Navigating the car parks of shopping centres can be a tricky affair, especially when time slips away as you wander the aisles or catch up with friends over a coffee. But what happens when you return to your car to find a $65 fine slapped on your windshield for overstaying your welcome? This is the dilemma that has sparked a fiery debate among Australian shoppers, and it's a situation that's all too familiar for one Perth woman.



After a routine visit to the Galleria shopping complex in Perth's northeast, a local shopper was left fuming when she discovered a parking fine for exceeding the free parking limit. Despite being a loyal customer for over two decades, she took to social media to express her disbelief and frustration, igniting a conversation about the enforceability of such fines on privately-owned property.


The Galleria's website boasts free parking for customers, but with a catch: there's a time limit of three hours, or five in certain areas. If you overstay, you risk a penalty. The centre insists that this policy is well-signposted throughout the car park, but that hasn't stopped many from questioning the legitimacy of the fines issued.



The debate is a heated one, with some Australians firmly believing that these fines are not legally binding. 'You are not legally obliged to pay these sorts of fines, they cannot be enforced,' one commenter declared. Others shared personal anecdotes of ignoring similar fines with no repercussions, suggesting that these penalties are more bark than bite.

The sentiment is echoed by many who argue that only statutory bodies, such as the police or council parking rangers, have the authority to issue legally enforceable fines. This perspective is not without merit, as private security firms do not hold the same powers as these official entities.

Adding legal weight to the debate, lawyer James Clements has previously shed light on the issue, describing these penalties as 'bullying tactics' and highlighting the difficulty in enforcement. He points out that private parking companies have faced government crackdowns preventing them from accessing driver information to collect fees. Moreover, they must prove who was driving at the time of the infringement, which is not always straightforward.



For those who find themselves in this predicament, Mr. Clements advises either ignoring the fine or disputing it without admitting to being the driver. This could prevent the situation from escalating to court.

However, prevention is better than cure. To avoid the hassle and potential legal tangles, it's wise for drivers to be vigilant about reading signs and understanding the terms and conditions upon entering a private car park. After all, knowledge is power, and in this case, it could save you $65.

At the Seniors Discount Club, we understand that every penny counts, and unexpected fines can be a significant inconvenience. We encourage our members to share their experiences and tips on dealing with parking fines at shopping centres. Have you ever been fined, and if so, did you pay or contest it? Join the conversation in the comments below and let's navigate these murky waters together.




Remember, if you're ever unsure about your rights or the best course of action, seeking legal advice can provide clarity and peace of mind. And for any other tips or stories you'd like to share with our community, don't hesitate to reach out to us at [email protected]. Let's help each other stay informed and empowered!