No jail for 78-year-old doctor in $318,000 Medicare fraud scheme
- Replies 13
Medicare fraud costs Australian taxpayers hundreds of millions of dollars each year, but perpetrators can sometimes receive surprisingly light sentences—as was the case for Dr Sam Beitner.
The 78-year-old Melbourne GP avoided prison despite admitting to a Medicare fraud scheme that netted him over $318,000, according to reports.
Dr Beitner recently appeared in County Court after admitting guilt to two charges related to improperly obtaining financial benefits from the Commonwealth.
The 78-year-old doctor had acquired the private Medicare information of 330 patients during his tenure as a general practitioner at various Melbourne clinics, such as St Kilda Super Clinic, Greenvale Medical Centre, and Mill Park Super Clinic.
Beitner's unlawful activities involved submitting fake Medicare claims from 2011 to 2016, in which he falsely asserted that he had administered over 5,000 medical services from his private residence in Kew and an abandoned office space in Melbourne's CBD.
Court documents also indicated that he extended these fraudulent claims to instances when he was overseas or hospitalised.
The prosecution alleged that money was deposited into the offender's bank accounts, which were subsequently withdrawn from ATMs near the Crown casino.
However, it was revealed in court that Beitner was not a gambler, and a family member had accessed the accounts.
County Court judge Michael O'Connell acknowledged that Commonwealth prosecutors had requested a prison sentence. They argued that, as a medical practitioner, Beitner had abused his position of trust and his access to the online claim system.
'You exploited that system, it was submitted, by utilising the medicare details of 330 legitimate patients so as to minimise the risk of detection,' said O'Connell.
However, O'Connell also noted several 'mitigating' factors, including Beitner's old age, serious health problems, and the fact that he had already repaid $318,435 to the Commonwealth.
As a result, O'Connell sentenced Beitner to three years in prison, but the entire sentence was suspended.
This means that Beitner will not serve any time behind bars, provided he abides by an 18-month good behaviour bond.
The Australian Health Practitioner Regulation Agency records indicate that Beitner's medical practitioner registration only lapsed recently, and no special conditions were placed on his registration despite being charged in 2018.
Last year, a set of reports exposed significant issues within the Medicare system, making it susceptible to exploitation, fraud, excessive billing, and errors extremely difficult to identify.
These reports revealed that billions of dollars were fraudulently acquired annually, often through billing deceased individuals and fabricating patient records.
Members, what are your thoughts on this? Do you think more must be done to crack down on Medicare fraud? And how has your experience with Medicare been lately?
Please share your thoughts and experiences with us in the comments below.
The 78-year-old Melbourne GP avoided prison despite admitting to a Medicare fraud scheme that netted him over $318,000, according to reports.
Dr Beitner recently appeared in County Court after admitting guilt to two charges related to improperly obtaining financial benefits from the Commonwealth.
The 78-year-old doctor had acquired the private Medicare information of 330 patients during his tenure as a general practitioner at various Melbourne clinics, such as St Kilda Super Clinic, Greenvale Medical Centre, and Mill Park Super Clinic.
The 78-year-old used the private Medicare details of 330 patients he had obtained while employed as a general practitioner at several clinics across Melbourne. Credit: Shutterstock.
Beitner's unlawful activities involved submitting fake Medicare claims from 2011 to 2016, in which he falsely asserted that he had administered over 5,000 medical services from his private residence in Kew and an abandoned office space in Melbourne's CBD.
Court documents also indicated that he extended these fraudulent claims to instances when he was overseas or hospitalised.
The prosecution alleged that money was deposited into the offender's bank accounts, which were subsequently withdrawn from ATMs near the Crown casino.
However, it was revealed in court that Beitner was not a gambler, and a family member had accessed the accounts.
County Court judge Michael O'Connell acknowledged that Commonwealth prosecutors had requested a prison sentence. They argued that, as a medical practitioner, Beitner had abused his position of trust and his access to the online claim system.
'You exploited that system, it was submitted, by utilising the medicare details of 330 legitimate patients so as to minimise the risk of detection,' said O'Connell.
However, O'Connell also noted several 'mitigating' factors, including Beitner's old age, serious health problems, and the fact that he had already repaid $318,435 to the Commonwealth.
As a result, O'Connell sentenced Beitner to three years in prison, but the entire sentence was suspended.
This means that Beitner will not serve any time behind bars, provided he abides by an 18-month good behaviour bond.
The Australian Health Practitioner Regulation Agency records indicate that Beitner's medical practitioner registration only lapsed recently, and no special conditions were placed on his registration despite being charged in 2018.
Last year, a set of reports exposed significant issues within the Medicare system, making it susceptible to exploitation, fraud, excessive billing, and errors extremely difficult to identify.
These reports revealed that billions of dollars were fraudulently acquired annually, often through billing deceased individuals and fabricating patient records.
Members, what are your thoughts on this? Do you think more must be done to crack down on Medicare fraud? And how has your experience with Medicare been lately?
Please share your thoughts and experiences with us in the comments below.
.png){kind=icon}
