This Surprising Habit, Not Price, Keeps Aussie Shoppers Loyal to Big Supermarkets – Are You One of Them?

As Australians, we're creatures of habit, especially when it comes to where we buy our groceries. It turns out that many of us are sticking to the major supermarkets like Coles and Woolworths, not because of the prices, but because of our shopping habits. This loyalty is not necessarily driven by the best deals or the lowest prices, but rather by a sense of familiarity and convenience that keeps us coming back to the same place week after week.

Recent research by the think tank e61 has shed light on this phenomenon, revealing that a significant number of Aussie shoppers show a strong brand loyalty to one major grocery store over others. This preference is so strong that it's shaping the market, giving these supermarkets more power and reducing competition. The study analyzed consumer bank transactions and found that in NSW and the Australian Capital Territory, there's a high degree of 'inertia' favoring industry giants Coles and Woolworths.



Economist Matt Ellias, the author of the report, suggests that this customer behavior persists even in areas serviced by a variety of grocery stores. The lack of shopping around isn't due to a scarcity of options but rather factors like convenience, unconscious habit, and a lack of resources to help shoppers find the best deal. Coles and Woolworths also have a competitive edge by strategically locating their stores in prime areas, often within shopping centers, which offer additional amenities and convenient parking.


shutterstock_1491300365.jpg
A report found shoppers tended to stick to one supermarket brand when grocery shopping. Credit: Shutterstock


The research indicates that brand loyalties run deep, with 70% of customers who do their primary large shop at Woolworths likely to return a month later, and 62% still shopping there six months later. Coles sees similar loyalty, with 62% of customers returning after a month and 55% after six months. In contrast, Aldi's numbers are lower, with 48% of customers returning after a month and 37% after six months.



Interestingly, Aldi's strategy of situating stores close to the major supermarkets seems to be a tactical move, making it easier for customers to switch without much hassle. Despite this, the pull of habit keeps many shoppers loyal to their usual supermarket.

This topic of supermarket loyalty and pricing has come under scrutiny recently, with the Australian Competition & Consumer Commission (ACCC) taking legal action against Coles and Woolworths over allegations of misleading discount practices. Furthermore, a CHOICE survey found that while Aldi offered the cheapest prices for a 14-item basket of groceries, the price difference between Coles and Woolworths was minimal, and all were significantly cheaper than IGA.

The ACCC's interim report on the supermarket sector also highlighted the difficulties shoppers face in comparing prices, contributing to a loss of trust in supermarket pricing claims. These challenges are reportedly due to various pricing practices, such as frequent specials, short-term lowered prices, bulk-buy promotions, member-only prices, and bundled prices.



So, what does this mean for you, our savvy seniors? It's a reminder to consider whether your shopping habits are serving you well. Are you visiting the same supermarket out of convenience or habit, or are you actively seeking the best deals to stretch your dollar further? It's worth taking a moment to reflect on your shopping routines and whether a change might be beneficial.

Key Takeaways
  • Australian shoppers often display brand loyalty to one major grocery store rather than shopping around for better prices, which strengthens the market share of large supermarkets like Coles and Woolworths.
  • According to research from the think tank e61, this consumer 'inertia' results in less competition and gives major supermarkets significant market power, as customers tend not to seek out potential better options at alternative stores.
  • The research found that a large number of customers remain loyal to their primary supermarket, with 70% of Woolworths' customers and 62% of Coles' customers returning for their main shopping one month later.
  • The Australian Competition & Consumer Commission (ACCC) is taking legal action against Coles and Woolworths over allegations of misleading discount practices, highlighting issues with supermarket pricing transparency and dwindling consumer trust in sale price claims.

We'd love to hear from you, our Seniors Discount Club members. Are you loyal to one supermarket, or do you shop around for the best prices? Have you found that your shopping habits have changed over time, or do you stick to what's familiar? Share your experiences and tips in the comments below – your insights could help fellow members make more informed choices about where they shop.
 

Seniors Discount Club

Sponsored content

Info
Loading data . . .
Interesting analysis, possibly true for the younger people. The choice of where you shop here in North Queensland is taken away from us due to duopoly rein of Woollies and Coles. IGA is optional but more costly. Being from Europe, IGA is a go to for items not available at duopoly. I used to shop exclusively at Woolworths but they discontinued some products so have to go to Coles as well. So depending on the items on shopping list, it could be a round trip of all 3, or just one Loyalty definitely doesn’t come into the equation, only specials on every Wednesday. I must say that somehow Coles here have a better customer service and sometimes I see employees joke and laugh together, not so at Woollies where all appear to be under a pump and asking question is totally unwelcome and is answered tersely. The consumers here would welcome Costco or Aldi so there is some competition to keep prices down.
 
Interesting analysis, possibly true for the younger people. The choice of where you shop here in North Queensland is taken away from us due to duopoly rein of Woollies and Coles. IGA is optional but more costly. Being from Europe, IGA is a go to for items not available at duopoly. I used to shop exclusively at Woolworths but they discontinued some products so have to go to Coles as well. So depending on the items on shopping list, it could be a round trip of all 3, or just one Loyalty definitely doesn’t come into the equation, only specials on every Wednesday. I must say that somehow Coles here have a better customer service and sometimes I see employees joke and laugh together, not so at Woollies where all appear to be under a pump and asking question is totally unwelcome and is answered tersely. The consumers here would welcome Costco or Aldi so there is some competition to keep prices down.
I believe Coles has the better staff training. Every Coles I've set foot in, the staff are friendly, well informed and appeared to be content with their jobs. Like every other supermarket, the staff are expected to scan a minimum number of products every minute. I don't believe that this is strictly adhered to, as one of the cashiers that I've chatted with, tells me she ignores that rule and has been working there for nearly 20 years.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ezzy
Just a word on half price specials. This was a study I conducted in October 2023 on Woolworths half price specials. They paint a different picture.

CATEGORY NO. OF ITEMS PERCENTAGE

Beauty & Personal Care 438 31.33%
Cleaning & Maintenance 511 36.55%
Pantry 62 4.43%
Freezer 29 2.07%
Dairy, Milk & Eggs 11 0.79%
Health and Wellness 147 10.52%
Snacks & Confectionery 80 5.72%
Home & Lifestyle 63 4.51%
Drinks 27 1.93%
Lunchbox 21 1.50%
Bakery 8 0.57%
Poultry, Meat & Seafood 1 0.07%

TOTAL 1398 100.00%

As you can see, the HUGE majority of these products DO NOT constitute a meal or an ingredient of a meal.

EDIT: Damn formatting didn't work! 👿
 
  • Wow
Reactions: deni67
My mum used to stock up on different items, but she also stocked up on toilet paper and tissues, guess that is where I get it from, also cleaning products and I also stock up on cat food too. I have always gone by the saying look after the pennies and the pounds will look after themselves. An old saying but so true. Sadly younger people think that it isn't worth their time to check out specials and stock up but even if you saw for instance peas and carrots in a tin on special and brought two instead of one that is a start to having more in your cupboards so when money is even tighter at least you have food in your cupboards so you can still eat.
Speaking of toilet paper, who remembers the great outbreak of Covid in 2020, people were buying toilet paper and leaving the aisles bare, even tissues and paper towels were going off.
I have no idea why people did that, I thought it was hilarious 😂
 
Speaking of toilet paper, who remembers the great outbreak of Covid in 2020, people were buying toilet paper and leaving the aisles bare, even tissues and paper towels were going off.
I have no idea why people did that, I thought it was hilarious 😂
I remember seeing people (on the news) having a punch up in Woolies over a packet of toilet rolls. I have no idea what was going through their heads. I just hope they were not representative of the general population.
 
  • Like
  • Haha
Reactions: deni67 and Ezzy
I shop at all three biggies, depending on the specials in their catalogues which are sent by email.
The Woollies eml’d catalogue is the is the most difficult to read, or turn pages, & that is ultra frustrating.
I miss the old junk mail, it informed me of what is going on around me.

Not had a local newspaper for about ten years now and miss out on so many community events and opportunities to interact with others. We never hear of church/school fetes, anymore.
The effects of excessively long LOCKDOWNS hv destroyed the confidence of many older persons, and so many favourite shops closed down.
The repeated shutting down of public transport does not help.
Now, as the #603 bus direct to the Alfred Hospital has been chucked out, it will take Two buses to get to to The Alfred, which involves crossing extremely dangerous intersections and dodging traffic. NOT great news for this who are in constant pain and hv difficulty walking any distance.
There is no bus from where I live to my closest supermarket, and taxis refuse to do short trips from supermarket to home.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ezzy
The scary thing I take away from this story is this statement "The study analyzed consumer bank transactions" who is giving this group access to peoples accounts. Sure they may only be getting certain details, but the fact that banks are managing to extract money using our accounts pisses me off even more at the them. They keep taking but never give.
Maybe it means that the study was done using shops sales records which show the manner of payment.
 
  • Like
Reactions: deni67
I now go to a small, family owned Foodland. They have only been opened for about 18 months but have brilliant disability parking, fully clean accessible toilets and once in the store there are wide aisles and extremely good customer service. I had one of the owners stop me one day asking if I would speak with him a minute or two. He asked about parking, access to the store, comfort in traversing the aisles and my capacity to get what I required. On saying I can’t reach some products he responded with “just ask someone, anyone will help.” And they do, and assist to unload and pack my groceries and even ask if I need a hand to get them into the car. My last visits to Coles and Woolworths saw me need to use a self service, as that’s primarily what they have and I was deflected from the checkouts they had, and had to fully manage on my own. My loyalty is firmly rooted in customer service!
 
  • Like
  • Love
Reactions: Ezzy and deni67
I now go to a small, family owned Foodland. They have only been opened for about 18 months but have brilliant disability parking, fully clean accessible toilets and once in the store there are wide aisles and extremely good customer service. I had one of the owners stop me one day asking if I would speak with him a minute or two. He asked about parking, access to the store, comfort in traversing the aisles and my capacity to get what I required. On saying I can’t reach some products he responded with “just ask someone, anyone will help.” And they do, and assist to unload and pack my groceries and even ask if I need a hand to get them into the car. My last visits to Coles and Woolworths saw me need to use a self service, as that’s primarily what they have and I was deflected from the checkouts they had, and had to fully manage on my own. My loyalty is firmly rooted in customer service!
I love our local Foodland, it is apparently the largest supermarket in Australia, or was a few years ago, that might have changed.
They have the best bakery around and I love their pick and mix items, it's the only place I can get my chocolate coated aniseed rings and my lolly spuds I use to have as a kid 💗
 
  • Like
  • Love
Reactions: Ezzy and Ivory
The scary thing I take away from this story is this statement "The study analyzed consumer bank transactions" who is giving this group access to peoples accounts. Sure they may only be getting certain details, but the fact that banks are managing to extract money using our accounts pisses me off even more at the them. They keep taking but never give.
I'll give you two guesses!!! Every card transaction is scrutinized based on the items you buy.
 
Maybe it means that the study was done using shops sales records which show the manner of payment.
I agree with that, it's not like they went into peoples personal accounts to have a look, that's laughable and the original person that wrote the comment you posted on is a bit paranoid I think.
 
I agree with that, it's not like they went into peoples personal accounts to have a look, that's laughable and the original person that wrote the comment you posted on is a bit paranoid I think.
Paranoid you may well be......
 

Join the conversation

News, deals, games, and bargains for Aussies over 60. From everyday expenses like groceries and eating out, to electronics, fashion and travel, the club is all about helping you make your money go further.

Seniors Discount Club

The SDC searches for the best deals, discounts, and bargains for Aussies over 60. From everyday expenses like groceries and eating out, to electronics, fashion and travel, the club is all about helping you make your money go further.
  1. New members
  2. Jokes & fun
  3. Photography
  4. Nostalgia / Yesterday's Australia
  5. Food and Lifestyle
  6. Money Saving Hacks
  7. Offtopic / Everything else

Latest Articles

  • We believe that retirement should be a time to relax and enjoy life, not worry about money. That's why we're here to help our members make the most of their retirement years. If you're over 60 and looking for ways to save money, connect with others, and have a laugh, we’d love to have you aboard.
  • Advertise with us

User Menu

Enjoyed Reading our Story?

  • Share this forum to your loved ones.
Change Weather Postcode×
Change Petrol Postcode×