A bizarre video raised questions about the new surveillance system at this Coles store

We all have a right to privacy, and that includes having a sense of safety and security when we go about our daily business.

But recently, supermarkets have been increasing surveillance and taking extra measures to keep their premises and customers safe. While this does provide some feeling of security for the store, some customers have been feeling a bit restricted when it comes to the stringent measures.

Case in point: A Coles store in Victoria ran into some trouble because of their new ‘smart gate’ system. A move that raised concerns about customer rights at Coles.



It wasn’t that long ago when Coles introduced new smart gates in some selected stores. These gates refused shoppers to exit if the surveillance suspects that they hadn’t bought the items they were carrying.

The video online shows two women clashing with a Coles manager over the smart gates installed at self-service checkouts. The footage, which was believed to be taken in an unnamed shop in Victoria, showed the manager asking the two women whether they had gotten permission from the store to film.


shutterstock_1716107401.jpg
Coles installed new smart gates near the self-service checkouts, which raised questions for two women. Credit: Shutterstock



‘No, but you’re filming us all the time,’ said one of the women.

‘Did you get permission to film us?’ another woman asked the manager.

The manager replied that there were signs at the front entrance of Coles stating that Coles has a right to film customers. The manager then refused to answer the women’s questions and asked them to leave the store.

The woman said in the video, ‘Are you being gagged? They’re being gagged.’

At this point, the women had passed through the gates and were standing on the other side, taunting customers with comments such as, ‘You’ve escaped!’ each time customers walked through the gates.

One commented that the gates made customers feel like ‘caged animals’ and that no one liked them.

However, when one customer was asked what they think about the gates, they said, ‘The gates don’t really bother me.’



One of the women remarked that she ‘couldn’t believe’ that the shopper wasn’t bothered with the gates.

The other woman said that ‘it’s always the young ones’ who don’t care.

One of the women then proceeded to tell viewers to ‘dig your heels in and push back’.

You can watch the video below:



The video sparked mixed reactions, with some people calling out the women for harassing the supermarket staff.

One shopper said, ‘The staff you're harassing didn’t install these.’

Another said, ‘There’s more than enough information about how these systems work if these [people] cared enough to do their research.’

‘Private company does thing in their store & these people think it's a public place that they get to complain about,’ a third commented.

‘Surely they have better things to do,’ said another commenter.

However, one shopper said that ‘the amount of theft that occurs here is ‘insane’ and that the new smart gates were necessary to stop thieves.

‘A couple walked out a few weeks ago with a full trolley—no longer after these gates went in. It’s not rocket science!’ they said.



A Coles spokesperson responded to the situation and said, ‘We know that retail crime is on the increase across all retailers.’

'We have a range of security measures in place to reduce theft from our stores, including CCTV, electronic article surveillance (EAS) and in some stores, new smart gate technology that automatically opens as customers make payment for their products.’

It seems like Coles is not the only supermarket giant wary of security risks. In a previous article, Woolworths also decided to take a step further in improving their security by installing automatic gates and high-tech surveillance in their self-serve checkout areas. Read more about the story here.

Key Takeaways
  • Two women confronted a Coles manager over new security gates installed at self-service checkouts.
  • The security gates were designed to prevent shoplifting, refusing to let customers leave if they hadn’t paid for all their items.
  • The confrontation, which was filmed and posted online, generated criticism towards the women for their behaviour towards supermarket staff.

What are your thoughts on Coles’s new smart gates? Do you think it’s helpful? Let us know in the comments below!
 
Sponsored
Wether you agree with them or not they were well out of line doing what they were doing. Chiles have signage up saying that CCTV is being used. They did not have the right to video people on private property without permission. Push back, yes for sure, but do it properly. That’s what get s people a bad name who are trying to push back. Should have called the police.
 
While it won’t affect me having the gates I’m not sure it is a necessary measure. Coles could just have more staff manning the self checkouts, including maybe one standing at the exits to prevent anyone just walking out with a trolley of unpaid items. It would take a lot of staff wages to add up to the cost of the gates, so makes sense to just employ more staff instead and add a human touch to our shopping experience.
 
We all have a right to privacy, and that includes having a sense of safety and security when we go about our daily business.

But recently, supermarkets have been increasing surveillance and taking extra measures to keep their premises and customers safe. While this does provide some feeling of security for the store, some customers have been feeling a bit restricted when it comes to the stringent measures.

Case in point: A Coles store in Victoria ran into some trouble because of their new ‘smart gate’ system. A move that raised concerns about customer rights at Coles.



It wasn’t that long ago when Coles introduced new smart gates in some selected stores. These gates refused shoppers to exit if the surveillance suspects that they hadn’t bought the items they were carrying.

The video online shows two women clashing with a Coles manager over the smart gates installed at self-service checkouts. The footage, which was believed to be taken in an unnamed shop in Victoria, showed the manager asking the two women whether they had gotten permission from the store to film.


View attachment 34096
Coles installed new smart gates near the self-service checkouts, which raised questions for two women. Credit: Shutterstock



‘No, but you’re filming us all the time,’ said one of the women.

‘Did you get permission to film us?’ another woman asked the manager.

The manager replied that there were signs at the front entrance of Coles stating that Coles has a right to film customers. The manager then refused to answer the women’s questions and asked them to leave the store.

The woman said in the video, ‘Are you being gagged? They’re being gagged.’

At this point, the women had passed through the gates and were standing on the other side, taunting customers with comments such as, ‘You’ve escaped!’ each time customers walked through the gates.

One commented that the gates made customers feel like ‘caged animals’ and that no one liked them.

However, when one customer was asked what they think about the gates, they said, ‘The gates don’t really bother me.’



One of the women remarked that she ‘couldn’t believe’ that the shopper wasn’t bothered with the gates.

The other woman said that ‘it’s always the young ones’ who don’t care.

One of the women then proceeded to tell viewers to ‘dig your heels in and push back’.

You can watch the video below:



The video sparked mixed reactions, with some people calling out the women for harassing the supermarket staff.

One shopper said, ‘The staff you're harassing didn’t install these.’

Another said, ‘There’s more than enough information about how these systems work if these [people] cared enough to do their research.’

‘Private company does thing in their store & these people think it's a public place that they get to complain about,’ a third commented.

‘Surely they have better things to do,’ said another commenter.

However, one shopper said that ‘the amount of theft that occurs here is ‘insane’ and that the new smart gates were necessary to stop thieves.

‘A couple walked out a few weeks ago with a full trolley—no longer after these gates went in. It’s not rocket science!’ they said.



A Coles spokesperson responded to the situation and said, ‘We know that retail crime is on the increase across all retailers.’

'We have a range of security measures in place to reduce theft from our stores, including CCTV, electronic article surveillance (EAS) and in some stores, new smart gate technology that automatically opens as customers make payment for their products.’

It seems like Coles is not the only supermarket giant wary of security risks. In a previous article, Woolworths also decided to take a step further in improving their security by installing automatic gates and high-tech surveillance in their self-serve checkout areas. Read more about the story here.

Key Takeaways

  • Two women confronted a Coles manager over new security gates installed at self-service checkouts.
  • The security gates were designed to prevent shoplifting, refusing to let customers leave if they hadn’t paid for all their items.
  • The confrontation, which was filmed and posted online, generated criticism towards the women for their behaviour towards supermarket staff.

What are your thoughts on Coles’s new smart gates? Do you think it’s helpful? Let us know in the comments below!

If you are innocent and haven't done the crime, then what are you worried about
 
We all have a right to privacy, and that includes having a sense of safety and security when we go about our daily business.

But recently, supermarkets have been increasing surveillance and taking extra measures to keep their premises and customers safe. While this does provide some feeling of security for the store, some customers have been feeling a bit restricted when it comes to the stringent measures.

Case in point: A Coles store in Victoria ran into some trouble because of their new ‘smart gate’ system. A move that raised concerns about customer rights at Coles.



It wasn’t that long ago when Coles introduced new smart gates in some selected stores. These gates refused shoppers to exit if the surveillance suspects that they hadn’t bought the items they were carrying.

The video online shows two women clashing with a Coles manager over the smart gates installed at self-service checkouts. The footage, which was believed to be taken in an unnamed shop in Victoria, showed the manager asking the two women whether they had gotten permission from the store to film.


View attachment 34096
Coles installed new smart gates near the self-service checkouts, which raised questions for two women. Credit: Shutterstock



‘No, but you’re filming us all the time,’ said one of the women.

‘Did you get permission to film us?’ another woman asked the manager.

The manager replied that there were signs at the front entrance of Coles stating that Coles has a right to film customers. The manager then refused to answer the women’s questions and asked them to leave the store.

The woman said in the video, ‘Are you being gagged? They’re being gagged.’

At this point, the women had passed through the gates and were standing on the other side, taunting customers with comments such as, ‘You’ve escaped!’ each time customers walked through the gates.

One commented that the gates made customers feel like ‘caged animals’ and that no one liked them.

However, when one customer was asked what they think about the gates, they said, ‘The gates don’t really bother me.’



One of the women remarked that she ‘couldn’t believe’ that the shopper wasn’t bothered with the gates.

The other woman said that ‘it’s always the young ones’ who don’t care.

One of the women then proceeded to tell viewers to ‘dig your heels in and push back’.

You can watch the video below:



The video sparked mixed reactions, with some people calling out the women for harassing the supermarket staff.

One shopper said, ‘The staff you're harassing didn’t install these.’

Another said, ‘There’s more than enough information about how these systems work if these [people] cared enough to do their research.’

‘Private company does thing in their store & these people think it's a public place that they get to complain about,’ a third commented.

‘Surely they have better things to do,’ said another commenter.

However, one shopper said that ‘the amount of theft that occurs here is ‘insane’ and that the new smart gates were necessary to stop thieves.

‘A couple walked out a few weeks ago with a full trolley—no longer after these gates went in. It’s not rocket science!’ they said.



A Coles spokesperson responded to the situation and said, ‘We know that retail crime is on the increase across all retailers.’

'We have a range of security measures in place to reduce theft from our stores, including CCTV, electronic article surveillance (EAS) and in some stores, new smart gate technology that automatically opens as customers make payment for their products.’

It seems like Coles is not the only supermarket giant wary of security risks. In a previous article, Woolworths also decided to take a step further in improving their security by installing automatic gates and high-tech surveillance in their self-serve checkout areas. Read more about the story here.

Key Takeaways

  • Two women confronted a Coles manager over new security gates installed at self-service checkouts.
  • The security gates were designed to prevent shoplifting, refusing to let customers leave if they hadn’t paid for all their items.
  • The confrontation, which was filmed and posted online, generated criticism towards the women for their behaviour towards supermarket staff.

What are your thoughts on Coles’s new smart gates? Do you think it’s helpful? Let us know in the comments below!

Does Coles and Woolies think that by putting a sign in the front of the store makes it legal to film people?
Did they ask customers for their permission? Someone should look into the legality of this.
Good on the women for questioning the manager. Obviously he didn't or couldn't answer truthfully.
 
We all have a right to privacy, and that includes having a sense of safety and security when we go about our daily business.

But recently, supermarkets have been increasing surveillance and taking extra measures to keep their premises and customers safe. While this does provide some feeling of security for the store, some customers have been feeling a bit restricted when it comes to the stringent measures.

Case in point: A Coles store in Victoria ran into some trouble because of their new ‘smart gate’ system. A move that raised concerns about customer rights at Coles.



It wasn’t that long ago when Coles introduced new smart gates in some selected stores. These gates refused shoppers to exit if the surveillance suspects that they hadn’t bought the items they were carrying.

The video online shows two women clashing with a Coles manager over the smart gates installed at self-service checkouts. The footage, which was believed to be taken in an unnamed shop in Victoria, showed the manager asking the two women whether they had gotten permission from the store to film.


View attachment 34096
Coles installed new smart gates near the self-service checkouts, which raised questions for two women. Credit: Shutterstock



‘No, but you’re filming us all the time,’ said one of the women.

‘Did you get permission to film us?’ another woman asked the manager.

The manager replied that there were signs at the front entrance of Coles stating that Coles has a right to film customers. The manager then refused to answer the women’s questions and asked them to leave the store.

The woman said in the video, ‘Are you being gagged? They’re being gagged.’

At this point, the women had passed through the gates and were standing on the other side, taunting customers with comments such as, ‘You’ve escaped!’ each time customers walked through the gates.

One commented that the gates made customers feel like ‘caged animals’ and that no one liked them.

However, when one customer was asked what they think about the gates, they said, ‘The gates don’t really bother me.’



One of the women remarked that she ‘couldn’t believe’ that the shopper wasn’t bothered with the gates.

The other woman said that ‘it’s always the young ones’ who don’t care.

One of the women then proceeded to tell viewers to ‘dig your heels in and push back’.

You can watch the video below:



The video sparked mixed reactions, with some people calling out the women for harassing the supermarket staff.

One shopper said, ‘The staff you're harassing didn’t install these.’

Another said, ‘There’s more than enough information about how these systems work if these [people] cared enough to do their research.’

‘Private company does thing in their store & these people think it's a public place that they get to complain about,’ a third commented.

‘Surely they have better things to do,’ said another commenter.

However, one shopper said that ‘the amount of theft that occurs here is ‘insane’ and that the new smart gates were necessary to stop thieves.

‘A couple walked out a few weeks ago with a full trolley—no longer after these gates went in. It’s not rocket science!’ they said.



A Coles spokesperson responded to the situation and said, ‘We know that retail crime is on the increase across all retailers.’

'We have a range of security measures in place to reduce theft from our stores, including CCTV, electronic article surveillance (EAS) and in some stores, new smart gate technology that automatically opens as customers make payment for their products.’

It seems like Coles is not the only supermarket giant wary of security risks. In a previous article, Woolworths also decided to take a step further in improving their security by installing automatic gates and high-tech surveillance in their self-serve checkout areas. Read more about the story here.

Key Takeaways

  • Two women confronted a Coles manager over new security gates installed at self-service checkouts.
  • The security gates were designed to prevent shoplifting, refusing to let customers leave if they hadn’t paid for all their items.
  • The confrontation, which was filmed and posted online, generated criticism towards the women for their behaviour towards supermarket staff.

What are your thoughts on Coles’s new smart gates? Do you think it’s helpful? Let us know in the comments below!

two stupid women.
 
Wether you agree with them or not they were well out of line doing what they were doing. Chiles have signage up saying that CCTV is being used. They did not have the right to video people on private property without permission. Push back, yes for sure, but do it properly. That’s what get s people a bad name who are trying to push back. Should have called the police.
would not coles be a private property? They can do what they like.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Marj53 and AlPhil
Personally, i have no issue with this but no need to fight over this maybe. Just do what K-Mart (also a Wesfarmers company) do, and Costco. Do a perfunctory check of the receipts if you exited with a shopping bag, or trolley.
 
We all have a right to privacy, and that includes having a sense of safety and security when we go about our daily business.

But recently, supermarkets have been increasing surveillance and taking extra measures to keep their premises and customers safe. While this does provide some feeling of security for the store, some customers have been feeling a bit restricted when it comes to the stringent measures.

Case in point: A Coles store in Victoria ran into some trouble because of their new ‘smart gate’ system. A move that raised concerns about customer rights at Coles.



It wasn’t that long ago when Coles introduced new smart gates in some selected stores. These gates refused shoppers to exit if the surveillance suspects that they hadn’t bought the items they were carrying.

The video online shows two women clashing with a Coles manager over the smart gates installed at self-service checkouts. The footage, which was believed to be taken in an unnamed shop in Victoria, showed the manager asking the two women whether they had gotten permission from the store to film.


View attachment 34096
Coles installed new smart gates near the self-service checkouts, which raised questions for two women. Credit: Shutterstock



‘No, but you’re filming us all the time,’ said one of the women.

‘Did you get permission to film us?’ another woman asked the manager.

The manager replied that there were signs at the front entrance of Coles stating that Coles has a right to film customers. The manager then refused to answer the women’s questions and asked them to leave the store.

The woman said in the video, ‘Are you being gagged? They’re being gagged.’

At this point, the women had passed through the gates and were standing on the other side, taunting customers with comments such as, ‘You’ve escaped!’ each time customers walked through the gates.

One commented that the gates made customers feel like ‘caged animals’ and that no one liked them.

However, when one customer was asked what they think about the gates, they said, ‘The gates don’t really bother me.’



One of the women remarked that she ‘couldn’t believe’ that the shopper wasn’t bothered with the gates.

The other woman said that ‘it’s always the young ones’ who don’t care.

One of the women then proceeded to tell viewers to ‘dig your heels in and push back’.

You can watch the video below:



The video sparked mixed reactions, with some people calling out the women for harassing the supermarket staff.

One shopper said, ‘The staff you're harassing didn’t install these.’

Another said, ‘There’s more than enough information about how these systems work if these [people] cared enough to do their research.’

‘Private company does thing in their store & these people think it's a public place that they get to complain about,’ a third commented.

‘Surely they have better things to do,’ said another commenter.

However, one shopper said that ‘the amount of theft that occurs here is ‘insane’ and that the new smart gates were necessary to stop thieves.

‘A couple walked out a few weeks ago with a full trolley—no longer after these gates went in. It’s not rocket science!’ they said.



A Coles spokesperson responded to the situation and said, ‘We know that retail crime is on the increase across all retailers.’

'We have a range of security measures in place to reduce theft from our stores, including CCTV, electronic article surveillance (EAS) and in some stores, new smart gate technology that automatically opens as customers make payment for their products.’

It seems like Coles is not the only supermarket giant wary of security risks. In a previous article, Woolworths also decided to take a step further in improving their security by installing automatic gates and high-tech surveillance in their self-serve checkout areas. Read more about the story here.

Key Takeaways

  • Two women confronted a Coles manager over new security gates installed at self-service checkouts.
  • The security gates were designed to prevent shoplifting, refusing to let customers leave if they hadn’t paid for all their items.
  • The confrontation, which was filmed and posted online, generated criticism towards the women for their behaviour towards supermarket staff.

What are your thoughts on Coles’s new smart gates? Do you think it’s helpful? Let us know in the comments below!

I'd love to see these shoppers get away with that attitude at an airport or courthouse.
Get used to it - it's going to get worse!
 
From Victorian legislation....

Section 7 of the Surveillance Devices Act 1999 stipulates that it is against the law to install, use or maintain an optical surveillance device to record or observe a private activity to which the person is not a party. To record such private activity, the law requires the consent, express or implied, of all parties to the private activity be obtained.

Contrary to popular belief, a shopping centre or any shop in its boundaries, is not public place and is therefore deemed a private entity.

Grocery shopping is a private activity undertaken in a private environment.
 
Last edited:
Personally, i have no issue with this but no need to fight over this maybe. Just do what K-Mart (also a Wesfarmers company) do, and Costco. Do a perfunctory check of the receipts if you exited with a shopping bag, or trolley.
No. Unless you suspect someone of having stolen something then you should not demand that they produce their receipt & check their bag - & it needs to be done by a qualified security guard, not store staff. I now do not go to K-Mart as I refuse to be treated like a thief when I have just paid for my goods - at a MANNED checkout. Put the checkouts back at the front of the store where they should be so that customers pay for their goods then immediately exit the store with no chance for theft on the way out.
 
No. Unless you suspect someone of having stolen something then you should not demand that they produce their receipt & check their bag - & it needs to be done by a qualified security guard, not store staff. I now do not go to K-Mart as I refuse to be treated like a thief when I have just paid for my goods - at a MANNED checkout. Put the checkouts back at the front of the store where they should be so that customers pay for their goods then immediately exit the store with no chance for theft on the way out.
Security staff at shops, banks and other businesses have NO more power than you or me. People who think that they are "knights in shining armour" are sadly mistaken. They have no powers of arrest, detainment or search AT ALL. If they attempt or perform these instances, they are liable to being charged with a range of criminal offences. And losing their employment.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Leenie
Does Coles and Woolies think that by putting a sign in the front of the store makes it legal to film people?
Did they ask customers for their permission? Someone should look into the legality of this.
Good on the women for questioning the manager. Obviously he didn't or couldn't answer truthfully.
I was a CCTV installer and it’s legal with a sign
From Victorian legislation....

Section 7 of the Surveillance Devices Act 1999 stipulates that it is against the law to install, use or maintain an optical surveillance device to record or observe a private activity to which the person is not a party. To record such private activity, the law requires the consent, express or implied, of all parties to the private activity be obtained.

Contrary to popular belief, a shopping centre or any shop in its boundaries, is not public place and is therefore deemed a private entity.

Grocery shopping is a private activity undertaken in a private environment.
but it has a sign up at the front near the entry and that is ALL that is required to make it legal.. as a former company owner installing these device I do know how places get around that law you quoted.
 
No. Unless you suspect someone of having stolen something then you should not demand that they produce their receipt & check their bag - & it needs to be done by a qualified security guard, not store staff. I now do not go to K-Mart as I refuse to be treated like a thief when I have just paid for my goods - at a MANNED checkout. Put the checkouts back at the front of the store where they should be so that customers pay for their goods then immediately exit the store with no chance for theft on the way out.
I had my own security company and store staff can ask and legally do to inspect your bags. Most stores have signage saying they have the right. Entry to the store is giving them permission to do that. That’s the law.
 
What about home security cameras? They can be recording people just walking past, driving past and even pick up neighbour activity?
 

Join the conversation

News, deals, games, and bargains for Aussies over 60. From everyday expenses like groceries and eating out, to electronics, fashion and travel, the club is all about helping you make your money go further.

Seniors Discount Club

The SDC searches for the best deals, discounts, and bargains for Aussies over 60. From everyday expenses like groceries and eating out, to electronics, fashion and travel, the club is all about helping you make your money go further.
  1. New members
  2. Jokes & fun
  3. Photography
  4. Nostalgia / Yesterday's Australia
  5. Food and Lifestyle
  6. Money Saving Hacks
  7. Offtopic / Everything else

Latest Articles

  • We believe that retirement should be a time to relax and enjoy life, not worry about money. That's why we're here to help our members make the most of their retirement years. If you're over 60 and looking for ways to save money, connect with others, and have a laugh, we’d love to have you aboard.
  • Advertise with us

User Menu

Enjoyed Reading our Story?

  • Share this forum to your loved ones.
Change Weather Postcode×
Change Petrol Postcode×