Millions may be overpaying for insurance as $500 discovery is made by Aussie driver

Navigating the insurance world can often feel like a maze, with premiums fluctuating and the fine print getting finer.

It's no wonder that insurance bills can be a source of significant stress for many Australians, especially those of us in our golden years.

With costs for home, car, health, and other forms of insurance soaring in recent years, it's crucial to stay vigilant about where our hard-earned money is going.


One Melbourne-based driver, Greg Schrader, was taken aback by a startling discovery that has sparked a warning for millions of Australians.

Schrader, curious to see if he was getting the best deal on his car insurance, decided to conduct a little experiment.

His Ford Ranger was due for insurance renewal, but rather than automatically re-signing, he decided to test the waters.


1743383994179.png
A $500 difference in car insurance premiums was noticed by an Australian driver based on different addresses in the same area. Credit: David Gyung / iStock


Schrader created a fake quote with AAMI, using all his own details except for one—he listed a house just a few doors down from his own as his place of residence.

The result is the quote came back at $1,250 for the year, a whopping $500 cheaper than his current policy.

Despite making no claims on his car, Schrader was puzzled by the significant price difference.


This eye-opening experience serves as a timely reminder to shop around and not simply settle for the renewal notice that lands in our mailbox.

'Pick up the phone, go online, do your due diligence, do your research,' Schrader advised.

He's not alone in his call for consumers to be proactive. Financial experts, including David Koch, urged Australians to treat insurance shopping with the same scrutiny as grocery shopping.

'We all know that the lesser-known sauces and the home brand spices all taste just as good as the products with big names and even bigger advertising budgets,' he said.

'Most of us are willing to give a different olive oil a go when the price of our favourite variety reaches levels of insanity.'

'But when it comes to insurance, we quite like sticking to the same brand. They make us feel cosy, safe and looked after—because we have always been with them. Sometimes they pull at the heartstrings with their marketing campaigns.'

'Maybe we believe that our loyalty will somehow be rewarded through better discounts. The sad reality is loyalty usually doesn’t pay.'.


The insurance industry is complex, with policy quotes based on a myriad of factors, including risk assessment, claims history, specific address, driver age, and vehicle type.

But with annual car insurance premium renewals having jumped 58 per cent from the previous year, it's clear that something is amiss.

While natural disasters and construction costs have been blamed for hikes in home and contents insurance premiums, the reasons behind the steep increase in car insurance costs remain less clear.

The financial strain of insurance is leading some Australians to make drastic decisions.

Finder research found that 16 percent of people—equivalent to 3.3 million Aussies—planned to cancel their health insurance policies by 2025.


Additionally, some have downgraded their home insurance policies or ditched travel insurance to save money.

As seniors, ensuring we're not overpaying for insurance is especially important.

It's worth taking the time to review your policies and compare the market. Y

You might be surprised at the savings you can find, just like Greg Schrader did.


Credit: TikTok

Key Takeaways
  • An Australian driver noticed a $500 difference in car insurance premiums for the exact vehicle based on different addresses within the same area.
  • The driver’s investigation highlights the importance of shopping around for insurance and not simply accepting renewal quotes.
  • Insurance quotes can vary significantly based on multiple factors, including address, claims history, and the driver's and vehicle's age.
  • It's essential for consumers to regularly review their insurance policies and consider switching providers to avoid overpaying due to assumed loyalty benefits.
Have you had a similar experience with insurance premiums? Or perhaps you've found a great way to save on your policies? Share your stories and tips in the comments below.
 

Seniors Discount Club

Sponsored content

Info
Loading data . . .
it's very simple, insurance companies give up a 15% discount for a new policy. They are not interested in giving a discount after a couple of years, as they know most won't look around, hence they all do it. Reason most don't compare with any insurance companies, it just too hard to really compare without just looking more into the policies. Ak: term and conditions all the million and one thing you have to read, before signing up. Have every try the compare websites? Say you are looking for car insurance policy, that are all the same, they offer different things, what they do or not cover to the amount of excess. So, it not so simply comparing.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DLHM and PattiB
No he just compared!!
I was wondering the response from the insurance company when he spoke to them and asked.Or did he say nothing
I try with my home insurance, told them, what was around. No, they would not budge. And because I change, you get the discount for a new online policy. Went back to RACV, with my "New" policy discount, my RACV Card discounts, it was much cheaper, lower excess and higher amount insured.
 
I'm surprised that HE'S surprised. I though that this was well known, different locations will change your quote. Highly likely the address he used was in another suburb that has a higher risk. You can also try numerous insurance companies and get different results for different suburbs, say company X may give you $1,000 for Parramatta, company Z will give you $1,200. Try again with another suburb and the cheaper one could be more expensive this time.

You must shop around with insurance AND if you get a better quote call your current provider who very well may match the price. BUT b careful with the inclusions in your policy and the excess amounts they use for the quote to ensure everything is equal.
he said the address he gave them for the quote was 4 doors down....
 
he said the address he gave them for the quote was 4 doors down....
Correct! From the article:-

Schrader created a fake quote with AAMI, using all his own details except for one—he listed a house just a few doors down from his own as his place of residence.

Even though there is a "cutoff" point, the geographical location of a residence does not change the risk of insuring a car with regards to the probability of one being victim of a collision or burglary when just a few doors down.

Does living on Stud Road in Rowville, Victoria, represent a much lower risk than the same road in Dandenong, just a few kilometres apart?

This is not justification for a discrepancy of $500 a year.
 
  • Like
  • Love
Reactions: DLHM and PattiB
Correct! From the article:-

Schrader created a fake quote with AAMI, using all his own details except for one—he listed a house just a few doors down from his own as his place of residence.

Even though there is a "cutoff" point, the geographical location of a residence does not change the risk of insuring a car with regards to the probability of one being victim of a collision or burglary when just a few doors down.

Does living on Stud Road in Rowville, Victoria, represent a much lower risk than the same road in Dandenong, just a few kilometres apart?

This is not justification for a discrepancy of $500 a year.
Well done @Veggiepatch! Perhaps that know-all @Greg350 will take more notice of you than he does of me. I know his type. Presumptuous and arrogant. He completely (deliberately) missed my point. Not as smart as he thinks he is. He also didn’t read the article properly. Just saw what he wanted to see.
 
Well done @Veggiepatch! Perhaps that know-all @Greg350 will take more notice of you than he does of me. I know his type. Presumptuous and arrogant. He completely (deliberately) missed my point. Not as smart as he thinks he is. He also didn’t read the article properly. Just saw what he wanted to see.
Selective reading rears its ugly head....
 
  • Like
  • Love
Reactions: DLHM and PattiB
Really, the insurance companies need to be fully investigated by the government. From the way they cheat customers with ever increasing premiums to insufficient payouts on a claim. The problem is they know they hve us all over a barrel. The government will not make things hard for them, because it knows that fair insurance is too expensive. SIO was sold off, and the private health insurance companies are being allowed to charge and do whatever they please, the government does not want to be responsible for an insurance that is just going to mean enormous losses. We all have stories of being cheated by our insurance company. from the so called "replacement cost' of our car when it is written off, which a reasonable man would consider to be that of replacing the car to its' state before it was damaged, but instead represents the original "agreed replacement cost'" written down by years of depreciation at 22.5%, an amount which could never replace the car. And Acts of God? well they are not something insurance companies have to payout on, either, they could not be anticipated, so the insurance company could not build the cost into the policy. That is why we have insurance, to cover us for the unexpected loss. I can only think that the government is terrified that the insurance companies are going to step away if things are made too tough for them, and the government, meaning the taxpayer, is going to have to pick up the costs.
 
I just did a quote for the travel insurance with the SDC 10% discount.
The quote said the promo code was invalid???
The price was $620.57 for the two of us, COVID Cover was extra $338.15.

I got the same cover,which included COVID for $361.60, from Tick Travel
Insurance.

The only thing not on my policy was $400/day for pet care, which I don't need.

So much for Finders " best value deal".

Pays to shop around.
Great will remember this mob
RACV, RAC, NRMA etc, they are all tarred with the same brush. The motorists associations supposedl. They are not there for the motorist, just their own profits.
Yep and I know 2 people that gave worked for one of those for over 25 years and have not been paying employees their rightfully bonuses because they can't afford it and making millions in profit
 
  • Like
Reactions: DLHM
it's very simple, insurance companies give up a 15% discount for a new policy. They are not interested in giving a discount after a couple of years, as they know most won't look around, hence they all do it. Reason most don't compare with any insurance companies, it just too hard to really compare without just looking more into the policies. Ak: term and conditions all the million and one thing you have to read, before signing up. Have every try the compare websites? Say you are looking for car insurance policy, that are all the same, they offer different things, what they do or not cover to the amount of excess. So, it not so simply comparing.
Absolutely,some say they cover windows yet fine print no to your sun roof that cops all the stones from all the trucks that go by without proper tops on the..Also beware hire cars most will only cover you for 14 days if it's your fault.Tje parts may take months to come in and it you only have the one car like many senior couples you won't be able to get around.Only found NRMA and GIO that cover you unlimited amount of days for car hire IF YOUR FAULT.
Please note members!!!!!!!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kevin. A. and DLHM
This warning goes out for all of our insurances. My wife and I have been using the same insurance company for our home and content insurance for over 15 years. With increasing cost of living prices biting into the home budget, when I latest home and content renewal came around, we were shocked to find the insurance company wanted to raise our premiums by over $1100 a year despite only ever making one claim due to power outage caused by flooding in 2013. Our home is not in a flood zone, and we are 80 meters above sea level. We looked at the renewal policy only to find that we were still paying commission to our bank for the privilege and this year the banks commission had gone up to $700. We thought at the time we first started the insurance that the banks commission was a one-off payment. However, as it turns out (silly me) we have been paying the bank commission every year and for what? When we started looking at other insurance quotes, we found most were around $1500 cheaper for higher insurance cover both with the value of the home and the content cover. We made sure our excess was the same for the home and content cover. Needless to say, I contacted our home and content insurance company and cancelled the policy. It pays to shop around these companies think we are nothing more than cash cows to be milked as often as possible and that we do not look at the renewal increases. The insurance companies keep increasing our premium each year with little justification other than cost of living increases.
 
Last edited:

Join the conversation

News, deals, games, and bargains for Aussies over 60. From everyday expenses like groceries and eating out, to electronics, fashion and travel, the club is all about helping you make your money go further.

Seniors Discount Club

The SDC searches for the best deals, discounts, and bargains for Aussies over 60. From everyday expenses like groceries and eating out, to electronics, fashion and travel, the club is all about helping you make your money go further.
  1. New members
  2. Jokes & fun
  3. Photography
  4. Nostalgia / Yesterday's Australia
  5. Food and Lifestyle
  6. Money Saving Hacks
  7. Offtopic / Everything else

Latest Articles

  • We believe that retirement should be a time to relax and enjoy life, not worry about money. That's why we're here to help our members make the most of their retirement years. If you're over 60 and looking for ways to save money, connect with others, and have a laugh, we’d love to have you aboard.
  • Advertise with us

User Menu

Enjoyed Reading our Story?

  • Share this forum to your loved ones.
Change Weather Postcode×
Change Petrol Postcode×