Pomegranate predicament: Growers' frustration bears fruit for imperfect produce distributor

In the lush Goulburn Valley of Victoria, a grower stares out over a sea of pomegranates, a crop that should have been a source of pride and profit.

Instead, it's become a symbol of the harsh realities of modern agriculture and the stringent standards of supermarket aesthetics.

Like many others, this grower has found himself unable to sell 20,000 kilograms of pomegranates to supermarkets, not because of taste or nutritional value, but due to 'purely aesthetic' damage caused by an unexpected summer hail storm.


The hail in January left small blemishes on the skin of the young fruit, which, despite being perfectly edible, meant that about half of the crop would not meet the supermarkets' standards for appearance.

This is a common story in the agricultural industry, where the pursuit of perfection often leaves perfectly good food without a market.

Another farmer in the same region reported 'dumping' around 30 tonnes of tomatoes daily due to minor issues like ‘slight discolouration, size issues, and blemishes on the skin’.


farmers-pick-why-eating-seasonal-produce-matters-3-scaled.jpg
Farmers lamented supermarkets' strict beauty standards, citing that even minor imperfections cause rejection. Credits: Farmers Pick


While both Woolworths and Coles stated they did not reject the produce, the reality is that the growers themselves chose not to present their fruits for sale, anticipating the likely rejection based on past experiences.

Fortunately, not all of this produce goes to waste.

Farmers Pick, an 'imperfect' fruit and vegetable distributor, stepped in to save all of the pomegranates and half of the tomatoes that would otherwise be destined for landfill.

Since its establishment in 2020, Farmers Pick has rescued three million kilograms of produce from 50 growers across Australia, selling them in home-delivered fresh produce boxes.


Co-founder Josh Ball voiced the frustrations of growers.

‘I think the farmers have been constantly squeezed over the past decade to make more beautiful fruit while trying to make the unrealistic beauty standards set for them,’ he stated.

‘Oranges for example, if they have got a blemish that's bigger than five per cent of the fruit on the skin, then they're rejected.’

‘And that'll be the reason why it'll be in a Farmers Pick box and not on a supermarket shelf,’ he added.

He also mentioned that Farmers Pick did not accept fruits and vegetables that were inedible, and the produce only exhibited ‘purely aesthetic’ damages.

‘It doesn't affect the taste, which is the most confusing part,’ Mr Ball said.

He added that the situation would become increasingly difficult due to climate change and the rising occurrence of natural disasters.

Farmers Pick attributed its rapid growth to its direct sourcing from farmers, which allowed it to ‘cut a few steps in the supply chain’ and offer customers prices approximately 30 per cent lower than those in supermarkets.

‘I think with the cost of living, people are being forced to really think about how they're doing their shopping, buying their food, and how they're eating,’ Mr Ball said.


A spokesperson from Coles stated that the company endeavours to fulfil customers' expectations regarding the quality of its produce.

‘We work very closely with our growers to determine the approximate quantities of produce we expect to purchase ahead of time, so we can give customers confidence that they will be able to buy in-season produce at great prices,’ the spokesperson said.

‘It also gives growers the confidence to grow crops with certainty they will be able to meet demand while not creating an oversupply.’

‘When entering agreements with our growers, we decide on specifications ahead of time,’ they added.


A spokesperson from Woolworths mentioned that they regularly assess their produce standards with suppliers to guarantee that the fruits and vegetables supplied to their stores meet customer expectations.

‘Our produce requirements are adaptable and respond to the quantity and availability of fruit and vegetables in the market, which is affected by seasonality, supply, and weather,’ the spokesperson said.

‘This allows us to work with growers to meet customer demand, while also reducing food waste from unsold fruit and veg in our stores.’


An ALDI spokesperson stated that their market buy range was described as ‘open spec’.

‘This means that the fruit delivers the same quality taste, but may be of different shapes and sizes, or have little blemishes that make them less beautiful, but just as delicious,’ they said.

‘Beyond this, there are a number of ways ALDI supports its grower partners including long-term partnerships, last-minute specials created in partnership to support growers to sell excess produce following favourable growing conditions, as well as changing pack or produce sizing and cosmetic markings requirements into support market conditions and reduce waste.’


From scrutinising the quality of fruits to exploring value buys, Australians are increasingly conscious of their grocery choices.

While these discussions continue, savvy shoppers are discovering overlooked treasures that offer incredible value for their wallets.

As consumers navigate through these considerations, they are eager to uncover hidden gems that not only meet their budgetary needs, but also deliver quality and satisfaction.
Key Takeaways
  • A Victorian grower was unable to sell 20,000 kilograms of pomegranates to supermarkets due to 'purely aesthetic' damage caused by hail.
  • Farmers expressed frustration with the beauty standards imposed by supermarkets, stating that even small blemishes lead to rejection of the produce.
  • Farmers Pick, a distributor of 'imperfect' fruit and vegetables, saved large quantities of produce from ending up in landfills by providing a market for aesthetically damaged but edible products.
  • Supermarkets responded by detailing their quality expectations and efforts to work with growers, with some alternatives being offered such as ALDI's market buy range for less than perfect produce.
Have you encountered 'imperfect' produce in your shopping experiences? Would you be willing to buy blemished but tasty fruits and vegetables if it meant supporting local growers and reducing waste? Share your thoughts and experiences in the comments below.
 
Sponsored
when will the clowns learn that a mark is nothing more than a MARK. I am so sick of the wastage. I had a stupid cousin who wouldn't use or buy anything with a mark on it... more money than sense. I even use anything in my fridge that's just going off. Cut of the marked part and use the rest. I've definitely known hunger and learned there isn't much that will make you sick. Tomatoes are prime example.... got a rot spot, cut it off and either cook it, make a salad out of it or even slice around problem and use in toasted sandwich'. Don't believe me? Ask the homeless folks.
 
Blemishes on fruit and veg are only part of the problem with supermarket chains wanting top dollar for fruit and veg. Consumers are reluctant to pay a supermarket premium price for a product with imperfections which may affect the shelf life of the product. Fruit and veg can easily rot from bruising or insect damage. The sale of produce with slight imperfections should show the supermarket giants that customers want produce at reasonable prices not for unreasonable profits.
 
when will the clowns learn that a mark is nothing more than a MARK. I am so sick of the wastage. I had a stupid cousin who wouldn't use or buy anything with a mark on it... more money than sense. I even use anything in my fridge that's just going off. Cut of the marked part and use the rest. I've definitely known hunger and learned there isn't much that will make you sick. Tomatoes are prime example.... got a rot spot, cut it off and either cook it, make a salad out of it or even slice around problem and use in toasted sandwich'. Don't believe me? Ask the homeless folks.
Agree totally ..... mushrooms that are over their 'use by' date can be made into a delicious sauce.
 
I can see their point.
These are from a bag of Odd Bunch mandarins bought today. If lots more like this were on display for sale who would actually buy them? 🤔
 

Attachments

  • IMG_20240516_174331.jpg
    IMG_20240516_174331.jpg
    104.3 KB · Views: 0
That's just crazy the prices have gone through the roof for fruit and vegetables and they are throwing it out. I don't give a shit what they look like as long as it's fresh. We have families struggling to put food on the table for their kids
 

Join the conversation

News, deals, games, and bargains for Aussies over 60. From everyday expenses like groceries and eating out, to electronics, fashion and travel, the club is all about helping you make your money go further.

Seniors Discount Club

The SDC searches for the best deals, discounts, and bargains for Aussies over 60. From everyday expenses like groceries and eating out, to electronics, fashion and travel, the club is all about helping you make your money go further.
  1. New members
  2. Jokes & fun
  3. Photography
  4. Nostalgia / Yesterday's Australia
  5. Food and Lifestyle
  6. Money Saving Hacks
  7. Offtopic / Everything else

Latest Articles

  • We believe that retirement should be a time to relax and enjoy life, not worry about money. That's why we're here to help our members make the most of their retirement years. If you're over 60 and looking for ways to save money, connect with others, and have a laugh, we’d love to have you aboard.
  • Advertise with us

User Menu

Enjoyed Reading our Story?

  • Share this forum to your loved ones.
Change Weather Postcode×
Change Petrol Postcode×