‘The most agonising pain a person could endure’: Experts rank the most unbearable pain

Pain is a deeply personal experience, yet some types of pain push the limits of human endurance in ways that defy expectations.

While many assume childbirth or serious injuries top the list of the most excruciating sensations, new research suggests there’s another condition that leaves them all in its shadow.

What follows is a fascinating look at how different types of pain compare—and which one reigns supreme as the most unbearable of all.


A little-known condition affecting roughly one in 100 Britons was identified as the most agonising pain a person could endure, according to a recent study.

Cluster headaches were a rare neurological disorder that left sufferers debilitated by searing head pain.

The attacks struck multiple times a day, could last for hours, and did not respond to standard painkillers.


image1.png
The excruciating condition of painkillers can’t stop. Image source: Pexel/JESHOOTS.com


A US study found these headaches were more excruciating than childbirth, gunshot wounds, and bone fractures.

Researchers asked 1,604 people with cluster headaches to compare their pain to over a dozen other conditions and injuries, including stab wounds and heart attacks.

Coming in third after childbirth was pancreatitis, a painful inflammation of the pancreas, often triggered by gallstones or excessive alcohol consumption.

Kidney stones and gallstones—where small, crystalline formations caused intense pain when they grew large enough—also ranked highly.


Participants rated their pain on a scale from 0 to 10, with childbirth scoring 7.2.

Gunshot victims rated their experience at 6.

Surgeons had previously noted that the pain varied significantly depending on where a person was shot.

Areas like the stomach, back, groin, and neck were particularly excruciating due to the concentration of nerves.


A slipped disc, or disc herniation, where soft tissue bulged between spinal bones and pressed on nerves, came close behind gunshot wounds at 5.9.

Migraines scored 5.4, slightly above fibromyalgia, a chronic pain disorder linked to nervous system dysfunction.

Heart attacks, often associated with crushing chest pain, only ranked at 5—the same as sciatica, a condition where a nerve running from the lower back to the feet became compressed.

Both conditions rated slightly higher than stab wounds, which averaged 4.9, though much like gunshot wounds, the severity depended on the location of the injury.


Cluster headaches remained poorly understood but affected an estimated 65,000 people in Britain.

The attacks caused sharp, burning, or piercing pain, typically concentrated on one side of the head near the eye.

They struck suddenly and could last up to three hours, occurring multiple times a day for weeks or months at a time.

The pain was so severe that common painkillers like paracetamol and ibuprofen were ineffective.

Experts had yet to determine what triggered cluster headaches.

They were more commonly diagnosed in people in their 30s and were about six times more prevalent in men than in women.


At the lower end of the pain scale was arthritis, a common condition causing joint inflammation, which rated a 4—still classified as more intense than mild pain.

Doctors used pain scales to gauge a patient’s experience, though researchers acknowledged their limitations due to the subjective nature of pain.

The study, published in Headache, noted that patients’ ratings could have been influenced by memory gaps, as they were asked to recall painful events that may have occurred years earlier.


Here’s how the worst pains compare—see the full ranking below!


image2.png
Experts rank cluster headache attacks as the worst pain ever. Image source: National Library of Medicine


Key Takeaways
  • Pain perception varies widely, but a study found cluster headaches to be the most agonising condition, surpassing childbirth, gunshot wounds, and bone fractures.
  • Participants rated their pain on a scale of 0 to 10, with pancreatitis, kidney stones, and gallstones also ranking highly, while heart attacks and stab wounds scored lower than expected.
  • Cluster headaches caused sudden, severe pain around one eye, lasted up to three hours, and occurred multiple times a day for weeks or months, with standard painkillers proving ineffective.
  • The condition remained poorly understood, affected around 65,000 Britons, was more common in men, and typically began in a person’s 30s, though researchers had yet to determine its exact cause.

With pain being such a personal experience, do you agree with these rankings, or have you endured something even worse?

Let us know your thoughts in the comments.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bagshaw

Seniors Discount Club

Sponsored content

Info
Loading data . . .
Oh lovely, just when i'm going in on Monday to have a biopsy done on my right lung I see that's on the list, low down but still there :oops:

I don't suffer from cluster headaches but I do suffer from ice pick headaches and they can be extremely painful, they don't last long but when they hit they are scary and painful.
 
Oh lovely, just when i'm going in on Monday to have a biopsy done on my right lung I see that's on the list, low down but still there :oops:

I don't suffer from cluster headaches but I do suffer from ice pick headaches and they can be extremely painful, they don't last long but when they hit they are scary and painful.
Hope all goes well with your biopsy on Monday ❤️
 
Hope all goes well with your biopsy on Monday ❤️
Hope alls well.
Thank you, all didn't go well because it didn't happen. All weekend I waited on a phone call to find out what time it was going to be and no one called me so I called my nurses this morning and they said it could be tomorrow or Wednesday, they were trying to find out the time for me but no one knows 🧐
So I ended up stopping my fast and had a cuppa.
Now I wait some more!
 
Pain is a very personal thing, some people can take a lot, to others a slight tinge can be excruciating. Also depends on when, where, how. A friend had one very painful childbirth but the next one was almost totally painless. And most of these lists are about males, who we know cannot bear pain as well as females can.
 
I have fibromyalgia and osteoarthritis in most of my joints, including my entire spine. I would disagree with the finding that fibromyalgia pain is worse than arthritis. I have very small hands and I often look at my fingers and wonder how something so small could generate so much pain.

My rheumatologist tells me I'm made of 'stern stuff' because I'm always cheerful and cracking jokes, even though I'm never pain free. That's because my tiny but formidable Victorian English Nana constantly drummed into her grandchildren that, 'Laugh and the world laughs with you. Cry and you cry alone.'
 
conditions that are nonstop, one gets used to the pain as its always there. These cant be compared to something that is acute in the moment of an event happening. Tolerance varies enormously. Just who are the experts? And how many participants, how many conditions, doubt enough were asked, and doubt a wide range of events were included to rate. These kind of studies are not proof of anything. I wouldn't be too concerned about them at all. They are hardly representative of populations/communities etc.
 
Gallstones and muscle spasms.
Muscles spasms fixed up now with Magnesium.
Gallstones worse than child birth. Child birth eventually the pain goes away after the birth. But gallstones never knew when it was gonna start and you definitely didn't know when it would end. Didnt matter what you did. Got so bad had my gallstones taken out.
 
Oh lovely, just when i'm going in on Monday to have a biopsy done on my right lung I see that's on the list, low down but still there :oops:

I don't suffer from cluster headaches but I do suffer from ice pick headaches and they can be extremely painful, they don't last long but when they hit they are scary and painful.
You will be ok beautiful lady. I will be thinking of you on Monday hopefully everything will be OK 👍 💐
 
Hubby had major surgery a a couple of days before his discharge he was screaming in pain. When I got in there he looked like death. I was worried something went wrong with his surgery.

Turns out because his surgery took 8 hours and he was basically bent in half kidney stones moved. The doctor said the pain of what he was going through was worst than childbirth.

My eldest daughter needed her gallbladder removed but was on a waiting list. She had two trips via ambulance to the hospital because of pain. I remember her saying Give me childbirth any day. Even today she will say that pain was worst than giving birth to any of her three kids
 
I have had many broken bones, osteoarthritis in both hips, stroke and heart attack but the worst pain I have endured is acute pancreatitis.

Coming in at second would be having a grain of sand scraping the back of your eyeball for 48 hours.

Childbirth was something I've never mastered....
 
How come there's no mention of diverticulitis, worst pain I've ever had and I've been stabbed, crushed fingers off and had kidney and gall stones, none of them were any where near as bad as diverticulitis.
 
  • Sad
Reactions: Sass

Join the conversation

News, deals, games, and bargains for Aussies over 60. From everyday expenses like groceries and eating out, to electronics, fashion and travel, the club is all about helping you make your money go further.

Seniors Discount Club

The SDC searches for the best deals, discounts, and bargains for Aussies over 60. From everyday expenses like groceries and eating out, to electronics, fashion and travel, the club is all about helping you make your money go further.
  1. New members
  2. Jokes & fun
  3. Photography
  4. Nostalgia / Yesterday's Australia
  5. Food and Lifestyle
  6. Money Saving Hacks
  7. Offtopic / Everything else

Latest Articles

  • We believe that retirement should be a time to relax and enjoy life, not worry about money. That's why we're here to help our members make the most of their retirement years. If you're over 60 and looking for ways to save money, connect with others, and have a laugh, we’d love to have you aboard.
  • Advertise with us

User Menu

Enjoyed Reading our Story?

  • Share this forum to your loved ones.
Change Weather Postcode×
Change Petrol Postcode×