Nutritionist exposes ‘misleading’ labels on supermarket egg cartons

It can be overwhelming when we head down to the grocery store and look at the endless selection of eggs.

While organic and free-range eggs are often more expensive, what is the real difference between each type, and why do these price tags continually jump higher and higher?



Recently, a nutritionist took to social media to help us understand the confusion among egg cartons at the supermarket and explain why it’s so important to pay attention to the labels.

So, read on and let’s dig into the truth behind these egg labels together!


compressed-Screen Shot 2023-08-01 at 2.27.19 PM.jpeg
A nutritionist is taking out the guesswork when it comes to shopping for eggs. Credit: Pexels/Anna Shvets.



Craig McCloskey began his video by talking about the various types of eggs that are commonly available.

He started with what is known as 'conventional eggs'. These eggs are the most affordable option, but they come from chickens that are kept in battery cages. These cages are small and crowded, with typically two to ten birds living in each one, and the chickens spend their entire lives in these confined conditions.

As a consequence of their living conditions, the quality of these eggs is considered to be poor.



Moving on, he spoke about 'cage-free eggs', which come from chickens that are not kept in battery cages. However, he pointed out that being cage-free does not necessarily mean the hens have access to the outdoors.

Instead, they are confined to a relatively small indoor space. Despite being a step up from conventional eggs, they are only marginally better due to the lack of outdoor access for the chickens.

The next option is 'free-range' eggs. Here, the chickens are given access to the outdoors, and they have around two square feet of space per chicken. This offers better living conditions compared to cage-free eggs since the hens can roam outside.

However, regardless of the type of eggs, all these chickens are typically fed a diet of corn or soy. While this feed is cost-effective, it may not be the best for the birds' health or the overall quality of the eggs they produce.



At the top of the list are 'pasture-raised' eggs, considered the best conditions for chickens. These hens have 10 square metres of space each and are able to eat a natural diet of grass, bugs, and worms.

They also live in more humane conditions. And because of these superior conditions, pasture-raised eggs are considered the healthiest option and are also the most expensive.

While the difference between each label comes down to the quality of diet and living conditions, we must also consider our own financial situation. As McCloskey pointed out: conventional eggs are still a much better option than ultra-processed foods.

1690871336711.png

If pasture-raised eggs are a financial option for you, they come with a variety of health benefits. According to Piedmont, pasture-raised chickens have more vitamin E and omega-3 fatty acids, which are advantageous from a heart health and overall well-being perspective.

Comments on the post from shoppers have suggested boycotting conventional eggs and grocery store eggs altogether and only getting eggs from local farmers or avid gardeners.

Key Takeaways

  • Nutritionist Craig McCloskey took to Instagram to explain the difference between conventional, cage-free, free-range, and pasture-raised eggs found in supermarkets.
  • He explained that conventional eggs are usually the lowest quality, coming from chickens kept in cramped battery cages.
  • Pasture-raised chickens, on the other hand, are given 108 square feet per chicken and a more natural diet, leading to increased vitamin E and omega-3 fatty acids.
  • McCloskey emphasised that eggs hold good nutritional value irrespective of their source, advising consumers to choose according to their financial, moral, and nutritional needs.



Although pasture-raised chickens are the most humane and offer the best nutrition, there really is no ‘wrong’ choice when it comes to eggs.

At the end of the day, members, choose wisely the next time you’re at the supermarket. Consider the labels on the egg cartons, but also your own financial situation—and don't forget that the eggs we eat contain a great number of vitamins and minerals, regardless of where they come from.

What are your thoughts, folks? Which preferences do you consider when choosing your eggs? Let us know in the comments below!
 
Sponsored
It can be overwhelming when we head down to the grocery store and look at the endless selection of eggs.

While organic and free-range eggs are often more expensive, what is the real difference between each type, and why do these price tags continually jump higher and higher?



Recently, a nutritionist took to social media to help us understand the confusion among egg cartons at the supermarket and explain why it’s so important to pay attention to the labels.

So, read on and let’s dig into the truth behind these egg labels together!


View attachment 26409
A nutritionist is taking out the guesswork when it comes to shopping for eggs. Credit: Pexels/Anna Shvets.



Craig McCloskey began his video by talking about the various types of eggs that are commonly available.

He started with what is known as 'conventional eggs'. These eggs are the most affordable option, but they come from chickens that are kept in battery cages. These cages are small and crowded, with typically two to ten birds living in each one, and the chickens spend their entire lives in these confined conditions.

As a consequence of their living conditions, the quality of these eggs is considered to be poor.



Moving on, he spoke about 'cage-free eggs', which come from chickens that are not kept in battery cages. However, he pointed out that being cage-free does not necessarily mean the hens have access to the outdoors.

Instead, they are confined to a relatively small indoor space. Despite being a step up from conventional eggs, they are only marginally better due to the lack of outdoor access for the chickens.

The next option is 'free-range' eggs. Here, the chickens are given access to the outdoors, and they have around two square feet of space per chicken. This offers better living conditions compared to cage-free eggs since the hens can roam outside.

However, regardless of the type of eggs, all these chickens are typically fed a diet of corn or soy. While this feed is cost-effective, it may not be the best for the birds' health or the overall quality of the eggs they produce.



At the top of the list are 'pasture-raised' eggs, considered the best conditions for chickens. These hens have 10 square metres of space each and are able to eat a natural diet of grass, bugs, and worms.

They also live in more humane conditions. And because of these superior conditions, pasture-raised eggs are considered the healthiest option and are also the most expensive.

While the difference between each label comes down to the quality of diet and living conditions, we must also consider our own financial situation. As McCloskey pointed out: conventional eggs are still a much better option than ultra-processed foods.


If pasture-raised eggs are a financial option for you, they come with a variety of health benefits. According to Piedmont, pasture-raised chickens have more vitamin E and omega-3 fatty acids, which are advantageous from a heart health and overall well-being perspective.

Comments on the post from shoppers have suggested boycotting conventional eggs and grocery store eggs altogether and only getting eggs from local farmers or avid gardeners.

Key Takeaways

  • Nutritionist Craig McCloskey took to Instagram to explain the difference between conventional, cage-free, free-range, and pasture-raised eggs found in supermarkets.
  • He explained that conventional eggs are usually the lowest quality, coming from chickens kept in cramped battery cages.
  • Pasture-raised chickens, on the other hand, are given 108 square feet per chicken and a more natural diet, leading to increased vitamin E and omega-3 fatty acids.
  • McCloskey emphasised that eggs hold good nutritional value irrespective of their source, advising consumers to choose according to their financial, moral, and nutritional needs.



Although pasture-raised chickens are the most humane and offer the best nutrition, there really is no ‘wrong’ choice when it comes to eggs.

At the end of the day, members, choose wisely the next time you’re at the supermarket. Consider the labels on the egg cartons, but also your own financial situation—and don't forget that the eggs we eat contain a great number of vitamins and minerals, regardless of where they come from.

What are your thoughts, folks? Which preferences do you consider when choosing your eggs? Let us know in the comments below!
If chickens are fed soy grain does soy show up in the egg. Should those allergic or intolerant to soy be wary
 
It can be overwhelming when we head down to the grocery store and look at the endless selection of eggs.

While organic and free-range eggs are often more expensive, what is the real difference between each type, and why do these price tags continually jump higher and higher?



Recently, a nutritionist took to social media to help us understand the confusion among egg cartons at the supermarket and explain why it’s so important to pay attention to the labels.

So, read on and let’s dig into the truth behind these egg labels together!


View attachment 26409
A nutritionist is taking out the guesswork when it comes to shopping for eggs. Credit: Pexels/Anna Shvets.



Craig McCloskey began his video by talking about the various types of eggs that are commonly available.

He started with what is known as 'conventional eggs'. These eggs are the most affordable option, but they come from chickens that are kept in battery cages. These cages are small and crowded, with typically two to ten birds living in each one, and the chickens spend their entire lives in these confined conditions.

As a consequence of their living conditions, the quality of these eggs is considered to be poor.



Moving on, he spoke about 'cage-free eggs', which come from chickens that are not kept in battery cages. However, he pointed out that being cage-free does not necessarily mean the hens have access to the outdoors.

Instead, they are confined to a relatively small indoor space. Despite being a step up from conventional eggs, they are only marginally better due to the lack of outdoor access for the chickens.

The next option is 'free-range' eggs. Here, the chickens are given access to the outdoors, and they have around two square feet of space per chicken. This offers better living conditions compared to cage-free eggs since the hens can roam outside.

However, regardless of the type of eggs, all these chickens are typically fed a diet of corn or soy. While this feed is cost-effective, it may not be the best for the birds' health or the overall quality of the eggs they produce.



At the top of the list are 'pasture-raised' eggs, considered the best conditions for chickens. These hens have 10 square metres of space each and are able to eat a natural diet of grass, bugs, and worms.

They also live in more humane conditions. And because of these superior conditions, pasture-raised eggs are considered the healthiest option and are also the most expensive.

While the difference between each label comes down to the quality of diet and living conditions, we must also consider our own financial situation. As McCloskey pointed out: conventional eggs are still a much better option than ultra-processed foods.


If pasture-raised eggs are a financial option for you, they come with a variety of health benefits. According to Piedmont, pasture-raised chickens have more vitamin E and omega-3 fatty acids, which are advantageous from a heart health and overall well-being perspective.

Comments on the post from shoppers have suggested boycotting conventional eggs and grocery store eggs altogether and only getting eggs from local farmers or avid gardeners.

Key Takeaways

  • Nutritionist Craig McCloskey took to Instagram to explain the difference between conventional, cage-free, free-range, and pasture-raised eggs found in supermarkets.
  • He explained that conventional eggs are usually the lowest quality, coming from chickens kept in cramped battery cages.
  • Pasture-raised chickens, on the other hand, are given 108 square feet per chicken and a more natural diet, leading to increased vitamin E and omega-3 fatty acids.
  • McCloskey emphasised that eggs hold good nutritional value irrespective of their source, advising consumers to choose according to their financial, moral, and nutritional needs.



Although pasture-raised chickens are the most humane and offer the best nutrition, there really is no ‘wrong’ choice when it comes to eggs.

At the end of the day, members, choose wisely the next time you’re at the supermarket. Consider the labels on the egg cartons, but also your own financial situation—and don't forget that the eggs we eat contain a great number of vitamins and minerals, regardless of where they come from.

What are your thoughts, folks? Which preferences do you consider when choosing your eggs? Let us know in the comments below!
a tad of information. an egg is laid, if the rooster has done its job it will hold a chicken. when the chicken is born it becomes a chicken, this chicken grows into a pullet then a hen, pullets lay eggs as do HENS. CHICKENS do not lay eggs. an egg is an egg does not matter where it lays the egg. Honestly this subject gives me the shits. GET IT CORRECT.
 
a tad of information. an egg is laid, if the rooster has done its job it will hold a chicken. when the chicken is born it becomes a chicken, this chicken grows into a pullet then a hen, pullets lay eggs as do HENS. CHICKENS do not lay eggs. an egg is an egg does not matter where it lays the egg. Honestly this subject gives me the shits. GET IT CORRECT.
I fully agree. I keep telling people that chickens are baby hens, and that chickens don’t lay eggs. 🤣👏
 
  • Like
Reactions: mylittletibbies
I grew up with lots of animals around us. So, before the labels came into being, we had hens that were in a big chook pen but not caged. They consumed wheat and all the veggie scraps that came out of our home. One of my favourite jobs as a child was to go down the back calling chookie, chookie, veggies. They came running.
The eggs were amazing. The consistency of the white and the colour of the yolk cannot be compared to anything I see today.
Today, I wish I had a home where I could maintain a chook pen, but not to be.
So, at the supermarket I have a choice. Pay $7-$8 for free range, or if they are not available, concede defeat and make do with the cage free.
I saw a carton of eggs the other day selling for $12. This would most likely be the pasture raised that was spoken about, or, each hen as it's own room with an en-suite.
We simply cannot afford so much for eggs. Actually, it is a stretch even for the $7, but hubby needs eggs in his diet whilst he is on cancer treatment. So, I do without some things to pay for others.
It saddens me that we have to pay more to eat healthy, or considerate of animal care. The only reason I don't buy organic produce is the price. Just too much.
I see the egg industry suffering because of this trend. There must be an answer, like government subsidies.
 
If chickens are fed soy grain does soy show up in the egg. Should those allergic or intolerant to soy be wary
No more than say pork would show up in your body! Once ingested, all food is processed to its microelements and then either absorbed or eliminated. It doesn't matter if that amino acid comes from soy or a steak, it is still an amino acid and will be used as such. So no, people sensitive to soy would not need to avoid eggs.
 
  • Like
Reactions: pymmie
Costco has the best price for free range eggs, however, they come in trays of 30 eggs. Broken down, a dozen of those eggs cost the same as a dozen caged eggs at Aldi.
 
I eat an egg every day for breakfast on a slice of toast; that sustains me until lunchtime. I don’t have anything until lunch about 12-12:30. Then nothing until a cup of coffee about 4 and my night meal about 6:30. Go to bed at 10-10:30 and nothing til next breakfast. So I am eating 7 eggs a week & they are only the cage eggs as the cost for my consumption alone would be prohibitive, then add in my husband’s 4 a week.
 
I buy cost effective eggs. preferably 800gr, as we prefer the larger size egg. I pay between $5.50 to $6.80 for a dozen of this size.
 
It can be overwhelming when we head down to the grocery store and look at the endless selection of eggs.

While organic and free-range eggs are often more expensive, what is the real difference between each type, and why do these price tags continually jump higher and higher?



Recently, a nutritionist took to social media to help us understand the confusion among egg cartons at the supermarket and explain why it’s so important to pay attention to the labels.

So, read on and let’s dig into the truth behind these egg labels together!


View attachment 26409
A nutritionist is taking out the guesswork when it comes to shopping for eggs. Credit: Pexels/Anna Shvets.



Craig McCloskey began his video by talking about the various types of eggs that are commonly available.

He started with what is known as 'conventional eggs'. These eggs are the most affordable option, but they come from chickens that are kept in battery cages. These cages are small and crowded, with typically two to ten birds living in each one, and the chickens spend their entire lives in these confined conditions.

As a consequence of their living conditions, the quality of these eggs is considered to be poor.



Moving on, he spoke about 'cage-free eggs', which come from chickens that are not kept in battery cages. However, he pointed out that being cage-free does not necessarily mean the hens have access to the outdoors.

Instead, they are confined to a relatively small indoor space. Despite being a step up from conventional eggs, they are only marginally better due to the lack of outdoor access for the chickens.

The next option is 'free-range' eggs. Here, the chickens are given access to the outdoors, and they have around two square feet of space per chicken. This offers better living conditions compared to cage-free eggs since the hens can roam outside.

However, regardless of the type of eggs, all these chickens are typically fed a diet of corn or soy. While this feed is cost-effective, it may not be the best for the birds' health or the overall quality of the eggs they produce.



At the top of the list are 'pasture-raised' eggs, considered the best conditions for chickens. These hens have 10 square metres of space each and are able to eat a natural diet of grass, bugs, and worms.

They also live in more humane conditions. And because of these superior conditions, pasture-raised eggs are considered the healthiest option and are also the most expensive.

While the difference between each label comes down to the quality of diet and living conditions, we must also consider our own financial situation. As McCloskey pointed out: conventional eggs are still a much better option than ultra-processed foods.


If pasture-raised eggs are a financial option for you, they come with a variety of health benefits. According to Piedmont, pasture-raised chickens have more vitamin E and omega-3 fatty acids, which are advantageous from a heart health and overall well-being perspective.

Comments on the post from shoppers have suggested boycotting conventional eggs and grocery store eggs altogether and only getting eggs from local farmers or avid gardeners.

Key Takeaways

  • Nutritionist Craig McCloskey took to Instagram to explain the difference between conventional, cage-free, free-range, and pasture-raised eggs found in supermarkets.
  • He explained that conventional eggs are usually the lowest quality, coming from chickens kept in cramped battery cages.
  • Pasture-raised chickens, on the other hand, are given 108 square feet per chicken and a more natural diet, leading to increased vitamin E and omega-3 fatty acids.
  • McCloskey emphasised that eggs hold good nutritional value irrespective of their source, advising consumers to choose according to their financial, moral, and nutritional needs.



Although pasture-raised chickens are the most humane and offer the best nutrition, there really is no ‘wrong’ choice when it comes to eggs.

At the end of the day, members, choose wisely the next time you’re at the supermarket. Consider the labels on the egg cartons, but also your own financial situation—and don't forget that the eggs we eat contain a great number of vitamins and minerals, regardless of where they come from.

What are your thoughts, folks? Which preferences do you consider when choosing your eggs? Let us know in the comments below!
Still might be getting more chooks once I clean up the back yard and then there will be no weeds as well as the fresh Healthy eggs
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Defiant540
I honestly don’t know why people need to use abuse or vulgar language to express their frustration with what is written here. Express your thoughts in a more reasonable and cultured way or even use asterisks to express what you wish to say. It seems like this country and so many of its citizens are foul-mouthed because they are frustrated. CHILL OUT it’s better for your health and well being in the end.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Loubeauxarts

Join the conversation

News, deals, games, and bargains for Aussies over 60. From everyday expenses like groceries and eating out, to electronics, fashion and travel, the club is all about helping you make your money go further.

Seniors Discount Club

The SDC searches for the best deals, discounts, and bargains for Aussies over 60. From everyday expenses like groceries and eating out, to electronics, fashion and travel, the club is all about helping you make your money go further.
  1. New members
  2. Jokes & fun
  3. Photography
  4. Nostalgia / Yesterday's Australia
  5. Food and Lifestyle
  6. Money Saving Hacks
  7. Offtopic / Everything else

Latest Articles

  • We believe that retirement should be a time to relax and enjoy life, not worry about money. That's why we're here to help our members make the most of their retirement years. If you're over 60 and looking for ways to save money, connect with others, and have a laugh, we’d love to have you aboard.
  • Advertise with us

User Menu

Enjoyed Reading our Story?

  • Share this forum to your loved ones.
Change Weather Postcode×
Change Petrol Postcode×