Politicians want to tax inheritances again! Shouldn’t retirees have a say first?

A new push for sweeping tax reforms has stirred debate as business, union, and community leaders gathered in Canberra this week.

Among the proposals is the return of an inheritance tax—an idea long abandoned in Australia but now being framed as a way to ease inequality.

Advocates argue the measures could unlock billions for hospitals, schools, and housing without burdening everyday Australians.


The Australia Institute released a report ahead of the government’s landmark economic roundtable, suggesting a package of wealth-focused tax changes could raise $70 billion annually.

Central to its recommendations was a two per cent wealth tax on individuals worth more than $5 million, which the institute claimed could generate $41 billion each year.

Even if family homes and superannuation were excluded, the report said the measure would still deliver $41 billion in revenue.


image1.png
Report calls for $70b in new taxes. Image source: Pexels/Nataliya Vaitkevich
Disclaimer: This is a stock image used for illustrative purposes only and does not depict the actual person, item, or event described.


Australia Institute senior economist Matt Grudnoff explained that restricting the tax to just the nation’s 200 wealthiest households would still raise $12.5 billion annually.

Another proposal was the reintroduction of inheritance taxes, which existed in state and federal forms during the 1960s and 1970s.

The report argued this could deliver $10 billion annually while reducing what it called ‘intergenerational inequality’.

‘A couple of generations ago, Australia had probate and succession duties that raised 0.36 per cent of GDP, which, if reintroduced today, would deliver an extra $10 billion in revenue,’ Grudnoff said.

Critics have long dubbed such measures a ‘death tax’, though the report emphasised that many developed economies—including the US, UK, Japan, and much of Europe—already had similar systems.

‘Australia is a low-tax country that does not do a good job of taxing wealth,’ Grudnoff said.

‘Correcting this would raise huge amounts of extra revenue for essential services and ease growing inequality in Australia.’

AD_4nXfsq5DzcnXy7KrrfPpVNuxWSiQ3jaU6MrzbjwbZhkKtwPpOzIS65devFIDQTyZ-KaMlH0d7WHe3E1G4QB5qeYKm5w-NjVFVZYfmFIDB325nq9tGyai8T0c3hMzLX0Jra0qc_bWSkQ



The report also recommended scrapping the capital gains tax discount, which it said would raise $19 billion annually and help ease property affordability.

Prime Minister Anthony Albanese noted that the roundtable process had considered nearly 900 submissions from experts, industry leaders, and individuals.

‘This process has brought forth a wide range of views on everything from deregulation to tax reform,’ he wrote in an opinion piece.

Treasurer Jim Chalmers, who headed the discussions in Canberra, said the forum had also drawn on more than 40 ministerial consultations held across the country.

‘This healthy public debate has also made it clear there is substantial common ground on many issues—and that is where the immediate opportunities lie,’ Albanese said.


While the debate over inheritance taxes sparks strong opinions, there’s another side to the story that often gets overlooked—what happens when inheritances never reach their intended heirs.

Unclaimed estates are a growing issue, with millions in assets quietly slipping away each year.

It’s a reminder that planning and paperwork can be just as important as policy changes when it comes to protecting a legacy.

Read more: Lost inheritance? Why millions in unclaimed estates end up with the government

Key Takeaways

  • The Australia Institute proposed $70 billion in new tax revenue through wealth-focused reforms.
  • A two per cent wealth tax on fortunes above $5 million was projected to raise $41 billion annually.
  • Inheritance taxes could return, with estimates of $10 billion a year in revenue.
  • Scrapping the capital gains tax discount was suggested to ease housing affordability and add $19 billion.

Would Australia be willing to revive old tax systems in exchange for better schools, hospitals, and housing?
 

Seniors Discount Club

Sponsored content

Info
Loading data . . .
This will eventually filter down to estates worth less than $5million as successive governments will see this as a cash cow in order to bale out their lack of good fiscal policy. Also, property investors will walk away from the rental market and with the current influx of migrants, the housing shortage will only get worse, resulting in supply and demand pressures driving up the rents of those properties that are still available for rental.
Ha ha ha ha ha. So this is bad because of something that might happen in the future.

Nah. Argument by speculation is not even an argument.
 
Ha ha ha ha ha. So this is bad because of something that might happen in the future.

Nah. Argument by speculation is not even an argument.
Oh dear!
 
Ha ha ha ha ha. So this is bad because of something that might happen in the future.

Nah. Argument by speculation is not even an argument.
In Australia, several taxes have started with a specific group before expanding to include more groups over time. Below is an overview of key taxes that fit this pattern, based on historical developments and available information:


1. Income Tax (Federal)


• Initial Implementation: Introduced in 1915 at the federal level to fund Australia’s World War I efforts, income tax initially targeted higher-income individuals and businesses. At the time, it applied to a relatively small group due to high tax-free thresholds and limited income distribution.


• Expansion:


• By 1942, during World War II, the federal government consolidated income tax collection, taking over from state governments to increase revenue. The Pay-As-You-Earn (PAYE) system, introduced in 1942, expanded the tax base to include wage earners in lower income groups by deducting tax directly from salaries, making collection more efficient and broadening the scope to a larger population.


• Over time, the progressive nature of income tax meant more individuals and income groups were taxed as thresholds adjusted and incomes grew. By the 1980s, the top 10% of earners paid 46% of income tax, while the bottom 50% contributed 11%, showing a broader application across income levels.


• The tax base was further expanded in the 1980s with reforms like the introduction of capital gains tax (1985) and fringe benefits tax (1986), which brought additional income sources and non-wage benefits into the tax net.


2. Payroll Tax


• Initial Implementation: Payroll taxes were introduced by the federal government during World War II (1941) as a broad-based, low-rate tax on employers to fund social programs, initially targeting businesses with significant wage bills.


• Expansion:


• In 1971, control of payroll taxes was transferred to state governments, which expanded their application by setting varying rates and thresholds across states. For example, in New South Wales, payroll tax applies to employers with wages exceeding $1,500,000 annually, with rates around 5.5%.


• Grouping provisions were introduced to treat related businesses as a single entity for tax purposes, expanding the tax’s reach to include groups of companies with integrated operations, even if individually they fell below the threshold. This meant smaller entities within a corporate group were taxed collectively if their combined wages exceeded state thresholds.


• Over time, variations in state thresholds and rates (e.g., 4.75% to 6.85%) further broadened the tax’s application to more businesses, including those with interstate operations.


3. Corporate Tax (Consolidation Regime)


• Initial Implementation: The tax consolidation regime, introduced in 2002, initially allowed wholly-owned corporate groups (100% owned by a single Australian resident head company) to be treated as a single entity for income tax purposes, simplifying compliance for large corporations.


• Expansion:


• The regime was expanded to include Multiple Entry Consolidated (MEC) groups, allowing Australian subsidiaries of foreign companies to consolidate, even without a common Australian head company. This broadened the scope to multinational enterprises.


• The “all-in rule” mandates that all 100%-owned resident entities must be included in a consolidated group, expanding the tax’s reach to subsidiaries that might otherwise have been taxed separately.


• Over time, this regime has incorporated more complex rules for tax losses and asset transfers, affecting a wider range of corporate structures, including trusts and partnerships within groups.


4. Goods and Services Tax (GST)


• Initial Implementation: Introduced in 2000, GST was a broad-based 10% consumption tax initially applied to most goods and services, with exemptions for specific sectors like fresh food, health, and education. It primarily targeted businesses with an annual turnover above a specified threshold (initially $50,000).


• Expansion:


• The GST threshold for registration has been adjusted over time (e.g., $75,000 for businesses, $150,000 for non-profits), bringing more businesses into the GST net as economic activity grew.


• The scope of GST was expanded to include digital products and services imported by consumers (effective 2017), targeting overseas suppliers and broadening the tax base to global entities selling to Australian consumers.


• All GST revenue is distributed to states, indirectly expanding its impact on state-level services and affecting a wider range of economic activities.


5. Estate Taxes (Death Duties)


• Initial Implementation: Estate taxes, in the form of probate duties, were first introduced in the early 19th century in New South Wales, targeting property passing by will, primarily affecting wealthier estates due to high exemption thresholds.


• Expansion:


• By 1901, all Australian colonies had adopted estate taxes with progressive rates based on estate value, broadening the tax to more estates as wealth distribution grew.


• Although abolished in 1979 following Queensland’s lead, the tax’s earlier expansion included more estates over time as thresholds were adjusted and more individuals accumulated taxable wealth.


Critical Notes


• Pattern of Expansion: Taxes in Australia often start with a focused group (e.g., high-income earners, large corporations, or specific sectors) to ensure manageability and political acceptance, then expand as governments seek to increase revenue, simplify administration, or address equity. War efforts (WWI and WWII) were significant catalysts for expanding income and payroll taxes.


• Equity and Efficiency: Reforms, especially since the 1980s, have aimed to broaden tax bases (e.g., capital gains, fringe benefits, GST) to improve equity and efficiency, capturing more groups while reducing reliance on narrow tax bases.
 
2% over $5m is peanuts so I'm fully in support. In most countries that do have an inheritance tax, it's much higher than that.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RealityCheck
This isn't about Labor governments. It's about taxing people who can easily afford it.

But you were triggered.
people have the right to put whatever comment they wish to. your comment is not relevant either.
 
In Australia, several taxes have started with a specific group before expanding to include more groups over time. Below is an overview of key taxes that fit this pattern, based on historical developments and available information:


1. Income Tax (Federal)


• Initial Implementation: Introduced in 1915 at the federal level to fund Australia’s World War I efforts, income tax initially targeted higher-income individuals and businesses. At the time, it applied to a relatively small group due to high tax-free thresholds and limited income distribution.


• Expansion:


• By 1942, during World War II, the federal government consolidated income tax collection, taking over from state governments to increase revenue. The Pay-As-You-Earn (PAYE) system, introduced in 1942, expanded the tax base to include wage earners in lower income groups by deducting tax directly from salaries, making collection more efficient and broadening the scope to a larger population.


• Over time, the progressive nature of income tax meant more individuals and income groups were taxed as thresholds adjusted and incomes grew. By the 1980s, the top 10% of earners paid 46% of income tax, while the bottom 50% contributed 11%, showing a broader application across income levels.


• The tax base was further expanded in the 1980s with reforms like the introduction of capital gains tax (1985) and fringe benefits tax (1986), which brought additional income sources and non-wage benefits into the tax net.


2. Payroll Tax


• Initial Implementation: Payroll taxes were introduced by the federal government during World War II (1941) as a broad-based, low-rate tax on employers to fund social programs, initially targeting businesses with significant wage bills.


• Expansion:


• In 1971, control of payroll taxes was transferred to state governments, which expanded their application by setting varying rates and thresholds across states. For example, in New South Wales, payroll tax applies to employers with wages exceeding $1,500,000 annually, with rates around 5.5%.


• Grouping provisions were introduced to treat related businesses as a single entity for tax purposes, expanding the tax’s reach to include groups of companies with integrated operations, even if individually they fell below the threshold. This meant smaller entities within a corporate group were taxed collectively if their combined wages exceeded state thresholds.


• Over time, variations in state thresholds and rates (e.g., 4.75% to 6.85%) further broadened the tax’s application to more businesses, including those with interstate operations.


3. Corporate Tax (Consolidation Regime)


• Initial Implementation: The tax consolidation regime, introduced in 2002, initially allowed wholly-owned corporate groups (100% owned by a single Australian resident head company) to be treated as a single entity for income tax purposes, simplifying compliance for large corporations.


• Expansion:


• The regime was expanded to include Multiple Entry Consolidated (MEC) groups, allowing Australian subsidiaries of foreign companies to consolidate, even without a common Australian head company. This broadened the scope to multinational enterprises.


• The “all-in rule” mandates that all 100%-owned resident entities must be included in a consolidated group, expanding the tax’s reach to subsidiaries that might otherwise have been taxed separately.


• Over time, this regime has incorporated more complex rules for tax losses and asset transfers, affecting a wider range of corporate structures, including trusts and partnerships within groups.


4. Goods and Services Tax (GST)


• Initial Implementation: Introduced in 2000, GST was a broad-based 10% consumption tax initially applied to most goods and services, with exemptions for specific sectors like fresh food, health, and education. It primarily targeted businesses with an annual turnover above a specified threshold (initially $50,000).


• Expansion:


• The GST threshold for registration has been adjusted over time (e.g., $75,000 for businesses, $150,000 for non-profits), bringing more businesses into the GST net as economic activity grew.


• The scope of GST was expanded to include digital products and services imported by consumers (effective 2017), targeting overseas suppliers and broadening the tax base to global entities selling to Australian consumers.


• All GST revenue is distributed to states, indirectly expanding its impact on state-level services and affecting a wider range of economic activities.


5. Estate Taxes (Death Duties)


• Initial Implementation: Estate taxes, in the form of probate duties, were first introduced in the early 19th century in New South Wales, targeting property passing by will, primarily affecting wealthier estates due to high exemption thresholds.


• Expansion:


• By 1901, all Australian colonies had adopted estate taxes with progressive rates based on estate value, broadening the tax to more estates as wealth distribution grew.


• Although abolished in 1979 following Queensland’s lead, the tax’s earlier expansion included more estates over time as thresholds were adjusted and more individuals accumulated taxable wealth.


Critical Notes


• Pattern of Expansion: Taxes in Australia often start with a focused group (e.g., high-income earners, large corporations, or specific sectors) to ensure manageability and political acceptance, then expand as governments seek to increase revenue, simplify administration, or address equity. War efforts (WWI and WWII) were significant catalysts for expanding income and payroll taxes.


• Equity and Efficiency: Reforms, especially since the 1980s, have aimed to broaden tax bases (e.g., capital gains, fringe benefits, GST) to improve equity and efficiency, capturing more groups while reducing reliance on narrow tax bases.
get over yourself.
 
Labor's problem of trying to always "buy people"...!
Well, they can keep being the Johns, but we won't give in to being prostituted!
Give with one hand and take with the other!
i stand with israel and this government has us right in the poo. albo is a communist and in his earlier years sat on the concrete with a mike and spouted out about palestine. He now has the USA and Israel against australia. what a bastard of a person.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mOiOz
I don’t think there can be much left in the sponge to squeeze out… 😤 😤….‘unlock billions for hospitals, schools, and housing without burdening everyday Australians’………..Very cynical…I don’t believe that…😠
 
whatever you have accumulated when you die has ALLREADY BEEN TAXED,it is wrong to tax again just because the taxpayer is dead what's left behind is rightly passed on to next of kin or as directed.......talk about greed!!!
 
NO
 
i stand with israel and this government has us right in the poo. albo is a communist and in his earlier years sat on the concrete with a mike and spouted out about palestine. He now has the USA and Israel against australia. what a bastard of a person.
:mad::mad::mad: That's too kind for him!
 
I fully support an inheritance tax as long as trhe first $300,000 is exempt .
so your saying ...im alright jack........what are you going to say when $300000 isa months pay??
 
i stand with israel and this government has us right in the poo. albo is a communist and in his earlier years sat on the concrete with a mike and spouted out about palestine. He now has the USA and Israel against australia. what a bastard of a person.
He thinks he's spiteing Trump and the Jewish people.... all he is really doing, is F****** up Australia!!!!
 
:mad::mad::mad: That's too kind for him!
my mate down the pub agrees ....but as he says "I always vote labor' and thats what happens ,,yes we get the govt we deserve...its the same for libs too its just thoughtless unthinking votes
 
He thinks he's spiteing Trump and the Jewish people.... all he is really doing, is F****** up Australia!!!!
he's never had a job in his life ....yep he's all for the worker
 
my mate down the pub agrees ....but as he says "I always vote labor' and thats what happens ,,yes we get the govt we deserve...its the same for libs too its just thoughtless unthinking votes
BS... he had to bring in over a hundred thousand refugees and gave them IMMEDIATE CITIZENS... why? So they could vote for him!!!!!!
Now he's increased the chances of Australia, not only becoming an Islamic country, like UK and France, but the reign of terrorism!!!
He needs to be jailed for TREASON, just like Obama - where he got the idea from!!!!!!
 

Join the conversation

News, deals, games, and bargains for Aussies over 60. From everyday expenses like groceries and eating out, to electronics, fashion and travel, the club is all about helping you make your money go further.

Seniors Discount Club

The SDC searches for the best deals, discounts, and bargains for Aussies over 60. From everyday expenses like groceries and eating out, to electronics, fashion and travel, the club is all about helping you make your money go further.
  1. New members
  2. Jokes & fun
  3. Photography
  4. Nostalgia / Yesterday's Australia
  5. Food and Lifestyle
  6. Money Saving Hacks
  7. Offtopic / Everything else
  • We believe that retirement should be a time to relax and enjoy life, not worry about money. That's why we're here to help our members make the most of their retirement years. If you're over 60 and looking for ways to save money, connect with others, and have a laugh, we’d love to have you aboard.
  • Advertise with us

User Menu

Enjoyed Reading our Story?

  • Share this forum to your loved ones.
Change Weather Postcode×
Change Petrol Postcode×