Shoppers flock from Kmart to Target and swear they'll never return: ‘It's always the first place I go’

In the ever-evolving landscape of Australian retail, a significant shift has occurred as shoppers increasingly turn their backs on Kmart in favour of another major retailer, with many declaring they have no intention of returning.

This trend has sparked curiosity and conversation among consumers, prompting us to delve into the reasons behind this retail migration.



Aussies now prefer Target over Kmart, and they have revealed the reason why.

The allure of Target's clothing range has become a major drawcard, with shoppers across the nation praising the brand for its exceptional value for money.

The secret seems to lie in the superior design and quality of Target's apparel, which has garnered a loyal following.


shutterstock_1532289209.jpg
Shoppers now prefer Target over Kmart, and they revealed the reason why. Credit: Shutterstock


In contrast, Kmart's focus on 'trendy' items has come under scrutiny, with customers noting that these products ‘wear down after a few washes’.

Despite both Kmart and Target falling under the Wesfarmers—a conglomerate that also owns Bunnings Warehouse and Officeworks—the two stores have maintained distinct identities.

Post-merger, Target has retained its exclusive clothing brands, such as Lily Loves, Preview, and Fila, while Kmart has taken over the home and beauty segments on the shelves.

Target's pricing may be a notch higher than what Kmart shoppers are accustomed to, but Australians have said the extra investment is well worth it.

'From my experience, Target materials feel more durable, and the designs are more refined. But Kmart does better with “trendy” home décor items, though sometimes longevity can be a hit or miss,' one shopper expressed online.



The sentiment is echoed in the maternity, baby, and kids' clothing sectors, where Target's offerings are perceived as superior in quality, durability, and design.

'Target baby and kids clothes were hugely better in quality than Kmart. Better feel, better wear, kept colour and didn't stretch out of shape. Their women's clothing was also generally better,' a customer shared.

Target's recent clothing lines have even made waves on social media.

'I'm obsessed with the new spring and linen collection at Target,' one said.

'The work wardrobes are just the best,' another added. 'It's always the first place I go nowadays when I need new clothes.'



Amidst the Kmart-Target merger, loyal customers have voiced concerns over the potential loss of Target's staple products.

'I have always bought our sheets from Target. It has been a staple product forever,' a woman said.

'I went in yesterday to buy a new set, and they were on clearance. Every colour. I think they will be replaced by Anko very soon.'

Another added, 'Target had better not lose its own brand of towels and sheets. They are far superior to even the most expensive Kmart brand.'

The difference between the two stores extends beyond product quality.

'I have found Target clothes to be consistently better quality than Kmart brand still. I have got a few things since the change over,' one shared.

'What I hated about our local Kmart store at the time was the mess. Clothes jammed so tight on shelves it was impossible to browse, so stuff inevitably ended up on the floor or scattered nearby. The shoes were the worst.’

'Our local Target, by comparison, was lovely to shop in,' another added.



The decision to merge the two entities came after Target experienced a $67 million slump in sales in 2020, leading to the closure or conversion of 167 stores into Kmart outlets.

This move aimed to consolidate operations and harness technology more effectively, with Wesfarmers' Executive, Mr Bailey, citing significant cost savings and productivity improvements as key benefits.

Despite the upheaval, Target staff were offered positions within Kmart or other Wesfarmers companies, ensuring a smooth transition for employees.

The company invested between $120 million and $170 million in the closures and conversions, with an additional $140 million allocated for store conversion and stock clearance costs.
Key Takeaways

  • Australian shoppers are increasingly choosing Target over Kmart due to a perception of higher quality and better value for money in Target's clothing ranges.
  • Target retains its own clothing brands post-merger, while Kmart focuses on 'trendy' home decor and beauty items, although the longevity of these products is sometimes questionable.
  • Customers praise Target for its durable materials and refined designs in both adult and kids' apparel, as opposed to Kmart's offerings, which may wear down more quickly.
  • Despite store closures and conversions from Target to Kmart, Target's commitment to maintaining its clothing brands post-merger has been positively received by shoppers, with the quality of Target's products being a key factor in customer preference.
Have you made the switch from Kmart to Target, or do you still find value in what Kmart has to offer? Share your experiences and thoughts in the comments below!
 
Sponsored
the list of products in Target that are far better quality than the same kind of items offered in Kmart is endless, given the choice I would much prefer to shop in Target, unfortunately that choice was taken away when Wesfarmers decided to close the majority of regional Target stores, faced with the choice of Target and Kmart in the same shopping center, they opted to close Target so we lost Target but gained Aldi, who very quickly and happily took over the empty store space ,while I am ever grateful for the addition of Aldi I miss Target badly. I guess it will be yet another store that offers online shopping that I will happily purchase from, like I need another online store to browse through:eek:
 
Yes, I use Target, but please remember we don't have the walkin access to a lot of other shops in my little town.
 
I am the opposite now. Since our local target moved I have taken to KMart more. Target use to have a terrific range of women exercise clothing far far better than Kmart. Did the trek over to our closest Target and the clothing was crap. Now Kmart on the other hand has a fabulous range of clothing these days but then that could change in 12 months then 12 months after that change again. I think it's what you are looking for at the right price at that moment but right at this stage Kmart out does Target even though they don't support of a lot of Aussie things.
 
It would be interesting to break down the phrase 'the right price'. The majority of KMart stock is made in China. By whom and at what social cost??? I will not shop there, nor purchase Items from any online or retail store which appears to support the extremely questionable social and business practices of overseas suppliers.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cheezil and magpie1
It would be interesting to break down the phrase 'the right price'. The majority of KMart stock is made in China. By whom and at what social cost??? I will not shop there, nor purchase Items from any online or retail store which appears to support the extremely questionable social and business practices of overseas suppliers.
good luck finding products not made in china. nothing made in australia. try india or bangladesh.
 
Always prefer Target. Have bought heaps there over many years. Their quality is better than Kmart. Unfortunately my local Target closed 5 years ago. Now the nearest is 12km away and Kmart is just down the road. Convenience and petrol win for Kmart.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Colette 3799
It would be interesting to break down the phrase 'the right price'. The majority of KMart stock is made in China. By whom and at what social cost??? I will not shop there, nor purchase Items from any online or retail store which appears to support the extremely questionable social and business practices of overseas suppliers.
Do you shop at Jay Jay's by any chance?

A bit overpriced....
 
  • Like
Reactions: IAN3005
Temu still China.
Very rare product marketed by the wonderland of Temu not made in China.
I succumbed to trying them, now enndeavouring to escape! I checked background before giving them a go. US base given so was reassured. Very insidious marketing.
 
We are not shopping K Mart anymore. We were away from home for 4 months. While away I bought two of the Microwave toasters as gifts. Arrived home to find the people already had one. Went to KMart for a refund, only to be told no more refunds without a docket. . So came home to try & find the dockets only to be told as they were bought over 60 days ago we cannot return them. How unfair is that? Lousy lot they are. They have lost a very good customer. Now we are stuck with two toasters because of their mean ness. Why does it matter when we bought them?
 
  • Like
Reactions: IAN3005
Always prefer Target. Have bought heaps there over many years. Their quality is better than Kmart. Unfortunately my local Target closed 5 years ago. Now the nearest is 12km away and Kmart is just down the road. Convenience and petrol win for Kmart.
12 k you will need to take your sleepwear and a toothbrush.
 
l don't know what the clothes are like there now but l bought a lovely blouse in Chatswood and had it for years and years
 
No I haven’t switched I have included. Bedding from target most other things from k mart
 

Join the conversation

News, deals, games, and bargains for Aussies over 60. From everyday expenses like groceries and eating out, to electronics, fashion and travel, the club is all about helping you make your money go further.

Seniors Discount Club

The SDC searches for the best deals, discounts, and bargains for Aussies over 60. From everyday expenses like groceries and eating out, to electronics, fashion and travel, the club is all about helping you make your money go further.
  1. New members
  2. Jokes & fun
  3. Photography
  4. Nostalgia / Yesterday's Australia
  5. Food and Lifestyle
  6. Money Saving Hacks
  7. Offtopic / Everything else

Latest Articles

  • We believe that retirement should be a time to relax and enjoy life, not worry about money. That's why we're here to help our members make the most of their retirement years. If you're over 60 and looking for ways to save money, connect with others, and have a laugh, we’d love to have you aboard.
  • Advertise with us

User Menu

Enjoyed Reading our Story?

  • Share this forum to your loved ones.
Change Weather Postcode×
Change Petrol Postcode×