Outrageous overcharge: How this Aussie woman was scammed out of hundreds for $6.99 item

In a world where every penny counts, especially for those who have waved goodbye to the regular paychecks of full-time employment, the thought of being overcharged is enough to make anyone's blood boil.

But imagine the shock when that overcharge isn't just a few dollars but hundreds!

This unfortunate reality befell a Sydney woman during what should have been a routine trip to her local newsagent.


The incident, which has sparked outrage and disbelief among the community, occurred when the woman, simply looking to purchase a greeting card, was charged a staggering $596.69 instead of the expected $6.99.

The woman, who shared her ordeal on social media, described feeling 'traumatised' by the experience, which unfolded at the counter of the newsagency.


1738637004423.png
Hundreds of dollars were spent on a greeting card at a newsagency in Sydney. Credit: Facebook


According to her account, the overcharge happened in a moment of distraction while entering her PIN.

She alleged that the attendant took advantage of her inattention to enter an incorrect amount into the register.

'The amount charged to my credit card is not even close to the greeting card price. It's very hard for that to be an error,' she stated, expressing her disbelief at the egregious discrepancy.


The situation escalated when she noticed the exorbitant charge on her receipt and immediately brought it to the attendant's attention.

Instead of receiving the help she expected, she claims she was met with refusal and hostility.

For 20 minutes, she pleaded for a refund, only to be 'aggressively' yelled at and spoken over by the attendant and another worker.

Feeling attacked, she called her boyfriend for support, and together, they spent an additional 25 minutes in the store trying to resolve the issue.

The woman's distressing experience took a turn for the worse when the police were called to the scene.


The owners of the Newsagent reportedly concocted a litany of excuses to avoid refunding the full amount.

‘The owners came up with every excuse as to why they couldn't refund me - they didn't know how it wasn't working, they didn't have cash, and they refused to go to an ATM to get cash out,’ she said.

‘Finally, they agreed to refund, but not the full amount [there was] a card surcharge of $10, which would be far less if the correct price of $6.99 was used.’

To add insult to injury, the woman left the store without the greeting card and, perhaps more importantly, without an apology.

‘I left the shop having been charged nearly $600, having to argue for my money back, paying $10 for a card fee, no greeting card and no apology.’ she added.

‘I typically wouldn't make a complaint unless I genuinely felt other people may be impacted.’


This is a cautionary tale for all of us, highlighting the importance of vigilance when making purchases, no matter how small.

It also underscores the need for consumer awareness and the right to demand fair treatment.

If you are in a similar situation, remember to stand your ground, ask for a manager, and, if necessary, contact your bank or financial institution to dispute the charge.
Key Takeaways
  • A Sydney woman was overcharged by hundreds of dollars for a greeting card at a newsagency.
  • She was distracted while entering her PIN and did not see the incorrect charge entered.
  • The staff at the newsagency were uncooperative when she requested a refund, leading to a confrontation.
  • The police were called, and the woman eventually received a refund minus a $10 card surcharge without receiving the card or an apology.
Have you ever been overcharged or mistreated by a retailer? How did you handle it? Share your stories in the comments below, and let's help each other stay informed and protected against such outrageous overcharges.
 

Seniors Discount Club

Sponsored content

Info
Loading data . . .
What a load of BS. Too many discrepancies in this woman's story to be true.
1. You don't put your pin in until the
price has registered.
2. You don't require a pin for $6.99.
3. If this happened, which it definitely
wouldn't have, it only required a
refund on your card. A simple
enough transaction.

I do not believe any business owner would refuse to give you a refund if such a mistake had been made

Expecting to get cash as a refund is ridiculous anyway. If you pay by card and for some reason you need a refund the refund is always put on your card, not in cash, unless it's just a small amount.

Also, looking at the receipt, they conveniently don't show the name, nor does it show that a card was purchased. Usually the receipt lists what was purchased.
Looks more like something that was computer generated or some old receipt for something else.
If this was a true story you'd be more than happy to show the name of the store that supposedly treated you so
badly.

This is just a made up story by somebody
looking for 5 minutes of fame.
If you're going to make up a story then at least have enough brains to make up one that people can't shoot holes through.

I'm surprised SDC even bothered to print it
C"mon guys wakey wakey
 
Last edited:
I can believe it happens, I got overcharged at Coles because the checkout c*ck counted 5 and entered 6 items instead of using the scanner.
Most cards don't have barcodes, they enter the amount in manually.
And she was distracted, let me guess; she was on her phone, which is the rudest thing you can do when you are at a counter.
Yeah the rest of it is an overkill about having the police and everything about trying to get a refund
 
Woolworths prefers to go paperless now, wishing you well without giving a paper receipt. Sure, you can check it on your phone later, but I prefer to get a paper receipt so that I can clear any discrepancies straight away. Not have to travel back to the store to clear it.
I ALWAYS get a paper receipt; the number of times I have been incorrectly charged (to the store's advantage), has been unbelievable! Fortunately, I have not had to go to extent of bringing in the law when querying the receipt and in a couple of cases, received both refund AND the product ..... :)
 
I never enter my PIN until I see the amount on the screen of the bank's machine. I have never had an experience like this but the story doesn't ring true anyway. There is no reason why the attendant would have entered an amount like that. I get my docket & check before leaving the store that it is still correct. I hate the way I get asked "do you want your docket?" as that makes me suspicious of the possibility of some sort of fraud if I don't take it. It's sad the way things are today that such a simple thing as this can make me suspicious of people's intentions.
I don't use either a debit or credit card Elaine, only cash .....
 
Yes ..... and boycott them!
Honestly mate. You don’t really believe this woman's story do you???
You can shoot holes through it from start to finish.
Firstly the receipt shows no name (convenient) doesn't show what she bought (since when does that happen)
Cards have the price on the back of them and get scanned which then registers on the receipt so the attendant couldn't change it.
She said the owner didn't have enough cash and wouldn't go to the ATM and get it. Since when do you get a cash refund for a card transaction.
I don't believe for one minute that a shop owner would refuse to refund you a $500 overpayment.
Nowhere did she mention the name of the shop because she'd be sued.
I don’t even believe this happened, but even if it did I would say she was trying to pull a scam with a false receipt (as easy as pie to do today with computers)
and that was the reason the store staff would argue with her.
I really can't believe so many people are buying into this story.

Biggest load of crock I've ever heard.
 
Last edited:
I can believe it happens, I got overcharged at Coles because the checkout c*ck counted 5 and entered 6 items instead of using the scanner.
Most cards don't have barcodes, they enter the amount in manually.
And she was distracted, let me guess; she was on her phone, which is the rudest thing you can do when you are at a counter.
Yeah the rest of it is an overkill about having the police and everything about trying to get a refund
Cards worth $6.99 would have the price printed on the back not a barcode.
Usually only the $2 or $3 cards are not printed with a price
Yes, mistakes are made but this story is BS.
 
Woolworths prefers to go paperless now, wishing you well without giving a paper receipt. Sure, you can check it on your phone later, but I prefer to get a paper receipt so that I can clear any discrepancies straight away. Not have to travel back to the store to clear it.
You can still check your receipt before leaving the store as it goes to your phone instantly.
 
This part gets me:

"According to her account, the overcharge happened in a moment of distraction while entering her PIN."
You don't put a pin in for that small amount.

But then again, the receipt looks legit, it's the bottom of it so it doesn't show up what she brought and where from.
And another thing, if she queried this straight away then there would have been no time to dummy up the receipt. She would have had to have gone home then back to the shop again and there would be a record of the police attendance with the time and date.
I'm a Photoshop semi pro and that wouldn't be easy to do, plus you'd have to have the exact paper they use. The writing on the receipts are quite small and you would have to have matched the font exactly.
Taking all of that into consideration it's not an easy thing to do unless you were a pro and I really don't think she is, but that's all my opinion.
 

Join the conversation

News, deals, games, and bargains for Aussies over 60. From everyday expenses like groceries and eating out, to electronics, fashion and travel, the club is all about helping you make your money go further.

Seniors Discount Club

The SDC searches for the best deals, discounts, and bargains for Aussies over 60. From everyday expenses like groceries and eating out, to electronics, fashion and travel, the club is all about helping you make your money go further.
  1. New members
  2. Jokes & fun
  3. Photography
  4. Nostalgia / Yesterday's Australia
  5. Food and Lifestyle
  6. Money Saving Hacks
  7. Offtopic / Everything else
  • We believe that retirement should be a time to relax and enjoy life, not worry about money. That's why we're here to help our members make the most of their retirement years. If you're over 60 and looking for ways to save money, connect with others, and have a laugh, we’d love to have you aboard.
  • Advertise with us

User Menu

Enjoyed Reading our Story?

  • Share this forum to your loved ones.
Change Weather Postcode×
Change Petrol Postcode×