He’s 66, sick, and grieving—now they want to evict him

When long-standing support systems shift behind closed doors, vulnerable Australians are often the ones left in limbo.

One such case has quietly unfolded in Perth, highlighting the human cost of housing decisions made beyond public view.

What’s at stake is far more than just a roof overhead.


When Noongar elder Harvey Coyne was hospitalised yet again, this time following another heart attack, his mind wasn’t just on survival.

It was also on where he’d go once discharged—and whether he’d still have a home to return to.

Sitting up in his bed at Fiona Stanley Hospital in Perth, his voice raw and unsteady, the 66-year-old summed it up plainly: ‘Without it, I’m pretty well buggered.’


image1.png
Hospitalised elder faces eviction while recovering. Image source: Facebook/NITV


Coyne had already been dealt more than his share of hardship. He lived with severe heart disease—requiring a triple bypass surgery—as well as emphysema, hypertension, and blindness in one eye.

Earlier this year, he broke his hip in a fall. On top of it all, he carried the trauma of being removed from his family during the Stolen Generations.

But just as he faced yet another life-threatening medical event, a new fight had landed on his doorstep—this time from his housing provider.

Housing Choices Australia, which managed Coyne’s community housing unit in Kenwick on Perth’s south-eastern outskirts, had moved to evict him.

The no-fault eviction notice—still legal in Western Australia—arrived while Coyne was in hospital, grieving the death of his nephew who had lived with him.


Coyne’s advocates claimed the timing and method of the eviction amounted to cruelty. If successful, they said, it would leave him homeless and force him back onto the streets—something he thought he had left behind in 2021 when he first moved into the property.

The organisation had previously raised concerns around noise, visitors, and cleanliness—claims Coyne rejected. Court filings also revealed he underwent 10 property inspections in a single year, something he said he ‘struggled to address…due to my age and health’.

The case attracted the attention of respected health figures, including Emeritus Professor Fiona Stanley—the former Australian of the Year and namesake of the very hospital where Coyne lay.

In a letter sent to Housing Choices Australia in March, Stanley expressed ‘grave’ concern over the eviction effort, especially in light of Coyne’s need for surgery.

‘This is an extremely serious operation with a number of risks for Mr Coyne. It is imperative that he has stable and secure accommodation in which to prepare for this procedure and then to recover and rehabilitate afterwards,’ she wrote.

‘Mr Coyne’s condition is life-threatening, and it is inconceivable to me that he should face homelessness at this time.’


His case was due to be decided in the Perth magistrates court next week.

Housing Choices Australia said it could not comment on Coyne’s specific situation due to ongoing legal proceedings and privacy obligations.

Its CEO, David Fisher, issued a statement saying the organisation was ‘committed to providing safe, secure, and appropriate housing for all our residents and supporting them to sustain their tenancies’.

He added: ‘As a not-for-profit community housing provider, we operate under the same standards and regulatory requirements as government housing agencies, and we take that responsibility seriously.’

The group also told advocates that it had been working with the state government to find a ‘sustainable housing solution that considers both his immediate and longer-term needs’.

But Coyne’s supporters argued the core issue ran much deeper.


According to housing advocate Jesse Noakes and several academics, Coyne’s struggle reflected a larger, systemic problem. The unit he lived in would once have been public housing, but over time the state shifted thousands of such properties to community housing providers like Housing Choices Australia.

In a briefing paper, human geographer Dr David Kelly from RMIT’s Centre for Urban Research noted that while public housing stock had declined by 7.4 per cent in the past decade, community housing units had risen by 61.4 per cent. That increase was aided in part by generous government subsidies.

Kelly said this trend had ‘redefined both the nature of the tenancy and the rights attached to it’.

‘Tenants like Harvey, had they remained in public housing, would have been afforded stronger on-paper protections against eviction, and subjected to fewer behavioural interventions disguised as support,’ he wrote.

He added that community housing organisations (CHOs) operated under different frameworks and priorities.


Housing Choices Australia was a major player in the sector. As of mid-2024, it owned 3,099 housing units and managed another 4,395. Its reported assets sat at $1.2 billion, with financial records showing about half of its revenue—roughly $33 million—came from government funding.

Publicly, the group stated its vision was for ‘all people in Australia to have a safe, affordable home and the opportunity to thrive’.

But WA Greens MLC Tim Clifford believed Coyne’s ordeal showed how that vision wasn’t always realised in practice.

‘It is clear from Mr Coyne’s case that the choice to outsource public housing to big NGOs means that there is less transparency, less accountability and less access to justice for renters,’ Clifford said.

He described the potential eviction as ‘unconscionable’ given Coyne’s fragile health and life circumstances.

As judgment loomed, Coyne remained in hospital—waiting not only for heart surgery, but for an answer that could decide whether he had a home to heal in afterward.

Key Takeaways
  • Noongar elder Harvey Coyne, facing severe health issues, was served a no-fault eviction notice while hospitalised.
  • Advocates and health figures, including Professor Fiona Stanley, condemned the timing and potential consequences of the eviction.
  • Coyne’s case highlighted the broader shift from public to community housing and the reduced tenant protections that came with it.
  • Critics argued that outsourcing public housing reduced transparency and justice, as Coyne awaited both surgery and a court ruling.

With more older Australians relying on housing providers in their later years, do you think enough is being done to protect tenants like Harvey? Let us know your thoughts in the comments.

In a previous story, we looked at how the housing crisis is hitting older Australians hard—and how little support they’re getting from major political parties.

For seniors like Harvey, whose health and stability depend on secure housing, this crisis isn’t just a headline—it’s personal.

If you’re wondering what’s being done at a policy level to fix the problem, that piece is worth a look too.

Read more: Older Australians are also hurting from the housing crisis. Where are the election policies to help them?
 

Seniors Discount Club

Sponsored content

Info
Loading data . . .
This is so sad! Probably another product of govt priorities failing us- excessive immigration, our own are struggling to secure or even keep housing (& medical) whilst newcomers are being welcomed & looked after! Immigration is not where i want my excessive taxes to be dispersed while older Aussies are being shortchanged!
 
Obviously, as he admitted himself, he hasn't been keeping the property in a good and clean condition, which would be the reason behind the possible eviction. Nobody goes to the extent of 10 property nspections in 12 months without good reason.
As Mr Coyne's health is so bad where is the help he so drastically needs. Where are his family, can they not clean up for him. Do none of the indigenous agencies
have funds that could be used to provide help. What about a Care package. Why can't the people advocating for him do something positive in the way of solving the reasons behind the eviction notice instead of just complaining about it.
There was apparently complaints also about noise and visitors. Other tenants in other units also have rights that the people in charge have to consider as well.
It's a two way street and despite Mr.Coyne's extremely bad health perhaps he should attempt to cut down on the noise and the visitors in an effort to help his situation. If there is an influx of so many visitors, can they not see the condition of the property and while they are visiting help clean up and keep the noise to a minimum.He must have been given warnings, eviction is usually a last resort.
 
Obviously, as he admitted himself, he hasn't been keeping the property in a good and clean condition, which would be the reason behind the possible eviction. Nobody goes to the extent of 10 property nspections in 12 months without good reason.
As Mr Coyne's health is so bad where is the help he so drastically needs. Where are his family, can they not clean up for him. Do none of the indigenous agencies
have funds that could be used to provide help. What about a Care package. Why can't the people advocating for him do something positive in the way of solving the reasons behind the eviction notice instead of just complaining about it.
There was apparently complaints also about noise and visitors. Other tenants in other units also have rights that the people in charge have to consider as well.
It's a two way street and despite Mr.Coyne's extremely bad health perhaps he should attempt to cut down on the noise and the visitors in an effort to help his situation. If there is an influx of so many visitors, can they not see the condition of the property and while they are visiting help clean up and keep the noise to a minimum.He must have been given warnings, eviction is usually a last resort.
I have to agree totally. His family should step in & help! By cleaning & looking after him & stooping the noise. If I was handed a property for nothing I would do everything possible to be respectful & look after the property. It's a sad situation but a two way street!
 
And here we go again....the sob story..we all probably have one, intergenerational trauma is NOT unique to indigenous and here's a story YOU want to hear an indigenous family single mother 5 kids swelling out to 10 kids on friday nights, lives across the street, First to go, the father/partner went to jail for offences and then the mother went to jail for offences...that was in Jan this year, the place was a pigsty with rubbish everywhere rats, snakes etc..and yet many complaints by residents saw NOTHING DONE! Given the current housing crisis that house went empty until they got out of jail 6 months later! No wonder people are up in arms when the special treatment is GIVEN ONLY TO A MINORITY!
 
I have the same opposite me. I only moved in 6 months ago and was told this was the good part of town.
My young neighbour has 4 young children she screams at all day long.
Different guys come and go and fights go on on a regular basis. She takes these fights out into the street and yells at the top of her voice with the most atrocious language.
The other week I was working in my front garden and she was screaming and abusing the latest flame at the top of her voice. I decided to take myself inside and as I was going up my front stairs she yelled at me "yes f*** off inside you f***ing dog.
I've never even spoken to her, mind my own business. The police are there continually.
When she gets angry she gets in her car and smashes it into her front fence.
It's colorbond with the lattice panels on top, so far she's smashed 5, plus two on the fence of the adjoining property.
Windows smashed and rubbish all over the place .
Nothing much they can do as she owns the place. Her previous partner committed suicide and she got his life insurance and bought the place so she can't be evicted.
And then her relatives say the neighbours are racial for reporting her.
🤷‍♀️
 
I have the same opposite me. I only moved in 6 months ago and was told this was the good part of town.
My young neighbour has 4 young children she screams at all day long.
Different guys come and go and fights go on on a regular basis. She takes these fights out into the street and yells at the top of her voice with the most atrocious language.
The other week I was working in my front garden and she was screaming and abusing the latest flame at the top of her voice. I decided to take myself inside and as I was going up my front stairs she yelled at me "yes f*** off inside you f***ing dog.
I've never even spoken to her, mind my own business. The police are there continually.
When she gets angry she gets in her car and smashes it into her front fence.
It's colorbond with the lattice panels on top, so far she's smashed 5, plus two on the fence of the adjoining property.
Windows smashed and rubbish all over the place .
Nothing much they can do as she owns the place. Her previous partner committed suicide and she got his life insurance and bought the place so she can't be evicted.
And then her relatives say the neighbours are racial for reporting her.
🤷‍♀️
Shocking behaviour!
 
Court filings also revealed he underwent 10 property inspections in a single year, something he said he ‘struggled to address…due to my age and health’.
Who do Housing Choices Australia think they are? They are acting in an illegal manner.

From the Real Estate Institute of Western Australia:-

Q: How often can a real estate agent carry out routine inspections?​

A: Not more than four times each year. Inspections must be held between 8am and 6pm. Tenants must be advised if the inspection is before midday or after midday.


Housing Choices Australia should be taken to the State Administrative Tribunal and sued for damages.
 
Obviously, as he admitted himself, he hasn't been keeping the property in a good and clean condition, which would be the reason behind the possible eviction. Nobody goes to the extent of 10 property nspections in 12 months without good reason.
As Mr Coyne's health is so bad where is the help he so drastically needs. Where are his family, can they not clean up for him. Do none of the indigenous agencies
have funds that could be used to provide help. What about a Care package. Why can't the people advocating for him do something positive in the way of solving the reasons behind the eviction notice instead of just complaining about it.
There was apparently complaints also about noise and visitors. Other tenants in other units also have rights that the people in charge have to consider as well.
It's a two way street and despite Mr.Coyne's extremely bad health perhaps he should attempt to cut down on the noise and the visitors in an effort to help his situation. If there is an influx of so many visitors, can they not see the condition of the property and while they are visiting help clean up and keep the noise to a minimum.He must have been given warnings, eviction is usually a last resort.
Agree. I feel sad for him but there might by another side to this story
 
Maybe the older Aussies that need all this help should have planned for their retirement years ago like the rest of us.Salary sacrificed,didn't smoke drink and gamble what they did earn,and now are crying poor.You should have your house flat caravan whatever you were able to afford depending on your income,paid off by now,you are 68 if of pension age?What have you done with your money since you were 16 years old,???
I hardly think the immigrants that are coming into this country with degrees in their chosen field,are buying a house,opening business and paying to school their children and let's not forget,paying their taxes,are hardly our wingy stingy pensioners that have never helped themselves,fault.
My rant for the day.Not saying any more on it.We have had duze s and dozens and dozens of these discussions over the years and I am not do sure the sdc people writing for this column, don't do it on purpose to get all our blood pressures up.
Good day to everyone.
 
  • Wow
  • Like
Reactions: SylviaK and DLHM
Agree. I feel sad for him but there might by another side to this story
There are many "authorities" who overstep their roles and responsibilities when it comes to the individual. Real estate agents, landlords and housing associations are just the tip of the iceberg. Throw in strata and body corporate managers for good measure.

That's why each state in Australia has their own Residential Tenancy Act.
 
Maybe the older Aussies that need all this help should have planned for their retirement years ago like the rest of us.Salary sacrificed,didn't smoke drink and gamble what they did earn,and now are crying poor.You should have your house flat caravan whatever you were able to afford depending on your income,paid off by now,you are 68 if of pension age?What have you done with your money since you were 16 years old,???
I hardly think the immigrants that are coming into this country with degrees in their chosen field,are buying a house,opening business and paying to school their children and let's not forget,paying their taxes,are hardly our wingy stingy pensioners that have never helped themselves,fault.
My rant for the day.Not saying any more on it.We have had duze s and dozens and dozens of these discussions over the years and I am not do sure the sdc people writing for this column, don't do it on purpose to get all our blood pressures up.
Good day to everyone.
A bit judgmental there!

We all weren't born with a silver spoon in our mouths.

Not everybody has a job paying $250000 a year or inherited millions from deceased relatives.

And I'm sick of false puritans who claim how great they are and have no vices or done anything wrong in their lives.
 
I pissed a lot of money against the wall over the years but still managed to save and buy a house all without any government hand outs? The amount made available to the Indigenous members or as they like to point out the traditional owners? claims made by the half chats. My question where the hell has all the money we taxpayers have been giving for years, they should all have their own rooves by now?
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Leenie and SylviaK
I was reading this story and feeling a certain amount of outrage until I read that the gentleman is indigenous.
The network available to this man is vast. Why is he not receiving the support that is out there? One can only wonder why it seems his own are not giving him the means to stop these actions.
My gut tells me there is more to this story. At a guess I would venture to say that the problem may be that the resources available are either being held back, denied, or ignored.
 
I was reading this story and feeling a certain amount of outrage until I read that the gentleman is indigenous.
The network available to this man is vast. Why is he not receiving the support that is out there? One can only wonder why it seems his own are not giving him the means to stop these actions.
My gut tells me there is more to this story. At a guess I would venture to say that the problem may be that the resources available are either being held back, denied, or ignored.
More to this story.....
 
  • Like
Reactions: SylviaK
Obviously, as he admitted himself, he hasn't been keeping the property in a good and clean condition, which would be the reason behind the possible eviction. Nobody goes to the extent of 10 property nspections in 12 months without good reason.
As Mr Coyne's health is so bad where is the help he so drastically needs. Where are his family, can they not clean up for him. Do none of the indigenous agencies
have funds that could be used to provide help. What about a Care package. Why can't the people advocating for him do something positive in the way of solving the reasons behind the eviction notice instead of just complaining about it.
There was apparently complaints also about noise and visitors. Other tenants in other units also have rights that the people in charge have to consider as well.
It's a two way street and despite Mr.Coyne's extremely bad health perhaps he should attempt to cut down on the noise and the visitors in an effort to help his situation. If there is an influx of so many visitors, can they not see the condition of the property and while they are visiting help clean up and keep the noise to a minimum.He must have been given warnings, eviction is usually a last resort.
You are 100% correct, I don't think these do-gooders here would like to live next to someone who caused noise and cleanliness problems in a unit next to them. And i'm sick of them mentioning that they are indigenous all the time looking for preferential treatment and sympathy - in my world we are all the same do the right thing and there won't be an issue. Who is the woman in the picture with him, I assume his wife, what's wrong with her keeping the place clean I'm 74 and have battled cancer twice but I keep my house clean with the help of a lady who now comes once a week to vacuum and wash my floors the rest I do myself. Stop looking for sympathy and clean your unit keep the noise down and stop annoying the hell out of other tenants who have the same rights you do.
 
This is so sad! Probably another product of govt priorities failing us- excessive immigration, our own are struggling to secure or even keep housing (& medical) whilst newcomers are being welcomed & looked after! Immigration is not where i want my excessive taxes to be dispersed while older Aussies are being shortchanged!

A bit judgmental there!

We all weren't born with a silver spoon in our mouths.

Not everybody has a job paying $250000 a year or inherited millions from deceased relatives.

And I'm sick of false puritans who claim how great they are and have no vices or done anything wrong in their lives.
 
As I said veggie not saying anymore on the subject. But I feel you have made it personal and insulting
1.I was not born with a sliver spoon in my mouth, one of six people and a steelworker for a dad,and
2. My husband was not in a $250k wage in the ,80s.🤣(Unheard off) and yes I am not claiming to be a puritan,he could get drunk on $2 back in his day too when he was 18 he tells me,
But, he didn't continue to get drunk or gamble his money,gave up smoking as a married man with two kiddies 11 months apart and started to behave like a responsible married father a d made decisions which would help his children and himself and his stay at home wife for our retirement and
3.We didn't inherit great fortunes from our parents that lived week to week like most and I don't consider them or us an arrogant silver spooned yuppies with great wealth that came or way.
So I am sorry to say,veggie, but you can have a decent retirement and life if you plan and organise yourself from the start.
No maybe you might've done with one car(old) and didnt drive a Harley on the side(I know plenty that did, and now whinge cos they are on a pension and have nothing and it's not big enough.
Lastly let's not blame the new immigrants to this country for our pensioners who are 70 and still renting and have nothing.
Definitely last comment on this.
Have a lovely day and enjoy the banter.
 

Join the conversation

News, deals, games, and bargains for Aussies over 60. From everyday expenses like groceries and eating out, to electronics, fashion and travel, the club is all about helping you make your money go further.

Seniors Discount Club

The SDC searches for the best deals, discounts, and bargains for Aussies over 60. From everyday expenses like groceries and eating out, to electronics, fashion and travel, the club is all about helping you make your money go further.
  1. New members
  2. Jokes & fun
  3. Photography
  4. Nostalgia / Yesterday's Australia
  5. Food and Lifestyle
  6. Money Saving Hacks
  7. Offtopic / Everything else
  • We believe that retirement should be a time to relax and enjoy life, not worry about money. That's why we're here to help our members make the most of their retirement years. If you're over 60 and looking for ways to save money, connect with others, and have a laugh, we’d love to have you aboard.
  • Advertise with us

User Menu

Enjoyed Reading our Story?

  • Share this forum to your loved ones.
Change Weather Postcode×
Change Petrol Postcode×