Shopper’s ‘annoying’ experience at ALDI sparks debate: ‘That stuff is a joke’

As the push for sustainability gains momentum, more people are seeking innovative ways to reduce their environmental footprint, and the paper recycling bag offers a practical solution.

ALDI, one of Australia’s largest supermarkets, also joined in on this advocacy. To reduce plastic use, they offer customers the chance to buy paper bags for their groceries.

However, a recent incident involving an ALDI customer and their paper bag has sparked a heated debate online.



An ALDI customer shared their frustration about the retailer’s paper bag—specifically its durability.

According to the customer, her shopping trip ended in disaster when the bag ripped, leaving her groceries scattered on the driveway.

The customer shared an image on social media showing a torn ALDI shopping bag next to several grocery items by the tyre of a car.


102.jpg
The ALDI shopper posted this image of the scattered groceries after her paper bag ripped. Credits: Facebook



The caption read: 'The one and only time I will use their bags. Last minute decision to even grab one. Very annoyed!!'

The items that had broken the paper bag included a large pasta salad, dog food, a pack of bacon, salami, and a few other smaller items.

The post quickly garnered attention, with many sympathising with the woman's plight.

However, others argued that the customer was at fault for not holding the bag from the bottom and overloading it with heavy and cold items.



Many defended the woman, sharing their own experiences of paper bag breakages.

'Happened to me picking up the bag at the register, that was three months ago. Will never buy the paper bag again from them,' one said.

Another lamented the shift away from plastic, saying, 'Bring back plastic bags [and] knives, forks, spoons and straws...this wood/paper stuff is a joke.'

Others pointed out that the situation could have been worse if the shopper was carrying breakable items.

'Lucky [there are] no eggs!' one user wrote.



Not everyone was quick to blame the bag, though.

Some commenters pointed out that the bag was overloaded and not properly handled.

'They are meant to be carried underneath. I don't know why they bother with handles. Old school paper bags you always carried from the bottom,' wrote one.

Another added, 'Cheese, dog food, and large pasta salad in the same bag? That'll do it.'


101.jpg
ALDI paper bags are used by customers to carry groceries without relying too much on the use of plastic. Credits: ALDI



The incident prompted calls for supermarkets to reconsider the type of bags they offer at the checkout.

Dr Trevor Thornton, from Deakin University, said that paper bags may not be the eco-friendly solution they're often portrayed as.



'The environmental impact needs to be taken into account because most of the paper bags are transported to Australia from overseas. Most paper bags are used just once because they tear or break and aren't fit for two-litre milk and large ice cream tubs,' he said.

'We also don't use paper bags multiple times like we did with plastic bags. Many of us grew up using plastic bags for multiple things, including the rubbish bin.'

Dr Thornton suggested that supermarkets need to offer better quality products to their customers.

‘If I complained about the quality of a product or the standard of food, the supermarket would do some investigations, but I've heard stories where customers are just told to buy two bags to make them sturdier’



Dr Thornton also urged for a life-cycle assessment to be conducted to determine the optimal strategy for supermarkets and other retailers concerning recyclable bags.

‘A couple of markets I go to, you can borrow a bag, but only if you return it the next time you go. It's almost sort of like a bag library,’ he shared.

He also said it would also be 'very interesting' to find out how much profit supermarket giants–Coles and Woolworths–are making by outsourcing the manufacturing of paper bags overseas.

So, next time you're at the checkout, consider your bag options carefully.

And remember, if you choose a paper bag, handle it with care and don't overload it!

You can also try other ways of carrying your groceries like this one trick shared by another ALDI shopper where she used a laundry basket to carry hers. You can read more details about it here.

Key Takeaways
  • An ALDI customer was frustrated after their paper shopping bag tore, causing their groceries to spill out onto the driveway.
  • Social media users debated who was to blame, with some suggesting it was due to user error or overloading the paper bag.
  • Dr Trevor Thornton from Deakin University commented on the environmental impact of paper bags and the need for supermarkets to reassess their approach to recyclable bags.
  • Dr Thornton also suggested that a life-cycle analysis should be done to determine the best option for supermarkets regarding carry bags, mentioning the concept of a 'bag library'.

What's your take on this issue, dear readers? Have you had a similar experience with paper bags? Share your thoughts in the comments below.
 
  • Like
Reactions: natalielocket
Sponsored
The paper bags are only meant for a few items not a heap of groceries but how long now have we taken our own bags we know the paper bags are weak but pile thins in to breaking point and wonder why buy a stronger reusable bag at least you can use it again and again leave a few in the car The paper bags are paper they will tear there’s about 8 kilos of weight in picture what do you expect
 
  • Like
Reactions: PattiB
I find it easier and more convenient to leave my bags in the car. I reload my groceries into my trolley and then pack them at my leasure in the right bag in the car. Coles & Woolworths sell reusable bags for $2, I have enough to supply my whole town. I leave them in the car in a small plastic tub. I carry one or two with me just in case. Shoppers have to take some responsibility for their shopping habits.
The supermarkets are making huge profits, reducing coustomer service, reducing checkouts to self serve and we spend our time complaining about their paper bags -don't buy them - clog the checkouts and don't use the self serve., use people power to force them to provide the service we pay for - we do all the work - do we get a pay rise - do we get invited to their Christmas Party!!! WhenI shop I give myself time to be difficult - I line up for one item. I ask for service for one item. It wouldn't take long for the managers of the stores to see what is happening - use your voice - write to the manager - ring the manager. We have the ability and the power - we just need to use it.
 
Our fruit shop chicken shop and other fresh food shops give you recyclable plastic bags. Why can’t the major supermarkets do the same. They started using plastic bags to stop our forests from being destroyed. We need forests to help our planet to survive so why are we back using all the wood
 
The ALDI paper bags are very weak, and the Coles ones aren't much better. I have my online Woolworths order delivered in their paper bags and they are stronger than the others and hold a good amount of weight.
Not everyone drives and has a car so keeping bags in your boot is not an option. I usually carry a folding bag in my handbag, but I have been caught out occasionally and need to buy a bag and have found the ALDI ones are the weakest.
 
I have a pack of 5 bags which I purchased from Coles years ago. I carry them in my handbag. Over the years I have made a few but the material is expensive. All are washable and I am never without them.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jenrobb
To the dopehat who mentioned "holding the bag" from the bottom, there is two funny loops at the top of the bag. I believe they are called "handles" and serve a purpose in moving the bag from one place to another.

Seriously, isn't the suggested weight limit for these bags 6 kgs? Feel free to correct me if I'm wrong.
 
To the dopehat who mentioned "holding the bag" from the bottom, there is two funny loops at the top of the bag. I believe they are called "handles" and serve a purpose in moving the bag from one place to another.

Seriously, isn't the suggested weight limit for these bags 6 kgs? Feel free to correct me if I'm wrong.
It's all in the design..... the Chinese are laughing all the way to the bank......
 
They go on and on about 'SAVING THE PLANET' by cutting down on plastic bags when all, or most, of the products are in plastic containers.... beats logic.
Cutting down on the use of plastics while cutting down trees to supply the raw material for the alternative. Do I see some sort of hypocrisy here?
 
I feel her pain but it was her fault for putting items such as pasta salad and cheese from the dairy cabinet in the bottom of the bag which will, of course have condensation on them causing moisture against paper bags. Of course the bag will collapse as they're not really conducive with wet goods, it's not rocket science
 
To the dopehat who mentioned "holding the bag" from the bottom, there is two funny loops at the top of the bag. I believe they are called "handles" and serve a purpose in moving the bag from one place to another.

Seriously, isn't the suggested weight limit for these bags 6 kgs? Feel free to correct me if I'm wrong.
Here it is! For the benefit of fellow SDC members.

thumbnail_IMG_20240229_102343281.jpgthumbnail_IMG_20240229_102601015.jpg
Notice the difference? Both bags have a capacity of 6 kgs BUT the Woolies bag is made in Australia from Australian materials whereas the Coles bag is made in China. :unsure:
 
Last edited:
There is a very easy solution . Make your own cotton fabric shopping bags.
I am with a craft group and we meet every Wednesday and do different projects. Over the X-mas period we were donated a large amount of cotton fabric and quite a few ladies are making shopping bags with very sturdy handles, has wadding inside , so it will last a long time . Some of the ladies make them pretty and add a quilted pocket on the outside and on the inside as well for phone , keys , wallet etc. They will all be donated to the lesser advantaged people in the country , like foster kids , disabled people , retirement villages etc, you name it. All you need is a sewing machine and they do not need to be fancy and a piece of cotton fabric. Easy to wash in your washing machine . They have a side table with all kinds of stuff , you can have and make items you like . Last week I made a cover with zipper for my iPad and also for my phone. Double fabric with wadding and it looks really good.
 
  • Like
Reactions: natalielocket
All these articles about being 'outraged, annoyed, furious and disgusted'. All first world problems! So a paper bag broke - guess what, take your own bags, or pack the damn bag properly. Take responsibility for your own actions.
 
Just take your own bags. - I bought five pretty bags from Temu and they do such a great job for $10. They fold up tiny and fit in my handbag.
 
Buy some Jute ones from KMart and take your own. By the way why aren't the supermarkets selling Jaffas, all the Allens sweets we don't want but no Jaffas.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Reaper123

Join the conversation

News, deals, games, and bargains for Aussies over 60. From everyday expenses like groceries and eating out, to electronics, fashion and travel, the club is all about helping you make your money go further.
  • We believe that retirement should be a time to relax and enjoy life, not worry about money. That's why we're here to help our members make the most of their retirement years. If you're over 60 and looking for ways to save money, connect with others, and have a laugh, we’d love to have you aboard.
  • Advertise with us

User Menu

Enjoyed Reading our Story?

  • Share this forum to your loved ones.
Change Weather Postcode×
Change Petrol Postcode×