Drivers left in disbelief over shocking fuel price gap between two nearby stations

Fuel prices have long been a hot topic, but a recent discovery has left drivers in disbelief.

What was once considered a standard part of the daily grind has turned into a puzzling and frustrating issue for commuters.

As tensions rise, the situation has sparked heated discussions about fairness, transparency, and just how much control consumers truly have.


A significant fuel price gap between two BP stations just two kilometres apart left drivers in shock.

On 29 January, a BP in Randwick was charging $2.07 per litre, while a nearby BP in Kingsford was selling for just $1.59.

The following day, the price at the Kingsford station increased to $1.63.


compressed-Untitled design.jpeg
Fuel price gap sparks outrage between nearby stations. Image source: X/@DanGinnane


Peter Khoury, an NRMA spokesman, shared that he was no longer surprised by such price discrepancies.

'Don't worry about the suburb next door, often it can happen when they're a street away from each other,' he explained.

Rugby league broadcaster Dan Ginnane brought attention to the issue on social media, highlighting the price gap.

'Same time. Same company. One suburb apart,' he wrote, sharing a photo of the two stations.


His post sparked outrage from his 27,000 followers, with many expressing frustration over the situation.

'I do not understand how Australia accepts this b******* to go on! I'm sure they will blame some non-existent fuel cycle,' one commenter wrote.

Another added: 'Drove through Miranda this morning. Shell $2.15, 50m down the road 7/11 $1.75. South Coast $1.57. How does that work?'

A third remarked that it wasn't just fuel prices: 'We have the same thing happening with our local supermarkets.'


A BP spokesperson clarified that the company did not control prices at all its stations, as some were independently owned franchises.

'BP always aims to be competitive with fuel prices. Our national network of BP branded independent business partners set their own retail pricing,' the spokesperson said.

The company also noted that most of their fuel in the region was imported, so prices were affected by global oil market fluctuations.

Khoury confirmed that BP operated differently from other fuel companies due to its franchise model.

'You can own a BP service station and set your own price and they will be more competitive on price,' he explained.


The National Roads and Motorists Association (NRMA) spokesman pointed out that on 30 January in Sydney, 41 per cent of stations were selling petrol for $2.10 or more.

Meanwhile, 27 per cent were charging $1.76 or less.

The average price for regular unleaded fuel in Sydney was $1.92, with the lowest price at $1.57 and the highest at $2.16.

'This is selling the same product in the same city,' Khoury said.

He also highlighted the extra costs consumers would face if filling up at more expensive stations.

He added: 'That is a gap of 59.2 cents a litre and if you were driving your standard 55-litre tank it would cost an extra $32.50 at the most expensive compared to the cheapest.'


Fuel prices in Australia are unregulated, meaning stations are free to charge whatever they want.

While the NRMA doesn’t support price regulation, it believes it would reduce the incentive for stations to offer lower prices.

In response, legislation has been introduced across the states requiring service stations to post their prices in real time.


Khoury suggested using apps to find cheaper stations and avoid paying higher prices.

'What you want to do is give people the information that they need to find the cheap BP and not fill up at the expensive one and that's what we've been doing at the NRMA,' he said.

'You just need to get on our app to find the cheaper one and if we can get people doing that then that's the ball game.'

The NRMA's efforts were seen as a way to reduce frustration among drivers.

'People are pissed off and this is how you stop them from being pissed off,' Khoury added.

In Australia, 44 cents of every litre of petrol or diesel sold is government tax.

Key Takeaways

  • A significant price gap between two BP stations in Sydney, just two kilometres apart, sparked outrage among drivers after one station charged $2.07 per litre, while the other sold it for $1.59.
  • NRMA spokesman Peter Khoury explained that such discrepancies were common due to the franchise model, where BP stations set their own prices.
  • The average price for petrol in Sydney was $1.92, with some stations charging as much as $2.16, while others sold it for as low as $1.57, causing confusion and frustration among consumers.
  • While fuel prices in Australia are unregulated, the NRMA has pushed for real-time price updates to help drivers find cheaper options and avoid being overcharged.

With fuel prices causing frustration across Sydney, do you think the current system is fair or should there be more regulation? Share your thoughts in the comments below!
 
Last edited:

Seniors Discount Club

Sponsored content

Info
Loading data . . .
44cents a litre tax...I recall some time in the past that was to replace a tax or two ...or was that GST ?..I guess I must be dreaming a govt wouldn't do anything like that...just what taxes were removed with GST ?I forget...or maybe im getting old
GST generally removed sales tax from purchases. Fuel for road vehicles has an "Excise Duty" of 50.6 cents, that changes half yearly with the CPI plus GST.
 
We have a "current system"? Who knew! Other than the Govt of every colour ripping off motorists at every point.

One thing's certain: we don't need more regulation!

As for BP - here in WA BP prices are always top level. BP is anything but competitive.

Meanwhile, the phenomenon described is not news in WA. It's been happening for a decade or more. We can always count on 7-Eleven matching the cheapest rate - and doing so honestly, advertising actual prices, not the discount as if it's cheapest.
 
Leave well enough alone, if we want government control everything maybe move to North Korea, you'd be whinging about everything there.

Funny how people whinge about the government always interfering in our lives, now everyone WANTS them to interfere. You realise what would happen with control of petrol prices, they would stay at the higher level always with little discounting.

The consumer needs to think a little about where and when they buy fuel, I do and often save 50 odd cents a litre. My daughter and daughter in law just go to the first station they see, never give a thought to what the price is.

No different to the supermarket, I don't go and buy the soft drink at full price, you wait until the week it's half price or 40% off and buy at that time. Of course you may have to pay the higher price sometimes at the service station, but you try to do that as a last resort.

Controlling the fuel price would never end well.
I agree. Govt already has enough influence on our bowsers.

But if you ever have to pay above, say, $1.99, then you're not doing your homework. Are you using an app like Petrol Spy? Do you keep track of the cheap days - they're a moveable feast. Plan ahead. It is doable.
 
Any driver who is 'in disbelief' over this sort of price difference is either not thinking, or stupid.

Two facts:

1. Petrol stations price their fuel on the basis of how much traffic they expect to visit them.
If they are on a major road, and have plenty of pumps, their prices will be through the roof.
But if they are tucked away on a side road and hard to get to, or have a tiny forecourt with few pumps, their prices will be very low.

2. There are several apps that can show you where the cheapest petrol is.
But you can expect to have to go out of your way, and / or need to sit and wait, to get it.
I use Petrol Spy and there is always at least one place that is considerably cheaper than others to get my fuel, close to where I live. I never go out of my way just to source 'the cheapest'. Not ony does that means extra km to travel but extra of my time, which I put a value on. Maybe I'm just lucky where I live, for which I'm grateful.
 
44 cents to the government ? Typical ripoff
The truth is, few of us know how much the Govt reaps in taxes, excises, and other money-grabbing imposts they disguise with innocuous-sounding words and phrases.

The primary scandal is that although Govt rationalises these taxes by claiming they're spent on relevant services, the money raised is only partially used for the purpose claimed. Often, the bulk of the proceedings is "repurposed."

The secondary scandal is that Opposition Parties sometimes complain about taxes - but they rarely, if ever, repeal them. Instead, with typical hypocrisy, they revel in the income and rightly rely on voters' short memories (about half that of the average goldfish).
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dynamo
I use Petrol Spy and there is always at least one place that is considerably cheaper than others to get my fuel, close to where I live. I never go out of my way just to source 'the cheapest'. Not ony does that means extra km to travel but extra of my time, which I put a value on. Maybe I'm just lucky where I live, for which I'm grateful.
Same. It's an essential tool.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dynamo
I agree. Govt already has enough influence on our bowsers.

But if you ever have to pay above, say, $1.99, then you're not doing your homework. Are you using an app like Petrol Spy? Do you keep track of the cheap days - they're a moveable feast. Plan ahead. It is doable.
Absolutely, always use Petrol Spy. So simple, keep in mind that you need fuel in the next day or so, look at the prices for where you maybe going and fuel up at the cheap one.

Here's a great example, 233.9 at Roseville, 177.7 at West Ryde, if you know you'll be going near there fill up. That's 56.2 cpl less and on my common 60 odd litre fill amounts to over $30 dollar saving. Most people are too lazy to look or can't be bothered and than whinge later about fuel prices.

1738379276586.png
 
  • Love
Reactions: BigAl6164
Somebody didn't get the phone call to change their price. ...OOPS!

This whole price cycle thing on the East Coast and in SA is joke and a way to continue to rip off motorists.

Apparently it doesn't happen in the West.
W.A. is great, they stipulate their prices and they can't be changed in a 24 hour period which gave you a chance to find cheaper fuel and it didn't change in the time it took you to get there.
 
I never buy at the top of the cycle and fill up when it's at the bottom. If caught out, I might get $20 worth to see me through until the next cheap price.

Price cycles are so annoying and sooo unnecessary!
The 7Eleven app allows you to "lock in" the cheap price and that price is operable any time, at any 7Eleven servo, for the next week, down to the very second!

What that means is, even if you can't afford petrol when it's cheap, you can lock in the cheap pric÷ and pay that amount next time you get your benefit or salary. Very handy.
 

Join the conversation

News, deals, games, and bargains for Aussies over 60. From everyday expenses like groceries and eating out, to electronics, fashion and travel, the club is all about helping you make your money go further.

Seniors Discount Club

The SDC searches for the best deals, discounts, and bargains for Aussies over 60. From everyday expenses like groceries and eating out, to electronics, fashion and travel, the club is all about helping you make your money go further.
  1. New members
  2. Jokes & fun
  3. Photography
  4. Nostalgia / Yesterday's Australia
  5. Food and Lifestyle
  6. Money Saving Hacks
  7. Offtopic / Everything else
  • We believe that retirement should be a time to relax and enjoy life, not worry about money. That's why we're here to help our members make the most of their retirement years. If you're over 60 and looking for ways to save money, connect with others, and have a laugh, we’d love to have you aboard.
  • Advertise with us

User Menu

Enjoyed Reading our Story?

  • Share this forum to your loved ones.
Change Weather Postcode×
Change Petrol Postcode×