Expert warns about health insurance costs as family gets hit with $9,300 bill: ‘Absolute disgrace’

Navigating the complex world of health insurance can be daunting, especially when faced with the potential for hefty annual bills that seem to offer little in return.

This is a reality for many Australians, including one family that pays a staggering $9,300 a year for private health insurance.

With cost-of-living pressures squeezing budgets tighter, it's no wonder that more Aussies are considering downgrading or even dropping their health insurance cover.



The case of Fiona's family, who reached out to finance expert Scott Pape, also known as the Barefoot Investor, highlights the dilemma many face.

Fiona questioned if health insurance was ‘necessary in Australia’, considering the country has ‘good public health care’.

She pondered whether the substantial amount spent on insurance premiums would be better invested elsewhere.


shutterstock_500169142.jpg
Barefoot Investor Scott Pape highlighted the problems of health insurance costs. Credit: Shutterstock


Pape's response was clear: while he described private health insurance as 'an absolute disgrace’, he warned against hastily dropping the policy.

‘It’s incredibly complicated and increasingly unaffordable, which is why people are opting out of the system in droves. But not you,’ Pape wrote in his weekly column.

‘As a higher income earner, the government has a gun pointed at your head. If you don’t hold private health insurance, they’ll hit you with a penalty tax called the “Medicare Levy Surcharge”, which will cost more than shutting up and just buying private health insurance.’

This surcharge applies to singles earning over $97,000 and families earning over $194,000 who do not have an appropriate level of hospital cover.

It's an additional charge on top of the standard Medicare levy, which is 2 per cent of taxable income.

The surcharge rates range from 1 to 1.5 per cent of income, depending on your earnings bracket.



However, Pape also pointed out that Fiona was ‘paying way too much’ for her family's health insurance and suggested that she could save thousands by taking a few simple steps.

He recommended visiting the government's privatehealth.gov.au website to compare policies using her policy ID number.

It could also be worth selecting 'hospital-only cover' since ‘most people don’t get much value from extras cover’.

‘If you’re unsure, ask your fund for a claims benefit statement. And if you’re done having kids, you could downgrade from Gold to Silver or Bronze and save thousands—just check the exclusions,’ he said.



Finally, Pape said to compare what the website says and her current policy.

‘These are the exact steps I take every year when my premium is due. It only takes a few minutes, but it can save you thousands,’ he said.

Private Healthcare Australia reported that over 216,000 policies were downgraded in the first half of 2024 alone. With 55 per cent of the Australian population holding some form of health insurance, the financial stress is palpable.

Finder revealed that 22 per cent of insured Australians consider health insurance one of their top three stressful expenses, with the average policy costing $214 per month.

Moreover, private health insurance premiums saw an average increase of 3.03 per cent in April, adding to the financial strain on policyholders.
Key Takeaways
  • A family paying $9,300 annually for private health insurance was advised by finance expert Scott Pape to compare their policy or consider downgrading to save money.
  • Fiona, the customer in question, questioned the need for private health insurance in Australia due to the presence of good public healthcare but was warned against dropping the policy because of tax penalties.
  • The Medicare Levy Surcharge imposes additional costs on higher-income earners without private hospital cover; therefore, maintaining health insurance could be less expensive than facing the tax.
  • With more than 216,000 policies downgraded in the first half of 2024 and premiums increasing, Australians are feeling the pressure of health insurance costs, which are becoming a top stressful expense for many.
Have you faced similar challenges with your health insurance? What steps have you taken to manage the costs? Share your stories and tips in the comments below!
 
  • Angry
  • Like
Reactions: Dynamo and BJM
Sponsored
I pay $360 a month for my health insurance I've been thinking of seeing the difference in cost just to gave hospital cover.

After seeing how friends and family have been treated by not having health insurance it makes me nervous to drop it.

My daughter needs surgery and if she goes through the public hospital she could be waiting 18 months to 2 years.
If she goes private she can have surgery next week.

She isn't in a health fund , she actually only dropped it 1 year ago.
So going private she will be out of pocket about $7000 being $2000 for surgeon and $5000 for one day stay in hospital.

It was only 6 months ago her 4 year old daughter needed grommets put into her ears and that day surgery cost her $5000

They say our medical system doesn't discriminate but it definitely does. If you are in a health fund or can pay for the procedure you will get it done awhole lot sooner
Definitely discriminatory……Not too sure if it’s dictated partly by hospitals or surgeons or both, but money definitely talks and it’s sad to know that your healthcare is down to whether or not you can afford a health fund. I think it’s heartbreaking sometimes when you have to wait such a long time, 9 times out of 10 in pain before you can get seen to, and that’s not 100% guaranteed…….although it’s good to know you will have treatment in an emergency situation. It’s ridiculous how much it costs to go private with no health insurance. It’s also very predictable that the older you get, the more care you might need….and usually the premiums become too high to be affordable anymore, especially when you need to change your cover to accommodate your changing needs………..I went to my doctor the other day for my yearly check up, just a normal appointment and got the shock of my life when it cost me $100, when just a few weeks before it was $85………
 
My husband became very ill and suddenly required major heart surgery. Health cover is so expensive but we really needed it this year. He would have been ramped in a waiting ambulance at Flinders public hospital without it. Surgeons operated on him at midnight to save his life.
 
I considered Private Health Cover a necessity when I was working. I felt it was akin to paying annual insurance.
Then, I had a 2 day hospital stay in a private hospital that was required because of 24hr drip infusions. It was a pleasant place, a share room with another person, own shower, and, good meals. I thought, well that was OK until I was sent a bill for the GAP. Just for the stay and the medication, I had to fork out an additional $2800.
That's when I dropped the private hospital cover.
I had no qualms staying on the basic cover, and did make use of the Extras.
Then, I had to leave my job to care for my ailing hubby.
The pension is not enough to cover private health insurance. So, I made the choice to keep the Extras but could not afford the hospital cover. Hubby was on a pension, so was covered on the public system.
It's been some 25 years and I still have the Extras cover. I have done the maths and find the uses I get out of optical aids, podiatry, chiro and physio are well covered by the Extras. I was using it for dental before I got the full set of dentures.
There are different levels of cover. It is probably a good idea to have a really good look at what you need, and, what is being wasted. No provider is the same as another.
If, as a pensioner, I still opted to have private cover, I would want to make darn sure it covered the bulk of the costs.
In the end, it is our choice.
i am sorry for you and the extra gap payment. i have been in a health fund for 30 years and I am now with queensland country health and I have only ever paid a gap fee once and that was due to the specialist being a tad greedy. I have had cancer treatment. 11 days covid, and so many other things done always private and never paid extra. I still have infusions every 4 weeks and I am so pleased I do not have to pay for the 2 bottles of plasma and sitting in the chair for 4 hours. i am one who is way ahead of the payments and I will stop the day I die.
Life can be cruel and I am pleased to say I manage it. 🌻 this is my happy flower.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MariaG
i am sorry for you and the extra gap payment. i have been in a health fund for 30 years and I am now with queensland country health and I have only ever paid a gap fee once and that was due to the specialist being a tad greedy. I have had cancer treatment. 11 days covid, and so many other things done always private and never paid extra. I still have infusions every 4 weeks and I am so pleased I do not have to pay for the 2 bottles of plasma and sitting in the chair for 4 hours. i am one who is way ahead of the payments and I will stop the day I die.
Life can be cruel and I am pleased to say I manage it. 🌻 this is my happy flower.
Love the flower. Glad you are soldiering on,
 

Join the conversation

News, deals, games, and bargains for Aussies over 60. From everyday expenses like groceries and eating out, to electronics, fashion and travel, the club is all about helping you make your money go further.

Seniors Discount Club

The SDC searches for the best deals, discounts, and bargains for Aussies over 60. From everyday expenses like groceries and eating out, to electronics, fashion and travel, the club is all about helping you make your money go further.
  1. New members
  2. Jokes & fun
  3. Photography
  4. Nostalgia / Yesterday's Australia
  5. Food and Lifestyle
  6. Money Saving Hacks
  7. Offtopic / Everything else
  • We believe that retirement should be a time to relax and enjoy life, not worry about money. That's why we're here to help our members make the most of their retirement years. If you're over 60 and looking for ways to save money, connect with others, and have a laugh, we’d love to have you aboard.
  • Advertise with us

User Menu

Enjoyed Reading our Story?

  • Share this forum to your loved ones.
Change Weather Postcode×
Change Petrol Postcode×