New Design
  1. Enable New Design

When second-hand shopping loses its charm: $200 item sparking debate

Food and Lifestyle

When second-hand shopping loses its charm: $200 item sparking debate

1759194960262.png When second-hand shopping loses its charm: $200 item sparking debate
Remember when a trip to Vinnies meant filling a bag for under $20? Those days might be becoming a distant memory, as charity shops across Australia grapple with rising costs. Credit: @MitchChuri / Instagram

Remember when a trip to Vinnies meant filling a bag for under $20? Those days might be becoming a distant memory, as charity shops across Australia grapple with rising costs and changing customer expectations.



The reality hit home for 29-year-old podcaster Mitch Churi during a weekend browse at his local Vinnies in Caringbah, NSW.



The former radio presenter, who spent nearly a decade at KIIS FM before being let go late last year, was doing what many Australians are doing in the cost-of-living crisis—turning to charity shops for affordable finds.



He spotted a blue leather biker jacket that caught his eye immediately. But when he checked the price tag, his jaw dropped: $200. Even his attempt to haggle it down to $100 was politely declined—Vinnies doesn't negotiate on prices.



'I know the Shire is old white money, but the biker that died in that jacket wouldn't have paid $200 for it,' Churi quipped, highlighting the disconnect between charity shop pricing and community expectations.



The charity shop transformation



Churi's experience isn't unusual. As the cost-of-living crisis continues to bite, even op shops are facing criticism over perceived high prices, with some Australians taking to social media to call out what they see as the 'gentrification' of charity shops.









Data from the Charity Retail Association showed that in the first quarter of 2024, charity shop sales increased by 14.3 percent compared to the same period in 2023, effectively turning charity shops into curated mini boutiques.




'The average price of an item in an op shop is currently around $5.50 per item on average'

Omer Soker, CEO of Charitable Recycle Australia



But that average masks significant variations. In affluent areas like Caringbah, where Churi shops, prices can reach near-retail levels for quality items. Most charity shops allow staff to set individual prices for their store, meaning that in affluent areas, prices will be higher.



However, due to resellers travelling far and wide in search of the ultimate bargain, deprived areas are also experiencing rising costs.









Why charity shops are getting more expensive



The price rises aren't happening in a vacuum. Cost of living issues had an impact on charities in 2022, with increases in expenses and liabilities outpacing increases in revenue and assets.



Total revenue in the sector increased by $11 billion, but expenses increased by $22 billion in the same period.



The amount charities spent on employees in 2022 increased nearly 10 per cent compared to 2021—the highest annual percentage increase recorded. These rising operational costs inevitably trickle down to shop pricing.




What's driving up charity shop costs?


Rising staff wages (up 10 per cent in 2022)


Higher rent and utility bills


Increased waste disposal costs


Growing demand from middle-class shoppers


Reseller activity pushing up 'market value'


Strategic pricing to match online platforms




There's also the reseller factor. Charity shop items are being sold on platforms like Depop for ten times the original price, contributing to the subsequent gentrification of the charity shop in recent years. Charity shops, recognising the resale value of their donations, are increasingly pricing items closer to their potential market value.









The housing crisis connection



For Churi, the jacket incident highlighted broader financial pressures facing his generation. Sydney's median rent has reached $720-853 per week, taking up 30 per cent of median incomes, forcing many young adults to remain living with family longer.



'I am at my parents' but they aren't normal parents, they are like roommates,' Churi explained, acknowledging the reality many face. With Sydney's median property value now $1,228,435 and median house prices at $1,525,956, homeownership feels increasingly out of reach for many.




Key Takeaways



  • Op shop prices rising due to operational costs and demand

  • Premium pricing in affluent areas now commonplace

  • Reseller activity affecting availability and cost

  • Traditional budget shoppers being priced out

  • Charity shops balancing fundraising with accessibility




This housing pressure means more people are turning to charity shops for essentials. A third of Australian households are turning to charity due to cost of living pressures, with one in five Australians sourcing second-hand clothes in op shops as household funds are exhausted by rising costs.









What this means for you



For older Australians who have traditionally relied on charity shops for affordable clothing and household items, these price rises can be particularly challenging. On fixed incomes, the difference between a $5 shirt and a $15 one can be significant over a weekly shop.



As 55-year-old Linda from Newcastle, who has been using charity shops since she was a child, noted: 'There's been a massive change in trend with quality and prices'.



The changes aren't all negative for charities, though. Revenue from the sale of goods stays in the local community, going directly towards funding services and programs—every year Vinnies NSW assists over 200,000 people experiencing disadvantage and homelessness.









The bigger picture



With 650 St Vincent de Paul shops across Australia, any pricing changes have widespread impact. The challenge for charity retailers is balancing their primary mission—raising funds for charitable works—with community expectations of affordability.



As business lecturer Dr Andrew Hughes from the Australian National University noted: 'I think they're taking advantage of people to be honest when they're getting a lot of their stock for no cost... But what I've noticed changing with charity operations is that they're doing a lot more retail marketing and benchmarking to their competitors'.



Some charity shops are trying to address accessibility concerns. Tasmania and the ACT saw slight improvements in affordability, with the ACT notably benefiting from rent increase limits introduced in 2019, showing that regulatory measures can help manage price pressures.









Did you know?


Did you know?
The first 'World Op Shop Day' is scheduled for 18 October 2025, celebrating the global impact of charity retail and second-hand shopping culture.



Looking ahead



The rise in charity shop prices reflects broader economic pressures affecting all retail. With the cost of living rising 2.4 per cent over the year to December 2024, and charity operating costs increasing faster than revenue, this trend seems likely to continue.



For budget shoppers, the key might be timing and location. Shops in less affluent areas often still offer better value, and many charity retailers run regular sales and specials. Some are also expanding online presence, potentially offering more competitive pricing.



As for Churi, he's moved on from radio to launch his own podcast, 'The Mitch Churi Chat Show,' giving him more control over his income. But his experience at Vinnies reflects a broader Australian reality—even our most affordable shopping options are feeling the pinch of economic pressures.



What This Means For You


The days of guaranteed bargains at the op shop might be over, but the community spirit and environmental benefits remain. The challenge now is ensuring these essential community resources remain accessible to those who need them most.



What's your experience with charity shop pricing in your area? Have you noticed significant changes, and how has it affected your shopping habits? Share your thoughts in the comments below.





  • Original Article


    https://www.news.com.au/finance/cul...8f13d1ee44e2cce4568bf441057cd2?from=rss-basic





  • The Mitch Churi Chat Show has officially landed

    Cited text: After a few months away from the studio, the former KIIS and Nova host is back behind the mic, with the first episode of The Mitch Churi Chat Show hav...


    Excerpt: The former radio presenter, who spent nearly a decade at KIIS FM before being let go late last year



    https://radiotoday.com.au/the-mitch-churi-chat-show-has-officially-landed/





  • Mitch Churi Unveils Next Move

    Cited text: Churi had been with KIIS for nearly a decade, first joining at the age of 19 as a barista for ARN’s most popular hosts, Kyle Sandilands and Jacki ‘O’ ...


    Excerpt: The former radio presenter, who spent nearly a decade at KIIS FM before being let go late last year



    https://au.variety.com/2025/radio/news/former-radio-presenter-mitch-churi-reveals-next-move-26887/





  • As the cost of living bites, even op shops are facing criticism over high prices. Is it fair?

    Cited text: But as the inflation and cost of living crisis continues to bite, even op shops are facing criticism over perceived high prices.


    Excerpt: As the cost-of-living crisis continues to bite, even op shops are facing criticism over perceived high prices, with some Australians taking to social media to call out what they see as the 'gentrification' of charity shops



    https://www.sbs.com.au/news/article...iticism-over-high-prices-is-it-fair/8w2nf3awg





  • As the cost of living bites, even op shops are facing criticism over high prices. Is it fair?

    Cited text: '[With] the rising popularity of thrifting, some of these prices are getting ridiculous,' the video creator said, going on to detail some of the alleg...


    Excerpt: As the cost-of-living crisis continues to bite, even op shops are facing criticism over perceived high prices, with some Australians taking to social media to call out what they see as the 'gentrification' of charity shops



    https://www.sbs.com.au/news/article...iticism-over-high-prices-is-it-fair/8w2nf3awg





  • What the gentrification of charity shops means for the small-budget shopper—Snatch

    Cited text: Data from the Charity Retail Association showed that in the first quarter of 2024, charity shop sales increased by 14.3 percent compared to the same p...


    Excerpt: Data from the Charity Retail Association showed that in the first quarter of 2024, charity shop sales increased by 14.3 percent compared to the same period in 2023, effectively turning charity shops into curated mini boutiques



    https://mccs-journalism.gold.ac.uk/...ity-shops-means-for-the-small-budget-shopper/





  • What the gentrification of charity shops means for the small-budget shopper—Snatch

    Cited text: Designer is great but it must be part of the mix not the only offer.” · Most charity shops allow staff to set individual prices for their store, meani...


    Excerpt: Most charity shops allow staff to set individual prices for their store, meaning that in affluent areas, prices will be higher.



    https://mccs-journalism.gold.ac.uk/...ity-shops-means-for-the-small-budget-shopper/





  • A decade of data: Australian Charities Report unveils sector’s economic impact amid rising costs | ACNC

    Cited text: ... Our data shows that cost of living issues had an impact on charities in 2022, with increases in expenses and liabilities outpacing increases in re...


    Excerpt: Cost of living issues had an impact on charities in 2022, with increases in expenses and liabilities outpacing increases in revenue and assets.



    https://www.acnc.gov.au/media/news/...ils-sectors-economic-impact-amid-rising-costs





  • A decade of data: Australian Charities Report unveils sector’s economic impact amid rising costs | ACNC

    Cited text: The amount charities spent on employees in 2022 increased nearly 10 per cent when compared to 2021—the highest annual percentage increase recorded.


    Excerpt: The amount charities spent on employees in 2022 increased nearly 10 per cent compared to 2021—the highest annual percentage increase recorded



    https://www.acnc.gov.au/media/news/...ils-sectors-economic-impact-amid-rising-costs





  • What the gentrification of charity shops means for the small-budget shopper—Snatch

    Cited text: They’re a reseller, and all of these items will be sold on Depop for ten times, if not more, of the price paid in charity shops. It’s reselling like t...


    Excerpt: Charity shop items are being sold on platforms like Depop for ten times the original price, contributing to the subsequent gentrification of the charity shop in recent years



    https://mccs-journalism.gold.ac.uk/...ity-shops-means-for-the-small-budget-shopper/





  • Australia’s rental crisis reaches new heights: 2024 Rental Affordability Index | SGS Economics & Planning

    Cited text: Sydney follows closely, with a median rent of $720, taking up 30 per cent of median incomes.


    Excerpt: Sydney's median rent has reached $720-853 per week, taking up 30 per cent of median incomes



    https://sgsep.com.au/publications/insights/rental-affordability-index-2024





  • Sydney property market data, trends and forecasts 2025

    Cited text: The median property value in Sydney is now $1,228,435.


    Excerpt: With Sydney's median property value now $1,228,435 and median house prices at $1,525,956



    https://www.openagent.com.au/suburb-profiles/sydney-property-market





  • Sydney property market data, trends and forecasts 2025

    Cited text: The median house price in Sydney is now $1,525,956.


    Excerpt: With Sydney's median property value now $1,228,435 and median house prices at $1,525,956



    https://www.openagent.com.au/suburb-profiles/sydney-property-market





  • Cost of living in 2024

    Cited text: For example, between November 2023 and November 2024, household spending on groceries decreased by 6 per cent. Recent Finder research has found 11 million Aus...


    Excerpt: A third of Australian households are turning to charity due to cost of living pressures, with one in five Australians sourcing second-hand clothes in op shops as household funds are exhausted by rising costs



    https://www.finder.com.au/money/cost-of-living





  • What the gentrification of charity shops means for the small-budget shopper—Snatch

    Cited text: 55-year-old Linda from Newcastle has been using charity shops since she was child and has noticed a rise in prices.


    Excerpt: As 55-year-old Linda from Newcastle, who has been using charity shops since she was a child, noted: 'There's been a massive change in trend with quality and prices'



    https://mccs-journalism.gold.ac.uk/...ity-shops-means-for-the-small-budget-shopper/





  • Vinnies Shops—St Vincent de Paul Society NSW | Vinnies

    Cited text: Revenue from the sale of goods stay in the local community, going directly towards funding our services and programs—every year we assist over 200,0...


    Excerpt: Revenue from the sale of goods stays in the local community, going directly towards funding services and programs—every year Vinnies NSW assists over 200,000 people experiencing disadvantage and homelessness



    https://www.vinnies.org.au/nsw/vinnies-shops





  • Charity shop—Wikipedia

    Cited text: Vincent de Paul Thrift Store (trading as Vinnies) which operate 650 shops across Australia, Anglicare Shops, that currently operate in 19 locations ac...


    Excerpt: With 650 St Vincent de Paul shops across Australia



    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charity_shop





  • Aussie mum's op shop outrage after spotting $280 item

    Cited text: Considering charity stores are inundated with free donations left on their doorsteps, Dr Andrew Hughes from the Australian National University questio...


    Excerpt: As business lecturer Dr Andrew Hughes from the Australian National University noted: 'I think they're taking advantage of people to be honest when they're getting a lot of their stock for no cost...



    https://au.finance.yahoo.com/news/aussie-mums-op-shop-outrage-after-spotting-280-item-234944007.html





  • Australia’s rental crisis reaches new heights: 2024 Rental Affordability Index | SGS Economics & Planning

    Cited text: Tasmania and the ACT saw slight improvements, with the ACT notably benefiting from rent increase limits introduced in 2019. These regulatory measures ...


    Excerpt: Tasmania and the ACT saw slight improvements in affordability, with the ACT notably benefiting from rent increase limits introduced in 2019, showing that regulatory measures can help manage price pressures



    https://sgsep.com.au/publications/insights/rental-affordability-index-2024





  • Cost of Living 2025: Everything you need to know about handling rising living costs | Mozo

    Cited text: The cost of living rose 2.4 per cent over the year to December 2024, up 0.2 per cent over the quarter.


    Excerpt: With the cost of living rising 2.4 per cent over the year to December 2024



    https://mozo.com.au/family-finances/cost-of-living-guide



Last edited:

Seniors Discount Club

Sponsored content

Info
Loading data . . .
Vinnie's are full of it!!
There are plenty of other op shops out there that are still reasonable prices

I was looking at a bag in Vinnies, that was marked at $120. I queried the price and the Manager said it was an original Prada. It wasn't it was a rip off copy.
It was new. Still had the handles wrapped.
I said to her why would someone give away a bag that sells for thousands.
In the end my daughter in law, who is pretty clued up on these things, proved to her that it wasn't an original.

She dropped the price to $20, my DIL took it up to the counter to pay for it
and bought me back the bag and $10 change. She said it's half price Tuesday so I asked for the 50% discount lol.
So the $120 bag ended up costing $10, which is probably about what it would cost in Bali.
How are Vinnies supposed to help the poor without sufficient revenue?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sherril54 and Ricci
Our local Salvos is a lot more expensive than Red Cross or Vinnies. I know a MUM whose daughter asked for a new dress for a special occasion - she had definitely grown out of her previous season but still modern clothes. She chose one at Target for about $35.00 (not an expensive dress) Her Mum took the girls to nearby Vinnies. She got the same dress(which looked like it was new), a dress for another of her daughters and a jumper for their 3rd daughter for just over $35.00
THe Salvos are way too fussy what they will accept. People I know tried to donate a beautiful very sturdy old wardrobe in perfect condition and they wouldn't accept it. At the same time they were appealing for furniture for people whose houses had been damaged by some of the worst floods I have ever seen photos of.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sherril54 and Ricci
I love op shopping, its a hobby of mine. Sometimes I walk out with nothing other times I find a bargain.

Last year I renovated my house including all new furniture. I purchased a 6 seater dining table and chairs and found out it wasn't big enough .
This is the set I purchased last year, way to small
View attachment 85528

I still have my solid large original table and chairs stored but it just doesn't work in the room
View attachment 85532

We were buying a gift from the good guys last week and popped into the Salvos store for a quick look and saw a table with chairs that were solid and exactly what we were originally looking for. Problem before was we couldn't find it in white and paying $2000 we were not going to repaint it.

This table is so heavy and solid and extends to fit 12.

We paid $165 for the table and 4 chairs. Hubby will now paint the table white as well as 4 of our original chairs which are very similar
This is the one we purchased last week with the four white chairs . Seats 6 people comfortably and extends when needed to sit 10 to 12

View attachment 85529View attachment 85530View attachment 85531

I do agree how so many op shops prices are ridiculous but there are still bargains out there.

My table and chairs I purchased last year I have now given to someone in need who my daughter saw on FB
how many tables does one need? also clothes.
 
how many tables does one need? also clothes.
One, which is why I gave the smaller one away to someone in need.
That large square one is in storage until I find someone who wants it. I paid $1,800 for it so Im not just going to throw it away.

I haven't seen you on here for awhile and was starting to miss your snarky comments 😕
 
Why on earth would you paint a beautiful wooden table white?
I love it as it is, including the grain and I feel it works well with everything else. Hubby is OCD and wants it white.

Hubby changed our fish tank white and actually looked better. And replaced the knobs with new silver ones
20251001_135654.jpg
We had a buffet n hutch which we have had since moving into our house in 1988. It was sentimental and didn't want to get rid of it so he cut it down ,painted it white and we use it for the TV in the family room plus added new silver handles
20251001_135747.jpg
 
Last edited:
How are Vinnies supposed to help the poor without sufficient revenue?
They are loosing revenue from a lot of people.by putting ridiculous prices on things.
They would make more money keeping prices low and selling volume. I know many people who don't even go into Vinnies anymore. They are by far the dearest op shops.
I noticed someone earlier commenting about Kmart shirts. I've noticed the same and even mentioned it to them. That they were charging the same price for second hand tshirts as they were new.

I know two women who volunteered at Vinnies and left and went to Good Sammies as they got sick of people complaining about the prices.

Also if they are going to sell things at inflated prices they need to know what they are doing
You would think that common sense would tell you that no one is going to give away a brand new Prada bag.
If they don't know how to tell whether something is an original or a fake, then they should assume it's a fake. After all they got it for nothing.
Not very good for business, or their reputation, trying to sell a fake as an original.
Vinnies certainly aren't doing themselves any favours.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Ricci
They are loosing revenue from a lot of people.by putting ridiculous prices on things.
They would make more money keeping prices low and selling volume. I know many people who don't even go into Vinnies anymore. They are by far the dearest op shops.
I noticed someone earlier commenting about Kmart shirts. I've noticed the same and even mentioned it to them. That they were charging the same price for second hand tshirts as they were new.

I know two women who volunteered at Vinnies and left and went to Good Sammies as they got sick of people complaining about the prices.

Vinnies certainly aren't doing themselves any favours.
I totally agree 100% what you said.

Last year when we renovated I took awhole lot of stuff to vinnies. As we were unloading at the back in the loading dock. The workers were helping us . I was amazed at how many of the items they put aside and stated that it would be going home with them.

I said to hubby in tge car, let's just think that they were volunteers who were also in need
 
They should give my daughter in law a job. She's bought quite a few bags off them for $10 and $20 which were originals and then they have knock offs at high prices.
Obviously they don't have a clue.
She also does the same with watches and vintage clothes and then on sells them.
I know some people object to that but I don't see a problem with it. If she didn't buy them somebody else would, at the price Vinnies put on it.
I say good luck to her that she has the knowledge to actually know what she's looking at.
She is paying the price they wanted so no one should say or have a right to say a thing.

I've also purchased wallets and bags that were authentic.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mylittletibbies
One, which is why I gave the smaller one away to someone in need.
That large square one is in storage until I find someone who wants it. I paid $1,800 for it so Im not just going to throw it away.

I haven't seen you on here for awhile and was starting to miss your snarky comments 😕
I thought the same thing ... people haven't been called dumb for a while until now.
 
how many tables does one need? also clothes.
Ah forgot to ask are bags included ? As Im giving away a few leather bags on here. Take a look in the notices thread
 
I bought a watch at op shop for $5 it wasn't going so I took to a watch place he said it just needed a new battery looked the watch up on line they are $395
 
When did Op shop workers start getting paid? I thought they were all volunteers.
Many of the church run stores have a paid manager to handle money and donations, like Anglicare for instance.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sherril54 and Kman
Why on earth would you paint a beautiful wooden table white?
To match the rest of the house, that's why.
I agree about its a beautiful timber table, it needs to match the rest of the house and paint can be sanded off later if sold to someone else.
I used to refurbish furniture.
 
Why on earth would you paint a beautiful wooden table white?
Many timber tables in the stores are white, and they are beautiful. My daughter has a really lovely white timber table; it suits her decor.
 
Our local op shop is realistic - they are given what they sell - no costs of goods, possibly some money spent on cleaning the product. Volunteers man (or, most commonly, woman) the shop, so no wages bill.
BUT
- rent goes up
- power costs go up
- telephone bills go up.

So what if people buy to resell at exorbitant prices? That's retail for you - the manufacturer makes it (i.e. the donor has it to dispose of), the distributor 'buys' it (accepts the donation and puts it on sale with the attendant costs involved), the buyer buys it. If the buyer then on-sells it, that's not the distributor's concern.

If I can (and did) buy enough wool to knit about 30 beanies for the Seafarers' Mission (Port Headland)'s Christmas hampers for less than $20, I'm winning. The op shop is winning. Who's complaining?
 
  • Like
Reactions: mylittletibbies
Our local op shop is realistic - they are given what they sell - no costs of goods, possibly some money spent on cleaning the product. Volunteers man (or, most commonly, woman) the shop, so no wages bill.
BUT
- rent goes up
- power costs go up
- telephone bills go up.

So what if people buy to resell at exorbitant prices? That's retail for you - the manufacturer makes it (i.e. the donor has it to dispose of), the distributor 'buys' it (accepts the donation and puts it on sale with the attendant costs involved), the buyer buys it. If the buyer then on-sells it, that's not the distributor's concern.

If I can (and did) buy enough wool to knit about 30 beanies for the Seafarers' Mission (Port Headland)'s Christmas hampers for less than $20, I'm winning. The op shop is winning. Who's complaining?
That would be a lovely community there at Port Hedland.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sherril54
When did Op shop workers start getting paid? I thought they were all volunteers.
Yes, I wondered that. For many years my Husband volunteered at the Helicopter Rescue op shop. I don`t think anyone was paid. All they got was a Christmas Luncheon. They loved him there. The only Male with all the Females. :ROFLMAO: :ROFLMAO:
 
i would
 
Don't understand why he is surprised by this price. I volunteer at an Op Shop & and often gobsmacked by the prices they put on second hand clothing, shoes and homewares. Way out of my price range. Prices of children's Kmart clothes dumb found me the most though when they are charging $5 & $6 for t-shirts when they are only $3.50 brand new. Yep I prefer to shop brand new these days cause at least most department stores have a guarantee on their clothing, Op Shops most certainly don't.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Penny4

Join the conversation

News, deals, games, and bargains for Aussies over 60. From everyday expenses like groceries and eating out, to electronics, fashion and travel, the club is all about helping you make your money go further.

Seniors Discount Club

The SDC searches for the best deals, discounts, and bargains for Aussies over 60. From everyday expenses like groceries and eating out, to electronics, fashion and travel, the club is all about helping you make your money go further.
  1. New members
  2. Jokes & fun
  3. Photography
  4. Nostalgia / Yesterday's Australia
  5. Food and Lifestyle
  6. Money Saving Hacks
  7. Offtopic / Everything else
  • We believe that retirement should be a time to relax and enjoy life, not worry about money. That's why we're here to help our members make the most of their retirement years. If you're over 60 and looking for ways to save money, connect with others, and have a laugh, we’d love to have you aboard.
  • Advertise with us

User Menu

Enjoyed Reading our Story?

  • Share this forum to your loved ones.
Change Weather Postcode×
Change Petrol Postcode×