Feel manipulated by supermarkets’ dishonest markdowns? You’re not alone

We all want great deals and savings, especially during these current periods of high inflation when prices for almost everything are soaring and we see a decrease in our purchasing power. The temptation to grab anything on sale to get your money’s worth is tempting, but are we really getting the best prices?

If you feel like the sale tags you’re seeing these days are too good to be true, you’re not the only one. On Reddit, price-conscious Aussies were recently discussing supermarket practices that are possibly dishonest and misleading.


For example, one user noticed that the price of Cheer Tasty slices had increased from its ‘regular’ price of $11 to $17.55 for two weeks but then was brought ‘down down’ to $14, leading members of the Australian Personal Finance subreddit to discuss their observations on their local groceries.

collage.png
Before and after: is it really a ‘down down’ price, or are shoppers being tricked into thinking they’re getting a great deal? Credit: Reddit

A top comment said: ‘They did this before the pandemic, raising prices, dropping them to more than they originally were, and then patting themselves on the back and praising themselves for low prices.’

Another chimed in: ‘It’s disgusting and they know it sells because you see a ‘down down’ tag and automatically assume you are on the winning side. I wouldn’t call that a low price.’

A third commented: ‘It's merchandising basics, really. One of my first jobs was as an activation rep for an alcohol company and we'd always put a bright neon starburst tag on anything that wasn't selling with ‘only $x!’ on it. It would then start to sell.’



unnamed.png
According to a price tracking website, PriceHipster, the ‘sale’ price of $14 on the item is still 40% more than it was in November last year.

It is, indeed, a practice that has been around even before the pandemic. And it’s not only in Australia – dodgy deals have also been noticed in neighbouring countries such as New Zealand.

Someone said: ‘It’s a sh***y practice. Coles introduced their new nut bars for $6 a pack a few months ago, and I thought, ‘Jeez, that's expensive.’ Lo and behold, a month later, they were ‘down down’ to their new price of $4.’

A commenter tried to defend the practice by saying: ‘Huh? Isn't that how literally every retail store works, ever? New products/stock are priced high, then lowered in price if they can't sell it all at that price point.’

Another user pointed out what’s wrong with this strategy: ‘It isn't a discount to move a product that isn't selling. It was pretty clear that $6 was never going to be the actual price for a pack of 5 basic nut bars.’ They continued: ‘Instead, it was an artificial price point so that they could then promote it at a reduced price.’


It’s probably even more glaring in December, as one user shared: ‘They're literally doing it for Christmas stock right now. Get a small amount of stock a month early with prices no one will pay, and then suddenly, come December, the ‘sale prices’ are "discounted" every week.’

The practice could be categorised as ‘misleading price displays’. According to the Australian Competition and Consumer Protection (ACCC), ‘Businesses must not display prices that are wrong or likely to create a false impression. This includes prices displayed in stores, in advertising, or whenever communicating with customers.’

According to the ACCC, some examples of misleading price displays include the following:
  • Stating the sale price is marked down from an earlier price when:
    • the items were not sold at that price in a reasonable period right before the sale started, or
    • only a very small proportion of items were sold at that price right before the sale.
  • Comparing the displayed price with an incorrect cost or wholesale price.
  • Comparing the displayed price to a recommended retail price (RRP) that no one generally charges for the product.
  • Promoting a price as being a sale or special price, when it is actually the normal price. Where an item is offered at a sale or special price for an extended period of time, it may be misleading to call it a sale or special price, as the price has effectively become the new selling price.
  • Advertising a price that is not the total price the consumer will have to pay.
However, there is a loophole that businesses exploit in cases such as these, as a ‘reasonable period’ is not properly defined by the law. The ACCC says: ‘What’s considered to be a reasonable period in the circumstances will vary from case to case and will depend on the type of product or market involved and usual frequency of price changes for that product or in that market.’


This is how one Redditor puts it: ‘If people bought the product at a higher price, in some cases, that's enough to establish that the product was at that higher price to now show a sale. If there were no sales but it can be established that the product was at that higher price for a reasonable amount of time, that shows that a consumer could have bought at that price, then that is also sometimes accepted.’

When grocery shopping, it pays to remember that everything inside a supermarket is designed to make you stay longer and spend more money, from the layout to the lighting. Even colours can push us to buy – did you know that bananas with peels that were Pantone colour 12-0752 (Buttercup) were more likely to sell than when they’re slightly brighter?


In 1982, a popular study also found that stores with background music saw customers spend 34 per cent more time shopping, which also meant more revenue. Other research revealed that we are only rationally selective when shopping within a 40 minute time period. Beyond that, people are more likely to shop emotionally, spending at least 50 per cent more on things they did not intend to buy when first going in.

How do you avoid the psychological traps in supermarkets, then? The National Geographic’s advice is simple: ‘Make a list and stick to it. Try not to shop so often – fewer and more efficient trips to the store are easier on the pocketbook – and don’t shop when you’re hungry.’

What do you think, folks? Have you encountered misleading sale tags in your local supermarkets? Let us know in the comments!
 
Sponsored
What I find misleading is that these Supermarkets say they have thousands of markdowns every week and sure they do. Great if you are constantly buying cleaning materials, personal hygiene products, hair dye or make-up. They are not so hot on food items discounts which is what all of us need on a weekly basis. ;)
 
What I find misleading is that these Supermarkets say they have thousands of markdowns every week and sure they do. Great if you are constantly buying cleaning materials, personal hygiene products, hair dye or make-up. They are not so hot on food items discounts which is what all of us need on a weekly basis. ;)
Plus unnecessary items such as coke and other sweet products.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jennie and Macarj
I like to get the catalogues to remind me of something I may be running short of so that I can get them at the reduced price. Not only is it the grocery stores that seem to inflate prices one week then say they are down a couple of weeks later BUt it is the big store such HM and some furniture stores who constantly try to tell us prices are on sale for 50% or more off. How come and who is gullible to think they are getting a bargain?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ricci and Macarj
What I find misleading is that these Supermarkets say they have thousands of markdowns every week and sure they do. Great if you are constantly buying cleaning materials, personal hygiene products, hair dye or make-up. They are not so hot on food items discounts which is what all of us need on a weekly basis. ;)
add chocolate and sweet treats to that list too. Food - real healthy food doesn't get a look in.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ricci
We all want great deals and savings, especially during these current periods of high inflation when prices for almost everything are soaring and we see a decrease in our purchasing power. The temptation to grab anything on sale to get your money’s worth is tempting, but are we really getting the best prices?

If you feel like the sale tags you’re seeing these days are too good to be true, you’re not the only one. On Reddit, price-conscious Aussies were recently discussing supermarket practices that are possibly dishonest and misleading.


For example, one user noticed that the price of Cheer Tasty slices had increased from its ‘regular’ price of $11 to $17.55 for two weeks but then was brought ‘down down’ to $14, leading members of the Australian Personal Finance subreddit to discuss their observations on their local groceries.

View attachment 10935
Before and after: is it really a ‘down down’ price, or are shoppers being tricked into thinking they’re getting a great deal? Credit: Reddit

A top comment said: ‘They did this before the pandemic, raising prices, dropping them to more than they originally were, and then patting themselves on the back and praising themselves for low prices.’

Another chimed in: ‘It’s disgusting and they know it sells because you see a ‘down down’ tag and automatically assume you are on the winning side. I wouldn’t call that a low price.’

A third commented: ‘It's merchandising basics, really. One of my first jobs was as an activation rep for an alcohol company and we'd always put a bright neon starburst tag on anything that wasn't selling with ‘only $x!’ on it. It would then start to sell.’



View attachment 10937
According to a price tracking website, PriceHipster, the ‘sale’ price of $14 on the item is still 40% more than it was in November last year.

It is, indeed, a practice that has been around even before the pandemic. And it’s not only in Australia – dodgy deals have also been noticed in neighbouring countries such as New Zealand.

Someone said: ‘It’s a sh***y practice. Coles introduced their new nut bars for $6 a pack a few months ago, and I thought, ‘Jeez, that's expensive.’ Lo and behold, a month later, they were ‘down down’ to their new price of $4.’

A commenter tried to defend the practice by saying: ‘Huh? Isn't that how literally every retail store works, ever? New products/stock are priced high, then lowered in price if they can't sell it all at that price point.’

Another user pointed out what’s wrong with this strategy: ‘It isn't a discount to move a product that isn't selling. It was pretty clear that $6 was never going to be the actual price for a pack of 5 basic nut bars.’ They continued: ‘Instead, it was an artificial price point so that they could then promote it at a reduced price.’


It’s probably even more glaring in December, as one user shared: ‘They're literally doing it for Christmas stock right now. Get a small amount of stock a month early with prices no one will pay, and then suddenly, come December, the ‘sale prices’ are "discounted" every week.’

The practice could be categorised as ‘misleading price displays’. According to the Australian Competition and Consumer Protection (ACCC), ‘Businesses must not display prices that are wrong or likely to create a false impression. This includes prices displayed in stores, in advertising, or whenever communicating with customers.’

According to the ACCC, some examples of misleading price displays include the following:
  • Stating the sale price is marked down from an earlier price when:
    • the items were not sold at that price in a reasonable period right before the sale started, or
    • only a very small proportion of items were sold at that price right before the sale.
  • Comparing the displayed price with an incorrect cost or wholesale price.
  • Comparing the displayed price to a recommended retail price (RRP) that no one generally charges for the product.
  • Promoting a price as being a sale or special price, when it is actually the normal price. Where an item is offered at a sale or special price for an extended period of time, it may be misleading to call it a sale or special price, as the price has effectively become the new selling price.
  • Advertising a price that is not the total price the consumer will have to pay.
However, there is a loophole that businesses exploit in cases such as these, as a ‘reasonable period’ is not properly defined by the law. The ACCC says: ‘What’s considered to be a reasonable period in the circumstances will vary from case to case and will depend on the type of product or market involved and usual frequency of price changes for that product or in that market.’


This is how one Redditor puts it: ‘If people bought the product at a higher price, in some cases, that's enough to establish that the product was at that higher price to now show a sale. If there were no sales but it can be established that the product was at that higher price for a reasonable amount of time, that shows that a consumer could have bought at that price, then that is also sometimes accepted.’

When grocery shopping, it pays to remember that everything inside a supermarket is designed to make you stay longer and spend more money, from the layout to the lighting. Even colours can push us to buy – did you know that bananas with peels that were Pantone colour 12-0752 (Buttercup) were more likely to sell than when they’re slightly brighter?


In 1982, a popular study also found that stores with background music saw customers spend 34 per cent more time shopping, which also meant more revenue. Other research revealed that we are only rationally selective when shopping within a 40 minute time period. Beyond that, people are more likely to shop emotionally, spending at least 50 per cent more on things they did not intend to buy when first going in.

How do you avoid the psychological traps in supermarkets, then? The National Geographic’s advice is simple: ‘Make a list and stick to it. Try not to shop so often – fewer and more efficient trips to the store are easier on the pocketbook – and don’t shop when you’re hungry.’

What do you think, folks? Have you encountered misleading sale tags in your local supermarkets? Let us know in the comments!
Well one day a long while back I saw the yellow special tag for a product and for some reason I felt there seemed something suss about it, so I lifted the specials tag up to look at the usual price and was so annoyed that the yellow specials tag was the same price as the usual tag underneath🙄so anytime I see a special, I check the one underneath first😆
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ricci

Join the conversation

News, deals, games, and bargains for Aussies over 60. From everyday expenses like groceries and eating out, to electronics, fashion and travel, the club is all about helping you make your money go further.

Seniors Discount Club

The SDC searches for the best deals, discounts, and bargains for Aussies over 60. From everyday expenses like groceries and eating out, to electronics, fashion and travel, the club is all about helping you make your money go further.
  1. New members
  2. Jokes & fun
  3. Photography
  4. Nostalgia / Yesterday's Australia
  5. Food and Lifestyle
  6. Money Saving Hacks
  7. Offtopic / Everything else

Latest Articles

  • We believe that retirement should be a time to relax and enjoy life, not worry about money. That's why we're here to help our members make the most of their retirement years. If you're over 60 and looking for ways to save money, connect with others, and have a laugh, we’d love to have you aboard.
  • Advertise with us

User Menu

Enjoyed Reading our Story?

  • Share this forum to your loved ones.
Change Weather Postcode×
Change Petrol Postcode×