
Sifting through charity shops can feel like a treasure hunt, but for some Aussies it has turned into a serious money-making venture.
Imagine spotting an ordinary item on a shelf, buying it for a few dollars, and selling it almost immediately for hundreds.
That’s exactly what Mat Carpenter experienced during a recent op shop visit.
Mat Carpenter, a professional thrifter and founder of #Flip Weekly—a newsletter and podcast teaching Aussies how to flip undervalued products—recently shared the story of his incredible find.
He had been wandering around a Savers store when a unique-looking mug caught his eye, priced at $7.49.
Mat explained that he had been on the lookout for anything that combined alcohol and pottery, having heard that pottery mugs made by Australia's oldest rum distillery, Beenleigh Rum, in the 1950s were highly sought after by collectors.
The brown ceramic jug depicted the caricatured face of ‘Bosun Bill’.
According to Beenleigh Artisan Distillers, the character came from the legend of 'The Bosun', who operated a floating sugar mill along the Albert and Logan Rivers.
‘He soon found a productive use for the excess molasses he produced- making Rum on the sly,’ the distillery's website stated.
When the floating sugar mill, the SS Walrus, washed ashore in 1984 on the distillery’s land, all that was found was the Bosun’s Copper Pot, inspiring the creation of the collectible mugs.
The mugs were made as memorabilia for the rum brand and now sell for top dollar online.
‘Fancy paying $500 for a rum jug that doesn't contain any rum.’
Mat shared advice for anyone hoping to turn op shop finds into cash, stressing that the key was knowing exactly what to look for.
Source: TikTok/flipweekly
The Sydneysider previously revealed that he earns $4,000 a month flipping items such as books, toys, DVDs, CDs and collectible clothing, and shares tips in his weekly newsletter.
‘My background is finding unusual ways to make money,’ he said.
‘There's nothing more unusual than picking up a mug in a thrift store for $7.50 and selling it 30 minutes later for $500.’
Did you know?
Charity Shop Clothing Fate Of clothes donated to charity shops, only 16.5 per cent are sold in stores, while 36 per cent is recycled domestically, 33 per cent is exported, and 14 per cent ends up in landfill.
Mat also keeps an eye out for overpriced items, recently highlighting a Vinnies store listing relatively common books for $500 and $1,000 as rare first editions.
After the media contacted the St Vincent de Paul Society, the charity shop confirmed the books were pulled from the shelves and admitted the pricing was an error.
Other Aussies have also struck gold in op shops.
Last year, one Queensland thrifter discovered a $2 pair of opal earrings that could be worth up to $1,000.
Another man, Tom, purchased a Seiko watch for less than the cost of a meal, only to realise the dial read ‘Australian Bureau of Statistics’, a detail that made the watch highly collectible.
After receiving multiple offers, Tom sold the watch on eBay for over $500.
What This Means For You
Mat Carpenter’s incredible $500 op shop find shows that hidden treasures can be lurking in the most unexpected places, waiting for someone with a keen eye and a little know-how to uncover them.
The mug he purchased for $7.49, depicting ‘Bosun Bill’ and tied to Beenleigh Rum memorabilia, turned into a quick profit within 30 minutes, proving that flipping op shop items can be surprisingly lucrative. Other Aussies have had similar luck, finding valuable opal earrings or collectible watches for a fraction of their true worth.
For readers, this serves as a reminder that your next visit to a charity shop could hold more than just bargains—it could be an opportunity to discover something unique and profitable for yourself.
Have you ever uncovered a hidden gem in a charity shop that could make someone else’s treasure?
Spirits & Liqueurs - Australia - Beenleigh - EuroVintage — Covers the history of Beenleigh Rum and the story of 'The Bosun' operating a floating sugar mill in Queensland.
https://eurovintage.co.nz/spirits-liqueurs/australia/beenleigh/
About - Beenleigh Rum — Describes the legend of James Stewart, known as 'The Bosun', who used excess molasses to make rum illegally.
https://www.beenleighrum.com.au/about
Beenleigh Rum - The Real Australian Spirit — Highlights that Beenleigh is Australia's oldest registered distillery holding the country’s ‘Number 1’ licence.
https://www.beenleighrum.com.au/
Beenleigh Rum - The Real Australian Spirit — Explains the distillery's origin story beginning in 1884 when an abandoned steamboat washed ashore at Beenleigh, Queensland.
https://www.beenleighrum.com.au/
Beenleigh Rum | eBay Australia — Shows current eBay listings of Bosun Bill mugs ranging from $35 to $850 depending on condition.
https://www.ebay.com.au/shop/beenleigh-rum?_nkw=beenleigh+rum
Shock over $2,000 Vinnies find as op shop defends 'ridiculous' prices — Discusses rising op shop prices and criticism amid the cost of living crisis.
https://au.news.yahoo.com/shock-ove...shop-defends-ridiculous-prices-012028671.html
Vinnies Online Op Shops | Shop, Donate & Support Australia — Highlights unique items at op shops, including luxury goods like a $2,000 Balenciaga handbag.
https://vinniesonline.com.au/
Op Shops: Everything You Know About Op Shopping In Australia – SwapUp — Explains the growth of the Australian op shop industry, valued at an estimated $1.4 billion in 2025.
https://swapup.com.au/blogs/journal/all-about-op-shops-in-australia
Beenleigh Rum Bosun Bill Ceramic Bottle | eBay — Features listings of Beenleigh Rum ceramic bottles and other high-value thrift finds like $2 opal earrings.
https://www.ebay.com/itm/175276996614
Op shops have changed drastically - here's why Aussies like me are furious — Discusses low resale rates of donated items and changes in op shop shopping habits over five years.
https://au.news.yahoo.com/op-shops-...hy-aussies-like-me-are-furious-234410908.html