SDC Rewards Member Upgrade yours now
The Conversation

The Conversation

Moderator
Staff member
Jun 15, 2022
1,024
2,013
113
3 In 4 People Want To Ride A Bike But Are Put Off By Lack Of Safe Lanes

Cycling is healthy and sustainable, but only 1.7% of trips in Melbourne are made by bike. Car use has soared since lockdowns were lifted.

We surveyed over 4,000 Victorians and found more than three-quarters are interested in riding a bike, but only in infrastructure that separates people from cars (such as off-road paths or protected bike lanes).

This proportion is far higher than previously thought, highlighting a huge opportunity to increase bike-riding rates by building separated bike lanes.

Our study, published in the Journal of Transport and Health, found high levels of interest in bike riding in groups with traditionally lower participation, including women and people living in outer-urban fringe areas.



However, these areas tend to have less access to safe, protective and supportive infrastructure than their higher socioeconomic counterparts.

Screen Shot 2022-09-26 at 18.26.21.png
Cycling is healthy and sustainable, but only 1.7% of trips in Melbourne are made by bike. TRACEY NEARMY/AAP

Infrastructure is key​

Previous research has shown that how unsafe someone feels when riding a bicycle – particularly in the presence of motor vehicle traffic – is the key barrier to cycling.

Too much existing bike infrastructure is simply a strip of white paint; 99% of existing on-ride bike infrastructure in Melbourne is made up of painted bike lanes, which result in closer motor vehicle passes and do not protect cyclists from potential injury.



Providing high quality, connected and protected bike lanes or paths that separate people on bikes from motor vehicle traffic would greatly increase cycling rates in Melbourne.

Screen Shot 2022-09-26 at 18.27.06.png
Many people are interested in riding, but only in paths separate from cars. DAN PELED/AAP Image

Bike infrastructure must work for women, as well as men​

For every woman that rides a bike in Melbourne, there are two men doing the same.

Despite lower participation, our study showed two-thirds of women are interested in riding a bike, and over half own a bike. Research suggests women are more likely than men to feel vulnerable to harassment by drivers when riding, may need more storage space than a bike usually provides, and may have more care-giving responsibilities than men. Differing perceptions of risk are also a factor.

Women have different infrastructure preferences to men, with a high preference for bike paths or lanes physically separated from motor vehicle traffic.

Taken together, these factors contribute to a pattern where many city bike paths and lanes are designed for the needs and confidence levels of male cyclists.



Common to many cities in Australia and around the world is what’s known as the “radial planning fallacy”, where transport systems are designed to optimise trips from outer-urban areas to city centres or businesses – rather than to facilitate local trips.

The majority of protected bike paths or lanes in Melbourne are radial in design, with a lack of connectivity between existing paths.

This kind of planning does not support the needs of many actual or aspiring cyclists, particularly women who tend to have more varied trips around places such as school, local shops and other locations close to home.

Screen Shot 2022-09-26 at 18.27.45.png
We must plan bike infrastructure that supports the needs of women, as well as men. Shutterstock

Outer suburbs are losing out​

Despite lower participation, we found that interest in bike riding is high in the outer urban fringe areas of Melbourne.

These areas also have the lowest level of access to safe and comfortable bike infrastructure.

People who are inexperienced or new to bike riding prefer bike paths or lanes that are physically separated from motor vehicle traffic.



But a lack of infrastructure dedicated to active transport, coupled with longer distances to essential services, means people living in outer-suburbs are often required to drive long distances.

Screen Shot 2022-09-26 at 18.28.23.png
Too much existing bike infrastructure is simply a strip of white paint. CHRISTOPHER SAMUEL/AAP

To address these health and transport inequities, it’s essential we plan and build protected and connected bike infrastructure across Melbourne, including new urban growth areas.



As well as boosting health outcomes, optimising social connection and reducing transport inequities, this would also contribute toward meeting Australia’s net-zero emissions targets.

This article was first published on The Conversation, and was written by Lauren Pearson PhD Candidate from Monash University, Ben Beck Senior Research Fellow, School of Public Health and Preventive Medicine from Monash University
 
I used to love riding bikes but sadly nolonger able to .

A couple if my daughters go on bike rides but is a little unnerving with cars and their careless drivers.

Two of my sons ride motor bikes and that is also really nerve racking with a friend losing her son in a bike accident 1 year ago yesterday . He was just 35
 
  • Like
Reactions: Gaena and Ricci
We have e-bikes and live in a rual city in QLD. We avoid any main roads and highways. There is no designated bike lanes on any of the roads, some roads are not even fit for car use, many are narrow. We try and use the footpaths as much as possible however many of these are designed for pedestrian use and not wide enough for bikes to overtake pedestrians or persons on mobility vehicles safely. we always give way to other by leaving the path however some areas either side of these paths are sloped, rocky and not suitable for bikes. Our city has a river that we need to cross in order to access the CBD. There are only two bridges that span the river and only one has a very narrow pedestrian walkway. Bicycle handbars just clear both sides of the railing. Only those with a death wish use the other bridge which has no pedestrian path. Our council has announce that a pedestian/cycle bridge is planned for the future however where they propose to locate is not supported by connecting pathways. We sit and wait and hope the council gets it right.
 
I’ve often thought I’d like to go for a bike ride with friends but they don’t make training wheels for those of us who have never learnt how. Did see some great tricycles for adults, price completely prohibitive. At 69 maybe I might feel a bit foolish. So maybe I’ll just admit it’s one of things better thought about and not actually carried out
 
I’ve often thought I’d like to go for a bike ride with friends but they don’t make training wheels for those of us who have never learnt how. Did see some great tricycles for adults, price completely prohibitive. At 69 maybe I might feel a bit foolish. So maybe I’ll just admit it’s one of things better thought about and not actually carried out
My husband is 65 and wants a motor bike which he has never ridden just because he is inove with my sons Harley
 
  • Like
Reactions: Gaena and Ricci
I used to ride a motor scooter but it got far too scary. I chose to have a bright yellow scooter but I was still invisible to a lot of car drivers and I had more than my fair share of close calls. When my daughter bought a motorbike I nearly died of fright and I did get the inevitable phone call to say she was in hospital, luckily it wasn't too bad and she gave up riding after that. My son has a push bike that he rides with his mates around Melbourne but he says it's getting more and more difficult to plan a safe-ish route. :(
 
I'm an avid bike rider BUT in Tasmania where they have bike lanes on the road the arrogant lycra clad imbeciles seem to think they don't have to ride in them and ride on the road, they are sooooo precious they have all sorts of excuses like there are stones that MIGHT hurt my tyres, or dirt or anything they want to come up with. Yes some car drivers are Aholes and refuse to give the distance they are suppose to, or they don't care what part of a road they are on they will just pull out and over take you with cars coming the other way, so my problem is looking for a place I can jump off my bike and wait for the crash. I have had cars pass me around BLIND bends and going up a hill where you can't see if any car is just about to come over the crest. In short both CAR and BIKE riders have a LOT to learn about road LAWS for a start and etiquette.
 
I used to ride a motor scooter but it got far too scary. I chose to have a bright yellow scooter but I was still invisible to a lot of car drivers and I had more than my fair share of close calls. When my daughter bought a motorbike I nearly died of fright and I did get the inevitable phone call to say she was in hospital, luckily it wasn't too bad and she gave up riding after that. My son has a push bike that he rides with his mates around Melbourne but he says it's getting more and more difficult to plan a safe-ish route. :(
My daughter who is 29 was on the back of a bike when she was 19 and her injuries were bad but not near as bad as the rider . She spent 3 days in hospital with shoulder injuries, bruises and slight concussion. The rider spent 3 months in hospital and many more months in rehabilitation. A car sped through a red light in Brighton on the main road and smashed into them. She has bever been on a motor bike since and her fiance often rides his bike from sydney to work in Wollongong. She has and never will go on the back of his bike.
She hates that two of her brothers have bikes including my eldest son who rides a Harley .
We all went to the funeral of a close friends son who was tragically killed riding his bike a year ago yesterday
 
  • Like
Reactions: Gaena
I'm an avid bike rider BUT in Tasmania where they have bike lanes on the road the arrogant lycra clad imbeciles seem to think they don't have to ride in them and ride on the road, they are sooooo precious they have all sorts of excuses like there are stones that MIGHT hurt my tyres, or dirt or anything they want to come up with. Yes some car drivers are Aholes and refuse to give the distance they are suppose to, or they don't care what part of a road they are on they will just pull out and over take you with cars coming the other way, so my problem is looking for a place I can jump off my bike and wait for the crash. I have had cars pass me around BLIND bends and going up a hill where you can't see if any car is just about to come over the crest. In short both CAR and BIKE riders have a LOT to learn about road LAWS for a start and etiquette.
Where we used to live there was a perfectly good bike track which many used but the Lycra brigade had bikes not made for these tracks. Well I recon if your bike is too expensive and not made for the bike tracks well they should have to pay registration like other that have to use the roads.
 
  • Like
Reactions: terri
I love bike riding , born and bred in a country town in The Netherlands .
We had mainly bikeways and usually divided from the road . From 5 yrs old I had to ride my bike to school together with my older brother and two kids from the neighbours across the road . This was about 5km as we lived on a farm. Had to ride back for lunch , so that was about 20 km a day.Nowadays I like to do trail biking and gives you so much pleasure , apart from when it is magpie season.
Years ago my husband rode his bike on a country road and a lot of people did not like bike riders and he got thrown with a watermelon , fell of his bike , injured himself . They did not care if he was alright . No more road biking . These days there are more bike ways , which is a lot safer.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Joannes and EJMHK
Arthritis in my knees is what stopped me from riding my bike bout 10yrs ago, prior to that I rode everywhere, now I walk instead.
 
I love bike riding , born and bred in a country town in The Netherlands .
We had mainly bikeways and usually divided from the road . From 5 yrs old I had to ride my bike to school together with my older brother and two kids from the neighbours across the road . This was about 5km as we lived on a farm. Had to ride back for lunch , so that was about 20 km a day.Nowadays I like to do trail biking and gives you so much pleasure , apart from when it is magpie season.
Years ago my husband rode his bike on a country road and a lot of people did not like bike riders and he got thrown with a watermelon , fell of his bike , injured himself . They did not care if he was alright . No more road biking . These days there are more bike ways , which is a lot safer.
Australia should look to the Netherlands on how to structure safe bike paths and how bike riders are treated. They have a wonderful system.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Joannes
Australia should look to the Netherlands on how to structure safe bike paths and how bike riders are treated. They have a wonderful system.
Amsterdam, what a dangerous place to be especially if you are NOT on a bike, the riders there are RUDE and BULLIES, they will not stop at crossings you have to run across bike paths when there is a gap in cyclists. Have been there and am talking from experience.
 
  • Sad
Reactions: Joannes
Bring in one seat tricycles with three wheels with a tray at the back like children's tricycles and a place for a walking stick to lock into like the a tyre pump but on the other side and shopping trolleys with four wheels to instead of trying to drag the shopping trolley behind you, the shopping trolley is pushed ahead of you. The four wheeled shopping trolley better if you use a walking stick as I do. 1680933139744.png There are 4 wheel shopping trolley from China, but looks too cheap. 1680933072419.png
 
Amsterdam, what a dangerous place to be especially if you are NOT on a bike, the riders there are RUDE and BULLIES, they will not stop at crossings you have to run across bike paths when there is a gap in cyclists. Have been there and am talking from experience.
Bike paths are for cyclists not pedestrians who have their own path and there are designated crossings for pedestrians on the bike paths. Its like crossing a road, you dont expect the cars to stop for you unless it is a designated crossing, Zebra or traffic lights.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Joannes
Amsterdam, what a dangerous place to be especially if you are NOT on a bike, the riders there are RUDE and BULLIES, they will not stop at crossings you have to run across bike paths when there is a gap in cyclists. Have been there and am talking from experience.
Yes they are rude. Get off the bike path! They are not for pedestrians. I have lived in the Netherlands for 40 years - but am also Aussie all the way! Learn and understand the rules. When in Amsterdam do as they do.. So that cycling stays safe.
 
Bike paths are for cyclists not pedestrians who have their own path and there are designated crossings for pedestrians on the bike paths. Its like crossing a road, you dont expect the cars to stop for you unless it is a designated crossing, Zebra or traffic lights.
You obviously did not read the bit where I said at CROSSINGS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
 
The crossings are also segregated. Stay off the red patches!
As I said from experience it is a bad place and I'm not alone in this lots of people I know felt the same cyclist world wide think they are entitled. And I am able to read and followed where I was suppose to stand to get across and they just ignored everyone who wanted to cross until a guy who was fed up with the ignorance of the people just stepped out and they HAD to stop.
 
As I said from experience it is a bad place and I'm not alone in this lots of people I know felt the same cyclist world wide think they are entitled. And I am able to read and followed where I was suppose to stand to get across and they just ignored everyone who wanted to cross until a guy who was fed up with the ignorance of the people just stepped out and they HAD to stop.
I had 40 years of experience over there. It took some getting used to - I will admit. Where Dutch pedestrians have right of way they take it. They don't stand still - because if they do cyclists will assume they are being given permission to ride through. So the guy who stepped out finally found out how it is done. And yes, the cyclists are rude and cocky - because they can get away with it. But if you learn to go with the flow - it works.
 

Join the conversation

News, deals, games, and bargains for Aussies over 60. From everyday expenses like groceries and eating out, to electronics, fashion and travel, the club is all about helping you make your money go further.

Seniors Discount Club

The SDC searches for the best deals, discounts, and bargains for Aussies over 60. From everyday expenses like groceries and eating out, to electronics, fashion and travel, the club is all about helping you make your money go further.
  1. New members
  2. Jokes & fun
  3. Photography
  4. Nostalgia / Yesterday's Australia
  5. Food and Lifestyle
  6. Money Saving Hacks
  7. Offtopic / Everything else
  • We believe that retirement should be a time to relax and enjoy life, not worry about money. That's why we're here to help our members make the most of their retirement years. If you're over 60 and looking for ways to save money, connect with others, and have a laugh, we’d love to have you aboard.
  • Advertise with us

User Menu

Enjoyed Reading our Story?

  • Share this forum to your loved ones.
Change Weather Postcode×
Change Petrol Postcode×