The Ins and Outs of Bread: Nutritionist reveals the best and worst types of bread for your health

Nutritionist Susie Burrell has shared some useful information for those who are looking to get the most out of their bread.

LzhT0XTnyc5RLMloGc4U3R_BM8FHhMHNNOEw1nwl6-uIfCX4UkA1V8yI7TzijI3vv95JdIrZLYqs4qOjtw1-FLZYR6rhbuGpaSILVgriQp73gPUYr4OZ26HesFDC6JfoMrF37lM

Nutritionist Susie Burrell shared her expert advice on picking and consuming bread. Credit: Susie Burrell.

Bread is known for being a good source of carbohydrates and B group vitamins — essential nutrients for energy production.

Ms Burrell noted that less-processed varieties of bread — such as rye, wholegrain, and artisan sourdough — offer more health benefits than heavily-processed varieties of bread.

Some of the nutrients found in grain-based bread include dietary fibre, vitamin E, zinc, and iron.

Aside from the vitamins and minerals that are found in less-processed bread variants, it is noteworthy that grain-based bread contains a significantly lower glycaemic index (GI) compared to white bread, wholemeal, and flatbread, meaning they have lower sugar levels and are healthier.

6ktaDAz5mYkDcMLtjEDFknu8ytJaC3BENkdPTBZ0r8vofFNXrz8xkUGe_LQ4VdHVxKj4sDkUsUP8Fcxzha7sUGhbAmiPvLy2aPW4gz-9QApwGXSukWRp4H9pI5OM2cN1STxyrMY

Bread is an excellent source of carbohydrates and vitamin E. Credit: Getty Images/iStockphoto.

Below are some of Ms Burrell's advice and notes on picking the perfect bread for you!

1. More grains the better

As previously mentioned, grain-based bread variants have more health benefits compared to heavily-processed varieties.

Ms Burrell said that consuming white bread can lead to regular glucose peaks and troughs, and subsequent insulin release.

She explained: "High insulin levels over time are related to weight gain and increased risk of developing Type 2 diabetes."

"Generally speaking, the more grains the bread has, the better it will be for you."

Recommended varieties:
  • Soy and linseed loaves
The nutritionist described these bread varieties as a "standout" due to their high polyunsaturated fat content. Polyunsaturated fat is one of the healthy fats that help individuals reduce inflammation in the body.
  • Sourdough
Sourdough bread has a lower GI than regular white bread, perfect for those who are cutting on sugar.

Varieties that you should avoid:
  • Wholemeal bread
"While wholemeal bread does contain more dietary fibre than standard white bread, it is still a high GI choice," Ms Burrell explained.
  • Turkish
The nutritionist dubbed this bread variety as the "worst bread of all".

She said: "Its mixture of large serving sizes, holes that readily get filled with butter or margarine, and large amounts of white flour gives it its high GI and carbohydrate load.

2. Serving sizes

While the aforementioned recommended varieties offer an array of health benefits, you should keep in mind that large serving sizes can still affect your body.

Ms Burrell explained: "The average adult will need just two to four slices of bread each day and be mindful of the increasing sizes."

"Some large, thick slices of bread can contain up to double the number of carbohydrates and are really not necessary for the majority of us who would ultimately like to drop a few extra kilograms."

3. White bread

tRpFeYmxuhmgwz5eJ2nFjrwaV2ZY6D7jWt8dUmJ4QKhpRxwcgLej96vkbUKp_54Mu5-GiaATyCS6ZTeyfVoSt61aoJkc5CX1J8ktBIZCNXSf-5aYKxkziGtM2k0tqarFvpZrWDU

White bread has a high GI content. Credit: Getty Images.

White bread has a high GI content, which means that consumers will experience glucose peaks quickly after eating.

The nutritionist said: "White bread has a base of refined white flour, in which whole grains have been processed so both the bran and germ component of the grain is removed."

4. Wholemeal bread

Wholemeal bread retains more of its dietary fibre and nutrients compared to white bread as it is processed less.

However, the milling of the flour — which gives the bread a slightly darker appearance compared to white bread — means that its GI content is higher than wholegrain varieties of bread.

5. Rye

SoNaAZG9HXc6256_dkQG6Q6PCuosG79GCCo7MTDd3FyZWgkm-hj_f5b3ZuTd52-fd2G5mKka8fAmWY6hmtvWNoEXmDro7ByX2sfYT8gIte9sZiG3FKLWExoFL67DmvaRdq5Xvsc

Darker rye loaves are better than lighter loaves. Credit: Getty Images.

It was said that the healthiest variety of rye bread are those with relatively darker loaves as darker colour indicates that it contains a higher percentage of rye flour.

Ms Burrell suggested: "So, where possible, seek out darker loaves of bread and as high a percentage of rye as a flour base as possible."

6. Sourdough

The nutritionist noted that choosing a loaf of sourdough bread is tricky.

She explained: "The slow fermentation phase involved in making sourdough helps to reduce the GI or digestion rate, while also increasing nutrient availability and digestibility."

However, she emphasised that sourdough slices made with white flour lack the essential nutrients that wholegrain bread offers.

"Sourdough slices are notoriously large, with the average slice equivalent to two small slices of wholegrain bread," she said.

The nutritionist advised that one should opt for small slices of wholegrain or rye sourdough bread instead.

7. Whole grain

Except for its low GI, whole grain bread offers a wide array of nutrients.

Ms Burrell said: "Bread made with whole grains are nutritionally denser, with higher amounts of dietary fibre, protein and key nutrients including zinc, B group vitamins and vitamin E."

"As a general rule of thumb, the greater the number of whole grains, and the denser the bread overall, the higher the nutrient content will be."

8. Low carb

It should be noted that low-carb loaves and wraps are becoming more popular, especially since a lot of people turned to fitness during the pandemic.

However, the nutritionist highlighted that "low-carb bread is generally not low calorie".

Aside from this caveat, Ms Burrell said that this variety offers health benefits to consumers.

She explained: "Most lower-carb loaves have been made using higher protein flours or additions such as soy, along with extra seeds and grains, that help to reduce the overall carbohydrate content."

9. Wraps

TzfxivCG-aUJeGcrX5H9ABiwOVGsGSIk2Gm5d1NOHhDE-BTiXE8DYlo36t3Xnfq33JzraZP0Ny0BX1qvyrF_y1H4DhuWnc_1zsyjqnxUbyYNZ3DuV48nmSF0LXN7NR2Thz1SfVM

The nutritional benefits of wraps depend on the ingredients used in making them. Credit: Getty Images.

While wraps are often marketed and considered healthier and lighter alternatives to bread, it should be noted that most wrap varieties available in the market contain a relatively high GI.

It was said that the high GI content resulted from the "dense carbohydrate content and the refined flour used to create the dense consistency of the wrap itself".

Ms Burrell advised: "Wraps can also be extremely large and contain more than 50g of carbohydrate in a single wrap, the equivalent of more than three slices of wholegrain bread, so watch your portions and opt for mini’s where you can."

What variety of bread is your favourite? Share them with us in the comments below!
 
Sponsored
I have had to give up on bread. Just lately every time I have bread , a sandwich or toast I get awful indigestion. It has happened before and if I lay off of it for a couple of weeks then everything seems fine again. :(
 
  • Wow
Reactions: KatKop
I have had to give up on bread. Just lately every time I have bread , a sandwich or toast I get awful indigestion. It has happened before and if I lay off of it for a couple of weeks then everything seems fine again. :(
Have you been tested for Coeliac Disease?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ricci
Yes, and no I don't have it.
I do not have coeliac disease but get severe indigestion from wheat flour breads as do my adult sons(into their 40s) I am now lactose intolerant, gluten intolerant and have IBS due to a gastro bug I got fron neighbours, I have to have gluten free bread and now no more indigestion(Abbots and Helgas soy and lynseed is the best) my sons cannot eat any wheat products including cereals without getting indigestion, so they try not to eat what products very often.
 
  • Like
  • Sad
Reactions: KatKop and Ricci
The Ins and Outs of Bread: Nutritionist reveals the best and worst types of bread for your health

Nutritionist Susie Burrell has shared some useful information for those who are looking to get the most out of their bread.

LzhT0XTnyc5RLMloGc4U3R_BM8FHhMHNNOEw1nwl6-uIfCX4UkA1V8yI7TzijI3vv95JdIrZLYqs4qOjtw1-FLZYR6rhbuGpaSILVgriQp73gPUYr4OZ26HesFDC6JfoMrF37lM

Nutritionist Susie Burrell shared her expert advice on picking and consuming bread. Credit: Susie Burrell.

Bread is known for being a good source of carbohydrates and B group vitamins — essential nutrients for energy production.

Ms Burrell noted that less-processed varieties of bread — such as rye, wholegrain, and artisan sourdough — offer more health benefits than heavily-processed varieties of bread.

Some of the nutrients found in grain-based bread include dietary fibre, vitamin E, zinc, and iron.

Aside from the vitamins and minerals that are found in less-processed bread variants, it is noteworthy that grain-based bread contains a significantly lower glycaemic index (GI) compared to white bread, wholemeal, and flatbread, meaning they have lower sugar levels and are healthier.


6ktaDAz5mYkDcMLtjEDFknu8ytJaC3BENkdPTBZ0r8vofFNXrz8xkUGe_LQ4VdHVxKj4sDkUsUP8Fcxzha7sUGhbAmiPvLy2aPW4gz-9QApwGXSukWRp4H9pI5OM2cN1STxyrMY

Bread is an excellent source of carbohydrates and vitamin E. Credit: Getty Images/iStockphoto.

Below are some of Ms Burrell's advice and notes on picking the perfect bread for you!

1. More grains the better

As previously mentioned, grain-based bread variants have more health benefits compared to heavily-processed varieties.

Ms Burrell said that consuming white bread can lead to regular glucose peaks and troughs, and subsequent insulin release.

She explained: "High insulin levels over time are related to weight gain and increased risk of developing Type 2 diabetes."

"Generally speaking, the more grains the bread has, the better it will be for you."

Recommended varieties:

  • Soy and linseed loaves
The nutritionist described these bread varieties as a "standout" due to their high polyunsaturated fat content. Polyunsaturated fat is one of the healthy fats that help individuals reduce inflammation in the body.
  • Sourdough
Sourdough bread has a lower GI than regular white bread, perfect for those who are cutting on sugar.

Varieties that you should avoid:

  • Wholemeal bread
"While wholemeal bread does contain more dietary fibre than standard white bread, it is still a high GI choice," Ms Burrell explained.
  • Turkish
The nutritionist dubbed this bread variety as the "worst bread of all".

She said: "Its mixture of large serving sizes, holes that readily get filled with butter or margarine, and large amounts of white flour gives it its high GI and carbohydrate load.


2. Serving sizes

While the aforementioned recommended varieties offer an array of health benefits, you should keep in mind that large serving sizes can still affect your body.

Ms Burrell explained: "The average adult will need just two to four slices of bread each day and be mindful of the increasing sizes."

"Some large, thick slices of bread can contain up to double the number of carbohydrates and are really not necessary for the majority of us who would ultimately like to drop a few extra kilograms."


3. White bread

tRpFeYmxuhmgwz5eJ2nFjrwaV2ZY6D7jWt8dUmJ4QKhpRxwcgLej96vkbUKp_54Mu5-GiaATyCS6ZTeyfVoSt61aoJkc5CX1J8ktBIZCNXSf-5aYKxkziGtM2k0tqarFvpZrWDU

White bread has a high GI content. Credit: Getty Images.

White bread has a high GI content, which means that consumers will experience glucose peaks quickly after eating.

The nutritionist said: "White bread has a base of refined white flour, in which whole grains have been processed so both the bran and germ component of the grain is removed."


4. Wholemeal bread

Wholemeal bread retains more of its dietary fibre and nutrients compared to white bread as it is processed less.

However, the milling of the flour — which gives the bread a slightly darker appearance compared to white bread — means that its GI content is higher than wholegrain varieties of bread.


5. Rye

SoNaAZG9HXc6256_dkQG6Q6PCuosG79GCCo7MTDd3FyZWgkm-hj_f5b3ZuTd52-fd2G5mKka8fAmWY6hmtvWNoEXmDro7ByX2sfYT8gIte9sZiG3FKLWExoFL67DmvaRdq5Xvsc

Darker rye loaves are better than lighter loaves. Credit: Getty Images.

It was said that the healthiest variety of rye bread are those with relatively darker loaves as darker colour indicates that it contains a higher percentage of rye flour.

Ms Burrell suggested: "So, where possible, seek out darker loaves of bread and as high a percentage of rye as a flour base as possible."


6. Sourdough

The nutritionist noted that choosing a loaf of sourdough bread is tricky.

She explained: "The slow fermentation phase involved in making sourdough helps to reduce the GI or digestion rate, while also increasing nutrient availability and digestibility."

However, she emphasised that sourdough slices made with white flour lack the essential nutrients that wholegrain bread offers.

"Sourdough slices are notoriously large, with the average slice equivalent to two small slices of wholegrain bread," she said.

The nutritionist advised that one should opt for small slices of wholegrain or rye sourdough bread instead.


7. Whole grain

Except for its low GI, whole grain bread offers a wide array of nutrients.

Ms Burrell said: "Bread made with whole grains are nutritionally denser, with higher amounts of dietary fibre, protein and key nutrients including zinc, B group vitamins and vitamin E."

"As a general rule of thumb, the greater the number of whole grains, and the denser the bread overall, the higher the nutrient content will be."


8. Low carb

It should be noted that low-carb loaves and wraps are becoming more popular, especially since a lot of people turned to fitness during the pandemic.

However, the nutritionist highlighted that "low-carb bread is generally not low calorie".

Aside from this caveat, Ms Burrell said that this variety offers health benefits to consumers.

She explained: "Most lower-carb loaves have been made using higher protein flours or additions such as soy, along with extra seeds and grains, that help to reduce the overall carbohydrate content."


9. Wraps

TzfxivCG-aUJeGcrX5H9ABiwOVGsGSIk2Gm5d1NOHhDE-BTiXE8DYlo36t3Xnfq33JzraZP0Ny0BX1qvyrF_y1H4DhuWnc_1zsyjqnxUbyYNZ3DuV48nmSF0LXN7NR2Thz1SfVM

The nutritional benefits of wraps depend on the ingredients used in making them. Credit: Getty Images.

While wraps are often marketed and considered healthier and lighter alternatives to bread, it should be noted that most wrap varieties available in the market contain a relatively high GI.

It was said that the high GI content resulted from the "dense carbohydrate content and the refined flour used to create the dense consistency of the wrap itself".

Ms Burrell advised: "Wraps can also be extremely large and contain more than 50g of carbohydrate in a single wrap, the equivalent of more than three slices of wholegrain bread, so watch your portions and opt for mini’s where you can."

What variety of bread is your favourite? Share them with us in the comments below!
Usually wholmeal or wholegrain. I tried rye recently and that was very nice.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ricci
I recently found a wholemeal 10 grain loaf made by a well known baker and thought it offered everything we are being told is better for us, after reading the article saying wholemeal is not good I am now very confused and at a loss as too what to buy now
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ricci
IMHO: So many store bought packaged breads are not baked enough nowadays, so alas they so often have to be toasted. I was taught to use unbleached rye flour and crushed grains to make bread and then store it for at least 1d; as otherwise fresh bread is worse for the digestion. If I had a good oven, I would make it again.

Lawson breads were better, when the price packaging was comprised of brown paper and a site windows.

Luckily have discovered a better bread with caraway seeds at a local IGA.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ricci

Join the conversation

News, deals, games, and bargains for Aussies over 60. From everyday expenses like groceries and eating out, to electronics, fashion and travel, the club is all about helping you make your money go further.

Seniors Discount Club

The SDC searches for the best deals, discounts, and bargains for Aussies over 60. From everyday expenses like groceries and eating out, to electronics, fashion and travel, the club is all about helping you make your money go further.
  1. New members
  2. Jokes & fun
  3. Photography
  4. Nostalgia / Yesterday's Australia
  5. Food and Lifestyle
  6. Money Saving Hacks
  7. Offtopic / Everything else

Latest Articles

  • We believe that retirement should be a time to relax and enjoy life, not worry about money. That's why we're here to help our members make the most of their retirement years. If you're over 60 and looking for ways to save money, connect with others, and have a laugh, we’d love to have you aboard.
  • Advertise with us

User Menu

Enjoyed Reading our Story?

  • Share this forum to your loved ones.
Change Weather Postcode×
Change Petrol Postcode×