ANZ faces backlash over $56,000 scam loss: Small business owner battle for accountability

In a digital age where convenience and speed often take precedence, the dark underbelly of cybercrime lurks, ready to pounce on the unsuspecting.

This tale is a stark reminder of the perils that can befall even the most seasoned online business operators.

It's a story that has left a small business founder financially devastated and embroiled in a battle with one of Australia's largest banks, ANZ, over who should bear the responsibility for a significant financial loss due to a scam.


Roland Sharman, the founder of Sail Shade World, a company that has flourished internationally over the past 18 years, found himself in a dire situation when he discovered that he had been scammed out of a staggering $56,000.

The scam involved 21 fraudulent credit card transactions in July, which shipped products to Jordan in the Middle East.


1725595557915.png
Small business owners lost $56,000 to credit card fraud. Credit: Shutterstock


To his dismay, the card details used were stolen, resulting in the money being retracted and the goods being lost forever.

As if the financial loss wasn't enough, Mr Sharman's woes were compounded by what he perceives as ANZ's failure to adequately inform him of a critical cybersecurity measure known as 3DSecure.

This protocol, designed to protect merchants and customers from fraudulent transactions, was not on Mr. Sharman's radar, and he claimed that the bank should have informed him of its availability.


The situation took a turn for the worse when ANZ reportedly refused to assist Mr Sharman, placing the onus on him for not utilising 3DSecure and leaving him vulnerable to fraud.

The bank's stance has sparked outrage and a heated debate about the responsibilities of financial institutions in preventing cybercrime.

Mr Sharman, now 80, described the gut-wrenching feeling of seeing the transactions cancelled due to their fraudulent nature.

He expressed frustration with ANZ's response, which seemed to deflect responsibility back onto him as the business owner.

The bank's representative allegedly told him it was not their job to look after his security, a claim that Mr Sharman vehemently disagrees with.


The cost of adding 3DSecure to his processing fee was a mere five cents per transaction, which Mr Sharman stated he would have willingly paid had he been informed about it.

He argued that the increased fees he has paid over the years for supposed enhanced security measures did not deliver when it mattered most.

After unsuccessful attempts to resolve the issue with ANZ representatives, Mr Sharman took his case to the Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA) on 16 August.

His lawyer believes that banks have been pushing the boundaries to profit from online transactions while shirking financial responsibility when their systems allow scams to occur.


To recoup some of his losses and advocate for change, Mr Sharman has launched a GoFundMe campaign.

His goal is not only to recover funds but also to initiate a movement that compels banks to accept responsibility for cybercrimes on their systems and push for legislation that offers customers greater protection.

In response to the allegations, ANZ Worldline Payment Solutions stated that the merchant's gateway provider must enable 3D Secure and that they are not the gateway provider in this case.

They claim to provide information about 3D Secure through various channels and encourage customers to confirm its availability if using a third-party provider.


In other news, ANZ faces sanctions for charging fees to deceased clients' estates, a significant violation of banking regulations.

The Banking Code Compliance Committee conducted an investigation and has publicly called out ANZ for failing to promptly cease these fees or refund them following clients' deaths. Learn more about the issue here.
Key Takeaways

  • A small business owner lost over $56,000 to scammers who used stolen credit card details for fraudulent transactions.
  • Roland Sharman, a businessman, criticised ANZ Bank for not informing him about the 3DSecure cybersecurity measure, which could have prevented the scam.
  • ANZ Bank claimed it is not at fault because the merchant's gateway provider did not enable the security protocol and insists it is not its responsibility to secure the customer’s transactions.
  • Roland Sharman has filed an official complaint with the Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA) and initiated a GoFundMe to recoup losses and push banks to accept greater responsibility for cybersecurity on their systems.
Have you or someone you know been affected by a similar situation? What measures do you take to protect yourself from online scams? Share your experiences and tips in the comments below.
 
Sponsored
4 weeks ago my centrelink pension didn't go into my bank account after a visit to the centrelink office in Capalaba the nice lady who helped me with the problem told me that the my gov app on my phone had been hacked. The person that hacked into something that centrelink themselves put on my phone ( I never use as I dont know what its for) when they helped me set up my reporting through their express app. She arranged for a replacement payment to go into my bank on the folloeing Tuesday and then the punch line" if they can't recover the amount that was hacked from their MY GOV app that they put on my phone I will have to repay back the replacement pension payment. After l told her that its not my fault their app got hacked she said that is the way the system works and its my responsability
 
4 weeks ago my centrelink pension didn't go into my bank account after a visit to the centrelink office in Capalaba the nice lady who helped me with the problem told me that the my gov app on my phone had been hacked. The person that hacked into something that centrelink themselves put on my phone ( I never use as I dont know what its for) when they helped me set up my reporting through their express app. She arranged for a replacement payment to go into my bank on the folloeing Tuesday and then the punch line" if they can't recover the amount that was hacked from their MY GOV app that they put on my phone I will have to repay back the replacement pension payment. After l told her that its not my fault their app got hacked she said that is the way the system works and its my responsability
Disgusting answer! Most businesses don't want responsibility for anything.
Centrelink needs immediate overhauling. And I hate the ANZ. BUT THATS ANOTHER STORY.
 
If you are running a business then it's the owners responsibility to investigate all avenues to protect yourself from fraud. He can't claim that the bank never told him about the 3D security as they could well have but not being taken notice of. Think it's a bit rich that he going the GoFundMe way for his mistake.
 
Disgusting answer! Most businesses don't want responsibility for anything.
Centrelink needs immediate overhauling. And I hate the ANZ. BUT THATS ANOTHER STORY.
This isn't directly a Centerlink issue, it's a MyGov issue. Someone has accessed your MyGov account and changed your banking details with their own to receive your payments. I hope you have changed all your passwords and set up 3 factor authentication.
 
If you are running a business then it's the owners responsibility to investigate all avenues to protect yourself from fraud. He can't claim that the bank never told him about the 3D security as they could well have but not being taken notice of. Think it's a bit rich that he going the GoFundMe way for his mistake.
As a businessman you would have thought he would have had the brains to go into everything and getting on to 'Go fund me ' to compensate him is a cheek.
 
4 weeks ago my centrelink pension didn't go into my bank account after a visit to the centrelink office in Capalaba the nice lady who helped me with the problem told me that the my gov app on my phone had been hacked. The person that hacked into something that centrelink themselves put on my phone ( I never use as I dont know what its for) when they helped me set up my reporting through their express app. She arranged for a replacement payment to go into my bank on the folloeing Tuesday and then the punch line" if they can't recover the amount that was hacked from their MY GOV app that they put on my phone I will have to repay back the replacement pension payment. After l told her that its not my fault their app got hacked she said that is the way the system works and its my responsability
Works in the governments favour obviously 🥵
 
  • Angry
Reactions: Granny*Deb
I've been affected by scams and it isn't pretty. At least my CBA took care of one and MasterCard took care of another. I still lost $900 in another. Don't know which 2 how they got my details and the other was a (hi mum, I lost my phone scam)🥵
I got a "Hi mum lost my phone' rubbish. My 3 adult children were having dinner with us when the message came in. It provided us with some entertainment
 
4 weeks ago my centrelink pension didn't go into my bank account after a visit to the centrelink office in Capalaba the nice lady who helped me with the problem told me that the my gov app on my phone had been hacked. The person that hacked into something that centrelink themselves put on my phone ( I never use as I dont know what its for) when they helped me set up my reporting through their express app. She arranged for a replacement payment to go into my bank on the folloeing Tuesday and then the punch line" if they can't recover the amount that was hacked from their MY GOV app that they put on my phone I will have to repay back the replacement pension payment. After l told her that its not my fault their app got hacked she said that is the way the system works and its my responsability
in other words ...-DO AS YOUR TOLD.......your friendly bank
 

Join the conversation

News, deals, games, and bargains for Aussies over 60. From everyday expenses like groceries and eating out, to electronics, fashion and travel, the club is all about helping you make your money go further.

Seniors Discount Club

The SDC searches for the best deals, discounts, and bargains for Aussies over 60. From everyday expenses like groceries and eating out, to electronics, fashion and travel, the club is all about helping you make your money go further.
  1. New members
  2. Jokes & fun
  3. Photography
  4. Nostalgia / Yesterday's Australia
  5. Food and Lifestyle
  6. Money Saving Hacks
  7. Offtopic / Everything else
  • We believe that retirement should be a time to relax and enjoy life, not worry about money. That's why we're here to help our members make the most of their retirement years. If you're over 60 and looking for ways to save money, connect with others, and have a laugh, we’d love to have you aboard.
  • Advertise with us

User Menu

Enjoyed Reading our Story?

  • Share this forum to your loved ones.
Change Weather Postcode×
Change Petrol Postcode×