Another lawsuit against a popular airline for ‘misleading’ customers - here’s what you need to know

Business class is often considered to be the epitome of travel, and many of us, save up for years to take that once-in-a-lifetime trip. However, what happens when that luxury you've saved for is different from what you were promised?

A recent case suggests you can take legal action to fight for what you've paid for. In an extraordinary event, an energy trader from Australia sued Emirates Airlines for 'misleading advertising' and horrific business class experiences, ultimately hoping to win back almost $5,000 from the company.



Brodie Chapman, who runs his own wholesale energy firm and travels up to 20 times a year with Emirates, was left extremely disappointed after the 'disgusting' business class seat didn't live up to his expectations.

'The seats were grubby, there were socks stuck down the side of my chair, it didn't recline properly, one of the screens didn't work, and there were stains on the seat,' complained Mr Chapman.

Chapman's case was bolstered by a previous victory in New Zealand's disputes tribunal, where Kiwi surgeon Mark Morgan successfully won the equivalent of roughly $12,600 after the court found that Emirates' business class service was not as advertised. Dr Morgan's experience involved worn-out seats that didn't lie flat and lacked the amenities that were promised.




1684134455454.png

Mark Morgan expressed his disappointment, stating that the reality fell short of expectations, leaving him and his wife with no choice but to endure uncomfortable seating on worn-out chairs. Source: dailymail.co.uk


Chapman alleged that the Emirates airline only advertises the A380 or new 777 interiors, and accused them of effectively 'mis-selling' the product. The airline defended by stating that it cannot guarantee any particular aircraft will be used and that products and services may vary on actual flights.

Daily Mail Australia reported that after this incident, others who have been similarly affected by the airline reached out to Dr Morgan for advice to pursue compensation claims.



So, what can we take away from these events?​

  1. Read the fine print carefully before booking your airfare, especially if the aircraft and amenities are important to you.
  2. Speak up and make your complaints known to the airline if your experience does not match what was advertised, and perhaps even seek compensation if the situation warrants it.
  3. Share your experience with fellow travellers, so others know what to expect and can make informed choices when purchasing their tickets.


Airline Passenger Rights and Compensation Regulations​

Ensuring that airline passengers are treated fairly is essential for the industry, and it’s why there are strict regulations and laws in place. Both the airline and the passenger must be aware of the regulations, as well as their rights and responsibilities when it comes to booking and taking flights.

One of the most important regulations for passengers relates to compensation for being denied boarding due to overbooking. Airlines must provide compensation, either in the form of money or vouchers, when this occurs, and in some cases, airlines may be required to pay nearly three times the cost of the ticket.



In addition, airlines must also adhere to certain standards and regulations when it comes to their advertising. Airlines must not misrepresent their services to passengers, and the regulations in place stipulate that airlines must not make false promises or use advertising materials that are deceptive.

Understanding what the regulations are is key to protecting the rights of airline passengers and making sure compensation is paid when required. This is why it's important to be informed when booking flights, and to take action if necessary if the flight experience is not as advertised.



Key Takeaways
  • An energy trader is suing Emirates over 'disgusting' business class seats on a flight, claiming the airline mis-sold his ticket.
  • Brodie Chapman is hoping to win back almost $5,000 from the airline after being disappointed by the standard of his business-class experience.
  • Chapman's bid for compensation follows a Kiwi surgeon who won thousands of dollars from Emirates after taking them to New Zealand's disputes tribunal over misleading advertising.
  • Emirates maintains that the services provided on flights may vary depending on aircraft and operational requirements and asserts that Chapman experienced only a 5% reduction in quality compared to the service advertised.
Here at the Seniors Discount Club, we love to see our members fight for fairness and what they've paid for. If you do embark on that once-in-a-lifetime trip, we truly hope it is everything you've dreamed of and advertised to be. Safe travels, dear members!
 
Sponsored
Business class is often considered to be the epitome of travel, and many of us, save up for years to take that once-in-a-lifetime trip. However, what happens when that luxury you've saved for is different from what you were promised?

A recent case suggests you can take legal action to fight for what you've paid for. In an extraordinary event, an energy trader from Australia sued Emirates Airlines for 'misleading advertising' and horrific business class experiences, ultimately hoping to win back almost $5,000 from the company.



Brodie Chapman, who runs his own wholesale energy firm and travels up to 20 times a year with Emirates, was left extremely disappointed after the 'disgusting' business class seat didn't live up to his expectations.

'The seats were grubby, there were socks stuck down the side of my chair, it didn't recline properly, one of the screens didn't work, and there were stains on the seat,' complained Mr Chapman.

Chapman's case was bolstered by a previous victory in New Zealand's disputes tribunal, where Kiwi surgeon Mark Morgan successfully won the equivalent of roughly $12,600 after the court found that Emirates' business class service was not as advertised. Dr Morgan's experience involved worn-out seats that didn't lie flat and lacked the amenities that were promised.




View attachment 19851

Mark Morgan expressed his disappointment, stating that the reality fell short of expectations, leaving him and his wife with no choice but to endure uncomfortable seating on worn-out chairs. Source: dailymail.co.uk


Chapman alleged that the Emirates airline only advertises the A380 or new 777 interiors, and accused them of effectively 'mis-selling' the product. The airline defended by stating that it cannot guarantee any particular aircraft will be used and that products and services may vary on actual flights.

Daily Mail Australia reported that after this incident, others who have been similarly affected by the airline reached out to Dr Morgan for advice to pursue compensation claims.



So, what can we take away from these events?​

  1. Read the fine print carefully before booking your airfare, especially if the aircraft and amenities are important to you.
  2. Speak up and make your complaints known to the airline if your experience does not match what was advertised, and perhaps



  1. even seek compensation if the situation warrants it.
  2. Share your experience with fellow travellers, so others know what to expect and can make informed choices when purchasing their tickets.


Airline Passenger Rights and Compensation Regulations​

Ensuring that airline passengers are treated fairly is essential for the industry, and it’s why there are strict regulations and laws in place. Both the airline and the passenger must be aware of the regulations, as well as their rights and responsibilities when it comes to booking and taking flights.

One of the most important regulations for passengers relates to compensation for being denied boarding due to overbooking. Airlines must provide compensation, either in the form of money or vouchers, when this occurs, and in some cases, airlines may be required to pay nearly three times the cost of the ticket.



In addition, airlines must also adhere to certain standards and regulations when it comes to their advertising. Airlines must not misrepresent their services to passengers, and the regulations in place stipulate that airlines must not make false promises or use advertising materials that are deceptive.

Understanding what the regulations are is key to protecting the rights of airline passengers and making sure compensation is paid when required. This is why it's important to be informed when booking flights, and to take action if necessary if the flight experience is not as advertised.



Key Takeaways

  • An energy trader is suing Emirates over 'disgusting' business class seats on a flight, claiming the airline mis-sold his ticket.
  • Brodie Chapman is hoping to win back almost $5,000 from the airline after being disappointed by the standard of his business-class experience.
  • Chapman's bid for compensation follows a Kiwi surgeon who won thousands of dollars from Emirates after taking them to New Zealand's disputes tribunal over misleading advertising.
  • Emirates maintains that the services provided on flights may vary depending on aircraft and operational requirements and asserts that Chapman experienced only a 5% reduction in quality compared to the service advertised.
Here at the Seniors Discount Club, we love to see our members fight for fairness and what they've paid for. If you do embark on that once-in-a-lifetime trip, we truly hope it is everything you've dreamed of and advertised to be. Safe travels, dear members!
We travelled Newcastle to Perth one way on credit saved from covid lockdown cancelations with Virgin Airlines. Because I was recuperating from a serious leg injury we decided to blow all the credit on 'comfortable' business class seats. They weren't as good as Japan's Jal premium coach. Nice staff as usual but as 'business' class seats we gave them a 1/5 rating. We had an oldie 737 experience which was very poor compared to their excellent A33 business class seats. There also was rubbish from the last occupant in the magazine holder and jammed in the side of my seat. Shoulda gone Qantas 😪 😁
 
My how times have changed, we are becoming the next land of litigation. If I have a problem when I fly I speak to the flight crew and they always go out of their way to help rectify any problems that I have, be they personal or with the aircraft, seating etc. I find that people expect too much, too often. By all means, if your seating area has not been cleaned down thoroughly from the last flight it is not the crew's fault. That is the job of someone else and ranting and raving at the crew is only going to put them offside with you straight up. Bring it to their attention, when they get a chance they will do something about it, the same with seat maintenance, passengers complain instead of bringing it to their attention.
 

Join the conversation

News, deals, games, and bargains for Aussies over 60. From everyday expenses like groceries and eating out, to electronics, fashion and travel, the club is all about helping you make your money go further.

Seniors Discount Club

The SDC searches for the best deals, discounts, and bargains for Aussies over 60. From everyday expenses like groceries and eating out, to electronics, fashion and travel, the club is all about helping you make your money go further.
  1. New members
  2. Jokes & fun
  3. Photography
  4. Nostalgia / Yesterday's Australia
  5. Food and Lifestyle
  6. Money Saving Hacks
  7. Offtopic / Everything else

Latest Articles

  • We believe that retirement should be a time to relax and enjoy life, not worry about money. That's why we're here to help our members make the most of their retirement years. If you're over 60 and looking for ways to save money, connect with others, and have a laugh, we’d love to have you aboard.
  • Advertise with us

User Menu

Enjoyed Reading our Story?

  • Share this forum to your loved ones.
Change Weather Postcode×
Change Petrol Postcode×