Woman sues famous transportation app after series of discriminatory treatment

Navigating the world has its set of challenges, especially when people have certain conditions.

Many Aussies, especially seniors, understand the importance of reliable transportation, especially when driving is no longer an option.

However, when supposedly accessible services become a barrier themselves, it presents an opportunity for action.


This is the story of Paula Hobley, a Victorian woman who strived for independence and normalcy despite the hurdles of blindness.

Ms Hobley has relied on taxis and rideshare services like Uber to attend medical appointments, meet friends, and complete her shopping.

Ms Hobley signed up for Uber's Service Assistance Programme, which should notify drivers that the traveller has a guide dog during the trip.


compressed-pexels-guide dog.jpeg
Ms Paula Hobley is blind and heavily relies on her guide dog for navigation. Image Credit: Pexels/Gustavo Fring


However, her pursuit of a simple, stress-free travel experience has been repeatedly thwarted by an unexpected adversary.

Her journey has been marred by a series of refusals from Uber drivers that violated both her rights and Australian law.

'As a person with a disability, I'm not a second-class citizen,' Ms Hobley stated in an interview.

'I have the right to access services in the same way as everyone else.'


Drivers would often tell Ms Hobley to book another service called Uber Pet.

'Uber Pet is for pets. A guide dog is not a pet,' she clarified.

According to the Disability Discrimination Act (1992), it is illegal to refuse service to a person with an assistance animal.

Yet, Ms Hobley faced this discrimination on dozens of occasions, which led her to take a stand by suing Uber in the Federal Court.

Her case highlighted a broader issue that has become endemic, as current policies failed to protect the rights of individuals with disabilities.

Ms Hobley's experiences were not isolated incidents.


According to a survey run by Guide Dogs Australia, nearly half of guide dog handlers had been denied a ride in the past two years.

This widespread problem has been an inconvenience among individuals who require assistance dogs.

In response to Ms Hobley's move, Uber immediately emphasised their commitment to working with stakeholders to prevent such refusals.

The ride-hailing app also reiterated the training and education they continue to provide to their drivers.

Uber explained that they have policies in place that require drivers to comply with laws regarding riders with disabilities, including those with assistance animals.


However, the continued occurrence of these refusals suggested that these measures are not enough.

Ms Hobley's legal battle was beyond her grievances; it's about holding companies accountable and ensuring that the rights of people with disabilities are upheld.

For our readers who may face similar challenges, Ms Hobley's story should be a reminder that you have rights that deserve to be respected.

It's also a call to action for all of us to support efforts to make our society more inclusive and accessible.
Key Takeaways

  • A Victorian woman sued the ride-hailing app Uber after allegedly discrimination against her and her guide dog.
  • Despite efforts to educate drivers and work with stakeholders, Uber has been unable to prevent service refusals for those with guide dogs.
  • A survey from Guide Dogs Australia indicated that nearly 50 per cent of passengers with guide dogs have been denied services in the past two years.
  • The case aimed to address the broader issue of disability discrimination in ride-sharing services.
What are your thoughts on this issue? Have you or someone you know faced similar challenges with transportation services like Uber? Let's discuss in the comments below and work together to raise awareness and drive change.
 

Seniors Discount Club

Sponsored content

Info
Loading data . . .
uber might have a policy in print .... but they do not try to enforce it.
it is shameful how they take our money and do not pay taxes or look after anyone.
they do not support the drivers when there is a problem either.
i have a couple of friends who also have written grievances with uber, the company.
 
One other issue regarding Uber drivers )and I am in no way trying to protect them) is that they own the car themselves and is often the family vehicle. They therefore can be uncertain about having any animals in their own vehicle if they have personal issues with it. Maybe Uber should be able to make it known to their drivers when a booking is made so that there are no more sad events with animals.
the app allows the driver to know it is an animal ride. so there is no excuse for not knowing.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Liz and Winks
One other issue regarding Uber drivers (and I am in no way trying to protect them) is that they own the car themselves and is often the family vehicle. They therefore can be uncertain about having any animals in their own vehicle if they have personal issues with it. Maybe Uber should be able to make it known to their drivers when a booking is made so that there are no more sad events with animals.
Fear of animals is not a disability, it is a phobia.
Fear is fear and it's THEIR car.They love and respect elephants...would you like it if there was one in the back seat when you call them as it's their companion and they love it to bits.I am guessing no!!!
Yes this is all unfair but we are allowed to be scared of animals too,why do they need therapy for that?
 
Th
good on her. i have just started comlink. ordered a taxi for 1pm monday for a doctor. at 1.15pm it still hadn't arrived so i took myself in my car. i returned home around 3pm and at 4pm comlink phoned me as the taxi company was wondering when i would like to be picked up. told them i hadn't even been picked up at 1pm. is this a rort, or what?
is happens even when you don't have a disability.I have been berated by (yes a good Ozzie taxied driver), because he didn't turn up I had to get someone to take me to the train station in a panic for an appointment I had waited 10 months for in Sydney,and he had the hide to ring my phone to complain that he was outside my house and were the hell was I.I told him I was on a train for the last ten minutes and that he was over half an hour late and couldn't wait any more.He said a profanity at me and hung up.
So yes my friends,it's not just Indians scared of dogs.We have our own DOGS employed as taxi drivers with no manners of any sort too😩😩😩
 
First of all ,a guide dog does NOT sit on the back or front seat of any Taxi Uber car or Bus or Plane . I am 87 years old and use a white cane now . The reason of that is because if you have a guide dog you are required to exercise them for kilometre walk per day . I cannot walk myself that far each day now . I have a carer to take me when I go out . When you ring for Taxi you ask for large car because the guide dog ALWAYS sits on the floor in front of your FEET in the Taxi . Same in Bus and if you go on plane the seat next to you is Vacant because the dog sits on the floor in front of that NOT on the seat . Some of the floors my poor guide dog sat on over the years have been so filthy you wouldn’t sit a pig on,even I could see it. Also I have half price Taxi card and you pay the driver your share on the day but he has to put the other on form for government and they pay them at the end of each month.A lot of drivers if they don’t own their own taxi and are driving for an owner don’t like doing this . They want the money in their hand so they can have their share of takings for the day . I don’t know whether service dogs are trained like this or not .It costs over $40,000 to train a guide dog and they are always asking for donations in your will which I 🫡
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mr Chips and Winks
On Sunday I was taken to an emergency surgery. After treatment I needed a taxi to return home. Over the next two 2 hours the receptionist rang various taxi companies which all promised to come within half an hour. The final call had a taxi there in ten minutes. I can only assume they would not come to a medical centre.
 
  • Wow
Reactions: Liz and DLHM
Fear is fear and it's THEIR car.They love and respect elephants...would you like it if there was one in the back seat when you call them as it's their companion and they love it to bits.I am guessing no!!!
Yes this is all unfair but we are allowed to be scared of animals too,why do they need therapy for that?
Sorry COW....got my scared animal mixed up🤣
 
Frankly I am torn actually have a half fare card but quite understand why drivers don’t want to take less than they can get from a passenger paying full fare. They have to live.
This is on the government drivers should be able to claim the rest of the fare.
They do. The government already pays the other half.
If you have these taxi vouchers yourself then you should be aware of this.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Liz and Mr Chips
Fear is fear and it's THEIR car.They love and respect elephants...would you like it if there was one in the back seat when you call them as it's their companion and they love it to bits.I am guessing no!!!
Yes this is all unfair but we are allowed to be scared of animals too,why do they need therapy for that?
When the Uber is booked they need to be aware it includes transport of an assistance animal. They can reject the job & someone else can pick it up.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Glucose
Sorry COW....got my scared animal mixed up🤣
No excuse, they drive an Uber for a living and there are laws and regulations that go along with the job.
If you can't carry out your job because of your own idiosyncrasies then get a different job. Simple as that.
Next they'll be not wanting to drive people with perfume on because they get hayfever.
 
A possible explanation to the "fear" of domestic pets, such as cats and dogs in Australia, is that these imports eat them. I wonder what some of the strange carcasses are that are hanging in the windows of some foreign owned food retailers.

Further to that, when I was living in Sydney, I would take my pet dingo for a walk at about 8 am most days. The schoolchildren, mostly Asian, would bolt across the road to get away from my dog!
 
But not the point, not everybody has a family member or a carer.
E.g. I have no family here in WA. except my daughter and I am her carer. If I was to get ill what would happen.
You can't rely on friends they have their own lives and worries.
But 'Parrot' has a good point and you could get a carer for your daughter too then if you were ill you wouldn't have to worry would you? Also you would have someone to clean the house etc
 

Join the conversation

News, deals, games, and bargains for Aussies over 60. From everyday expenses like groceries and eating out, to electronics, fashion and travel, the club is all about helping you make your money go further.

Seniors Discount Club

The SDC searches for the best deals, discounts, and bargains for Aussies over 60. From everyday expenses like groceries and eating out, to electronics, fashion and travel, the club is all about helping you make your money go further.
  1. New members
  2. Jokes & fun
  3. Photography
  4. Nostalgia / Yesterday's Australia
  5. Food and Lifestyle
  6. Money Saving Hacks
  7. Offtopic / Everything else
  • We believe that retirement should be a time to relax and enjoy life, not worry about money. That's why we're here to help our members make the most of their retirement years. If you're over 60 and looking for ways to save money, connect with others, and have a laugh, we’d love to have you aboard.
  • Advertise with us

User Menu

Enjoyed Reading our Story?

  • Share this forum to your loved ones.
Change Weather Postcode×
Change Petrol Postcode×