do t know.
 
Depending on type of vehicle, some seats will not withstand the weight of a morbidly obese person. The supports collapse. I know people who had to have seating in their vehicles reinforced because they or their passengers were too heavy for the standard supports.
 
Brings me to tears to see such judgement of a stranger just trying to get around. Reasons behind it ? Well we just do t know.
Maybe he should inform himself of available options and not just complain about discrimination and expect to be treated as a normal person. There are plenty of avenues for assistance available to him so that he doesn't have to feel bad about his situation when he can't be accommodated as he wishes to be. The rest of the world is not at fault or responsible for his problems and should not be made to feel guilty for it.
 
A bit mean you don’t know if it’s a medical problem or not !
If it's a medical problem he should be informing himself of suitable options available to meet his needs, not just expect to be treated as a normal person. There are many avenues of assistance available for people with medical problems, to ensure that they don't feel discriminated against.
 
My sympathy would lie with Uber drivers because some of this persons comments and expectation to be treated as a normal person are quite unreasonable. I think that Uber needs to implement standards for meeting people with disabilities needs and ensuring that they actually dispatch a suitable form of transport to meet those person's needs, not just expect their driver to sort out the problem and chastise them for complaints being lodged. My opinion would be that Uber as the employer is responsible to ensure they have all the facts from the customer and have suitable transportation equipment dispatched to meet the needs of the customer with disabilities. I abhor an employer who does not support their employees appropriately to enable them to do their job properly.
 
Regardless its his problem and he for one should be ordering a larger vehicle eg a van .

I saw this interview and I'm sure he would have stated it was a medical issue but he didn't

85% of morbidly Obese are from over eating
Not being difficult but I honestly havnt seen that percentage, may I ask where the info came from?
 
  • Like
Reactions: siameezer
Maybe he should inform himself of available options and not just complain about discrimination and expect to be treated as a normal person. There are plenty of avenues for assistance available to him so that he doesn't have to feel bad about his situation when he can't be accommodated as he wishes to be. The rest of the world is not at fault or responsible for his problems and should not be made to feel guilty for it.
Can’t disagree with you, my problem is the harshness of the comments , a little kindness wouldn’t go astray either offering alternatives.
 
Can’t disagree with you, my problem is the harshness of the comments , a little kindness wouldn’t go astray either offering alternatives.
I think his expectations are unreasonable in my opinion, although I do feel sorry for him. He is quoted as having said, "I want to be able to be like everyone else." I think that might be almost an impossibility to achieve in a general sense given his condition. The only thing that I can possibly suggest for him is to seek help and advice from disability experts and consultants who would be able to provide advice to suit his needs.
 
Can’t disagree with you, my problem is the harshness of the comments , a little kindness wouldn’t go astray either offering alternatives.
You are also judging people , you. Can’t sugar coat others problems .
 
SO! one can be on the disibility scam for being FAT.
This means half of australia must be collecting as well.
go and sit with a coffee and watch the fat people go by.
 

Join the conversation

News, deals, games, and bargains for Aussies over 60. From everyday expenses like groceries and eating out, to electronics, fashion and travel, the club is all about helping you make your money go further.

Seniors Discount Club

The SDC searches for the best deals, discounts, and bargains for Aussies over 60. From everyday expenses like groceries and eating out, to electronics, fashion and travel, the club is all about helping you make your money go further.
  1. New members
  2. Jokes & fun
  3. Photography
  4. Nostalgia / Yesterday's Australia
  5. Food and Lifestyle
  6. Money Saving Hacks
  7. Offtopic / Everything else
  • We believe that retirement should be a time to relax and enjoy life, not worry about money. That's why we're here to help our members make the most of their retirement years. If you're over 60 and looking for ways to save money, connect with others, and have a laugh, we’d love to have you aboard.
  • Advertise with us

User Menu

Enjoyed Reading our Story?

  • Share this forum to your loved ones.
Change Weather Postcode×
Change Petrol Postcode×