Five Shocking Kitchen Design Mistakes Even Architects Avoid – Are You Making Them Too?

When it comes to kitchen design, we all have our dream features and layouts that we believe will make our culinary space both functional and fabulous. However, an experienced Aussie architect has thrown a spanner in the works by highlighting five common kitchen elements that she believes are design disasters waiting to happen. Before you embark on your next kitchen renovation or find yourself green with envy over a friend's new walk-in pantry, take a moment to consider these professional insights that might just save you from a kitchen calamity.


The walk-in pantry paradox

The walk-in pantry is often seen as the pinnacle of kitchen luxury, a symbol of space and organization. Yet, according to Georgina Wilson, a Sydney-based architect with two decades of experience, this coveted feature could be robbing you of valuable storage space. She argues that a well-designed kitchen maximizes storage by integrating it into the main area, ensuring a seamless flow and accessibility. Before you commit to a walk-in pantry, consider whether it truly serves your space or simply eats into it.


compressed-kitchen.jpeg
Georgina Wilson shared some advice on making your ideal kitchen. Image Credit: Pexels/Mark McCammon


Island bench blunders: Sinks and cooktops

Island benches are a central hub for preparation and social interaction in the kitchen. However, installing a sink or cooktop in this prime real estate can be a recipe for disaster. Not only does it interrupt the prep area, but it also poses a risk of splashing unsuspecting guests or family members with water or hot oil. Georgina's advice is to keep your island bench clear, maintaining it as an uninterrupted workspace for culinary creations.


The golden rule of 900

Spacing is everything in a kitchen, and there's a golden rule to follow: the 900mm rule. This is the minimum distance you should maintain between your island and other surfaces or appliances. It's the sweet spot that allows for comfortable movement without feeling cramped, ensuring your kitchen is a pleasure to use rather than a tight squeeze.

The servery window illusion

Those charming magazine images of servery windows might have you dreaming of handing out treats to your family in the sunshine, but the reality can be less idyllic. Georgina warns that servery windows can be a terrible idea, often leading to wasted space and a less efficient kitchen layout. Before falling for the aesthetic, consider how a servery window will function in your day-to-day life.

Downdraft rangehoods: A hot air hazard

Downdraft rangehoods might seem like a sleek, space-saving solution, but they defy a basic principle of physics: hot air rises. Georgina suggests that these rangehoods are far less effective at venting out smoke and odors, potentially leaving your kitchen in a haze.


While Georgina's advice has stirred up some heated debate, with many Aussies defending their beloved kitchen features, it's clear that what works for one person may not work for another. Some homeowners swear by their island cooktops for their social and practical benefits, while others wouldn't trade their servery windows for the world, citing the ease of entertaining and interaction they provide.
Ultimately, the key to a successful kitchen design is to tailor it to your individual needs and preferences. As one Aussie aptly put it, 'Just do what you want in your space, these rules are opinions only.' So, whether you're planning a complete kitchen overhaul or just pondering some minor tweaks, take these professional tips as food for thought, but always season your decisions with a pinch of personal taste.
Key Takeaways

  • An Australian architect advises against certain features in kitchen designs, such as walk-in pantries and serveries.
  • Installing sinks or cooktops on an island bench is discouraged as it can be dangerous and disruptive to the kitchen's prep area.
  • The rule of 900mm is stressed as the minimum distance between an island and any other kitchen element to maintain a user-friendly space.
  • Downdraft rangehoods are not recommended due to their ineffectiveness, as hot air rises, contrary to the direction of the downdraft.
Now, we'd love to hear from you, our savvy Seniors Discount Club members. Have you encountered any of these design dilemmas in your own kitchen? Or perhaps you've found a way to make these so-called 'mistakes' work in your favor? Share your kitchen triumphs and tribulations in the comments below – let's stir up some conversation!
 
Sponsored
After years of renting and just "Putting up"with design flaws that made life in the kitchen a misery we had the chance to build our own home, knowing exactly what I wanted in our home I put pencil to paper and designed what I considered to be the perfect floor plan for that new home, I thought that I had it right, now after living here for 4 years I have realised that mistakes were made, especially with the kitchen design, while visitors rave over the design of the most important room in our house, I find that there is just too much room between appliances and areas used the most, like between the fridge and designated prep area, I am able to get a days worth of steps when preparing dinner each evening and quite often am just too tired to make all those steps (my health is not that good) I have no idea how to correct the mistakes made in the design to make it easier and just wish I had listened to the builder when he made suggestions about the kitchen and what I thought I wanted, too much space is just as bad as too little believe me!
 
Well, in my drop off the perch home I am a happy little chook.
I came to the conclusion that I did not need a stand alone laundry. Instead, I added a butler's pantry (just means it has a sink, benches and pantry shelving), and, put the front load washer under the bench. I love, love, love it.
I have had walk in pantries before and have always utilised them efficiently. There is a way of storing and organising that can be a minefield for those who are happy to just toss things in on the nearest shelf.
Having the butler's pantry as well, means there are no appliances in the kitchen area. Coffee/tea making facilities have their own little corner next to the bikkie section, and, I just love bringing out my adorable serving tray when I have visitors.
I have never liked open plan, and find my galley style kitchen much more efficient. The good old triangle is faultless in our setup. Stove - sink - fridge within a step after turning...you beauty. Perfect for us oldies, and no excuses for not putting things away.
I have a dining area at the end of the kitchen that just means a couple of steps and things are on the table. It also means a few steps to take them off the table and clean up with no effort.
The builder did not get it when I told him what I wanted, but, I stood my ground, and, glad I did. Might not suit a bigger family, but it suits us and any visitors that have crossed our doorway have never had a complaint.
In the end. It's horses for courses. Modern trends come and go. In my humble opinion, efficiency is more important than magazine style offerings.
 
Well, Gaena, ever thought of putting pencil to paper, again with the aid of a ruler & starting all over again.

As they say, you have to live in it to know it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MariaG
Well, Gaena, ever thought of putting pencil to paper, again with the aid of a ruler & starting all over again.

As they say, you have to live in it to know it.
Yes I have considered redesigning the kitchen but at our stage of life we do not want to even think about extending the mortgage, I will just have to keep making numerous steps each night while making dinner and put up with my mistakes
 
  • Like
Reactions: PattiB
Love the walk-in pantry could not do with out it. Island bench - ours is 4 metres long and has the sink in it. It works for us though. It is a real benefit with visitors able to be part of the food prep. If it had been smaller though I could see the issue of having the sink there and being in the way. We have open plan and it works well for us with the design, wouldn't have it any other way.
 
My kitchen is all wrong by those standards...and I love it. The way the experts wanted it i told them I'll need roller skates to go from one area to another. I send the whole lot packing until one listen to me and even changed my mind about one set of cupboards opening which then allowed for a deep drawer for saucepans etc (that was gold advice...yes i am not stubborn, but the other men had no idea how i use my kitchen, no way i was going to give up my server window, my cooking top on the island and i even kept my old sink ...many friends said i was lucky they were not happy with their new sink and i got a stunning curved fumes extractor) of course walking pantry is actually normal cupboard size with a curve hollow everything reachable
 
  • Like
Reactions: PattiB
My kitchen is all wrong by those standards...and I love it. The way the experts wanted it i told them I'll need roller skates to go from one area to another. I send the whole lot packing until one listen to me and even changed my mind about one set of cupboards opening which then allowed for a deep drawer for saucepans etc (that was gold advice...yes i am not stubborn, but the other men had no idea how i use my kitchen, no way i was going to give up my server window, my cooking top on the island and i even kept my old sink ...many friends said i was lucky they were not happy with their new sink and i got a stunning curved fumes extractor) of course walking pantry is actually normal cupboard size with a curve hollow everything reachable
Good for you Michelle Sc, I’m glad that you got exactly what you wanted. So many builders & “experts“ have no idea as to what actually works for real people. Walk in pantries are so good, my last house had one, at my insistence, but we didn’t build the house we now live in and I really miss it. I can remember the builder telling me that pantries were no longer a thing but I won that battle, the first of many over my 72 years.
 
  • Love
Reactions: Michelle Sc
As long as it is ergonomically correct.
A range hood is a WOFTAM. There should be a powerful fan that extracts foul smells outside. Better still, have a kitchen completely separate from the house. The inside kitchen is used for preparation, presentation, and washing up.
check out the Asian way...
 
  • Like
Reactions: Michelle Sc

Join the conversation

News, deals, games, and bargains for Aussies over 60. From everyday expenses like groceries and eating out, to electronics, fashion and travel, the club is all about helping you make your money go further.

Seniors Discount Club

The SDC searches for the best deals, discounts, and bargains for Aussies over 60. From everyday expenses like groceries and eating out, to electronics, fashion and travel, the club is all about helping you make your money go further.
  1. New members
  2. Jokes & fun
  3. Photography
  4. Nostalgia / Yesterday's Australia
  5. Food and Lifestyle
  6. Money Saving Hacks
  7. Offtopic / Everything else
  • We believe that retirement should be a time to relax and enjoy life, not worry about money. That's why we're here to help our members make the most of their retirement years. If you're over 60 and looking for ways to save money, connect with others, and have a laugh, we’d love to have you aboard.
  • Advertise with us

User Menu

Enjoyed Reading our Story?

  • Share this forum to your loved ones.
Change Weather Postcode×
Change Petrol Postcode×