New Design
  1. Enable New Design

This mall tragedy sparks urgent calls for safer shopping centre car parks. What happened?

News & Politics

This mall tragedy sparks urgent calls for safer shopping centre car parks. What happened?

Screenshot 2025-09-18 at 10.40.47.png This mall tragedy sparks urgent calls for safer shopping centre car parks. What happened?
A heartbreaking accident at a Sydney shopping centre has left a community in mourning and reignited urgent conversations about the safety of Australia's car parks. Image source: 7NEWS Australia / Youtube.

A heartbreaking accident at a Sydney shopping centre has left a community in mourning and reignited urgent conversations about the safety of Australia's car parks.



What happened is particularly relevant for families with young children and older Australians navigating increasingly crowded spaces.





A five-month-old baby girl died at the scene on Monday afternoon at Minto Mall in Sydney's southwest, despite police commencing CPR on the infant before she was treated by NSW Ambulance paramedics.



Her five-year-old sibling was transported to The Children's Hospital at Westmead in a serious but stable condition.



The tragedy occurred around 3:30pm on Brookfield Road when a 35-year-old driver reportedly reversed her Renault SUV over the two children.



What makes this incident particularly devastating is that the children were reportedly in a pram, and investigators believe the mother was trying to navigate the notoriously narrow parking spaces.



In this article




'A lot of shoppers—there were a few people who were traumatised from seeing it'

Eyewitness account, SBS News



When car parks become danger zones



The incident has thrust Minto Mall's parking facilities into harsh spotlight, with local parents sharing their own frightening experiences navigating what many describe as impossibly narrow spaces.




Tanzin Cook, a local mother-of-two, took to social media to share her own ordeal from 2018, describing having just 20 centimetres to squeeze her children through between cars. 'If you're in an SUV or 4WD, you are f***** beyond measure,' she said bluntly.



Her experience wasn't unique. Cook recalled having to climb through the passenger side to reach the driver's seat so she could reposition her car safely—a manoeuvre many older Australians would find challenging or impossible.







'There was no other way I could have done it,' she explained. 'Based on reports I've read, the mum was in a similar situation. This is a really bad car park and it is not easy to navigate with kids.'




Understanding Australian parking standards


Minto Mall, renovated in 2022, serves over 80 specialty stores in Sydney's southwest and provides free parking for all shoppers 24/7. According to centre management, the car park meets Australian standards for parking bay dimensions, but these standards were developed decades ago when vehicles were smaller and shopping habits were different.




The community responds with calls for change



The tragedy has galvanised the local community, with social media flooded with similar stories from frustrated shoppers. Comments on Cook's video painted a picture of a car park that many residents actively avoid.



'Every time I go here, I have to park away from everyone because of exactly the same issue,' wrote one local mum. Another added: 'I drive a 4WD and I dread going to this car park, it's an absolute nightmare.'









However, the discussion also sparked debate about safety practices. Some commenters pointed out that regardless of tight spaces, children should be loaded into vehicles before shopping, and modern cars come equipped with reverse sensors and cameras.



The death has shocked the Minto community, with witnesses reporting being traumatised after watching the aftermath, and the tragedy raising questions about carpark safety and the vulnerability of young children around vehicles.





Mall management promises improvements



Centre manager Michael Prestia acknowledged the community's concerns while defending the current design. 'In order to acquire DA approvals, the Australian standards for car parking bays needed to be met,' he told Daily Mail.









However, he also committed to future improvements: 'Minto Mall will continue to seek ways of how to improve the Centre's car park in view of access, egress and parking, in the interest of the customers' wellbeing and safety.'



The mall, which underwent major redevelopment three years ago, is already planning further upgrades in the coming months. The centre recently added two electric vehicle charging stations in the South Carpark, showing some commitment to modernising facilities.



What this means for older shoppers



For Australian seniors, this tragedy highlights broader concerns about navigating increasingly challenging retail environments. Modern shopping centres often prioritise maximising parking spaces over user safety and accessibility.










Warning signs of dangerous parking situations



  • Spaces so narrow you can't fully open car doors

  • Having to climb over seats to exit your vehicle

  • Needing to park far from other cars for safety

  • Feeling rushed or stressed while loading/unloading

  • Poor visibility due to large vehicles or structural barriers




The incident also underscores the importance of being extra cautious around car parks, where pedestrians of all ages—but particularly children and older adults with mobility concerns—are vulnerable to serious accidents.



Practical steps for safer shopping trips



While we wait for infrastructure improvements, there are practical steps shoppers can take to protect themselves and their families.



Consider shopping during off-peak hours when car parks are less crowded. If you're driving a larger vehicle, don't hesitate to park further away where spaces are more generous. Always take your time—rushing leads to mistakes.









For those with grandchildren, the tragedy serves as a stark reminder to maintain constant visual contact with little ones in car parks, one of the most dangerous environments they'll encounter during routine activities.



Did you know?


Did you know?
Car park accidents account for approximately 20 per cent of all vehicle-related incidents in Australia, with most occurring at low speeds during parking manoeuvres. The majority involve pedestrians, making awareness and careful movement crucial for everyone's safety.



Support and investigation continues



NSW Police are continuing their investigation into the incident, though they're treating it as a tragic accident rather than criminal negligence. Authorities are urging anyone with information or dashcam/CCTV footage to contact Crime Stoppers NSW on 1800 333 000.



The broader community has rallied around the affected family, with local federal MP Dr Mike Freelander acknowledging the tragedy on social media and expressing condolences to those impacted.



As the investigation continues, the focus remains on preventing similar tragedies through improved design, better awareness, and a commitment to putting safety before convenience in our shopping centres.



Centre manager Prestia concluded: 'We are most saddened by the tragic incident that occurred on September 15 and wish to send our deepest condolences to the family, relatives and friends of the family on the loss of their beautiful five-month old baby girl.'



What This Means For You


This tragedy reminds us that simple, everyday activities like shopping can present unexpected risks. Have you experienced similar challenges with narrow parking spaces at your local shopping centres? Share your thoughts and any safety tips that have worked for you in the comments below.




Last edited:

Seniors Discount Club

Sponsored content

Info
Loading data . . .
I think this is a good case of where it's a great idea for all cars to back into carparks then it's easy out. Some schools it's compulsory and it is probably for this very reason. I have also watched some people driving the bigger vehicles at schools picking up children and they have no idea how to park them properly so can only imagine the chaos in a busy peak time shopping centre. Don't buy a bug vehicle if you can't handle it properly. You are an absolute menace. Having said that my daughter has an Isuzu mux and I am impressed and amazed how well she manages to park, back in to tricky spots etc.
 
I know this carpark well as my husband worked in the real estate office right in front of where this happened.

Regardless at what carport it is drivers need to be much more careful as do the parents with prams.

I can't say how many parents I see that leave their babies in a pram while they pack away the groceries.
I have told all my children and more than once to put the kids in the car in their seat before anything else.

Parents should never push a pram between cars.

Both drivers and pedestrians need to be more cautious. It's the same as pedestrians even without prams need to beware of cars pulling out or backing out, the same as cars need to look at their surroundings before slowly driving out.

Parents also need to keep their children next to them at all times. I can't say how many children I see running in front of their parent.

I know in this particular case the women thought she was in drive when infact she was in reverse
 
I have noticed that as cars and utes have got bigger the parking spaces size have not changed. These larger vehicles leave little room between cars parked and also you can not see over the larger ones to see any vehicles coming. Reviews into space size needs to happen with a new minimum size to cater for this change. Parking has become a real issue in many places. The other day I was completely parked in for an hour as I had two larger SUVs parked so close to me that I could not get any door open - on one side the car had reversed in and the other front in. Fortunately my mirrors fold inward automatically, otherwise I think I would have lost them - this is how close they both were. It is a very sad situation of what happened at Minto and I feel for the family in this tragic incident.
 
I have noticed that as cars and utes have got bigger the parking spaces size have not changed. These larger vehicles leave little room between cars parked and also you can not see over the larger ones to see any vehicles coming. Reviews into space size needs to happen with a new minimum size to cater for this change. Parking has become a real issue in many places. The other day I was completely parked in for an hour as I had two larger SUVs parked so close to me that I could not get any door open - on one side the car had reversed in and the other front in. Fortunately my mirrors fold inward automatically, otherwise I think I would have lost them - this is how close they both were. It is a very sad situation of what happened at Minto and I feel for the family in this tragic incident.
How did the drivers get out without marking your car. You should not be allowed to hem someone in. I would be going to the information kiosk and having their rego called over the loudspeaker to please go to their car immediately. You could have an urgent appointment and it's not good enough. Consideration would be nice.
 
I am so sorry for the family of the little one who lost her life, I hope the other child is recovering. That poor family will never forgive themselves. So very sad ! Perhaps all shopping centre car parks should be made to make the spaces wider or section off a proportion for SUV’s. 🤷‍♀️something needs to change !
 
Another problem with a very busy car park, is that some drivers are so focussed on getting an available spot, they get distracted and careless.

If you don’t require “disabled” parking, and the car park isn’t too full, it’s better to park further away from the shopping centre entrance, providing it’s not pouring with rain. The extra steps can be a bonus.

My biggest problem is with the oversized vehicles. They can make it very difficult to see even when reverse parked. It seems there are now more oversized vehicles than “normal” vehicles.

There are certain shopping centres I won’t go to because the car parks are so crowded. And there are increasing numbers of drivers who appear not to know even basic understanding of parking and awareness of others.

I used to enjoy driving, but not so much anymore.
 
Some people have oversize - wider cars because you definitely cannot fit 3 baby seats etc on the rear passenger seat. Even in an early model Commodore if you squeeze 3 in they are literally against each other and almost touching the doors. I have personally witnessed that. A friend of ours had to buy a People Mover for that reason and she "hated" it because of parking problems. She always tried to find a carpark on the outer "edge" of the carpark and got very efficient reversing cameras fitted. In some country towns in NSW it is compulsory to "reverse" park.
 
How did the drivers get out without marking your car. You should not be allowed to hem someone in. I would be going to the information kiosk and having their rego called over the loudspeaker to please go to their car immediately. You could have an urgent appointment and it's not good enough. Consideration would be nice.
S/he reversed in.
 

Join the conversation

News, deals, games, and bargains for Aussies over 60. From everyday expenses like groceries and eating out, to electronics, fashion and travel, the club is all about helping you make your money go further.

Seniors Discount Club

The SDC searches for the best deals, discounts, and bargains for Aussies over 60. From everyday expenses like groceries and eating out, to electronics, fashion and travel, the club is all about helping you make your money go further.
  1. New members
  2. Jokes & fun
  3. Photography
  4. Nostalgia / Yesterday's Australia
  5. Food and Lifestyle
  6. Money Saving Hacks
  7. Offtopic / Everything else
  • We believe that retirement should be a time to relax and enjoy life, not worry about money. That's why we're here to help our members make the most of their retirement years. If you're over 60 and looking for ways to save money, connect with others, and have a laugh, we’d love to have you aboard.
  • Advertise with us

User Menu

Enjoyed Reading our Story?

  • Share this forum to your loved ones.
Change Weather Postcode×
Change Petrol Postcode×