Learner driver turned away over 'not orange enough' blinkers sparks debate—is it fair?

Navigating the road to getting a driver's license can be fraught with unexpected detours, as one Sydney resident discovered when they were turned away from their driving test for an obscure road rule violation.

The incident has sparked a conversation among Australians about the importance of understanding the nuances of road regulations, even those that might seem trivial at first glance.


The prospective driver took to social media to express their frustration after Service NSW refused to let them sit their driving test.

The reason was that their car's indicator lights were deemed 'not orange enough.'


1723771076475.png
Sydney driver turned away from test over 'not orange enough' blinkers. Credit: Reddit


This left the learner driver questioning the decision's fairness, especially since mechanics had never flagged them for this issue during routine services.

‘Is this reasonable?’ the learner asked.

‘We’ve had it serviced by multiple mechanics over the years, but no one's mentioned it. They also refused to refund me.’


The online community quickly weighed in, with many expressing surprise over enforcing such a rule.

Some sympathised with the driver, stating, ‘Yeah, that’s BS, mate, can’t get much more orange than that, can it?’

Others suggested they lodge a complaint, while others humorously recommended a 'blinker fluid top-up.'

When approached for comment, ServiceNSW did not discuss the individual case but emphasised the importance of ensuring a vehicle meets all standards before a driving test.

‘Before a driving test starts, the testing officer will ensure the applicant’s vehicle is suitable and safe for use,’ the spokesperson said.

‘There are several reasons a driving test can be terminated, including the applicant’s vehicle indicator lights not operating, being damaged, dirty, or discoloured.’


The uploaded footage of the incident showed a silver SUV with a blinking indicator light that appeared sufficiently orange and luminous to the average person.

However, the law in NSW is specific about vehicle requirements for driving tests.

The state government's website clearly states that a test will be terminated if any indicator offences, such as discoloured lights, cannot be rectified at the time of the test.


In similar news, calls are increasing for stricter regulations on older drivers in Victoria due to concerning accident statistics involving drivers over 65.

Disturbing figures show that older drivers were responsible for accidents resulting in 145 deaths and injurious to 7,080 over five years. You can read more about it here.
Key Takeaways
  • A Sydney prospective driver claimed they were turned away from their driving test because their car's blinkers weren't 'orange enough.'
  • The incident sparked debate on social media, with some expressing shock and others suggesting that the rule should be known.
  • ServiceNSW explained that a driving test could be terminated for reasons including indicator lights that do not operate or are discoloured.
  • The NSW government stipulates that vehicles must meet safety standards, including maintaining properly functioning and coloured indicator lights for driving tests.
Have you or someone you know ever been caught off guard by a little-known road rule? Share your experiences in the comments below.
 

Seniors Discount Club

Sponsored content

Info
Loading data . . .
If the car is legally registered then they should not be able to do this.
Australia you are becoming a very unfriendly place.
What they could have done was let them do the test but also issue a notice to the owner to get the lights updated. As this is not the Learners fault but the car owner.
 
I have never heard of this road rule, but...….there are an awful lot of vehicles out there where the blinker lights just don't stand up to the question, they are in obscure places, they are barely seeable. Maybe all blinkers should be in the same places on all vehicles.
 
How many times have you seen a car with the faded light problems, parts hanging off the car, lights & indicators that don't work at all & rust. The police should be checking on where the problem cars were passed for their rego check instead of only targeting the owner.
 
From the Australian Design Rules Vehicle Standard (Australian Design Rule 6/00 – Direction Indicators) 2005.
Annex 5

COLOUR- OF AMBER LIGHTS:

TRICHROMATIC CO-ORDINATES

Limit towards yellow: y<0.429

Limit towards red: y>0.398

Limit towards white: z<0.007​

For checking these colorimetric characteristics, a source of light at a colour temperature of 2,856 K corresponding to illuminant A of the International Commission on Illumination (CIE) shall be used in conformity with the Convention on Road Traffic (E/ CONF.56/16/Rev.1).

I highly doubt that the examiner had the correct chromatic testing equipment to make this determination. He or she just made an uniformed opinion!
 
Interesting to note that many turn indicators on modern cars use orange bulbs and a clear lense. In bright sunlight these can be difficult to recognise when flashing. Other modern blinkers are garishly bright and thus affect one's night vision, as do those bloody blue headlights the light from which one cannot see past.
 
Interesting to note that many turn indicators on modern cars use orange bulbs and a clear lense. In bright sunlight these can be difficult to recognise when flashing. Other modern blinkers are garishly bright and thus affect one's night vision, as do those bloody blue headlights the light from which one cannot see past.
You hit the nail in the head right there!

When I rode motorcycles, I fitted the maximum available wattage headlight globe and replaced to pissy horns with two from a Holden or Ford. Just to be seen and heard! Not entirely successful, may I add.
 
You hit the nail in the head right there!

When I rode motorcycles, I fitted the maximum available wattage headlight globe and replaced to pissy horns with two from a Holden or Ford. Just to be seen and heard! Not entirely successful, may I add.
I recall doing (max wattage headlight bulb) that to 34 watt 6-volt Miller dynamo before coming back home at night from London. We went straight over the only traffic island without advertising hoarding on the Oxford by-pass which sprung out upon us in the dark too suddenly to swerve around. Josef Lucas' 60 watt 6-volt dynamos were far better. I could dazzle car drivers when riding with high beam; however in these days of bloody blue headlights at eye level on SUVs, my days of night bike-riding are over. Even the modern yellow headlights are overbright for need.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Veggiepatch
I had a chat with a NSW highway patrol officer regarding some drivers using those blinding front low visibility/ fog lights in good conditions even during daylight hours.
These can be just as bad as an on-coming vehicle with high beam turned on.
According to him it is an offence and they conducted a blitz on this the previous long weekend.
Same fine as using your high beam.
If you wish to be seen and do not have day time running lights then use your headlights.
 
I recall doing (max wattage headlight bulb) that to 34 watt 6-volt Miller dynamo before coming back home at night from London. We went straight over the only traffic island without advertising hoarding on the Oxford by-pass which sprung out upon us in the dark too suddenly to swerve around. Josef Lucas' 60 watt 6-volt dynamos were far better. I could dazzle car drivers when riding with high beam; however in these days of bloody blue headlights at eye level on SUVs, my days of night bike-riding are over. Even the modern yellow headlights are overbright for need.
As an afterthought, thanks to my misunderstanding of what wattage headlight globe I needed for that Miller dynamo my eyes had become well adapted to good night vision and I recall being dazzled by the street lights beyond that roundabout reflecting light off the very wet road, hence that roundabout emerged from the dark rather suddenly and all one could was go over the top so as to maintain stability on two wheels. At night contrast is all-important as our colour-vision photo-receptors become unused and we rely on sensing contrasts in terms of greys and black. With bright lights in the distance, greys and blacks become the same shade.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Veggiepatch

Join the conversation

News, deals, games, and bargains for Aussies over 60. From everyday expenses like groceries and eating out, to electronics, fashion and travel, the club is all about helping you make your money go further.

Seniors Discount Club

The SDC searches for the best deals, discounts, and bargains for Aussies over 60. From everyday expenses like groceries and eating out, to electronics, fashion and travel, the club is all about helping you make your money go further.
  1. New members
  2. Jokes & fun
  3. Photography
  4. Nostalgia / Yesterday's Australia
  5. Food and Lifestyle
  6. Money Saving Hacks
  7. Offtopic / Everything else

Latest Articles

  • We believe that retirement should be a time to relax and enjoy life, not worry about money. That's why we're here to help our members make the most of their retirement years. If you're over 60 and looking for ways to save money, connect with others, and have a laugh, we’d love to have you aboard.
  • Advertise with us

User Menu

Enjoyed Reading our Story?

  • Share this forum to your loved ones.
Change Weather Postcode×
Change Petrol Postcode×