Why are authorities blocking this restaurant's plans? Community members reveal reason
- Replies 0
Australia takes pride in its comforting and innovative food scene.
The Land Down Under has also welcomed international food giants in recent years.
Yet, in one of Sydney's most historic suburbs, a massive restaurant chain recently became the centre of a heated battle, one that has even drawn in the local police.
McDonald's Australia lodged a proposal to open a two-storey restaurant on Redfern Street, right in the suburb's main dining and shopping precinct.
The site, currently home to a tobacconist and a linen shop, sits at the busy corner of Redfern and Regent Streets.
These streets have been witnesses to decades of change within the community.
Yet, instead of a warm welcome, the fast-food giant has been met with a wall of opposition.
Locals have labelled the proposed store a 'fluorescent blight' and a 'poison and blemish on the map of Redfern'.
For many, it was not just about the food; it was about the soul and the future of their neighbourhood.
Redfern was the birthplace of the Aboriginal civil rights movement in the 1970s.
Since then, it has cemented its reputation as a hub for the Indigenous community.
About 269 submissions against the plan stated that the McDonald's store would be too close to these vital Indigenous community services.
Meanwhile, 17 supporters were in favour of McDonald's setting up shop in the area.
In a rare move, local police officers joined the chorus of objectors.
Senior Constable Peter Langbein submitted a formal objection to the City of Sydney council's planning panel.
In the letter, Constable Langbein warned that a new McDonald's store in the area could lead to a spike in robberies, violence, and even e-bike theft.
'Patrons leaving the premises during late hours are likely to engage in a range of behaviour, which need not rise to a level of criminality yet will adversely affect the neighbourhood, including talking amongst themselves, yelling, screaming and arguing,' Constable Langbein added.
Alisi Tutuila, the Chair of the Aboriginal Housing Company, feared that the restaurant would undermine years of work to make Redfern safer at night.
The council's Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Advisory Panel also raised concerns about the store encouraging 'unhealthy eating habits' and the potential to worsen existing health disparities in the community.
It's not just residents and police who are worried about the establishment.
David Jank, the co-owner of nearby Arcadia Liquors, called the move 'insensitive'.
'I've owned the bar 12 years, I know a lot of social problems that are in existence in the area,' Mr Jank said.
'I just can't see any positivity to it whatsoever.'
Gabriel, a licensee of the Tudor Hotel, echoed Mr Jank's sentiments.
'The last few years Redfern has been changing for the positive. I think this is a step backwards,' he lamented.
Ambour Hardware proprietor Joe Ambour stated that the area has changed dramatically throughout the hardware shop's 55-year run.
'People don't want the customer service anymore,' Mr Ambour said.
'They just want what is cheap. They will Google whatever is the cheapest and just go there.'
In response to the community's uproar, McDonald's Australia spoke out about the looming concerns.
According to a McDonald's spokesperson, the brand has been listening to the community and 'will be engaging openly with stakeholders and community members over the coming weeks to understand and address any concerns'.
'For more than 50 years, Macca's has been a proud member of Australian communities, providing hundreds of local jobs and supporting local community groups,' a McDonald's spokesperson added.
'We are always looking for opportunities to serve our customers and communities better and see strong potential in Redfern.'
'If approved, the proposed McDonald's in Redfern would create more than 100 local jobs, create opportunities for community partnerships and sponsorships, and involve an investment of approximately $3 million.'
On the other hand, the City of Sydney Council could recommend the proposal be refused at an upcoming planning panel meeting.
The Redfern McDonald's debate could be a reminder that local voices still matter and that the places people call home are worth fighting for.
What do you think about this local backlash? Should McDonald's be allowed to open in Redfern, or is the community right to push back? Have you seen similar concerns in your area? Share your thoughts and stories related to this predicament in the comments section below!
The Land Down Under has also welcomed international food giants in recent years.
Yet, in one of Sydney's most historic suburbs, a massive restaurant chain recently became the centre of a heated battle, one that has even drawn in the local police.
McDonald's Australia lodged a proposal to open a two-storey restaurant on Redfern Street, right in the suburb's main dining and shopping precinct.
The site, currently home to a tobacconist and a linen shop, sits at the busy corner of Redfern and Regent Streets.
These streets have been witnesses to decades of change within the community.
Yet, instead of a warm welcome, the fast-food giant has been met with a wall of opposition.
Redfern is hailed as one of the most culturally significant areas in Sydney. Image Credit: TimeOut/Cassandra Hannagan
Locals have labelled the proposed store a 'fluorescent blight' and a 'poison and blemish on the map of Redfern'.
For many, it was not just about the food; it was about the soul and the future of their neighbourhood.
Redfern was the birthplace of the Aboriginal civil rights movement in the 1970s.
Since then, it has cemented its reputation as a hub for the Indigenous community.
About 269 submissions against the plan stated that the McDonald's store would be too close to these vital Indigenous community services.
Meanwhile, 17 supporters were in favour of McDonald's setting up shop in the area.
In a rare move, local police officers joined the chorus of objectors.
Senior Constable Peter Langbein submitted a formal objection to the City of Sydney council's planning panel.
In the letter, Constable Langbein warned that a new McDonald's store in the area could lead to a spike in robberies, violence, and even e-bike theft.
'Patrons leaving the premises during late hours are likely to engage in a range of behaviour, which need not rise to a level of criminality yet will adversely affect the neighbourhood, including talking amongst themselves, yelling, screaming and arguing,' Constable Langbein added.
Alisi Tutuila, the Chair of the Aboriginal Housing Company, feared that the restaurant would undermine years of work to make Redfern safer at night.
The council's Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Advisory Panel also raised concerns about the store encouraging 'unhealthy eating habits' and the potential to worsen existing health disparities in the community.
It's not just residents and police who are worried about the establishment.
David Jank, the co-owner of nearby Arcadia Liquors, called the move 'insensitive'.
'I've owned the bar 12 years, I know a lot of social problems that are in existence in the area,' Mr Jank said.
'I just can't see any positivity to it whatsoever.'
The proposed McDonald's store could occupy one of Redfern's storied buildings. Image Credit: City of Sydney
Gabriel, a licensee of the Tudor Hotel, echoed Mr Jank's sentiments.
'The last few years Redfern has been changing for the positive. I think this is a step backwards,' he lamented.
Ambour Hardware proprietor Joe Ambour stated that the area has changed dramatically throughout the hardware shop's 55-year run.
'People don't want the customer service anymore,' Mr Ambour said.
'They just want what is cheap. They will Google whatever is the cheapest and just go there.'
In response to the community's uproar, McDonald's Australia spoke out about the looming concerns.
According to a McDonald's spokesperson, the brand has been listening to the community and 'will be engaging openly with stakeholders and community members over the coming weeks to understand and address any concerns'.
'For more than 50 years, Macca's has been a proud member of Australian communities, providing hundreds of local jobs and supporting local community groups,' a McDonald's spokesperson added.
'We are always looking for opportunities to serve our customers and communities better and see strong potential in Redfern.'
'If approved, the proposed McDonald's in Redfern would create more than 100 local jobs, create opportunities for community partnerships and sponsorships, and involve an investment of approximately $3 million.'
On the other hand, the City of Sydney Council could recommend the proposal be refused at an upcoming planning panel meeting.
The Redfern McDonald's debate could be a reminder that local voices still matter and that the places people call home are worth fighting for.
