Abandoned for hours: Cancer patient recounts shocking treatment in his local hospital

When we think of hospitals, we often envision sanctuaries of healing and care, and places where the sick and vulnerable are treated with dignity and compassion.

However, a distressing incident at a local hospital in Perth raised severe concerns about the state of Australian healthcare, particularly those battling life-threatening conditions.


Perth local Gary Helm, a 65-year-old facing stage four cancer, found himself in a situation described as a nightmare.

After arriving at the Sir Charles Gairdner Hospital, he waited for a bed for four agonising hours.

The wait time was not the only distressing aspect; Gary faced a corridor wall adjacent to a toilet, in full view of passersby, while waiting for a hospital bed.

The image of a vulnerable cancer patient relegated to such conditions has shocked and outraged the community.


compressed-hospital beds.jpeg
Several Australian hospitals face bed shortage amid the government's efforts to meet the demand. Image Credit: Pexels/Pixabay


Mr Helm expressed how terrible it felt, noting the discomfort of being stared at by others in the hospital.

'Not one thing has changed,' he lamented as he recounted the same situation he faced in 2021.

The hospital, which lacked available beds at the time, stated that it was Gary's only option.

'It was also a long weekend. Staff take leave on long weekends. That makes discharge more challenging,' WA Health Minister Amber-Jade Sanderson said.


However, this explanation provides little solace to those who suffer as a result.

The problem extends beyond Gary's experience.

Irene Fedec, a sister of another patient, also voiced her concerns about the conditions.

'There was a patient in a bed at the end of a corridor. He wasn't even in a room,' she said.

While Ms Fedec did not blame the staff, the dire shortage of hospital beds has been a persisting issue.

The Health Minister has acknowledged a 23 per cent increase in hospital presentations, attributing the spike to the first wet winter weather.

Janet Reah of the Australian Nurses Federation WA expressed her disappointment at patient mismanagement and indicated systemic issues within the Australian healthcare system.


The government has responded by stating that 700 hospital beds have been added, with another 600 on the way, as demand across the state continues to rise.

Yet, the situation remains critical, not just for those in the emergency room but also for the emergency services themselves.

Ambulances spent countless hours ramped outside metropolitan emergency departments, with Sir Charles Gairdner Hospital and Royal Perth Hospital experiencing significant increases in ramping time.

In a similar report, 89-year-old Bernard Anthony Skeffington was forced to wait in an ambulance while waiting for a bed at the Royal Adelaide Hospital.

However, Skeffington succumbed while waiting for admission. May he rest in peace.

This incident raises important questions about the state of our healthcare system and the experiences of our senior citizens within it.

It's crucial to stay informed about these issues and advocate for necessary improvements.
Key Takeaways

  • Stage-four cancer patient Gary Helm was outraged after being left in a hospital corridor for hours awaiting a bed at Sir Charles Gairdner Hospital.
  • According to the WA Health Minister, the incident was attributed to a lack of bed availability and hospital staff leave during the long weekend.
  • Despite hospital claims of improved bed numbers, ambulances still face significant ramping times outside emergency departments.
  • The hospital and Health Minister cited increased presentations and the challenges posed by the long weekend for the congestion in the emergency department.
Have you or a loved one faced similar challenges in hospitals? What changes would you like to see in our healthcare system? Please share your thoughts and insights with us in the comments below.
 
Sponsored
this is a very good reason to have private insurance.
I have private health insurance and even though I had a bed for my replacement knee surgery, I suffered an infection but was discharged after 3 days as they needed the bed! No follow up at home so I organised it myself. They wanted me to call in at intervals so they could check the infection. I live in the country area so I have to travel 160k round trip. Not happy!!
 
The whole health system has gone to rack and ruin - no government is prepared to bite the bullet and start doing something meaningful to ensure that there are beds available across Australia. We are becoming a third world country and nobody could give a toss
 
Last edited:
this is a very good reason to have private insurance.
Yes, if you can afford it. Mu Husband, since passed, had a few medical issues, and when we enquired, the premium just kept on going up, and we knew when he had to finish work, and I would be the only one in the work place, we would be pushing it to afford it.
 
  • Like
  • Sad
Reactions: Tervueren and Gsr
I MAKE SURE I CAN AFFORD IT. i cut my cloth accordingly, as we all can. love your reply, NOT
Looks like you have a bit of an attitude problem Jest from reading some of your posts so why don't you just keep your fucked up attitude to yourself loser
 
I MAKE SURE I CAN AFFORD IT. i cut my cloth accordingly, as we all can. love your reply, NOT
Can you afford not to have it, We only have top hospital now the extra $2000 a year for extras we weren't using. A family member had advanced Cancer, fortunately he could see a private Oncologist immediately and start his tmt unwise the wait was 2 months just to get a appt in the public system.
 
Last edited:
  • Sad
  • Like
Reactions: Tervueren and Gsr
Part of the problem is the large amount of people who can afford private health cover but who don’t have it and prefer to clutter up the beds in the public hospital system. We struggle to keep our private hospital cover but we don’t want to have to wait for surgery or tests or whatever in the public system if we become seriously ill. There needs to be a means test and people who have incomes higher than that should have to pay the full cost of being in a public hospital out of their own pockets. This should encourage more of them to get and use private cover and free up beds for people who really can’t afford private cover. This includes the politicians who seem to like to clutter up the public hospital system as well. Ambulance ramping will continue until this issue is addressed, and also until people can afford to go to see a Dr at a surgery and don’t need to go to out patients departments for issues a gp can deal with. More gps need to be trained and given incentives to work in general practice to help alleviate the shortage as well.
 
Can you afford not to have it, We only have top hospital now the extra $2000 a year for extras we weren't using. A family member had advanced Cancer, fortunately he could see a private Oncologist immediately and start his tmt unwise the wait was 2 months just to get a appt in the public system.
Try telling that to someone who is living in private rental
 
  • Like
Reactions: natalielocket
Part of the problem is the large amount of people who can afford private health cover but who don’t have it and prefer to clutter up the beds in the public hospital system. We struggle to keep our private hospital cover but we don’t want to have to wait for surgery or tests or whatever in the public system if we become seriously ill. There needs to be a means test and people who have incomes higher than that should have to pay the full cost of being in a public hospital out of their own pockets. This should encourage more of them to get and use private cover and free up beds for people who really can’t afford private cover. This includes the politicians who seem to like to clutter up the public hospital system as well. Ambulance ramping will continue until this issue is addressed, and also until people can afford to go to see a Dr at a surgery and don’t need to go to out patients departments for issues a gp can deal with. More gps need to be trained and given incentives to work in general practice to help alleviate the shortage as well.
The Medicare system was introduced many years ago for the benefit of every Australian. We have all paid for it except people who have always bludged off the system & never or paid minimum taxes. I agree Private health cover is very costly, but If I got seriously ill or needed a new hip or knee I wouldn't like to wait for years, as is the situation now.
 
CharlesGairdner Hospital also have some very rude staff. My 90 year old mother was admitted through emergency after a turn.. I rang to see how she was (we live 3,500 klms away). Was told they can’t give me any information because she didn’t write me down on her next of kin form. Wouldn’t even say she was okay Or pass on a message. Was very rude about it. Had to wait to get in touch with my long distance truck driver brother to ring the hospital and ask them to add me to the list.
 
  • Angry
Reactions: Tervueren
Part of the problem is the large amount of people who can afford private health cover but who don’t have it and prefer to clutter up the beds in the public hospital system. We struggle to keep our private hospital cover but we don’t want to have to wait for surgery or tests or whatever in the public system if we become seriously ill. There needs to be a means test and people who have incomes higher than that should have to pay the full cost of being in a public hospital out of their own pockets. This should encourage more of them to get and use private cover and free up beds for people who really can’t afford private cover. This includes the politicians who seem to like to clutter up the public hospital system as well. Ambulance ramping will continue until this issue is addressed, and also until people can afford to go to see a Dr at a surgery and don’t need to go to out patients departments for issues a gp can deal with. More gps need to be trained and given incentives to work in general practice to help alleviate the shortage as well.
Most of what I am reading on all these related posts are quite true - ramping, private health, lack of staff etc. but you cannot force nurses or doctors to be trained - IT MUST BE A CALLING for the person, not for the government to make the decisions for more to be trained
 

Join the conversation

News, deals, games, and bargains for Aussies over 60. From everyday expenses like groceries and eating out, to electronics, fashion and travel, the club is all about helping you make your money go further.

Seniors Discount Club

The SDC searches for the best deals, discounts, and bargains for Aussies over 60. From everyday expenses like groceries and eating out, to electronics, fashion and travel, the club is all about helping you make your money go further.
  1. New members
  2. Jokes & fun
  3. Photography
  4. Nostalgia / Yesterday's Australia
  5. Food and Lifestyle
  6. Money Saving Hacks
  7. Offtopic / Everything else
  • We believe that retirement should be a time to relax and enjoy life, not worry about money. That's why we're here to help our members make the most of their retirement years. If you're over 60 and looking for ways to save money, connect with others, and have a laugh, we’d love to have you aboard.
  • Advertise with us

User Menu

Enjoyed Reading our Story?

  • Share this forum to your loved ones.
Change Weather Postcode×
Change Petrol Postcode×