Who's winning the supermarket price war? Shopper crowns unexpected winner

In the ever-competitive world of grocery shopping, Australians are always looking for the best deals to stretch their dollars.

With the cost of living on the rise, supermarket price tags are now under more scrutiny than ever before.

So, when a shopper set out on a journey to compare prices, the results were bound to turn heads.


Melbourne-based personal trainer Alexei Joshua had grown accustomed to shopping at Woolworths or Coles.

However, Alexei could not help but notice that prices for certain items had soared over the years.

Curiosity got the better of the 26-year-old man, which pushed him to go on a mission to find out if his usual shop costs less if he shopped at a discount retailer.


compressed-pexels-supermarket.jpeg
Supermarket prices vary depending on location. Image Credit: Pexels/Pixabay


As German supermarket ALDI gained popularity among Aussie shoppers as a budget-friendly alternative, Alexei went on to shop in-store and compare it with his usual haul.

The initial comparison didn't go as planned for Alexei as he only wanted to buy staple ingredients—which included avocados, tomatoes, onions, capsicum, spaghetti, tomato paste, diced tomatoes, beef mince, chicken breast, and mixed berries from both supermarkets.

However, he encountered a snag when he found that ALDI was out of stock on several items.


This predicament forced Alexei to buy more expensive alternatives and skewed the results of his first shopping experiment.

'I was fully expecting ALDI to be cheaper, but stock was a big issue,' Alexei shared.

'I had to buy something because obviously I had to eat, and it ended up being more expensive.'

His total bill for his ALDI haul cost $65.04. Meanwhile, his Woolworths haul cost him $60.87.

Determined to get a more accurate comparison, Alexei repeated the experiment.


This time, he started shopping at ALDI to avoid the stock issues.

He carefully selected 'identical' items, including fresh produce and branded products like Pepsi Max, Weet-bix, and YoPro pouches.

His verdict? ALDI's bill came in slightly cheaper at $35.65, while Woolworths rang up at $38.80.

However, sale prices at Woolworths dropped his total bill to $36.60.

Alexei's findings aligned with a government-commissioned supermarket price report conducted by consumer advocacy group CHOICE.

The report consistently found ALDI to be the more affordable option for a basket of staples.

In their comparison, ALDI's total for 14 items was $50.64, with Coles at $66.18, Woolworths at $69.17, and IGA at a steeper $73.80.


So, what does this mean for savvy shoppers who want a bang for their buck?

While ALDI may generally offer lower prices, the availability of items could significantly impact the total bill.

It's wise to check for sales and stock availability before heading out or to consider visiting multiple stores to get the best deals.

It's all about being a savvy shopper—keeping an eye on the catalogues, using loyalty promos, and not being afraid to switch things up if your regular items are cheaper elsewhere.
Key Takeaways

  • Melbourne-based trainer Alexei Joshua conducted a price comparison between ALDI and Woolworths for a selection of staple groceries.
  • Alexei's initial comparison was affected by stock issues at ALDI, which led to purchasing more expensive alternatives.
  • A repeat of the experiment with a careful selection of available products resulted in ALDI being slightly cheaper than Woolworths.
  • A government-funded report found ALDI to be cheaper than Coles, Woolworths, and IGA for a basket of staple items.
Have you done your price comparisons between supermarkets? What strategies do you use to keep your grocery bills down? Share your experiences and tips with us in the comments below!
 

Seniors Discount Club

Sponsored content

Info
Loading data . . .
I'm not happy with Aldi fruit and vegetables. They don't have an option for a checkout that bags your items.
They don't have half price specials. They don't have much brand choice. They don't have reward points or discount fuel points. Although I believe we are paying for the reward points if you are careful what you buy, I think Woolies is a better option. :unsure:
 
I do my weekly shop at Coles, mainly for convenience. I do a monthly shop at Aldi for meat, dairy and pantry items as I find their prices much better than Coles. I have shopped at Aldi in many countries for years now and find the quality of their produce is excellent. I do tend to agree about the staying power of their vegetables, but find that Coles fresh vegetables and fruit leaves a lot to be desired too as that section often looks pretty sad in Coles. I rarely shop at Woolworths as I find them too expensive.
 
I buy very little fruit and veg from Aldi, maybe bananas and occasionally blueberries which I look at very carefully and eat pretty carefully. You need to use common sense when shopping otherwise it is false economy for sure. I have about 6 items I now get from Aldi which are heaps cheaper than anywhere else and I am keeping an eye out to see if I can add to that. Shopping is definitely becoming a complicated and timely process for sure and the less money you have the worse it is.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Colette 3799
Key Takeways
Woolworths, Coles, Aldi fruit and vegetables are NOT CHEAP NOR FRESH
SHOP around, there are better smaller shops that offer better value and much fresher too
I have shopped with woollies in store and online for years and have never experienced these so called unfresh vegetables you’re talking about. Lucky me hey.😊
 
  • Like
Reactions: DLHM and magpie1
It depends who does the buying for each store and your store could make sure they only buy decent stuff. I have shopped at different stores around Perth and there is a distinct difference in some of them. Wouldn't touch their fresh produce with a barge pole but most not a problem.
I have shopped with woollies in store and online for years and have never experienced these so called unfresh vegetables you’re talking about. Lucky me hey.😊
 
  • Like
Reactions: Littleboy8
we need to rethink our shopping habits...we can no longer "one shop "all our requirements,Shop via two shop purchases to complete your shopping ,pick the best from the market, yes it does require a little extra effort but thats the world we are in if one is time poor then one must pay the price...thats shopping!... saving money does require some extra effort
 
  • Like
Reactions: Trina G
I dropped into an ALDI store yesterday just as a stickybeak because I was next door. I walked slowly around the entire store and to be honest all I came away with was two packets of seeds. I thought I saw a great bargain for Dove Bodywash only to find when I got up close it was not the regular one litre bottle. Then I went in search for some shampoo/conditioner, no luck at all. Yes they were still stacking the shelves after our non event Alfred, however, they didn't seem to be lacking in the goldrush stakes of toilet paper, meats, some fruit and vegies, and Easter eggs. Nor rain or wind will stop🐇.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Littleboy8
Key Takeways
Woolworths, Coles, Aldi fruit and vegetables are NOT CHEAP NOR FRESH
SHOP around, there are better smaller shops that offer better value and much fresher too
Explain why fruit and veg stalls at Dandenong Markets charge $18.99 per kilo for button mushrooms when the same can be got at Woolworths, Coles or Aldi for $12-13 per kilo.

Based on December 2023 prices.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DLHM and Littleboy8
I think you have just got to shop around for the best price. If it's too expensive don't buy it. Go to your all your locals. In Sydney you have Flemmington and Parklea ?? trying to remember. In Brisbane it's Rocklea, however, maybe not at the moment. But there are green grocers all the way up the Warrego on the side of the road. Surely it's the same in every other state.
 
I only shop at Woolworths or at my local corner shop. I shopped at Aldi's once and I was so disappointed with the quality of their service and the fact they're not an Australian company. That means their profits go out of Australia.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Littleboy8
I only shop at Woolworths or at my local corner shop. I shopped at Aldi's once and I was so disappointed with the quality of their service and the fact they're not an Australian company. That means their profits go out of Australia.
Yes woollies here is totally Australian owned not to be confused with the South African owned woollies as some people on here believe. Aldis is German owned and all the profits go out of Australia 🇦🇺
 
I used to live across the road from an Aldi. So close I could walk the trolley to my front door, unpack at home and wheel the trolley back.
I had the opportunity to scrutinise their produce quite closely at the time. Their fruit and veg were sub-standard to say the least, and, not much cheaper than main-stream, or places like Harris or local fruito.
Probably the worst experience I had was the eggs. This is around 10 years ago, so cannot be compared to today's market. At the time, I toddled in and thought the cage free was the best price I had seen anywhere. When I set out to crack them, the white came out like it was watered down, and the yolk was not anywhere near yellow. So, to see what their more expensive offering was, over the road I went. The range free was still a little cheaper than other retailers, however, the standard was abysmal.
There were a few other things that were deceptively cheap, however, my finding is that because there were only two of us, it was not economical to buy larger packets or bigger boxes.
Now there is just me, I can afford the time to catalogue shop and make use of loyalty discounts and rebates that work fine for me.
In the end, it is up to the shopper to decide what is best for their circumstances. That's why some people love Costco, and others don't. If you want to save, you need to do your shopping list, stick to it and shop the catalogues.
 

Join the conversation

News, deals, games, and bargains for Aussies over 60. From everyday expenses like groceries and eating out, to electronics, fashion and travel, the club is all about helping you make your money go further.

Seniors Discount Club

The SDC searches for the best deals, discounts, and bargains for Aussies over 60. From everyday expenses like groceries and eating out, to electronics, fashion and travel, the club is all about helping you make your money go further.
  1. New members
  2. Jokes & fun
  3. Photography
  4. Nostalgia / Yesterday's Australia
  5. Food and Lifestyle
  6. Money Saving Hacks
  7. Offtopic / Everything else

Latest Articles

  • We believe that retirement should be a time to relax and enjoy life, not worry about money. That's why we're here to help our members make the most of their retirement years. If you're over 60 and looking for ways to save money, connect with others, and have a laugh, we’d love to have you aboard.
  • Advertise with us

User Menu

Enjoyed Reading our Story?

  • Share this forum to your loved ones.
Change Weather Postcode×
Change Petrol Postcode×