She Broke My ONE Wedding Rule - Why I Had No Choice But To Kick My Sister Out

Weddings are a time of joy, celebration, and often, meticulous planning. Every couple dreams of a perfect day to mark the beginning of their lives together, and sometimes, that dream includes a specific vision that they hope their guests will help bring to life. But what happens when someone close to you, someone you consider family, blatantly disregards your wishes on your special day? This is the dilemma one bride faced, leading to a decision that has since sparked a whirlwind of opinions.



The bride, a 25-year-old newlywed, took to the popular AITA (Am I The Asshole) Reddit forum to share her story. She grew up with an adopted sister, 'Jen', who was given special treatment due to her rough start in life. The bride understood and supported this, even though it meant that Jen often got her way, and she, by comparison, felt like she came second.


shutterstock_365387675.jpg
A bride expressed frustration over her adopted sister for not granting her wedding wish. Credit: Shutterstock


Fast forward to adulthood, and the bride is now independent, successful, and ready to tie the knot with her fiancé 'Kip'. They planned a big, joyful wedding with a unique twist: a color scheme that reflected their favorite colors. Guests were asked to wear yellow, blue, or green, depending on their relationship to the bride or groom. The bride even chose a dress with green embroidered details to fit the theme.



However, Jen was not on board. She despised yellow and flatly refused to wear it, prompting the bride to warn her that non-compliance would result in her being asked to leave. It seemed like a straightforward rule, yet on the wedding day, Jen arrived in a purple dress, completely disregarding the agreed-upon color scheme.

The bride felt she had no choice but to ask Jen to leave, a decision that was met with resistance until the threat of security was made. While the rest of the wedding proceeded without a hitch, the aftermath was anything but smooth. The bride's parents were furious, accusing her of cruelty over something they perceived as trivial. The bride stood her ground, asserting that it was her wedding and her right to enforce the rules she had set.

The bride's fiancé, Kip, supported her decision, pointing out the favoritism that had been shown to Jen over the years. The incident has divided family and friends, with some saying they wouldn't have invited Jen in the first place, while others believe the bride should have been more lenient.



The Reddit community weighed in, with many siding with the bride, noting that Jen's choice to wear purple seemed like an act of spite, especially since all other guests had managed to adhere to the color scheme. Others criticized the parents for their ongoing favoritism and suggested it was time for the bride to confront them and her sister about their behavior.

However, some questioned the importance of the color scheme, arguing that the focus should be on the people and the marriage itself, rather than the aesthetics. They wondered if the strict rules were worth the potential fallout and whether the bride's priorities were misplaced.

As the debate rages on, one thing is clear: weddings can bring out the best and worst in people. The bride's story is a reminder that while it's important to respect the wishes of the couple, it's equally important to consider the lasting impact of the decisions made on such a significant day.



Key Takeaways
  • A woman shares her story on a Reddit forum about kicking her sister out of her wedding for not following the colour scheme dress code.
  • The woman explained her decision, stating she had made it clear to her sister that she would be asked to leave if she didn't wear yellow.
  • Online reactions to the woman's story were mixed, with some supporting her right to uphold her wedding rules and others criticising the importance placed on aesthetic.
  • The narrative reveals ongoing family tensions and favouritism, sparking discussions about the complex dynamics between siblings and their parents.

At the Seniors Discount Club, we understand the complexities of family dynamics, especially when it comes to events as emotionally charged as weddings. We invite our readers to share their thoughts and experiences. Have you ever had to enforce a difficult rule at a family event? How did you handle the situation, and what was the outcome? Let's discuss the delicate balance between standing up for oneself and maintaining family harmony.
 

Seniors Discount Club

Sponsored content

Info
Loading data . . .
I have to support the bride & groom in this regard. The guidelines were set & all guests, except one, were able to comply with the bride's wishes. Afterall it was her special day.

It almost seems that her sister was out to ruin the couple's day by going against the trend, a defiance, a rebellious statement which would have made her an 'ugly duckling', standing out in the crowd because she bucked the wishes of the bride.
 
Personally I think the bride is too full of self-importance and had I been told what colour to wear, would have declined the invitation on principle. A wedding is of great significance and a celebration, not a "play" where "we all dress up in costume". The sister would have been better not to have turned up and made her statement that way. We recently declined an invitation as with it came an envelope printed with our names requesting money instead of a present!!!
 
Personally I think the bride is too full of self-importance and had I been told what colour to wear, would have declined the invitation on principle. A wedding is of great significance and a celebration, not a "play" where "we all dress up in costume". The sister would have been better not to have turned up and made her statement that way. We recently declined an invitation as with it came an envelope printed with our names requesting money instead of a present!!!
It WAS the bride and groom's special day and I don't think they were being selfish at all, but I do agree with you that if the sister didn't like the colour request she should have just declined the invitation, NOT tried to sabotage such a special day for her sister.
 
Personally I think the bride is too full of self-importance and had I been told what colour to wear, would have declined the invitation on principle. A wedding is of great significance and a celebration, not a "play" where "we all dress up in costume". The sister would have been better not to have turned up and made her statement that way. We recently declined an invitation as with it came an envelope printed with our names requesting money instead of a present!!!
If a couple are living together before they are married, which seems to be the trend today, they have already set up house & don't need an electric kettle etc & money would be a good idea.

Such was the case with my eldest Grandson when he married. They were only living in a duplex but had most of what they needed, some donated because he worked at a Salvation Army sheltered workshop & most guests gave them money, which they knew would happen.

When we married 52 1/2 years ago my parents gave us a fridge l had grown up with so was around 15 years old. Approx 6 months into the marriage we had to buy a new one because it broke down. Other guests gave us 'normal gifts' because we hadn't been living together & needed those items.
 
One very weird wedding!
The mix of the three colours would have looked hideous.
Don't think guests should have been requested to do this anyway. I'm sure the bride could have introduced her colour scheme in another way. Certainly issues between the two sisters which their Mother perhaps should have intervened and sorted before the big day. I would not like to be told what colour dress I am to to wear and would have politely declined the invitation.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Glucose and Lotty
Personally I think the bride is too full of self-importance and had I been told what colour to wear, would have declined the invitation on principle. A wedding is of great significance and a celebration, not a "play" where "we all dress up in costume". The sister would have been better not to have turned up and made her statement that way. We recently declined an invitation as with it came an envelope printed with our names requesting money instead of a present!!!
Whilst it is a personal choice l think gifting money is a good idea. However to put it into an envelope supplied by the bride and groom with the guests name is so wrong.
 
Your adopted sister has a massive chip on her shoulders because of the way she was favoured when you were kids. Good on you for standing up to her and really who cares if she doesn't talk to you, and your parents showed their favouritism once again, they should have just stayed out of it.
 
It’s the brides day. The sister could have found a beautiful dress in one of the many shades of yellow, from the palest lemon to the brightest gold. This could just be a culmination of events over the years, I can understand the Bride wanting her wedding to be done her way, but this may cause family ill feeling for the foreseeable future. Family photos of the wedding won’t be family photos with one missing. On the other hand the sister was asked to respect the chosen colour scheme and knew the consequences.
 
Too much pettiness goes into weddings today.
People have forgotten the true meaning of marriage being a celebration of unity between a couple - not a Halloween Party or competition.
When I married I only had my brother and sister as maid-of-honour and best man in my retinue - and told my sister to choose a colour scheme for herself, and the 2 mothers.
 
One very weird wedding!
The mix of the three colours would have looked hideous.
Don't think guests should have been requested to do this anyway. I'm sure the bride could have introduced her colour scheme in another way. Certainly issues between the two sisters which their Mother perhaps should have intervened and sorted before the big day. I would not like to be told what colour dress I am to to wear and would have politely declined the invitation.
Was the wedding for the guests or for the bride and groom? Don't like the rules then do them a favour and don't go!
 
In our days you never wore black to a wedding & we followed that rule. Being the brides biggest day, it is a shame that a simple request could not be adhered to. I think it goes deeper in this instance. Unfortunately, the rift in the family will last and happy occasions that follow a marriage will be missed. Like a lot of weddings & funerals there is always something that pulls a family apart.
 
I think there is more to this story , and there is always two sides of a story.

What I get is that the bride is actually jealous of her adopted sister.
Sounds like she has held a grudge for along time.

I have never heard of a bride choosing a colour for the guest to wear unless it's one colour and it's usually black.

Yellow is such a bad colour and a colour which doesn't suit many people. It's a colour which can actually make someone look sick.

I think it's a horrible thing how she chose three colours and categorised people by colour coding them. Looks like she chose yellow for her family. Another colour for the grooms family abd another colour for friends

I think the bride is a self centred twit
 

Join the conversation

News, deals, games, and bargains for Aussies over 60. From everyday expenses like groceries and eating out, to electronics, fashion and travel, the club is all about helping you make your money go further.

Seniors Discount Club

The SDC searches for the best deals, discounts, and bargains for Aussies over 60. From everyday expenses like groceries and eating out, to electronics, fashion and travel, the club is all about helping you make your money go further.
  1. New members
  2. Jokes & fun
  3. Photography
  4. Nostalgia / Yesterday's Australia
  5. Food and Lifestyle
  6. Money Saving Hacks
  7. Offtopic / Everything else
  • We believe that retirement should be a time to relax and enjoy life, not worry about money. That's why we're here to help our members make the most of their retirement years. If you're over 60 and looking for ways to save money, connect with others, and have a laugh, we’d love to have you aboard.
  • Advertise with us

User Menu

Enjoyed Reading our Story?

  • Share this forum to your loved ones.
Change Weather Postcode×
Change Petrol Postcode×