Discover how Peter Dutton's latest Centrelink proposal could affect your benefits!

Navigating the complexities of Centrelink can be a challenge for many Australians, especially our senior community members who rely on welfare for their livelihood.

It's crucial to stay informed about any changes that could impact your benefits. Recently, Peter Dutton, the leader of the opposition, has made headlines with his pledge to reintroduce a controversial measure that could significantly alter the way welfare is managed for recipients in Indigenous communities.

This proposal has sparked widespread debate, with supporters arguing it promotes responsible spending, while critics raise concerns about its potential to condemn vulnerable groups. As discussions continue, understanding the implications of such policies becomes increasingly crucial for all affected individuals.


The cashless welfare card, a system initially rolled out in 2016, is designed to restrict how welfare payments can be spent.

The card aims to prevent money from being used on alcohol, gambling, and tobacco by quarantining up to 80 per cent of welfare payments.


1736816755088.png
Peter Dutton's proposal reintroduced the cashless debit card for welfare recipients in Indigenous communities. Credit: Depositphotos


Only the remaining 20 per cent is deposited into recipients' bank accounts, ensuring the bulk of the funds are spent on essentials like groceries.

During its trial between 2019 and 2021 in the Bundaberg and Hervey Bay region, the card reportedly blocked over $400,000 from spending on prohibited items.

Proponents of the card argue that it helps to reduce substance abuse and associated social issues within vulnerable communities.


However, the card has been a subject of intense debate. Critics, including the current Labor government, argue that it infringes on personal autonomy and has failed to achieve its goals.

Social Services Minister Amanda Rishworth pointed out that the card's restrictions adversely affected many people's lives.

‘So many people's lives were adversely affected because they couldn't access enough cash...to be able to live their life,’ she claimed.

The Labor government, led by Prime Minister Anthony Albanese, scrapped the welfare card shortly after coming into power in 2022.

The move was supported by findings from the Parliamentary Budget Office, which projected a saving of almost $290 million over four years by discontinuing the card.


Despite the opposition from the government, Peter Dutton is steadfast in his commitment to reintroduce the cashless debit card, particularly in Indigenous communities.

He believed that, with proper consultation, the card can ensure that children receive the support they deserve from their parents.

Dutton has also promised to hold a Royal Commission into sexual abuse in Indigenous communities and to conduct a full audit of spending on Indigenous programs to address inefficiencies.

‘There are communities where safety, housing, health, education and employment are critical issues,’ he said.

‘That's where our efforts must be targeted.’


As the federal election looms, with a date yet to be set but required by 17 May at the latest, Dutton and Albanese are hitting the campaign trail with their respective promises and policy proposals.

For our members who are Centrelink recipients, it's essential to understand how these potential changes could affect you.

While the cashless welfare card is unavailable, its reintroduction could significantly shift how you receive and spend your benefits.

It's a reminder of the importance of staying engaged with political developments and advocating for policies that respect the dignity and autonomy of all individuals, regardless of their financial situation.
Key Takeaways

  • Peter Dutton has proposed the reintroduction of the cashless debit card for welfare recipients in Indigenous communities to prevent spending on alcohol and gambling.
  • The card quarantines 80 per cent of a recipient's income and blocked over $400,000 on prohibited items during a Bundaberg and Hervey Bay trial from 2019 to 2021.
  • The current government led by Anthony Albanese scrapped the welfare card shortly after coming to power in 2022, with Social Services Minister Amanda Rishworth stating it was 'time to give people their autonomy back'.
  • Dutton's plans are part of his campaign promises as he and Prime Minister Anthony Albanese are on the election trail, with an election to be held no later than 17 May.
Have you or someone you know been affected by the cashless welfare system? What are your concerns or opinions on the proposed reintroduction of the card? Your insights are valuable. Feel free to share them in the comments below.
 

Seniors Discount Club

Sponsored content

Info
Loading data . . .
Sorry if you don't seem to like the fact that I have indigenous friends who themselves have different opinions to you.
My husband and I did restoration work many years ago in Laverton and Leonara.
Have you ever been there. I doubt it.
Have you seen how they have to live.
We.could have had ongoing work forever because as fast as things are repaired they are wrecked again through alcohol fueled violence.
Not always just the men, and the children are neglected, running around the streets at all hours of the night their parents not even aware that they are missing.
This is not all families. there are many wonderful people there but they are all affected nonetheless and the majority of them approved of the card as they said things had improved.
It was also reported that elders in other communities also wanted the card to remain.
If you don't want to believe this that is your prrrogative.
I didn't think I was wailing just asking you a simple question.
You have a very high opinion of yourself.
Calling other members "bottom shelfers",says more about you than them.

I shall wait with bated breath for your return insults.
The Indigenous Whisperer
Your comments are discriminative and unfounded.

Where are your facts that “there are many more non-indigenous people wasting money. ” Show where those accurate statistics are recorded. Not just based on your opinion.

As for your unemployment payment statistics, did it occur to you that there is a much larger population of non-indigenous people in Australia compared with indigenous people? Of course there will be more recipients for unemployment payments for the larger population.

What about the other benefits that are afforded only to Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people? Do you know about them, or just choose to ignore those facts?

Your ignorance is showing. Don’t try to pass on your opinions as truth.
Oh, so you both take the comment about the bullying personally? Of well, if the cap fits….
What makes you think I care to engage in conversation with either of you? The most aggressive here seem to be the ones responsible for producing the drug addled and/or jailbirds…guess that makes you the experts in something. You don’t get to demand anything from me! I’m in credit as far as wasted tax-payer monies oh clever ones!
 
  • Haha
Reactions: DLHM
The introduction of this type of card will become a black market product. Desperate people will sell the cards for a low price and the black market will profit from the sale of a card. This will cause severe stress, worse than it already is so I feel that the card system would need to have a very high level of protection as far as identity is concerned and this will cause other issues. I would certainly resent having to use a card of this nature as it would cause me embarrassment and indignation.
 
The introduction of this type of card will become a black market product. Desperate people will sell the cards for a low price and the black market will profit from the sale of a card. This will cause severe stress, worse than it already is so I feel that the card system would need to have a very high level of protection as far as identity is concerned and this will cause other issues. I would certainly resent having to use a card of this nature as it would cause me embarrassment and indignation.
Yes of course it would - it would cause embarrassment and indignation for anyone!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mr Chips
Oh, so you both take the comment about the bullying personally? Of well, if the cap fits….
What makes you think I care to engage in conversation with either of you? The most aggressive here seem to be the ones responsible for producing the drug addled and/or jailbirds…guess that makes you the experts in something. You don’t get to demand anything from me! I’m in credit as far as wasted tax-payer monies oh clever ones!
🤣🤣🤣🤣😂😂😂😂Of course you don't want to engage in conversation, people usually don't when they can't prove their point.
As far as your insulting comments about our sons. I'm afraid I can't accept responsibility for my eldest son, who for reasons that are none of your business, was raised by my ex husband..
I raised my intellectually handicapped daughter and my youngest son who I am proud to say has a well paid management job. a lovely wife and three beautiful children, living on their 120 acre property that he has worked extremely hard for.
I will however accept responsibility for trying to help my eldest son, but inadvertently, according to advice, I was actually enabling him.
If you want to throw brickbats at me for that, go for it.
You are a nasty piece of work.
 
🤣🤣🤣🤣😂😂😂😂Of course you don't want to engage in conversation, people usually don't when they can't prove their point.
As far as your insulting comments about our sons. I'm afraid I can't accept responsibility for my eldest son, who for reasons that are none of your business, was raised by my ex husband..
I raised my intellectually handicapped daughter and my youngest son who I am proud to say has a well paid management job. a lovely wife and three beautiful children, living on their 120 acre property that he has worked extremely hard for.
I will however accept responsibility for trying to help my eldest son, but inadvertently, according to advice, I was actually enabling him.
If you want to throw brickbats at me for that, go for it.
You are a nasty piece of work.
Oh go away from me! My care factor is NIL about you or your family. Clearly it is all about YOU!
 
as long as the pension scheme they want to introduce applies to parliamentary pensions ok ....bet your bottom dollar THAT wont happen... can anyone advise the difference between PENSION and. WELFARE?? the gov. seems to think they are the same thing (except for parliament pension )
 
"Critics, including the current Labor government, argue that it infringes on personal autonomy..." You are just too funny Labor! Where was your support for personal autonomy during the pandemic...

I concur with IAN3005, be very mindful of what one supports as it WILL ultimately be rolled out to everyone.
except politicians pension
 
1984 is approaching faster than we think. He better not get bright ideas about extending that to ALL cardholders. I am sure he has that in the back of his mind. Mongrel....
we need to remind our prime minister that the money he is talking about is OUR money and he is authorised to spend it wisely
 
Some would say that the crime in Alice Springs is a direct result of the intervention coupled with the withdrawal of funding that provided support to children, their families and communities.

There has already been a Board of Inquiry into the Protection of Aboriginal Children from Sexual Abuse in 2006. “The little children are sacred“ handed down its report in 2007 report

A decade later, co-chair of the report, Rex Wild QC says Canberra largely ignored the report’s key recommendations and instead used it as a political tool to push for the intervention. (FYI I highly recommend Daniel James’s excellent article The children of the intervention. ( the monthly Oct 2024)
Is this the kind of track Petter Dutton is offering to get us back to?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Knell
Oh, so you both take the comment about the bullying personally? Of well, if the cap fits….
What makes you think I care to engage in conversation with either of you? The most aggressive here seem to be the ones responsible for producing the drug addled and/or jailbirds…guess that makes you the experts in something. You don’t get to demand anything from me! I’m in credit as far as wasted tax-payer monies oh clever ones!
I am arguably the most aggressive poster on SDC. I will not back down to anyone and will protect other reasonable posters from aggressive types.

Explain why my three children have not been "guilty" of anything more than a minor traffic infringement, while "good old Daddy" here has spent two stints in jail. Does a person's offspring's behaviour determine what type of individual THEY are? Who knows? Adolf Hitler's parents may have been the most law abiding parents in history. It didn't prevent them from creating one of the most obnoxious people known to mankind in modern times.

A shallow argument to say the least!
 
Oh, so you both take the comment about the bullying personally? Of well, if the cap fits….
What makes you think I care to engage in conversation with either of you? The most aggressive here seem to be the ones responsible for producing the drug addled and/or jailbirds…guess that makes you the experts in something. You don’t get to demand anything from me! I’m in credit as far as wasted tax-payer monies oh clever ones!
You just don’t get it. You’re proving yourself to be so disillusioned that you just can’t be taken seriously. 🤣

If you don’t “care to engage in conversation” with us, then you shouldn’t keep bouncing back with more useless crap.

I would never “demand anything” from you. Your stupid comments are something nobody wants. You really have tickets on yourself. Seems you’re just jealous.
 
I am arguably the most aggressive poster on SDC. I will not back down to anyone and will protect other reasonable posters from aggressive types.

Explain why my three children have not been "guilty" of anything more than a minor traffic infringement, while "good old Daddy" here has spent two stints in jail. Does a person's offspring's behaviour determine what type of individual THEY are? Who knows? Adolf Hitler's parents may have been the most law abiding parents in history. It didn't prevent them from creating one of the most obnoxious people known to mankind in modern times.

A shallow argument to say the least!
Oh look! The gang is altogether now..almost. As usual, can rely on you to introduce the strawman fallacies. Can’t be bothered. Your judgement means less than nothing to me. Scroll on...
 
  • Haha
Reactions: DLHM
Sorry if you don't seem to like the fact that I have indigenous friends who themselves have different opinions to you.
My husband and I did restoration work many years ago in Laverton and Leonara.
Have you ever been there. I doubt it.
Have you seen how they have to live.
We.could have had ongoing work forever because as fast as things are repaired they are wrecked again through alcohol fueled violence.
Not always just the men, and the children are neglected, running around the streets at all hours of the night their parents not even aware that they are missing.
This is not all families. there are many wonderful people there but they are all affected nonetheless and the majority of them approved of the card as they said things had improved.
It was also reported that elders in other communities also wanted the card to remain.
If you don't want to believe this that is your prrrogative.
I didn't think I was wailing just asking you a simple question.
You have a very high opinion of yourself.
Calling other members "bottom shelfers",says more about you than them.

I shall wait with bated breath for your return insults.
The Indigenous Whisperer
Your going to be hitting your head trying to get through to that one
 
  • Like
Reactions: DLHM
Oh, so you both take the comment about the bullying personally? Of well, if the cap fits….
What makes you think I care to engage in conversation with either of you? The most aggressive here seem to be the ones responsible for producing the drug addled and/or jailbirds…guess that makes you the experts in something. You don’t get to demand anything from me! I’m in credit as far as wasted tax-payer monies oh clever ones!
Where have you been ? We haven't seen you on here for awhile.

But I see you are the same or maybe worst

Can I ask you a personal question ? ...why are you a bully ? Yet you are calling everyone else a bully. Knell knell knell , you started it all

The two ladies you are bullying are two of the nice ones on here. I think you should back off !!
 
Last edited:

Join the conversation

News, deals, games, and bargains for Aussies over 60. From everyday expenses like groceries and eating out, to electronics, fashion and travel, the club is all about helping you make your money go further.

Seniors Discount Club

The SDC searches for the best deals, discounts, and bargains for Aussies over 60. From everyday expenses like groceries and eating out, to electronics, fashion and travel, the club is all about helping you make your money go further.
  1. New members
  2. Jokes & fun
  3. Photography
  4. Nostalgia / Yesterday's Australia
  5. Food and Lifestyle
  6. Money Saving Hacks
  7. Offtopic / Everything else
  • We believe that retirement should be a time to relax and enjoy life, not worry about money. That's why we're here to help our members make the most of their retirement years. If you're over 60 and looking for ways to save money, connect with others, and have a laugh, we’d love to have you aboard.
  • Advertise with us

User Menu

Enjoyed Reading our Story?

  • Share this forum to your loved ones.
Change Weather Postcode×
Change Petrol Postcode×