A home of half a century, now without light: Senior residents find their home plunged into dispute over ‘murky’ rules

After five decades in the same home, nothing feels quite as jarring as suddenly losing the natural light that once filled your living space.

Yet across Australia, an increasing number of property owners are discovering that their rights to light and outlook aren't as protected as they assumed.

The confusion stems from what legal experts describe as a patchwork of property laws that vary significantly between states and territories, leaving many homeowners—particularly those who've lived in their properties for decades—uncertain about their rights when neighbours build extensions or new developments that block sunlight.

The myth of guaranteed light access

​

Having a bad relationship or dispute with a neighbour can make life very stressful.

No one wants to feel uncomfortable or unsafe in their own home.

Yet many Australians operate under the mistaken belief that they have an automatic 'right to light' similar to what exists in some other countries.

In reality, Australian property law offers limited protection for light access.

Unlike England, where ancient 'rights to light' can prevent certain developments, Australia generally doesn't recognise such rights unless they are explicitly written into property titles or local council planning schemes.

This creates particular challenges for older homeowners who may have enjoyed unobstructed sunlight for decades, only to find their neighbour has every legal right to build a two-storey extension that plunges their kitchen into perpetual shadow.

Why the rules seem so murky

​

The apparent confusion around property and light rights stems from Australia's federal system, where property law falls primarily under state jurisdiction.

What's legal in New South Wales might not be in Victoria, and local council regulations add another layer of complexity.

For instance, the basic urban fence is 1.5 metres high and made of hardwood palings.

Other fence types can be erected if allowed at that location, and neighbours agree on the design and cost beforehand. Still, these standards vary between councils and states, creating genuine confusion for property owners.

Recent legislative changes have added to the complexity of the issue. It was 2017, and we are now in 2025, since significant retirement village regulations in Victoria have undergone new amendments, with debate still ongoing regarding dispute resolution processes and resident rights.

The real impact on seniors

​

For senior Aussies, these disputes can be particularly distressing.

After decades of establishing routines around natural light patterns—perhaps reading the morning paper by a sunny window or tending plants in a well-lit kitchen—sudden changes can affect both physical and mental well-being.

The financial implications are equally concerning. Properties that lose significant natural light often experience decreased market values, which can be devastating for seniors planning to downsize or access equity for aged care costs.

Taking action: Your options for resolution

​

When you have a dispute with your neighbour, the last thing you should do is rush to court.

The most effective way of working out a solution is to talk to each other, with the aim of coming to an arrangement that suits you both.

The first step should always be direct communication. Many disputes arise from misunderstandings about building plans or timelines, and a friendly conversation may reveal solutions, such as slightly repositioning structures or adding windows to maintain light flow.

If direct discussion doesn't work, the next step is to try to resolve the dispute through community mediation. Services such as Uniting Communities Mediation Service offer free mediation to eligible people.

Understanding your council's planning rules

​

Before any dispute escalates, it's worth understanding your local council's planning schemes.

Many councils have specific rules about setback requirements, maximum building heights in residential areas, overshadowing regulations for neighbouring properties, and private open space requirements.

When prevention isn't enough

​

Sometimes disputes can't be avoided, particularly when new neighbours purchase properties with different development intentions. In these cases, understanding the formal complaint processes becomes crucial.

Alternative dispute resolution offers processes that are alternatives to having a decision made by a judge or magistrate in court. These services are generally faster, cheaper, and less adversarial than court proceedings.

For retirement village residents, recent legislative changes in some states have improved dispute resolution pathways. At the time, a recommendation was put forward to regulate the sector more effectively and enhance innovation, growth, and consumer protection.

The importance of early intervention

​

Many property disputes escalate unnecessarily because initial warning signs are ignored.

If your neighbour mentions building plans or you notice development application signs appearing, this is the time to act—not after construction has begun.

Early intervention might involve:

• Requesting to see building plans

• Understanding the timeline for construction

• Negotiating modifications before approval

• Seeking advice about your rights and options

Long-term residents and changing neighbourhoods

​

For seniors who've lived in their homes for decades, the changing character of neighbourhoods can be particularly challenging.

Areas that were once filled with single-storey homes may gradually transition to higher-density housing, fundamentally altering the light and privacy that long-term residents have enjoyed.

While property owners generally have the right to develop their land within planning constraints, understanding these broader neighbourhood trends can help in making decisions about whether to stay and adapt or consider relocating.

Australia's property laws around light access may seem murky and inconsistent, but understanding your options and acting early can make all the difference in resolving disputes.

Remember that maintaining good neighbourly relationships often provides the best protection for your property enjoyment—something that's particularly valuable when you're planning to stay in your home for years to come.

Have you experienced a dispute with neighbours over building developments? What strategies worked best for resolution? Share your experiences in the comments below—your insights could help other readers navigate similar challenges.