Simple yard job turns shocker as $200 plants vanish overnight

Spring has arrived in full force, bringing with it the urge to freshen up gardens and tidy outdoor spaces.

For many, it’s a chance to get stuck into long-overdue yard work. But as one homeowner recently learned, a simple day in the garden can sometimes deliver a far bigger surprise than expected.


Alexis Withers, a busy business owner who runs Bitesoft dental with her husband Luke, found herself in a bit of a bind when her regular gardener was unavailable.

Like many of us do these days, she turned to Airtasker—a popular online marketplace for odd jobs—to find someone to help tidy up her front yard.


1757298875971.png
Woman pays $200 for garden tidy-up, left shocked as plants cut to stumps instead of trimmed. Credit: @Lexii_Withers / TikTok


The job was simple: mow the lawn and give her beloved heliconias a trim, all for a tidy sum of $200.

But when Alexis returned to inspect the work, she was left absolutely gobsmacked.

Instead of a gentle tidy-up, her once-lush, palm-like heliconias had been hacked back to their stumps!


The dramatic before-and-after video she shared online shows the plants reduced to little more than bare stalks, leaving her garden looking more like a scene from a post-cyclone clean-up than a spring refresh.

‘When we saw the result, we were quite shocked,’ Alexis admitted. ‘Instead of trimming the plants, they were cut in half.’

In her video, she even pleaded with fellow green thumbs: ‘Does anyone know how I can grow back my plants quickly?’

Despite the drastic haircut, Alexis was quick to point out that the gardener was ‘such a lovely person’ and she didn’t want to make him feel uncomfortable by complaining.

Instead, she sent a polite text: ‘Next time, please just trim the leaves rather than cutting them in half.’


As for her regular gardener, Alexis confessed she’s ‘too scared’ to show him the aftermath!

The online reaction was a mixed bag. Some viewers described the scene as ‘sad’ and admitted they’d be in tears if it happened to them.

Others were more philosophical, suggesting the gardener may have actually done her a favour. ‘They’ll grow back better than ever!’ one commenter reassured.

And it turns out, there’s some truth to that. Tim Pickles, a garden centre owner, weighed in to say that while the sight of butchered plants can be confronting, it’s ‘no big deal’ in the long run.

‘They don’t like winter, the leaves get burnt by frost. They will grow back, even better, as soon as the weather warms up,’ he explained.


In fact, regular pruning of dead flowers and foliage is not only normal, but it actually encourages new, healthy growth.

The good news for Alexis—and anyone else who’s suffered a gardening shock—is that most plants are far tougher than we give them credit for.

With a bit of sunshine, water, and patience, those bare stumps will likely be bursting with new growth in no time. In fact, a hard prune can often lead to a healthier, bushier plant down the track.
Key Takeaways
  • A Sunshine Coast woman hired a gardener through Airtasker to mow her lawn and trim her heliconias for $200, but was shocked when the plants were cut down to their stumps instead of being lightly trimmed.
  • The homeowner, Alexis Withers, shared a before-and-after video online showing the dramatic difference, and asked for advice on how to regrow her plants quickly.
  • Despite being surprised by the gardener’s actions, Alexis said he was a 'lovely person' and chose not to confront him aggressively, only gently requesting less severe pruning next time.
  • Gardening experts assured that the heavy cutting was not a major problem, as the plants are likely to bounce back and grow even better with warmer weather, with many Aussies sharing mixed reactions online.
Have you ever hired someone to help in the garden and ended up with a surprise? Did your plants bounce back, or was it a lesson learned the hard way? Share your stories, tips, or even your own before-and-after photos in the comments below.

Read more: Homeowners wary of criminals targeting these items in their homes
 

Seniors Discount Club

Sponsored content

Info
Loading data . . .
We hired a painter to paint the inside and outside of our house. We have a double brick home and double story. We wanted all woodwork and gutters painted and gables.
They did an amazing job but a couple of weeks later we had heavy rain and my bedroom downstairs ceiling was leaking. This bedroom is right at the front under the first gable.

We got out a roof tiler and he said there were about 15 cracked tiles which would have happened by being walked on carelessly. Cost us $500 to fix .

As for our garden , we do get a lawnmower guy out to do the grass and edges as for the gardens , hubby would trust no one to do that
 
My experience with heliconias is they will come back - in force - with a bit of water and time.
Some plants actually benefit from a hard pruning. Himself always cuts our roses back hard every winter ('when they have stopped flowering', he says, but sometimes the roses don't realise they are expected to stop flowering!)
 
I have artificial grass on my tiny front yard. Only need to sweep up stray leaves. I love it.
The grass on the footpath is mowed by someone who did a great deal with my 2 neighbours and myself and I never have to worry about it.
I look after my own pot plants and would trust nobody else to treat them the way I do.
If I had a situation arise like this person did, I would make sure I stayed around to keep an eye on the unknown worker. Always a risk, just like online dating.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Michelle Sc
I had a similar experience. The age care gardener did the same thing(he used a chain saw) Good news - the shrubs probably needed it, they have put on a heavy growth & look better than ever. Some were cherry guava & had never flowered, now they are loaded
 
She is lucky. Once I spent 2 hours triming a row of lovely red salvia expecting a flush of blooms in spring. New lawnmower bloke decided to be helpful and take out all the socalled "dead stumps" and bin them, never to be seen again. Well that was his first and last job, and from thereon I told them only the lawn, and "absolutely nothing else" 😂
 
Is it a "male" thing? I soon learnt not to let my father & my hubby loose "weeding" Both were farmers & to them if you can't eat it, it's a weed.
 

Join the conversation

News, deals, games, and bargains for Aussies over 60. From everyday expenses like groceries and eating out, to electronics, fashion and travel, the club is all about helping you make your money go further.

Seniors Discount Club

The SDC searches for the best deals, discounts, and bargains for Aussies over 60. From everyday expenses like groceries and eating out, to electronics, fashion and travel, the club is all about helping you make your money go further.
  1. New members
  2. Jokes & fun
  3. Photography
  4. Nostalgia / Yesterday's Australia
  5. Food and Lifestyle
  6. Money Saving Hacks
  7. Offtopic / Everything else

Latest Articles

  • We believe that retirement should be a time to relax and enjoy life, not worry about money. That's why we're here to help our members make the most of their retirement years. If you're over 60 and looking for ways to save money, connect with others, and have a laugh, we’d love to have you aboard.
  • Advertise with us

User Menu

Enjoyed Reading our Story?

  • Share this forum to your loved ones.
Change Weather Postcode×
Change Petrol Postcode×