Energy advocates criticise new charges on users: 'Madness and rip-off'

The Australian spirit is one of fairness and mateship, but many Aussies feel nothing but comradery when it comes to the recent introduction of a 'sun tax'.

The new tariff, which has been quietly rolled out in some states, is causing outrage among households that have invested in solar panels, with many feeling they are being unfairly penalised for their environmentally conscious choices.


The sun tax, a term coined to describe the new export tariff, is part of a two-way pricing structure that effectively charges customers for exporting solar-generated energy back to the grid when the network is congested, typically in the middle of the day.

Energy advocates and consumers have criticised this move by energy distributors, arguing that it undermines solar power's financial and environmental benefits.

Heidi Lee Douglas, a renewable energy advocate and the chief executive of Solar Citizens, has opposed the tax, labelling it as 'madness' and a 'rip-off'.


1724029115505.png
Outrage over hidden 'sun tax' for Australian households with solar panels. Credit: Shutterstock


She argued that charging people for making energy from sunlight is simply not fair, especially during a cost-of-living crisis.

‘'Energy companies want to charge people with solar panels to make energy from sunlight, and that's simply not fair,’ she said.

‘The new two-way tariff is a blunt instrument that charges people with solar panels for feeding their energy into the grid during the day, rather than supporting them to store their energy or feed it back into the grid at another time.’

‘Rather than stick people with penalties for not having batteries they can't afford in a cost of living crisis, households need more support to access the benefits of battery storage.’

‘People in NSW were absolutely furious, and Queenslanders will be livid when they find out more about the big tariff rip-off planned for households with solar panels.'


The sun tax sends a discouraging message to those considering solar installation, potentially slowing down the adoption of renewable energy.

While the tariffs were introduced in mid-2022, most households and businesses will feel the full impact the following year, as distributors need to submit a price proposal to the Australian Energy Regulator (AER) to justify the need for the tax.

Some distributors, like Ausgrid, have already outlined the changes.

They plan to charge customers 1.2c/kWh for electricity produced during peak export periods and offer a payment of 2.3c/kWh for electricity exported during peak demand hours.

Another hurdle for many households is the cost of solar batteries, which can store unused energy for later use.


Prices range from $8,750 to over $20,000, making it a significant investment.

While the NSW State Government has announced a rebate starting at $1,600 for battery storage systems, and Queensland had a similar rebate that has since closed, the upfront cost remains a barrier for many.

‘The Queensland government must find ways of getting more households powered by solar and create the incentives to shift people into having solar and batteries,' Ms Douglas added.

‘About 60 per cent of the community is currently locked out of the benefits of solar, including renters and people living in apartments or social housing, and they have among the most to gain from reduced energy bills.’

These groups stand to gain the most from reduced energy bills, yet they are often left behind in the transition to renewable energy.


Data from the clean energy regulator shows that solar and battery storage uptake is significantly higher in Sydney's outer suburbs compared to more established areas.

As energy costs continue to rise, the push for solar and battery storage is expected to grow despite the challenges posed by the sun tax.

David Sedighi, chief operating officer of VoltX Energy, notes that solar makes new homes more energy-efficient and attractive to prospective buyers.

Energy savings aside, solar has made these new homes more energy efficient, enabling people to meet compliance for a Building Sustainability Index (BASIX) certificate,' he said.

‘We know having solar makes a new home more attractive to prospective buyers in the future, too, as the cost of energy increases.’

'The so-called sun-tax where energy providers charge customers a tariff for rooftop solar exported to its network will also drive demand for batteries.'


In related news, the NSW government has launched a $200 million initiative to boost energy efficiency for 24,000 homes.

The program covers upgrades like draught-proofing, insulation, heating and cooling systems, and solar power, with subsidies for 10,000 low-income renters and apartment residents. Learn more here.
Key Takeaways

  • There's public outrage over a hidden 'sun tax' being imposed on Australian households with solar panels.
  • This tariff penalises people for exporting solar energy back to the grid during peak times.
  • Energy advocates slam the tariff as unfair, especially amid a cost of living crisis.
  • The tariff aims to encourage people to use their solar-generated energy rather than feed it back into the grid, and some support for battery storage solutions has been introduced.
Have you been affected by the sun tax, or are you concerned about how it might impact your decision to go solar? Share your thoughts and experiences in the comments below.
 
Last edited:
Sponsored
Can anyone explain to me why I pay more for using a smaller amount of electricity than I do if I use more eg when I have my split system on.
I am very frugal when using power and do most things in off peak times. The more I use the cheaper kw hours are.i turn everything off when not in use and only have one light on at night. I don’t understand how using more can cost me less per kw. I don’t even have heating on anymore, I put my Oodie on and I’m warm as toast.
 
Like recycling, the renewable energy industry is just a myth. It is manufactured as a "feelgood" philosophy to make one "warm and fuzzy" because you are made to believe you are doing your part in saving the planet.

The irony of this whole solar energy illusion is that China, the world's biggest manufacturer of solar panels with a 77.8% share of the global market (2022), produces 32.9% of the world's carbon emissions (2022). Meanwhile, you are indirectly feeding China's slowly expanding influence, especially in the Pacific by going solar and supporting China's solar industry.

Don't get me started on the extraction and processing of lithium ore, its energy consumption and damage to the environment, as compared to the extraction and refining of fossil fuels.

"Environmentally sustainable" energy is a nasty hypocritical two headed monster, of which many people are not aware of.
Sodium will replace lithium in due course and there is plenty of that stuff in the sea, although sea water will have to be evaporated by solar power to obtain it and the sodium will have to separated from the chlorine. Besides the sea, there are also salt mines and salt domes the latter being nice exploration targets for oil companies.

As for the notion of paying for feeding electricity into the grid through whatever form one pays for doing it, that is a classic loser-pays argument the logic of which is understood only by Thatcherite economists of whom there are far too many despite the scourge of viruses.

I decided not to install solar because at the time the Tasmanian electricity provider was charging 28 cents for whatever unit of hydropower they delivered and returned only 5 cents per unit for my delivering solar power they would sell back to me at 28c a unit. So I saved between $10 000 and $13 000 on installing solar panels, let alone the cost of a shed full of deep-cycle 12 volt batteries at $250 each and an inverter and the cost of a sparkie to install stuff and of course the cost of the shed and getting Council approval to build that second shed in my back garden so as to house the batteries. Bugger the environment if the power companies want to rip us off'; their Boards of Directors' kids can be equally warmed globally as will be mine unless someone with influence pulls their finger out of their stupidity.
 
The Government we currently have is living in La-La-Land, and we are all paying the price for all their failed fantasies.
If we have to Vote to select our Government in, then we should have the right to vote them out, if they don’t fulfil their promises. The general public are forced to pay for every blunder that eventuates from all the stupid failures that the Government makes. We live very poorly while they splash & waste our money on having a luxury life at our expense 😡🤬 THIS IS NOT HOW AUSTRALIA SHOULD BE!!!!
THIS IS NOT HOW AUSTRALIA SHOULD BE!!! Nor ever was; the UK just made it for few years between 1945 and 1979.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kevin. A.
This sun tax is nothing more than profiteering from solar energy. People have made the financial commitment to install solar power systems on their homes and now they are being penalized my greedy energy providers. This "Sun Tax" should be stopped now, and the government needs to provide cost effective solutions for people to install battery storage systems to store their excess power. Power companies already charge top dollar for energy and now they want to apply the thumb screws and profiteer from those who export their excess solar power to the grid. The government ministers should hang their heads in shame for even considering such a money grab like this sun tax. The government has promoted the uptake of solar and now they wish to allow greedy power companies to gain even more profits by gouging customers for exporting excess solar. Not a Happy Solar Chappy.
 
Like recycling, the renewable energy industry is just a myth. It is manufactured as a "feelgood" philosophy to make one "warm and fuzzy" because you are made to believe you are doing your part in saving the planet.

The irony of this whole solar energy illusion is that China, the world's biggest manufacturer of solar panels with a 77.8% share of the global market (2022), produces 32.9% of the world's carbon emissions (2022). Meanwhile, you are indirectly feeding China's slowly expanding influence, especially in the Pacific by going solar and supporting China's solar industry.

Don't get me started on the extraction and processing of lithium ore, its energy consumption and damage to the environment, as compared to the extraction and refining of fossil fuels.

"Environmentally sustainable" energy is a nasty hypocritical two headed monster, of which many people are not aware of.
I think that renewable energy can at least be part of the solution to the world's energy needs.
Fossil fuels are a finite resource, and they will eventually run out. If we cannot find renewable solutions to our energy needs without the major use of fossil fuels, then what do we do when fossil fuels are exhausted.
I suppose one could argue that the sun will eventually die out (few billion years' time) and that will stuff up solar energy anyway. However, I think that we need to find economically viable and sustainable renewable energy solutions for the world now and not later.
 

Join the conversation

News, deals, games, and bargains for Aussies over 60. From everyday expenses like groceries and eating out, to electronics, fashion and travel, the club is all about helping you make your money go further.

Seniors Discount Club

The SDC searches for the best deals, discounts, and bargains for Aussies over 60. From everyday expenses like groceries and eating out, to electronics, fashion and travel, the club is all about helping you make your money go further.
  1. New members
  2. Jokes & fun
  3. Photography
  4. Nostalgia / Yesterday's Australia
  5. Food and Lifestyle
  6. Money Saving Hacks
  7. Offtopic / Everything else

Latest Articles

  • We believe that retirement should be a time to relax and enjoy life, not worry about money. That's why we're here to help our members make the most of their retirement years. If you're over 60 and looking for ways to save money, connect with others, and have a laugh, we’d love to have you aboard.
  • Advertise with us

User Menu

Enjoyed Reading our Story?

  • Share this forum to your loved ones.
Change Weather Postcode×
Change Petrol Postcode×