Escape to Down Under Gone Wrong: This Family Left Scotland for Australia and Regretted It Almost Immediately!

The allure of sunny skies, sprawling beaches, and the promise of a laid-back lifestyle often paints an idyllic picture of Australia for those living in far colder climates. It's a dream that has enticed many to pack up their lives and head Down Under in search of a fresh start. However, the reality of such a drastic move can sometimes be a stark contrast to the fantasy, as one Scottish family discovered after their recent relocation to Sydney.


Kimberley Lucas and her family boldly decided to leave Scotland and start anew in Australia in early 2023. Less than two years later, they've decided to return to their homeland, having found the Australian lifestyle challenging to adapt to. The family's experience is a cautionary tale for those considering a similar move, highlighting the importance of thorough research and realistic expectations when emigrating.


1733802715284.png
A Scottish family that moved to Sydney in 2023 planned to return to Scotland due to difficulties adapting to the Australian lifestyle. Credit: @kimberleylucas_ / TikTok


The Lucas family's struggles began with the demanding work culture they encountered. Kimberley's construction worker husband worked at least 50 hours per week, sometimes stretching to over 60, with no overtime pay. This gruelling schedule meant he was absent most of the day, leaving little time for family interaction—a stark contrast to the 39-hour workweek stipulated in his contract.


Financial pressures further compounded their difficulties. The cost of childcare in Australia was a significant burden, particularly since the family, not being permanent residents, received no governmental assistance. Public school fees amounted to $7,000 per year, while daycare costs for just three days a week soared to $23,700 annually. In Scotland, not only is education free, but families also benefit from 30 hours of nursery fees each week. The prospect of spending $31,000 on childcare the following year, with permanent residency still 8 to 10 months away, was daunting.

Beyond the financial and work-related challenges, the Lucas family grappled with social isolation. Kimberley lamented the difficulty in forming deep connections in their new community, noting that casual conversations rarely evolved into friendships. The age difference between her and other local mothers seemed to widen the social gap, leaving her yearning for the occasional night out to unwind.

The absence of family support was keenly felt. The simple pleasures of dropping by a grandparent's house for coffee or having the children enjoy sleepovers at their aunt's were sorely missed. Kimberley expressed regret that her children were missing out on the kind of cherished family bonding she experienced in her own childhood.


The Lucas family's story resonates with many expatriates who have faced similar challenges. Social media users who heard their story echoed that expat life is not always the dream it's made out to be. Some shared their own struggles with making friends and finding a work-life balance in Australia, while others commended the family for prioritising their happiness and well-being over sticking it out in an unsuitable environment.

Kimberley's candid sharing of her family's experience reminds her that the grass isn't always greener on the other side. While Australia is undoubtedly a beautiful country with much to offer, it's not the perfect fit for everyone. The Lucas family's short-lived Australian adventure underscores the importance of embracing new opportunities and recognising when it's time to let go and return to familiar shores.

For our readers at the Seniors Discount Club who might be contemplating a similar move, remember that it's crucial to consider all aspects of life in a new country, including work culture, cost of living, social opportunities, and proximity to family. Having a backup plan and the flexibility to pivot is essential if things don't go as expected.

Key Takeaways

  • A Scottish family who moved to Sydney in 2023 is planning to return to Scotland, citing difficulties in adapting to the Australian lifestyle.
  • Kimberley Lucas highlighted issues such as long working hours with no overtime for her husband, high childcare costs, and the struggle to obtain permanent residency.
  • The family has faced social challenges, with Ms Lucas finding it difficult to make friends and the distance from their extended family in Scotland affecting their familial bonds.
  • Despite the natural beauty of Australia, the Lucas family feels it does not feel like home, prompting their decision to move back to Scotland.
Have you or someone you know ever made a big move like this and found it wasn't what you expected? Share your stories with us in the comments below. Your insights could be invaluable to others facing the same decision.
 
  • Like
Reactions: natalielocket

Seniors Discount Club

Sponsored content

Info
Loading data . . .
I left my homeland ( England) just before I was 21. I had been made redundant, was sick of the small village I was in, and came out here on a 2 year working holiday. I came out to a friend who I stayed with just a short time. This is my 51st year of living in Australia. I love it here ( except for the heat), and could never go back to England to live. Maybe because I was young and naive, that I adapted here.
 
I think if you read between the lines the wife was homesick.

If people think they can move here and have the benefits of Aussie residents then they are naive !! Didn't they research before coming ?

Australia won't pay for things like childcare or social security until you have lived Here for a number of years. Did they think they would get it all for free ?

As for her husband working 60 hours and not getting paid overtime that doesn't seem right.
I have to say most people working in the building business do work long hours.
My son is a builder and works around 10 hours 5 days a week but gets paid very well. He also works every 2nd Saturday between 6 to 10 hours.
My son takes home close to $3000 a week.
 
Last edited:
It's a bit naive to move half way around the world and not expect things to be different.
Surely they should have realised that they would not qualify for subsidised childcare, etc while they were still not Australian citizens. Of course you would miss family and surely you would have thought all this through before making such a life changing decision.
Also I would have thought his employer could have been reported for working him so many hours without overtime, in excess of his contract.
The construction industry is so short of workers there would have been plenty of work available. No need to stick with someone who is not paying you for the hours you are working.
A very expensive lesson in looking before you leap.
 
I think if you read between the lines the wife was homesick.

If people think they can move here and have the benefits of Aussie residents then they are nieve !! Didn't they research before coming ?

Australia won't pay for things like childcare or social security until you have lived Here for a number of years. Did they think they would get it all for free ?

As for her husband working 60 hours and not getting paid overtime that doesn't seem right.
I have to say most people working in the building business do work long hours.
My son is a builder and works around 10 hours 5 days a week but gets paid very well. He also works every 2nd Saturday between 6 to 10 hours.
My son takes home close to $3000 a week.
Exactly. My thought too. I think homesickness is the main problem. Such a life changing decision requires a lot of research and really deep thinking when it comes to leaving family behind.
 
We live in Victoria and 30 years ago we moved to Perth, W.A. We lived there for 10 years & moved back to Victoria. We were not accepted by them. As soon as they knew you were from THE EASTERN STATE it was like they painted you with a tar brush & always looked down on us. We are all born in Victoria & have English, Scottish & Irish ancestors….yet the people in Perth treated us like we were from another country. It was very depressing for us but after 10 years we moved back to Melbourne.

I will always say that Perth is a lovely place but they do think they live in another country over there & they all rubbish the Eastern States.

We actually didn’t move to another Country but it sure did feel like we did.
 
We live in Victoria and 30 years ago we moved to Perth, W.A. We lived there for 10 years & moved back to Victoria. We were not accepted by them. As soon as they knew you were from THE EASTERN STATE it was like they painted you with a tar brush & always looked down on us. We are all born in Victoria & have English, Scottish & Irish ancestors….yet the people in Perth treated us like we were from another country. It was very depressing for us but after 10 years we moved back to Melbourne.

I will always say that Perth is a lovely place but they do think they live in another country over there & they all rubbish the Eastern States.

We actually didn’t move to another Country but it sure did feel like we did.
What a horrible experience for you HelenB. We visit Perth regularly & find the people warm & welcoming, but we’re Tasmanian so WA residents have a bit in common with us, forgotten about by the eastern states. Of course we got the usual jokes about us all being inbred & having 2 heads but they gave up on realising that didn’t offence & instead laughed with them. My son has lived & worked in Perth for over 20 years & enjoys being there.
 
I moved to Perth after living for almost 65 years in the eastern states just over a year ago. I have never been chastised for being a Sydneysider, a Callalaian, a Bundabergian or a Melbournite.

I found Perth to be a breath of fresh air, with minimal violence compared to the streets of Dandenong. It became a case of kill or be killed as I don't cower down to anyone.

The south west coast of Western Australia is an absolute gem of beauty, with the likes of Bussleton, Albany and Denmark being the highlights.

I will never relocate back to my old stamping grounds, except to visit.
 
Should have done their homework. No excuse with all that's available on the internet
I came here in 1972 and was surprised with the similarities with England. I fully expected it to be different.
A place is what you make it. I've seen many Pomms compare what's missing here than what they had in the UK. A recipe for disaster.
 
Last edited:
Yep, been there, done that. Still here 50yrs later. Best place in the world to bring up a family. They didn’t give it enough time. Australia is a large country. There is a place to suit every one here, just take the time to find it. I was extremely homesick, but got over it eventually by giving this big continent a chance. As much as I love Scotland, there are opportunities here that you would never have in the UK.
 
Sydney would be one of the worst place to move to, SA is mocked as being the nanny state or backward state but is much more laid back, friendlier and with a better work life balance than the eastern states who so up themselves!
I live and have lived and worked in Sydney all my life and have never heard of anyone knocking or mocking anyone else from any other state
 
We came from the UK in 1986 with two small children. I have never been back, just not interested, but my Mum came with us and my sister already lived here. My husband’s Mum is still alive at 98! Plus he has a sister and brother in England so he goes over every couple of years to see them. Before we came to live here, we came for a holiday and I cried all the way back to the UK. Obviously I was born in the wrong place. I just love everything about Australia (maybe not Peter Dutton lol). Best thing we did was moving here.
 

Join the conversation

News, deals, games, and bargains for Aussies over 60. From everyday expenses like groceries and eating out, to electronics, fashion and travel, the club is all about helping you make your money go further.

Seniors Discount Club

The SDC searches for the best deals, discounts, and bargains for Aussies over 60. From everyday expenses like groceries and eating out, to electronics, fashion and travel, the club is all about helping you make your money go further.
  1. New members
  2. Jokes & fun
  3. Photography
  4. Nostalgia / Yesterday's Australia
  5. Food and Lifestyle
  6. Money Saving Hacks
  7. Offtopic / Everything else
  • We believe that retirement should be a time to relax and enjoy life, not worry about money. That's why we're here to help our members make the most of their retirement years. If you're over 60 and looking for ways to save money, connect with others, and have a laugh, we’d love to have you aboard.
  • Advertise with us

User Menu

Enjoyed Reading our Story?

  • Share this forum to your loved ones.
Change Weather Postcode×
Change Petrol Postcode×