Proposed Medicare reforms spark discussions online. Can these proposals help Aussie seniors' healthcare concerns?

As Australians navigate the complexities of healthcare, it's crucial to stay informed about policies that could affect everyone's wallets and well-being.

For Australian seniors and families, a proposal from the past has resurfaced and stirred concerns about its possible financial impact on annual healthcare expenses.


Current opposition leader Peter Dutton once advocated for 'American-style' Medicare reforms.

If implemented, these reforms could see families shell out an additional $800 for their healthcare annually.

This figure is not just a random estimate; it's grounded in a detailed analysis and its potential ripple effects on household budgets.

The said reforms were part of a broader vision to overhaul Medicare, with the intent to address 'staggering' increases in health spending.


compressed-pexels-GP checkup.jpeg
The proposed reforms could force Australians to spend more for their medical appointments. Image Credit: Pexels/cottonbro studio


Mr Dutton, who once served as Health Minister, proposed a series of measures aimed at modernising and strengthening the system.

Among these plans was the introduction of a $7 fee for general practitioner (GP) visits, emergency department visits for minor ailments, and pathology tests.

These fees encouraged a more efficient use of healthcare services and could prompt Australians with means to contribute to their healthcare costs.

Mr Dutton previously argued that the health system was 'riddled with inefficiency and waste', and immediate action was necessary to ensure its sustainability.


However, the proposed $7 GP fee sparked significant controversy.

The said 'GP tax' became a point of contention within the Abbott Government back in 2014.

Despite the considerable debate about Medicare's future and universal healthcare across Australia, the policy was eventually scrapped.

The Labor Party, now led by Prime Minister Anthony Albanese, has been vocal in its criticism of Dutton's past stance on Medicare.

They previously warned that the said reforms could have ended bulk billing.

Without bulk billing, every GP visit, blood test, or medical scan could incur a fee.

For a family of four, this meant an additional $6326 or $665 annually.

Meanwhile, a family with three kids may have to pay $8000 or $832 annually for healthcare.


Dutton's legislative efforts to increase the cost of PBS medicines by $5 per prescription could also burden families—especially those without a concession card.

New South Wales, in particular, was projected to be hit hardest by the proposed 'American-style' healthcare reforms.

Despite the discussions surrounding the reforms, Mr Dutton has defended his record as Health Minister.

Mr Dutton highlighted his achievements in increasing hospital funding, establishing the Medical Research Future Fund, and raising bulk billing rates.

He also dismissed the Australian Labor Party's (ALP) claims as a 'scare campaign' and has pledged to continue investing in key health services if elected.

The Australian healthcare landscape has seen several changes over the past decades.

While these reforms were not implemented, they should serve as a reminder for everyone to stay engaged with policies that could impact everyone's health and finances.

As seniors, it's crucial to understand how such changes could affect your access to affordable healthcare, regardless of income and situation.
Key Takeaways

  • Former Health Minister Peter Dutton previously supported 'American-style' Medicare reforms, which could introduce fees for GP visits, tests and emergency department visits.
  • The proposed reforms could cost Australian families up to $800 a year, depending on the family size.
  • Prime Minister Anthony Albanese previously criticised these reforms and claimed that it would have led to a significant increase in health costs.
  • Despite the criticism, Peter Dutton defended his record on health and cited increases in hospital funding and bulk billing rates during his tenure as Health Minister.
Have you experienced any changes in your healthcare expenses over the past few years? What are your thoughts on the proposed Medicare reforms and their potential impact on your healthcare costs? Share your experiences and insights about these proposed reforms in the comments section below.
 

Seniors Discount Club

Sponsored content

Info
Loading data . . .
My doctors clinic has always bulk billed and I never pay for x rays, blood tests etc. only people who don’t have a concession card pay 🙂
 
  • Love
Reactions: Sherril54
Good luck if Dutton is elected to the BIG SEAT and ENJOY, he will do nothing to support you, you are living in a fool`s paradise. He showed no interest in pensioners while in the position of Health Minister (unless you were well healed) and could pay for private health insurance, he was planing to introduce a patient co-payent to top up medicare. You would trust him?? he cannot get any story right and is pulling your leg you think he does not have Trumpian type policy (across the board) in mind. HAPPY EASTER!
We already pay a $40 co-payment plus a medicare levy plus over $5000 in health insurance pa. Our retirement plan is gone under this current government with cost of living. Happy to pay a $7 co-payment, if it improves the system.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Glucose and Leenie
Wakey. Wakey. Seniors and families are already “Shelling Out” extra medical costs in rural areas where services do not exist or, ARE NOT COVERED BY MEDICARE???
 
  • Like
Reactions: Leenie
Do you want Nuclear Power? Vote Liberal and then figure what we can do with radio active waste. Also very expensive to build...
Do you want Nuclear Power? Vote Liberal and then figure what we can do with radio active waste. Also very expensive to build...
$600 billion dollars and I’ll be dead by the time it’s built so will Dutton but your kids and their kids kids etc will be paying for it forever.
And he’ll be down in hell laughing at them all.👹
 
Good luck if Dutton is elected to the BIG SEAT and ENJOY, he will do nothing to support you, you are living in a fool`s paradise. He showed no interest in pensioners while in the position of Health Minister (unless you were well healed) and could pay for private health insurance, he was planing to introduce a patient co-payent to top up medicare. You would trust him?? he cannot get any story right and is pulling your leg you think he does not have Trumpian type policy (across the board) in mind. HAPPY EASTER!
Then go ahead and vote for even worse destruction - a continuation of the appallingly bad government we are seeing now, encouraging racial division, bringing in immigrants by the hundreds of thousands to exacerbate major homelessness and poverty and put horrendous pressure on infrastructure, sending record numbers of businesses bankrupt...
Neither party cares about pensioners, Sherril54. But at least the LNP wants the nation as a whole to be more economically healthy, which benefits everyone.

Personally, I'd rather see both major parties turfed out and preferably wiped out, for good. But if we have to have the lesser of two evils, sadly Dutton is our only choice this time around, as much as I dislike him. As for "Trumpian type'' policies. Bring them on please! Trump is cutting government waste, restoring morality and common sense (even if his own morals are shockingly low!), getting tough on crime, and focusing on restoring trade health and sensible military policies. Only those who swallow media lies oppose him. He is intensively dislikable on a personal basis, but he is doing what needs to be done without bending to the stupid whose focus is platitudes or the power-mad evil. Did you know he has basically broken the power of the dangerous European oligarchs? They were ruining the whole world. He is the only politician with the guts and strategy to take them down. .
 
$600 billion dollars and I’ll be dead by the time it’s built so will Dutton but your kids and their kids kids etc will be paying for it forever.
And he’ll be down in hell laughing at them all.👹
Get your facts right. Nuclear is the least dangerous and the least environmentally harmful form of energy production currently known. It is also far, far more economical than renewables. Of course if either party cared about either economy or the environment, they would be focused on much more innovative and basically FREE energy creation, but that would upset the status quo, and we can't have that, can we? There are over 200 energy-creation patents locked in vaults, never to be exposed, because they take money out of the pockets of big oil and mining companies and producers of solar panels and wind turbines.
 
Get your facts right. Nuclear is the least dangerous and the least environmentally harmful form of energy production currently known. It is also far, far more economical than renewables. Of course if either party cared about either economy or the environment, they would be focused on much more innovative and basically FREE energy creation, but that would upset the status quo, and we can't have that, can we? There are over 200 energy-creation patents locked in vaults, never to be exposed, because they take money out of the pockets of big oil and mining companies and producers of solar panels and wind turbines.
$600 billion - Another Albo/Bowen LIE
 
Why are you bringing up something that was said over a decade ago. Are you believing the ads untrue ads that the Labour party are shoving down our throat.
If any party has hurt medicace it has been the Labour party the percentage you got back before Labour got in was around 86% where we are now down to 77% so that tells me that Labour is more dangerous to Medicare
Since Labour came in when I used the home plan it was free and now I am out by $35 and I am on the age pension with the concession card and there are so many other thing that have gone off the Medicare list that are not talked about just what they have added. Labour is more like Trump that stand there like the last election and promise things but do nothing but racked up a deficit of a mouth watering 1 Trillion so with his promises it is just like adding it to Australia's credit card and most of us know if you spend beyond our means you are in financial trouble. I think those who run this site should be like lots of media should be impartial in what is written
And the Labour party allowed the biggest rise in the healthfund
If Labour get in we are going to buy at least 2 or 3 more generators as we are a suburb that are chosed to cut our power as they haven't enough power to handle the power load so it is starting already intermittent power.
To get rid of Medicare is Political suicide for any political party
You could not have put it better. SDC is just a mouthpiece for the ALP. I fully regret spending money to belong to such a pathetic organisation. Still someone has to debunk the biased BS that they present camouflaged as important article. The parties other than the ALP have issued policies and clearly in the case of the LNP no cuts to Medicare is clearly stated and as you rightly point out it would be political suicide to do that but SDC ignores the truth and goes on this dirty road.
 
Why are you bringing up something that was said over a decade ago. Are you believing the ads untrue ads that the Labour party are shoving down our throat.
If any party has hurt medicace it has been the Labour party the percentage you got back before Labour got in was around 86% where we are now down to 77% so that tells me that Labour is more dangerous to Medicare
Since Labour came in when I used the home plan it was free and now I am out by $35 and I am on the age pension with the concession card and there are so many other thing that have gone off the Medicare list that are not talked about just what they have added. Labour is more like Trump that stand there like the last election and promise things but do nothing but racked up a deficit of a mouth watering 1 Trillion so with his promises it is just like adding it to Australia's credit card and most of us know if you spend beyond our means you are in financial trouble. I think those who run this site should be like lots of media should be impartial in what is written
And the Labour party allowed the biggest rise in the healthfund
If Labour get in we are going to buy at least 2 or 3 more generators as we are a suburb that are chosed to cut our power as they haven't enough power to handle the power load so it is starting already intermittent power.
To get rid of Medicare is Political suicide for any political party
I and am sure many others are tired 💤 of all the B/S and lies that are coming out of Labor’s smug
Get your facts right. Nuclear is the least dangerous and the least environmentally harmful form of energy production currently known. It is also far, far more economical than renewables. Of course if either party cared about either economy or the environment, they would be focused on much more innovative and basically FREE energy creation, but that would upset the status quo, and we can't have that, can we? There are over 200 energy-creation patents locked in vaults, never to be exposed, because they take money out of the pockets of big oil and mining companies and producers of solar panels and wind turbines.
look what they did to TESLA and what he created , put him out of business, and the ones who created vehicles that ran on water , in the US most of them died mysteriously. We hav e LUCAS HEIGHTS in Sydney and no one has ever gotten sick or died and products have saved 👨 lives.
 
My doctors clinic has always bulk billed and I never pay for x rays, blood tests etc. only people who don’t have a concession card pay 🙂
You are very luck you’ll not many Drs here bulk bill, xrays and pathology are bulk billed , last time pathology asked did I mind if they bulk billed , so am wondering if charges are coming in the future.
 
Here's a potted history of universal health care in this country for those who have conveniently forgotten. Then judge for yourself who really wants to maintain it in this country. Medibank universal health was introduced by Whitlam ( ALP). Fraser (LNP) got rid of it and turned it into a private health insurer. Hawke ( ALP) reintroduced universal health and called it Medicare. John Howard (LNP) was no fan of medicare openly criticising it. He introduced the Private Health insurance rebate. Money that would have been better spent on Medicare. Gillard (ALP) introduced a temporary rebate freeze. Abbot ( LNP) sold Medibank private to a private health insurance company. A proposal to introduce a co payment was not popular instead he cut the rebate for non concessional patients which was a co payment by stealth effectively leading to bulk billing of only concession card holders. The Freeze on the medicare rebate was not lifted under subsequent LNP effectively ending bulk billing. Labor announced a policy to end the freeze in 2017. During their latest term in government they have ended the freeze on most patholgy payments, introduced a number of incentives to improve bulk billing uptake including incentives to improve the quality of health care like My medicare, and larger rebates for long consults. Medicare is an ALP legacy and they will fight to maintain and strengthen it. LNP have hated it since it was formed. Its in their DNA. It goes against their core beliefs. If you doubt this just read what the IPA ( their favored think tank) has to say on it.
Thank you so much, I bet there will be people who will not even read this history. It is exactly what I have been trying to say.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Littleboy8
Just read some of the replies here. I think you are outvoted by some well thought out replies. As for being left with a deficit. That was primarily due to covid & extra spending. This is the first deficit Labor has been left with in how many elections?? Usually it's Labor wasting money & leaving a huge deficit for Liberals to clean up. I said when they got in power, we're in for a rough ride now & it was true. We need a conservative Govt to tighten the purse strings.
Good luck to you then, I hope you have a big bank balance yourself, you probably do because you don`t care about others who may not be so fortunate.And also read some Political history and find out exactly what Liberals have done for the vulnerable, NOTHING!
 

Join the conversation

News, deals, games, and bargains for Aussies over 60. From everyday expenses like groceries and eating out, to electronics, fashion and travel, the club is all about helping you make your money go further.

Seniors Discount Club

The SDC searches for the best deals, discounts, and bargains for Aussies over 60. From everyday expenses like groceries and eating out, to electronics, fashion and travel, the club is all about helping you make your money go further.
  1. New members
  2. Jokes & fun
  3. Photography
  4. Nostalgia / Yesterday's Australia
  5. Food and Lifestyle
  6. Money Saving Hacks
  7. Offtopic / Everything else

Latest Articles

  • We believe that retirement should be a time to relax and enjoy life, not worry about money. That's why we're here to help our members make the most of their retirement years. If you're over 60 and looking for ways to save money, connect with others, and have a laugh, we’d love to have you aboard.
  • Advertise with us

User Menu

Enjoyed Reading our Story?

  • Share this forum to your loved ones.
Change Weather Postcode×
Change Petrol Postcode×