McDonald's Newest Menu Item has Fans Divided: Find Out What the Outrage is All About

Whether you’re buying a quick snack, a complete family meal, or a late-night burger craving, a classic Maccas meal quells junk food cravings and hits the spot like no other.

Recently, the fast food chain announced the release of its Summer Menu for 2023. But one addition has sent Macca’s loyal customers into a heated debate – and it’s all because of its name.



The new menu has been the talk of the town since its announcement – with some Macca’s fans poking fun at the ‘Aussie’ burger after the egg (which appeared in previous versions) was taken off the menu.

But that wasn’t the end of it.


maccas1 (1).jpg
Macca’s fans have been arguing over the ‘missing’ egg. Credit: McDonald’s Australia

The debates have now taken over social media forums with an unexpected twist, with outrage forming over the use of the name ‘potato scallops’ on the new menu.

Although the term is embraced by Macca’s fans in the majority of Australia, in other parts of the country like Victoria and South Australia customers prefer the term ‘potato cakes’ or ‘potato fritters’ instead. No hate here members, but as NSW residents we will say, ‘potato cake’? Really? Potato fritters we can accept, but come on, folks. These aren’t cakes. 😉



‘I have only known them as potato scallops and I’m 72 years old,’ shared one woman.

‘Potato cakes always, I have, however, learned to tolerate the scallop name due to marrying a Queensland husband and wanting to stay married,’ another quipped.

A third disagreed: ‘Neither, they are bloody fritters.’

Thousands have commented on the name, with people from Victoria claiming the only true scallop is a shellfish.


maccas2 (1).jpg
The item is served with a side of chicken salt. Credit: McDonald’s Australia

‘If you were to eat a scallop, you would be eating a creature from the sea. If you were to order a scallop, you would get the creature from the sea. It is a potato cake,’ one suggested.

However, one person fiercely disagreed with this statement: ‘Potato scallops are made from scalloped potatoes (a cooking term for thin slices) they don't resemble a cake at all.’

Another agreed and said people don’t just say ‘scallops’ when ordering, they say ‘potato scallops’ to clarify.



Others have boycotted the potato fritters/scallops/cakes entirely because of the confusing name.

‘I won't touch potato scallops but I would have smashed some potato cakes. I reckon I would give these a rating of 0 out of ten based on their average name alone,’ one man said.

It appears McDonald’s had predicted the great debate over the controversial name, and even made a video of three people disagreeing over it.

Fritters, scallops, or potato cakes? It seems that this debate has been around for ages. But why are Aussies arguing over a simple name? In a 2015 Linguistics Roadshow survey, a team of experts discovered just how strong regional divides are when it comes to certain words. The ‘potato scallops’ name was the most debated term of the experiment.

University of Queensland linguistics expert Dr Rob Pensalfini said that the divide was created by several factors, including brands and ethnicity in the area.

‘The one I always remember is this weird horrible sliced meat, apparently called luncheon [in Queensland]. It's called devon in Victoria, it's called fritz in South Australia and polony in Western Australia,’ he shared.

The doctor admitted that the study was ‘fascinating’ because it provided a deeper insight on how terms vary from town to town.


Key Takeaways

  • Maccas fans are furious over the naming of a new potato-based menu item.
  • The new potato scallop name has caused heated debates – with people across Australia and New Zealand each having their own preference for what it should be called.
  • Common terms for the potato scallops include ‘potato scallops’, ‘potato cakes’, and ‘potato fritters’.
What do you call them, members? Let us know in the comments below! But please keep in mind, this debate is just for fun, so let’s not let it get too heated!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ricci and BJM
Sponsored
Whether you’re buying a quick snack, a complete family meal, or a late-night burger craving, a classic Maccas meal quells junk food cravings and hits the spot like no other.

Recently, the fast food chain announced the release of its Summer Menu for 2023. But one addition has sent Macca’s loyal customers into a heated debate – and it’s all because of its name.



The new menu has been the talk of the town since its announcement – with some Macca’s fans poking fun at the ‘Aussie’ burger after the egg (which appeared in previous versions) was taken off the menu.

But that wasn’t the end of it.


View attachment 11640
Macca’s fans have been arguing over the ‘missing’ egg. Credit: McDonald’s Australia

The debates have now taken over social media forums with an unexpected twist, with outrage forming over the use of the name ‘potato scallops’ on the new menu.

Although the term is embraced by Macca’s fans in the majority of Australia, in other parts of the country like Victoria and South Australia customers prefer the term ‘potato cakes’ or ‘potato fritters’ instead. No hate here members, but as NSW residents we will say, ‘potato cake’? Really? Potato fritters we can accept, but come on, folks. These aren’t cakes. 😉



‘I have only known them as potato scallops and I’m 72 years old,’ shared one woman.

‘Potato cakes always, I have, however, learned to tolerate the scallop name due to marrying a Queensland husband and wanting to stay married,’ another quipped.

A third disagreed: ‘Neither, they are bloody fritters.’

Thousands have commented on the name, with people from Victoria claiming the only true scallop is a shellfish.


View attachment 11641
The item is served with a side of chicken salt. Credit: McDonald’s Australia

‘If you were to eat a scallop, you would be eating a creature from the sea. If you were to order a scallop, you would get the creature from the sea. It is a potato cake,’ one suggested.

However, one person fiercely disagreed with this statement: ‘Potato scallops are made from scalloped potatoes (a cooking term for thin slices) they don't resemble a cake at all.’

Another agreed and said people don’t just say ‘scallops’ when ordering, they say ‘potato scallops’ to clarify.



Others have boycotted the potato fritters/scallops/cakes entirely because of the confusing name.

‘I won't touch potato scallops but I would have smashed some potato cakes. I reckon I would give these a rating of 0 out of ten based on their average name alone,’ one man said.

It appears McDonald’s had predicted the great debate over the controversial name, and even made a video of three people disagreeing over it.

Fritters, scallops, or potato cakes? It seems that this debate has been around for ages. But why are Aussies arguing over a simple name? In a 2015 Linguistics Roadshow survey, a team of experts discovered just how strong regional divides are when it comes to certain words. The ‘potato scallops’ name was the most debated term of the experiment.

University of Queensland linguistics expert Dr Rob Pensalfini said that the divide was created by several factors, including brands and ethnicity in the area.

‘The one I always remember is this weird horrible sliced meat, apparently called luncheon [in Queensland]. It's called devon in Victoria, it's called fritz in South Australia and polony in Western Australia,’ he shared.

The doctor admitted that the study was ‘fascinating’ because it provided a deeper insight on how terms vary from town to town.


Key Takeaways

  • Maccas fans are furious over the naming of a new potato-based menu item.
  • The new potato scallop name has caused heated debates – with people across Australia and New Zealand each having their own preference for what it should be called.
  • Common terms for the potato scallops include ‘potato scallops’, ‘potato cakes’, and ‘potato fritters’.
What do you call them, members? Let us know in the comments below! But please keep in mind, this debate is just for fun, so let’s not let it get too heated!
Definitely potato scallops
 
Whether you’re buying a quick snack, a complete family meal, or a late-night burger craving, a classic Maccas meal quells junk food cravings and hits the spot like no other.

Recently, the fast food chain announced the release of its Summer Menu for 2023. But one addition has sent Macca’s loyal customers into a heated debate – and it’s all because of its name.



The new menu has been the talk of the town since its announcement – with some Macca’s fans poking fun at the ‘Aussie’ burger after the egg (which appeared in previous versions) was taken off the menu.

But that wasn’t the end of it.


View attachment 11640
Macca’s fans have been arguing over the ‘missing’ egg. Credit: McDonald’s Australia

The debates have now taken over social media forums with an unexpected twist, with outrage forming over the use of the name ‘potato scallops’ on the new menu.

Although the term is embraced by Macca’s fans in the majority of Australia, in other parts of the country like Victoria and South Australia customers prefer the term ‘potato cakes’ or ‘potato fritters’ instead. No hate here members, but as NSW residents we will say, ‘potato cake’? Really? Potato fritters we can accept, but come on, folks. These aren’t cakes. 😉



‘I have only known them as potato scallops and I’m 72 years old,’ shared one woman.

‘Potato cakes always, I have, however, learned to tolerate the scallop name due to marrying a Queensland husband and wanting to stay married,’ another quipped.

A third disagreed: ‘Neither, they are bloody fritters.’

Thousands have commented on the name, with people from Victoria claiming the only true scallop is a shellfish.


View attachment 11641
The item is served with a side of chicken salt. Credit: McDonald’s Australia

‘If you were to eat a scallop, you would be eating a creature from the sea. If you were to order a scallop, you would get the creature from the sea. It is a potato cake,’ one suggested.

However, one person fiercely disagreed with this statement: ‘Potato scallops are made from scalloped potatoes (a cooking term for thin slices) they don't resemble a cake at all.’

Another agreed and said people don’t just say ‘scallops’ when ordering, they say ‘potato scallops’ to clarify.



Others have boycotted the potato fritters/scallops/cakes entirely because of the confusing name.

‘I won't touch potato scallops but I would have smashed some potato cakes. I reckon I would give these a rating of 0 out of ten based on their average name alone,’ one man said.

It appears McDonald’s had predicted the great debate over the controversial name, and even made a video of three people disagreeing over it.

Fritters, scallops, or potato cakes? It seems that this debate has been around for ages. But why are Aussies arguing over a simple name? In a 2015 Linguistics Roadshow survey, a team of experts discovered just how strong regional divides are when it comes to certain words. The ‘potato scallops’ name was the most debated term of the experiment.

University of Queensland linguistics expert Dr Rob Pensalfini said that the divide was created by several factors, including brands and ethnicity in the area.

‘The one I always remember is this weird horrible sliced meat, apparently called luncheon [in Queensland]. It's called devon in Victoria, it's called fritz in South Australia and polony in Western Australia,’ he shared.

The doctor admitted that the study was ‘fascinating’ because it provided a deeper insight on how terms vary from town to town.


Key Takeaways

  • Maccas fans are furious over the naming of a new potato-based menu item.
  • The new potato scallop name has caused heated debates – with people across Australia and New Zealand each having their own preference for what it should be called.
  • Common terms for the potato scallops include ‘potato scallops’, ‘potato cakes’, and ‘potato fritters’.
What do you call them, members? Let us know in the comments below! But please keep in mind, this debate is just for fun, so let’s not let it get too heated!
Potato cakes.
If you can get any.
Best to make your own. So dear now in the fish and chips shop.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ricci
Whether you’re buying a quick snack, a complete family meal, or a late-night burger craving, a classic Maccas meal quells junk food cravings and hits the spot like no other.

Recently, the fast food chain announced the release of its Summer Menu for 2023. But one addition has sent Macca’s loyal customers into a heated debate – and it’s all because of its name.



The new menu has been the talk of the town since its announcement – with some Macca’s fans poking fun at the ‘Aussie’ burger after the egg (which appeared in previous versions) was taken off the menu.

But that wasn’t the end of it.


View attachment 11640
Macca’s fans have been arguing over the ‘missing’ egg. Credit: McDonald’s Australia

The debates have now taken over social media forums with an unexpected twist, with outrage forming over the use of the name ‘potato scallops’ on the new menu.

Although the term is embraced by Macca’s fans in the majority of Australia, in other parts of the country like Victoria and South Australia customers prefer the term ‘potato cakes’ or ‘potato fritters’ instead. No hate here members, but as NSW residents we will say, ‘potato cake’? Really? Potato fritters we can accept, but come on, folks. These aren’t cakes. 😉



‘I have only known them as potato scallops and I’m 72 years old,’ shared one woman.

‘Potato cakes always, I have, however, learned to tolerate the scallop name due to marrying a Queensland husband and wanting to stay married,’ another quipped.

A third disagreed: ‘Neither, they are bloody fritters.’

Thousands have commented on the name, with people from Victoria claiming the only true scallop is a shellfish.


View attachment 11641
The item is served with a side of chicken salt. Credit: McDonald’s Australia

‘If you were to eat a scallop, you would be eating a creature from the sea. If you were to order a scallop, you would get the creature from the sea. It is a potato cake,’ one suggested.

However, one person fiercely disagreed with this statement: ‘Potato scallops are made from scalloped potatoes (a cooking term for thin slices) they don't resemble a cake at all.’

Another agreed and said people don’t just say ‘scallops’ when ordering, they say ‘potato scallops’ to clarify.



Others have boycotted the potato fritters/scallops/cakes entirely because of the confusing name.

‘I won't touch potato scallops but I would have smashed some potato cakes. I reckon I would give these a rating of 0 out of ten based on their average name alone,’ one man said.

It appears McDonald’s had predicted the great debate over the controversial name, and even made a video of three people disagreeing over it.

Fritters, scallops, or potato cakes? It seems that this debate has been around for ages. But why are Aussies arguing over a simple name? In a 2015 Linguistics Roadshow survey, a team of experts discovered just how strong regional divides are when it comes to certain words. The ‘potato scallops’ name was the most debated term of the experiment.

University of Queensland linguistics expert Dr Rob Pensalfini said that the divide was created by several factors, including brands and ethnicity in the area.

‘The one I always remember is this weird horrible sliced meat, apparently called luncheon [in Queensland]. It's called devon in Victoria, it's called fritz in South Australia and polony in Western Australia,’ he shared.

The doctor admitted that the study was ‘fascinating’ because it provided a deeper insight on how terms vary from town to town.


Key Takeaways

  • Maccas fans are furious over the naming of a new potato-based menu item.
  • The new potato scallop name has caused heated debates – with people across Australia and New Zealand each having their own preference for what it should be called.
  • Common terms for the potato scallops include ‘potato scallops’, ‘potato cakes’, and ‘potato fritters’.
What do you call them, members? Let us know in the comments below! But please keep in mind, this debate is just for fun, so let’s not let it get too heated!
Hi I am 80 yrs old and they are a scallop because of the slice of potato used is known as a scallop shape of potato. How ever I decided to have a take away treat and tried the Aussie deluxe and a scallop Disappointed in the burger and disgusted in the scallops undersized tasteless and tough couldn’t eat it nothing like the traditional scallop interested if anyone else has tried them .
 
Got a couple of these Potato Scallops today and the Chicken Salt wasn't included in the order plus they taste quite powdery, not to mention that they cost well over $3.00 each. Thankfully my son bought them for me as I couldn't justify spending that much money on a slice of potato with a thin coating of batter. Will stick to my local takeaway store for potato scallops in the future. Not only are their potato slices much thicker and the coating much more delicious, they only charge $1.20 each and more often than not, when you buy one you get one free.
 
Whether you’re buying a quick snack, a complete family meal, or a late-night burger craving, a classic Maccas meal quells junk food cravings and hits the spot like no other.

Recently, the fast food chain announced the release of its Summer Menu for 2023. But one addition has sent Macca’s loyal customers into a heated debate – and it’s all because of its name.



The new menu has been the talk of the town since its announcement – with some Macca’s fans poking fun at the ‘Aussie’ burger after the egg (which appeared in previous versions) was taken off the menu.

But that wasn’t the end of it.


View attachment 11640
Macca’s fans have been arguing over the ‘missing’ egg. Credit: McDonald’s Australia

The debates have now taken over social media forums with an unexpected twist, with outrage forming over the use of the name ‘potato scallops’ on the new menu.

Although the term is embraced by Macca’s fans in the majority of Australia, in other parts of the country like Victoria and South Australia customers prefer the term ‘potato cakes’ or ‘potato fritters’ instead. No hate here members, but as NSW residents we will say, ‘potato cake’? Really? Potato fritters we can accept, but come on, folks. These aren’t cakes. 😉



‘I have only known them as potato scallops and I’m 72 years old,’ shared one woman.

‘Potato cakes always, I have, however, learned to tolerate the scallop name due to marrying a Queensland husband and wanting to stay married,’ another quipped.

A third disagreed: ‘Neither, they are bloody fritters.’

Thousands have commented on the name, with people from Victoria claiming the only true scallop is a shellfish.


View attachment 11641
The item is served with a side of chicken salt. Credit: McDonald’s Australia

‘If you were to eat a scallop, you would be eating a creature from the sea. If you were to order a scallop, you would get the creature from the sea. It is a potato cake,’ one suggested.

However, one person fiercely disagreed with this statement: ‘Potato scallops are made from scalloped potatoes (a cooking term for thin slices) they don't resemble a cake at all.’

Another agreed and said people don’t just say ‘scallops’ when ordering, they say ‘potato scallops’ to clarify.



Others have boycotted the potato fritters/scallops/cakes entirely because of the confusing name.

‘I won't touch potato scallops but I would have smashed some potato cakes. I reckon I would give these a rating of 0 out of ten based on their average name alone,’ one man said.

It appears McDonald’s had predicted the great debate over the controversial name, and even made a video of three people disagreeing over it.

Fritters, scallops, or potato cakes? It seems that this debate has been around for ages. But why are Aussies arguing over a simple name? In a 2015 Linguistics Roadshow survey, a team of experts discovered just how strong regional divides are when it comes to certain words. The ‘potato scallops’ name was the most debated term of the experiment.

University of Queensland linguistics expert Dr Rob Pensalfini said that the divide was created by several factors, including brands and ethnicity in the area.

‘The one I always remember is this weird horrible sliced meat, apparently called luncheon [in Queensland]. It's called devon in Victoria, it's called fritz in South Australia and polony in Western Australia,’ he shared.

The doctor admitted that the study was ‘fascinating’ because it provided a deeper insight on how terms vary from town to town.


Key Takeaways

  • Maccas fans are furious over the naming of a new potato-based menu item.
  • The new potato scallop name has caused heated debates – with people across Australia and New Zealand each having their own preference for what it should be called.
  • Common terms for the potato scallops include ‘potato scallops’, ‘potato cakes’, and ‘potato fritters’.
What do you call them, members? Let us know in the comments below! But please keep in mind, this debate is just for fun, so let’s not let it get too heated!
Why not call them “ CRUNCHY POTATO CAKES “ !
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ricci
all
Whether you’re buying a quick snack, a complete family meal, or a late-night burger craving, a classic Maccas meal quells junk food cravings and hits the spot like no other.

Recently, the fast food chain announced the release of its Summer Menu for 2023. But one addition has sent Macca’s loyal customers into a heated debate – and it’s all because of its name.



The new menu has been the talk of the town since its announcement – with some Macca’s fans poking fun at the ‘Aussie’ burger after the egg (which appeared in previous versions) was taken off the menu.

But that wasn’t the end of it.


View attachment 11640
Macca’s fans have been arguing over the ‘missing’ egg. Credit: McDonald’s Australia

The debates have now taken over social media forums with an unexpected twist, with outrage forming over the use of the name ‘potato scallops’ on the new menu.

Although the term is embraced by Macca’s fans in the majority of Australia, in other parts of the country like Victoria and South Australia customers prefer the term ‘potato cakes’ or ‘potato fritters’ instead. No hate here members, but as NSW residents we will say, ‘potato cake’? Really? Potato fritters we can accept, but come on, folks. These aren’t cakes. 😉



‘I have only known them as potato scallops and I’m 72 years old,’ shared one woman.

‘Potato cakes always, I have, however, learned to tolerate the scallop name due to marrying a Queensland husband and wanting to stay married,’ another quipped.

A third disagreed: ‘Neither, they are bloody fritters.’

Thousands have commented on the name, with people from Victoria claiming the only true scallop is a shellfish.


View attachment 11641
The item is served with a side of chicken salt. Credit: McDonald’s Australia

‘If you were to eat a scallop, you would be eating a creature from the sea. If you were to order a scallop, you would get the creature from the sea. It is a potato cake,’ one suggested.

However, one person fiercely disagreed with this statement: ‘Potato scallops are made from scalloped potatoes (a cooking term for thin slices) they don't resemble a cake at all.’

Another agreed and said people don’t just say ‘scallops’ when ordering, they say ‘potato scallops’ to clarify.



Others have boycotted the potato fritters/scallops/cakes entirely because of the confusing name.

‘I won't touch potato scallops but I would have smashed some potato cakes. I reckon I would give these a rating of 0 out of ten based on their average name alone,’ one man said.

It appears McDonald’s had predicted the great debate over the controversial name, and even made a video of three people disagreeing over it.

Fritters, scallops, or potato cakes? It seems that this debate has been around for ages. But why are Aussies arguing over a simple name? In a 2015 Linguistics Roadshow survey, a team of experts discovered just how strong regional divides are when it comes to certain words. The ‘potato scallops’ name was the most debated term of the experiment.

University of Queensland linguistics expert Dr Rob Pensalfini said that the divide was created by several factors, including brands and ethnicity in the area.

‘The one I always remember is this weird horrible sliced meat, apparently called luncheon [in Queensland]. It's called devon in Victoria, it's called fritz in South Australia and polony in Western Australia,’ he shared.

The doctor admitted that the study was ‘fascinating’ because it provided a deeper insight on how terms vary from town to town.


Key Takeaways

  • Maccas fans are furious over the naming of a new potato-based menu item.
  • The new potato scallop name has caused heated debates – with people across Australia and New Zealand each having their own preference for what it should be called.
  • Common terms for the potato scallops include ‘potato scallops’, ‘potato cakes’, and ‘potato fritters’.
What do you call them, members? Let us know in the comments below! But please keep in mind, this debate is just for fun, so let’s not let it get too heated!
all depends on the thickness of the potato, thin they are fritters, thick they are cakes. simple really
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ricci

Join the conversation

News, deals, games, and bargains for Aussies over 60. From everyday expenses like groceries and eating out, to electronics, fashion and travel, the club is all about helping you make your money go further.

Seniors Discount Club

The SDC searches for the best deals, discounts, and bargains for Aussies over 60. From everyday expenses like groceries and eating out, to electronics, fashion and travel, the club is all about helping you make your money go further.
  1. New members
  2. Jokes & fun
  3. Photography
  4. Nostalgia / Yesterday's Australia
  5. Food and Lifestyle
  6. Money Saving Hacks
  7. Offtopic / Everything else

Latest Articles

  • We believe that retirement should be a time to relax and enjoy life, not worry about money. That's why we're here to help our members make the most of their retirement years. If you're over 60 and looking for ways to save money, connect with others, and have a laugh, we’d love to have you aboard.
  • Advertise with us

User Menu

Enjoyed Reading our Story?

  • Share this forum to your loved ones.
Change Weather Postcode×
Change Petrol Postcode×