Man with delusional disorder declared fit for trial after allegedly shooting his mother
- Replies 1
In an unexpected twist, a man accused of shooting his elderly mother in Australia has been declared fit to stand trial, despite previously being considered unfit due to his delusional disorder.
Paul Cohrs, a former deputy mayor of Wentworth Shire Council, now finds himself facing a Supreme Court trial for the alleged murder of his 82-year-old mother, Bette Cohrs.
This incident occurred at her residence in Red Cliffs, Northwest Victoria, back in October 2018. Shockingly, after purportedly committing the heinous act, Mr Cohrs turned the shotgun on himself, but he managed to survive.
In a recent court appearance, Mr Cohrs chose to represent himself, rejecting the offer of a lawyer appointed by Victorian Legal Aid. The court went on to hear from Justice Lesley Taylor, who explained that two substantive hearings, six months apart, were held to assess Cohrs' capacity to stand trial.
Justice Taylor reminded Mr Cohrs that the 12-month period provided by legislation to allow a defendant to recover sufficiently to stand trial was nearing its end: 'That's the 12 months we're at now, and the period expires in two days' time.'
It was a year ago when Justice Taylor ruled that Mr Cohrs was unfit to face a regular trial due to his delusional disorder. A report from psychiatrist Dr Maria Triglia revealed that his mental state severely impacted his ability to understand certain aspects of the trial.
However, the court was informed that two recent psychiatric assessments found that, while Mr Cohrs still exhibited signs of the disorder, it had weakened enough for him to comprehend the trial proceedings.
Mr Cohrs acknowledged and accepted the assessments provided by the psychiatrists, effectively waiving the need for any further evidence.
This unexpected turn prompted Justice Taylor to firmly declare that Mr Cohrs would face trial without any further delay.
Mr Cohrs has also requested to remain at Thomas Embling Hospital in Melbourne until the trial commences next year, citing the need for access to phones and computers to prepare his case. The hospital environment is also reportedly where he feels 'comfortable' and 'respected’.
Dr Triglia had previously testified that the accused suffered from persecutory delusions and held fixed false beliefs of being the target of a conspiracy.
The doctor had suggested antipsychotic medication for Mr Cohrs, but he refused to take any medication, voicing concerns about unwarranted medical treatment.
This recent development in the case serves as a crucial reminder for all of us to watch out for one another and ensure everyone's safety.
Members, we invite you to share your perspectives and opinions on the compelling case of Paul Cohrs. How do you personally feel about the recent ruling that he is fit for trial, despite his diagnosed delusional disorder? We value your insights on this situation.
Paul Cohrs, a former deputy mayor of Wentworth Shire Council, now finds himself facing a Supreme Court trial for the alleged murder of his 82-year-old mother, Bette Cohrs.
This incident occurred at her residence in Red Cliffs, Northwest Victoria, back in October 2018. Shockingly, after purportedly committing the heinous act, Mr Cohrs turned the shotgun on himself, but he managed to survive.
In a recent court appearance, Mr Cohrs chose to represent himself, rejecting the offer of a lawyer appointed by Victorian Legal Aid. The court went on to hear from Justice Lesley Taylor, who explained that two substantive hearings, six months apart, were held to assess Cohrs' capacity to stand trial.
Tragically, in 2018, Bette Cohrs-Schulz met her untimely demise at Red Cliffs. Now, her son has been accused of the devastating act of fatally shooting her. Image by Kindel Media from Pexels
Justice Taylor reminded Mr Cohrs that the 12-month period provided by legislation to allow a defendant to recover sufficiently to stand trial was nearing its end: 'That's the 12 months we're at now, and the period expires in two days' time.'
It was a year ago when Justice Taylor ruled that Mr Cohrs was unfit to face a regular trial due to his delusional disorder. A report from psychiatrist Dr Maria Triglia revealed that his mental state severely impacted his ability to understand certain aspects of the trial.
However, the court was informed that two recent psychiatric assessments found that, while Mr Cohrs still exhibited signs of the disorder, it had weakened enough for him to comprehend the trial proceedings.
Mr Cohrs acknowledged and accepted the assessments provided by the psychiatrists, effectively waiving the need for any further evidence.
This unexpected turn prompted Justice Taylor to firmly declare that Mr Cohrs would face trial without any further delay.
Paul Cohrs, the former deputy mayor of Wentworth Shire, took the step of representing himself in court. Image by EKATERINA BOLOVTSOVA from pexels
Mr Cohrs has also requested to remain at Thomas Embling Hospital in Melbourne until the trial commences next year, citing the need for access to phones and computers to prepare his case. The hospital environment is also reportedly where he feels 'comfortable' and 'respected’.
Dr Triglia had previously testified that the accused suffered from persecutory delusions and held fixed false beliefs of being the target of a conspiracy.
The doctor had suggested antipsychotic medication for Mr Cohrs, but he refused to take any medication, voicing concerns about unwarranted medical treatment.
This recent development in the case serves as a crucial reminder for all of us to watch out for one another and ensure everyone's safety.
Members, we invite you to share your perspectives and opinions on the compelling case of Paul Cohrs. How do you personally feel about the recent ruling that he is fit for trial, despite his diagnosed delusional disorder? We value your insights on this situation.
Last edited by a moderator:
.png){kind=icon}
