New Design
  1. Enable New Design

Should Kmart even be selling these items? The surprising legal truth behind the $10 controversy

Food and Lifestyle

Should Kmart even be selling these items? The surprising legal truth behind the $10 controversy

Screenshot 2025-09-03 at 12.04.49.png Should Kmart even be selling these items? The surprising legal truth behind the $10 controversy
When shoppers spotted Kmart Australia's new $10 Novelty Warning Lights sporting distinctive red and blue colours, social media erupted with concerns about their potential misuse.

When shoppers spotted Kmart Australia's new finds sporting distinctive red and blue colours, social media erupted with concerns about their potential misuse.



In this article



But the heated debate reveals some fascinating truths about Australian law—and highlights important safety considerations for anyone who might encounter these lights in the wrong hands.





Kmart Australia has started selling a $10 Novelty Warning Light that's caused quite a stir among concerned shoppers.



The AA battery-powered device flashes red and blue lights and can operate with or without sound, leading many to worry it resembles police car emergency lighting too closely for comfort.



One person complained about the potential of the distinctive blue and red coloured lights being illegally placed in cars to impersonate police or other emergency services.



The concerns aren't unfounded—fake police incidents are more common than you might think, and the consequences can be serious.



The product sparking fierce debate




'I***** are definitely going to put them on their cars'

Concerned Kmart shopper, Daily Mail Australia



The controversy isn't just theoretical. In Melbourne, a 16-year-old teenager spent weeks masquerading as an emergency services worker, driving around in his customised white truck fitted with over $100,000 worth of sirens, lights and gear.



The truck was so realistic with flashing lights fitted on the roof and a siren that motorists pulled to the side to let his vehicle pass.




When fake police become frighteningly real



The teenager had been responding to traffic crashes and even assisted people at the scenes of several accidents before being caught by police.



Senior Constable Fritz Ebert described the situation as unlike anything he'd seen in five years, noting the danger of 'a 16-year-old unaccompanied inexperienced driver, driving at peak hour traffic' while 'pretending to be an emergency service'.



More recently, a 20-year-old Sydney woman described a 'genuinely terrifying' ordeal when she was allegedly chased by armed and masked police impersonators in a silver Holden Commodore with flashing blue and red lights at Bidwill in Sydney's northwest at about 1:30am.










Real police impersonation incidents in Australia


Melbourne teenager with $100,000 fake emergency vehicle (2017)


Sydney woman chased by armed fake police with blue/red lights (2021)


Multiple cases of fake police pullovers reported annually across Australia


Many instances of people using fake police flash lights on their vehicles to pull people over




The serious legal consequences



The penalties for impersonating police officers in Australia are no joke. In NSW, anyone who impersonates a police officer faces a maximum penalty of two years imprisonment and/or a fine of 10 penalty units (currently $11,000).



But it gets more serious if you actually try to exercise police powers. If someone impersonates a police officer and does something that police officers have the power to do—like pretending to arrest someone—they can be charged with the more serious 'aggravated' offence, with a maximum penalty of 7 years imprisonment.



The aggravated offence applies where a person not only impersonates an officer but 'purports to exercise a power or function as a police officer, with intent to deceive' - including 'pretending to be a police officer in order to stop someone's vehicle, 'arrest' someone, or search someone's home or vehicle'.









The legal distinction that matters



Here's where the Kmart debate gets interesting from a legal perspective. The law specifically states that 'impersonation' does not include conduct engaged in solely for satirical purposes—think costume parties or theatrical productions.



Legal experts note that using red/blue lights to communicate to a driver that they should pull over would constitute 'representing oneself by conduct to be a police officer' and would therefore be impersonating a police officer. However, simply owning the lights isn't the problem.



As one defender pointed out in the original discussion: 'It's not illegal to sell because it doesn't say it's for a car, it's just a light.' The legal risk comes entirely from how you use them.










What's legal vs illegal with these lights



  • Legal: Buying, owning, using for parties, theatre, or home decoration

  • Legal: Using in legitimate film or TV production (with proper permits)

  • Illegal: Mounting on vehicles and using on public roads

  • Very illegal: Using them to pull over other drivers or impersonate police




Legitimate uses that defenders highlight



The controversy isn't entirely one-sided. These lights can be used 'for plays, events, skits and other functions by kids' and to 'organize a police theme party and use this as a party decor item'.



Professional applications include use 'as a party decoration or in an industrial setting to increase visibility, attract attention, or signal an alert' and for 'kid's parties, carnivals, plays, and other events'.



A 7-inch red police beacon toy is 'perfect for themed parties, Halloween decorations, or playful emergencies in escape rooms' and can be used 'during games like cops and robbers, as a dramatic alert in pranks, or for adding fun to kids' activities'.









Film and television production represents another legitimate market, though regulations vary by state, and generally 'you cannot display red and/or blue lights' on vehicles without proper authorization.



What this means for your safety



For older Australians, the key concern isn't whether Kmart should sell these lights, but how to stay safe if you encounter someone misusing them.



Police advice is clear: 'Anyone stopped by an unmarked vehicle with blue and red flashing lights, should ask for identification, obtain the vehicle registration and contact police immediately to confirm the legitimacy of those on board'.



Did you know?


Did you know?
The 'satirical purposes' exception in Australian law means you can legally dress as a police officer for a costume party or act in a film role without breaking impersonation laws. However, this protection disappears the moment you try to exercise any police-like authority or powers.



The bigger picture on product responsibility



The debate reflects a broader question about retailer responsibility for products that could be misused. Several commenters defended Kmart's position: 'If one idiot does actually use them wrongly then that's on them, don't hold Kmart responsible for human stupidity.'









In South Australia, road traffic rules state that 'a vehicle, other than an exempt vehicle, a special use vehicle, or a State Government enforcement vehicle must not be fitted with a light that flashes', making the installation illegal regardless of where you bought the light.



The reality is that similar products are widely available through various retailers and online platforms. As one emergency lighting retailer explains: 'Our products are available to the general public. However, not everyone can operate an emergency light in their car on public roads... you can purchase a light from us in any color, but whether or not you can use it on public roads in the United States is dictated by state statutes'. The same principle applies in Australia.



A question of balance and responsibility



The Kmart controversy highlights the tension between legitimate uses and potential misuse of everyday products. While the lights have genuine applications in entertainment, education, and industrial settings, the concerns about police impersonation reflect real safety issues that have affected Australian communities.



The general principle in emergency lighting regulation is that 'emergency strobe lights that are either red or blue are, by and large, disallowed' for civilian vehicles, with 'the general spirit of the law being that civilian vehicles should not appear to have the same features as those of police'.



Perhaps the most balanced take came from a shopper who noted: 'They could be used for live shows, film and TV, events/parties etc. There's plenty of legitimate uses.' The key is ensuring people understand both the legitimate applications and the serious legal consequences of misuse.



What This Means For You


What do you think? Should retailers like Kmart continue selling these novelty warning lights, or do the risks outweigh the legitimate uses? Have you ever encountered someone using fake emergency lights inappropriately? Share your thoughts and experiences below.





  • Original Article


    https://www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/...priate-10-item-Australian-stores-allowed.html





  • What Does the Law Say About Impersonating a Police Officer?

    Cited text: How would you know if you were dealing with a fake cop?


    Excerpt: Kmart Australia has started selling a $10 Novelty Warning Light



    https://www.sydneycriminallawyers.c...law-say-about-impersonating-a-police-officer/





  • What is the Law on Impersonating an Emergency Services Vehicle in NSW? - Criminal Defence Lawyers Australia

    Cited text: This was the very scenario that transpired when a Melbourne teenager was busted after spending weeks masquerading as an emergency services worker roam...


    Excerpt: In Melbourne, a 16-year-old teenager spent weeks masquerading as an emergency services worker, driving around in his customised white truck fitted with over $100,000 worth of sirens, lights and gear.



    https://www.criminaldefencelawyers....onating-an-emergency-services-vehicle-in-nsw/





  • What is the Law on Impersonating an Emergency Services Vehicle in NSW? - Criminal Defence Lawyers Australia

    Cited text: It is reported that for several weeks leading up to October 2017, the boy, who was believed to be on his learner driver licence, drove around Melbourn...


    Excerpt: In Melbourne, a 16-year-old teenager spent weeks masquerading as an emergency services worker, driving around in his customised white truck fitted with over $100,000 worth of sirens, lights and gear.



    https://www.criminaldefencelawyers....onating-an-emergency-services-vehicle-in-nsw/





  • What is the Law on Impersonating an Emergency Services Vehicle in NSW? - Criminal Defence Lawyers Australia

    Cited text: The 16-year-old made his truck look so realistic with flashing lights fitted on the roof and a siren that motorists, in fact, pulled to the side the l...


    Excerpt: The truck was so realistic with flashing lights fitted on the roof and a siren that motorists pulled to the side to let his vehicle pass.



    https://www.criminaldefencelawyers....onating-an-emergency-services-vehicle-in-nsw/





  • What is the Law on Impersonating an Emergency Services Vehicle in NSW? - Criminal Defence Lawyers Australia

    Cited text: He had been responding to traffic crashes and even assisted people at the scenes of several accidents.


    Excerpt: The teenager had been responding to traffic crashes and even assisted people at the scenes of several accidents



    https://www.criminaldefencelawyers....onating-an-emergency-services-vehicle-in-nsw/





  • What is the Law on Impersonating an Emergency Services Vehicle in NSW? - Criminal Defence Lawyers Australia

    Cited text: Responding to the footage, Senior Constable Fritz Ebert said the truck and the driver’s behaviour were unlike anything he had seen in his five years w...


    Excerpt: Senior Constable Fritz Ebert described the situation as unlike anything he'd seen in five years, noting the danger of 'a 16-year-old unaccompanied inexperienced driver, driving at peak hour traffic' while 'pretending to be an emergency…



    https://www.criminaldefencelawyers....onating-an-emergency-services-vehicle-in-nsw/





  • What is the Law on Impersonating an Emergency Services Vehicle in NSW? - Criminal Defence Lawyers Australia

    Cited text: “It would seem he’s been attending, trying to get vehicles out of the way and then getting out, and I guess pretending to be an emergency service help...


    Excerpt: Senior Constable Fritz Ebert described the situation as unlike anything he'd seen in five years, noting the danger of 'a 16-year-old unaccompanied inexperienced driver, driving at peak hour traffic' while 'pretending to be an emergency…



    https://www.criminaldefencelawyers....onating-an-emergency-services-vehicle-in-nsw/





  • Impersonating Police Offences & Defences NSW—Lexology

    Cited text: A 20-year-old Sydney woman was allegedly pulled over by armed and masked police impersonators in the early hours of the morning, in what she described...


    Excerpt: a 20-year-old Sydney woman described a 'genuinely terrifying' ordeal when she was allegedly chased by armed and masked police impersonators in a silver Holden Commodore with flashing blue and red lights at Bidwill in Sydney's northwest at…



    https://www.lexology.com/library/detail.aspx?g=640b91a1-85dc-41aa-92c5-97a4e73bb289





  • The Penalties for Impersonating a Police Officer in NSW—Criminal Defence Lawyers Australia

    Cited text: Instances of people asserting authority by impersonating police undermines the administration of justice, and it can easily be done- there have been m...


    Excerpt: Many instances of people using fake police flash lights on their vehicles to pull people over



    https://www.criminaldefencelawyers....es-for-impersonating-a-police-officer-in-nsw/





  • Impersonation of Police Officer—Charges, Penalties and Sentencing

    Cited text: The maximum penalty is two years imprisonment and/or a fine of 10 penalty units. The offence of ‘Impersonation of Police Officer’ is contained in s 54...


    Excerpt: In NSW, anyone who impersonates a police officer faces a maximum penalty of two years imprisonment and/or a fine of 10 penalty units



    https://www.armstronglegal.com.au/criminal-law/nsw/offences/dishonesty/impersonation-police-officer/





  • Aggravated Impersonation of Police Officer—Charges, Penalties and Sentencing

    Cited text: The person can be charged with the more serious ‘aggravated’ offence, if they impersonate a police officer and do one of the things that police office...


    Excerpt: If someone impersonates a police officer and does something that police officers have the power to do—like pretending to arrest someone—they can be charged with the more serious 'aggravated' offence, with a maximum penalty of 7 years…



    https://www.armstronglegal.com.au/c...esty/aggravated-impersonation-police-officer/





  • Impersonating Police Offences & Defences NSW—Criminal Defence Lawyers Australia

    Cited text: However, the offence is considered ‘aggravated’ where a person not only impersonates an officer but purports to exercise a power or function as a poli...


    Excerpt: The aggravated offence applies where a person not only impersonates an officer but 'purports to exercise a power or function as a police officer, with intent to deceive' - including 'pretending to be a police officer in order to stop…



    https://www.criminaldefencelawyers.com.au/blog/impersonating-police-offences-defences-nsw/





  • CRIMES ACT 1900—SECT 546D Impersonation of police officers

    Cited text: (4) In this section-- 'impersonation' does not include conduct engaged in solely for satirical purposes.


    Excerpt: The law specifically states that 'impersonation' does not include conduct engaged in solely for satirical purposes



    https://www5.austlii.edu.au/au/legis/nsw/consol_act/ca190082/s546d.html





  • Revisiting red/blue lights—South Australia

    Cited text: I have no doubt that using red/blue lights to communicate to a driver that he or she is required to pull over would be representing oneself by ‘conduc...


    Excerpt: Legal experts note that using red/blue lights to communicate to a driver that they should pull over would constitute 'representing oneself by conduct to be a police officer' and would therefore be impersonating a police officer



    https://australianemergencylaw.com/2020/02/20/revisiting-red-blue-lights-south-australia/





  • Amazon.com: Lumistick 7 Inch LED Police Light Party Beacon | Rotating Flashing Alert Ultra Bright Emergency Warning Light for Party (Blue, 1 Police Beacon) : Industrial & Scientific

    Cited text: This can be used for plays, events, skits and other functions by kids. Organize a police theme party and use this as a party decor item.


    Excerpt: These lights can be used 'for plays, events, skits and other functions by kids' and to 'organize a police theme party and use this as a party decor item'.








  • Amazon.com: Lumistick 7 Inch LED Police Light Party Beacon | Rotating Flashing Alert Ultra Bright Emergency Warning Light for Party (Red, 1 Police Beacon) : Industrial & Scientific

    Cited text: ✔ FOR PARTY: Beacon can be used as a party decoration or in an industrial setting to increase visibility, attract attention, or signal an alert. This ...


    Excerpt: Professional applications include use 'as a party decoration or in an industrial setting to increase visibility, attract attention, or signal an alert' and for 'kid's parties, carnivals, plays, and other events'.








  • Amazon.com: Rhode Island Novelty 7 Inch Red Police Beacon Light, One Piece per Order : Musical Instruments

    Cited text: Occasions—A 7-inch red police beacon toy is perfect for themed parties, Halloween decorations, or playful emergencies in escape rooms. Use it during...


    Excerpt: A 7-inch red police beacon toy is 'perfect for themed parties, Halloween decorations, or playful emergencies in escape rooms' and can be used 'during games like cops and robbers, as a dramatic alert in pranks, or for adding fun to kids'…








  • Is it legal for a civilian vehicle to look like an emergency vehicle if it's for a movie? If so, are emergency lights allowed, and how should we prove to LEO that it's for a movie? - Quora

    Cited text: Answer (1 of 7): Every State has different rules on how similar to an emergency vehicle that a personal vehicle can appear. Generally, you cannot disp...


    Excerpt: regulations vary by state, and generally 'you cannot display red and/or blue lights' on vehicles without proper authorization.



    https://www.quora.com/Is-it-legal-f...w-should-we-prove-to-LEO-that-its-for-a-movie





  • Impersonating Police Offences & Defences NSW—Lexology

    Cited text: “Anyone stopped by an unmarked vehicle with blue and red flashing lights, should ask for identification, obtain the vehicle registration and contact p...


    Excerpt: Police advice is clear: 'Anyone stopped by an unmarked vehicle with blue and red flashing lights, should ask for identification, obtain the vehicle registration and contact police immediately to confirm the legitimacy of those on board'.



    https://www.lexology.com/library/detail.aspx?g=640b91a1-85dc-41aa-92c5-97a4e73bb289





  • Revisiting red/blue lights—South Australia

    Cited text: The Road Traffic (Light Vehicle Standards) Rules 2018 (SA) cl 114(5) says ‘A vehicle, other than an exempt vehicle, a special use vehicle, or a State ...


    Excerpt: In South Australia, road traffic rules state that 'a vehicle, other than an exempt vehicle, a special use vehicle, or a State Government enforcement vehicle must not be fitted with a light that flashes'



    https://australianemergencylaw.com/2020/02/20/revisiting-red-blue-lights-south-australia/





  • Can Civilians Use Emergency and Warning Lights—Extreme Tactical Dynamics

    Cited text: Our products are available to the general public. However, not everyone can operate an emergency light in their car on public roads. What this means i...


    Excerpt: As one emergency lighting retailer explains: 'Our products are available to the general public.



    https://www.extremetacticaldynamics...emergency-and-warning-light-use-by-civilians/





  • Can Civilians Use Emergency and Warning Lights—Extreme Tactical Dynamics

    Cited text: First and foremost, emergency strobe lights that are either red or blue are, by and large, disallowed. There are some exceptions, but the general spir...


    Excerpt: The general principle in emergency lighting regulation is that 'emergency strobe lights that are either red or blue are, by and large, disallowed' for civilian vehicles, with 'the general spirit of the law being that civilian vehicles…



    https://www.extremetacticaldynamics...emergency-and-warning-light-use-by-civilians/



Last edited:

Seniors Discount Club

Sponsored content

Info
Loading data . . .
Doesn’t any “Regulator” screen these products????
Were police and emergency services alerted???
Does ANYTHING and EVERYTHING slip through customs without “red flag” alerts?
What next; uniforms , badges, weapons???😡
 
I can't get past how a 16 year old child can own a car with $100,000 worth of lights and sirens. Where on earth does a 16 year old child get that much money to waste on lights and sirens. Are his parents that rich that they wouldn't even question what he is spending their money on?????
 
Last edited:
So, is making a citizen's arrest to help someone likely to get you arrested yourself?
 
This is a silly and possibly dangerous move by K-Mart. Years ago I was pulled over late at night by a car with a flashing red and blue light in the grill of the car whilst travelling along the highway. I pulled over and stopped. Four thuggish young men got out of the car. I felt like something was not right and quickly took off heading straight for the police station which was not too far away. When I reported this I was told that it had happened to a few people that night and was told that it was not a police car and not the police. I was lucky that instincts kicked in.

Maybe if K-Mart wants to sell such a thing a different colour that is not related to any emergency colour.
 
With everything that you can buy, there will be some idiot or scammer that will use it for personal gain. There is always someone that thinks the law doesn't apply to them.
 
Get real KMart. This is dangerous. My grandson (18) bought his first car for $6000 cash (in the presence of his father). Obviously father did not do necessary checks as 2 years down the track he was followed into his driveway by (??) police in an unmarked car & his first car was confiscated under the guise (maybe??) of being a stolen car but it was legally registered at the Transport department into his name after purchase. Some time after confiscation he was told the (supposed) original owner reported it stolen but that report was not made until 1 1/2 years after supposed stealing. SUSPICIOUS?? Absolutely. It had gone from the so-called original owner to some woman who then sold it for cash to my grandson.

If the police and Transport staff had done did their work consciously and properly then the VIN number and many other details should have been checked by these two important authorities. It has been an expensive loss and lesson for our boy who saved hard for his first car. He has now bought another car (on terms) from a dealer, not for cash from some crooked scammer. Those lights from KMart will most definitely end up being used for fraudulent reasons thereby putting innocent people at risk of losing money or being attacked. We hear so many cases every day of car stealing (then being crashed or burned) people being attacked and KMart’s stupidity is going to bring on more cases with these lights.
 
Last edited:
what a stupid thing to be on the market. more stupid are those that purchase, but we will always have idiots.
KMART GET IT OFF YOUR SHELVES.
 
Nothing is illegal - until you get caught. who reads the fine print - who reads all the information that comes with the article? Certainly not the idiots who'd think it funny to dress their car up and pretend to be police. Or the criminally minded, who surely will find a way to use such toys to their best advantage.
I believe it isn't illegal to own a flick knife - but it is illegal to carry one, and certainly illegal to use it! Those lights are in the same category.
Prevention is always better than cure.
 
Another nightmare for authorities. What is wrong with Kmart.
 
Remove immediately, imagine the wrong people getting their hands on it. Teens adding to a car roof ? What next .
 
  • Like
Reactions: Benny's Light
These items are an invitation leading to trouble
 
  • Like
Reactions: Benny's Light

Join the conversation

News, deals, games, and bargains for Aussies over 60. From everyday expenses like groceries and eating out, to electronics, fashion and travel, the club is all about helping you make your money go further.

Seniors Discount Club

The SDC searches for the best deals, discounts, and bargains for Aussies over 60. From everyday expenses like groceries and eating out, to electronics, fashion and travel, the club is all about helping you make your money go further.
  1. New members
  2. Jokes & fun
  3. Photography
  4. Nostalgia / Yesterday's Australia
  5. Food and Lifestyle
  6. Money Saving Hacks
  7. Offtopic / Everything else
  • We believe that retirement should be a time to relax and enjoy life, not worry about money. That's why we're here to help our members make the most of their retirement years. If you're over 60 and looking for ways to save money, connect with others, and have a laugh, we’d love to have you aboard.
  • Advertise with us

User Menu

Enjoyed Reading our Story?

  • Share this forum to your loved ones.
Change Weather Postcode×
Change Petrol Postcode×